Who are the heretics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter adolfo123
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

adolfo123

Guest
Well my question rise’s from the fact the the church now for some time calls the protestants brothers in christ ??? How can this be if they protest dogmas of the faith and are people like the jehovah witness (apostolics non-trinity believing cult) and mormons also brothers in christ Jesus???

If this be the case then why not call the gnostics brothers in christ and other heretics of ages long ago???

Why not call the Muslims brothers???

Now I know there is a human brotherhood but my question is addressing spiritual brotherhood…
 
Protestants are considered by the Church to be “separated brethren”. This term recognizes their historical lineage from Catholicism while acknowledging that a separation-physical, spiritual, theological-exists. Often that separation entails heretical views of one sort or another but the Church takes a more mature, rather than an isolationist, stance on these matters now. She desires the return of all her children. JWs and Mormons are a little farther out there in terms of deviation from Church teachings or creeds but that just makes them a bit more lost-a place we all come from and a place we’re all called out of.
 
Protestants are considered by the Church to be “separated brethren”. This term recognizes their historical lineage from Catholicism while acknowledging that a separation-physical, spiritual, theological-exists. Often that separation entails heretical views of one sort or another but the Church takes a more mature, rather than an isolationist, stance on these matters now. She desires the return of all her children. JWs and Mormons are a little farther out there in terms of deviation from Church teachings or creeds but that just makes them a bit more lost-a place we all come from and a place we’re all called out of.
Did not the magesterium call them heretics???
 
It is my understanding that a heretic is one who rejects one or more beliefs after having accepted them. Thus one who leaves Catholicism and joins a Protestant community is guilty of heresy, but one born into that community is not. He never had the belief; so has not rejected it.

I think the Catholic position is that the Protestant beliefs are heretical, but the members are not heretics.
 
Did not the magesterium call them heretics???
If they believe in heresy, they’re heretics, in which case we want them to come out of it, of course. But the prodigal son never stopped being a son-or a brother-even if he rejected that status himself.
 
It is my understanding that a heretic is one who rejects one or more beliefs after having accepted them. Thus one who leaves Catholicism and joins a Protestant community is guilty of heresy, but one born into that community is not. He never had the belief; so has not rejected it.

I think the Catholic position is that the Protestant beliefs are heretical, but the members are not heretics.
I think this is true. At least, in one legitimate use of the word heretic. Like most words, **“heretic” has a broad and then a more narrow meaning ** (just like “philosophy” broadly means “love of wisdom” but academically and scholastically it pertains to the more narrow definition of “a systematized investigation into first causes” or something to that effect). In a broad sense, “heretic” could simply mean a follower of a belief system erroneously derived from Catholicism. In a more narrow sense, it additionally means that such a person once accepted Catholicism but was then led into error. In other words, it has the added component of apostasy to it.
Why not call the Muslims brothers???
This is because, I think, Muslims do not believe Christ to be divine whatsoever. Protestants (with some exceptions) share our belief that Christ is God. Obviously, to be fully Christian is to be Catholic and accept the truths that come along with that. But if you accept Jesus, I think that technically makes you Christian (though not necessarily to the full extent of that term).
If this be the case then why not call the gnostics brothers in christ and other heretics of ages long ago???
There certainly are times where it is prudent for you to “turn up the heat” talking to and talking about followers of heresy. But it depends. Sometimes, you reasonably expect more of certain people and thus take a more demanding attitude with them. Sometimes, it is more prudent to be gentle, understanding, and patient. The Church, in her wisdom, now sees the present time requiring such a gentle approach. Many may find this as a very bad idea. I used to. But now I don’t.

This is because I would debate a lot with Protestants and Atheists and other kinds of heathens and whenever I took a harsh, black and white tone, I observed they just became more settled in their obstinacy.

When I realized I had secured people in their errors, I eventually began talking to unbelievers like friends, not even bringing up religion at all at first, and focusing what I had in common with them (even certain environmental concerns, for crying out loud). They gradually saw me as an ally. Then, I would bring up a small question regarding their wider worldview of things, and eventually we launched into a cordial, tame discussion about God and the Catholic Church. I have had success stories with this. One such person, a friend who was an incredibly intelligent anti-theist (not just atheist) came back to the Church with a knowledge of Church teaching that seemed to surpass mine. He later said that it was his Catholic friends and their kindness that did it for him … but he also said it was because we told him the** truth**. Both of those things seemed to be necessary.

Every time I have argued in a condemning or at least un-gentle spirit with any unbeliever, I have been met with disaster. The reason for this, I think, is that nowadays, the culture is so confused that they are largely if at all not culpable for their errors. They are more victims of error now then they are criminals. We should treat them as such. I believe in the middle ages, truth was much clearer … the media and modern cultural subversion techniques were simply not possible. I am very open, in fact, (call me a fanatic if you want) that burning heretics back then would be completely justified sometimes (though perhaps not in all cases). But nowadays, such behavior would not help spread the faith. We need to strike at the heart and mind of people in a way that they will understand. With the fallout of the World Wars, the Sexual Revolution, Abortion, and in general the Culture of Death, we need to demonstrate love in a tender way. And the Church, who knows best, wants to implement that strategy. For, now, it is the best way to spread the Gospel.

Correct me if I’m wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top