Who can answer this question in the Bible? (I believe this is one of the hardest question)

  • Thread starter Thread starter anhphan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Not only for intellectuals,but also for average thinking persons the only answer in the matter is that suffering,pain ,illness and death have come to this world on account of the original sin and every human has to undergo these.When we have the promise of Jesus ,who also suffered for us but resurrected,that at the end we will meet him in heaven where there is no suffering,pain or death but eternal life with him,we have nothing to be worried about.For those who don’t believe in him,such promise is not there. There is no other solution or answer.Reconcile to this fact whether one agree or not.Thank God that he has given us a life to live in this beautiful world to know about him,witness his glory and power,and live with an expectation of a glorious life after death.
 
We all start out simply. No one that I know was born with a PH,d but with a thirst for understanding and progression. To say that simple answers and explanations are of an inferior mind-quest-intelligence makes me sad because most of my replies ARE simple with the conviction that all posters will try to progress according to their needs. It reminds me that Peter was kind of a Dumb Bunny, but he was simple in his faith-he believed.
 
Sure, but you look at some of the most perfect people in the history of the world— Jesus? Mary? John the Baptist? They had to deal with a crushing amount of suffering during their lives. If there was anyone God was likely to protect from pain and suffering, would it not be the second person of the Trinity? Or his mother? Or his foster-father? Or his forerunner? Or his apostles?

So their suffering had value and purpose to it, that was more important than merely “being comfortable” and living a nice happy life until it’s time to die and trade it for a nice happy eternity. But it’s not until we’re able to be outside of time and space, and see things as they are, that we’re able to understand the repercussions of our actions and whether we wasted our suffering or put it to good use. But, unlike Habakkuk, we have a better vantage point to be able to understand the big picture differently in light of faith, even though it’s still very limited.

St. Therese had a little snippet that went—
“In light of heaven, the worst suffering on earth, a life full of the most atrocious tortures on earth, will be seen to be no more serious than one night in an inconvenient hotel.”
Bishop Sheen had a nice insight that went–
There’s nothing more tragic in all of the world than wasted pain. Think of how much suffering there is in hospitals, among the poor and bereaved. Think also of how much of that suffering goes to waste. How many of those lonesome, suffering, abandoned, crucified souls are saying with Our Lord at the moment of Consecration: "This is my body, take it?"And yet, that is what we should be saying at that second. "Here is my body, take it! Consecrate it! Offer it ! Offer it to the Heavenly Father with yourself, in order that He, looking down on this great Sacrifice, may see only you, His beloved Son in whom He is well pleased. Transmute the poor bread of my life into your life; thrill the wine of my wasted life into your divine Spirit; unite my broken heart with your Heart; change my cross into a crucifix. Let not my abandonment and my sorrow go to waste. Gather up the fragments, and as the drop of water is absorbed by the wine at the Offertory of the Mass, let my life be absorbed in you. Let my little cross be entwined with your great Cross so that I may purchase the joys of everlasting happiness in union with you.

Consecrate these trials of my life which would go unrewarded unless united with you; transubstantiate me so that , like bread which is now your Body and wine which is now your Blood, I, too, may be wholly yours. I do not care if the species remain, or that, like the bread and the wine, I may seem to all earthly eyes the same as before. My station in life, my routine duties, my work, my family-- all these are but the species of my life which remain unchanged; but the substance of my life, my soul, my will, my heart, transubstantiate them, transform them wholly into your service so that through me all may know how sweet is the love of Christ!
 
Everything is always for our benefit. That’s all you have to know. We don’t know everything, but God does, and He takes into account all the suffering that we will face because of evil. But we learn from our trials and we gain merit from them, in order to have more glory in Heaven. We suffer but God provides.
 
We all start out simply. No one that I know was born with a PH,d but with a thirst for understanding and progression. To say that simple answers and explanations are of an inferior mind-quest-intelligence makes me sad because most of my replies ARE simple with the conviction that all posters will try to progress according to their needs. It reminds me that Peter was kind of a Dumb Bunny, but he was simple in his faith-he believed.
No, I am especially perturbed when people try to give simple answers for suffering. To anyone who has truly suffered (I’m not talking about temporary problems of privileged Americans and the like) the answers aren’t good enough. Frankly, they sound like easy passes for the people that have it good. “Well, no reason to waste our lives helping the suffering, they will be righted in a later life.” I’m sorry, there is no proof of a later life, so this complacency needs to be rid of immediately.
 
Everything is always for our benefit. That’s all you have to know. We don’t know everything, but God does, and He takes into account all the suffering that we will face because of evil. But we learn from our trials and we gain merit from them, in order to have more glory in Heaven. We suffer but God provides.
The same old “God works in mysterious ways” response. That response can work for literally anything, so what good does it provide?
 
I honestly think the answer is somewhere along the lines of pain leads to growth. Humans aren’t wired for utopia (probably due to the fall) and too much comfort is inherently uncomfortable. That’s why the attempts to make a utopia (communism, Nazi germany, etc.) have all been blood soaked failures.
 
I honestly think the answer is somewhere along the lines of pain leads to growth. Humans aren’t wired for utopia (probably due to the fall) and too much comfort is inherently uncomfortable. That’s why the attempts to make a utopia (communism, Nazi germany, etc.) have all been blood soaked failures.
Sure, this is true in some cases. But what about the millions of children that die of starvation every year. What about the many people born to birth defects or diseases that makes their entire life torture. What growth does this lead to?
 
I know more about suffering than I will ever tell or relate. The view that Americans are privileged is indicative of what you really don’t know about this country or its people. The very poor, the near poor and the so-called low class and middle-class are abundant. What is seen and accepted on TV and through the media is not the true picture. Even we Americans would do well to read between the lines. As The Lord said, “Ther poor will always be with us.” I don’t know your own circumstances, where you live, or your sufferings. I will pray for you-weather you want me to or not. Let there be peace in your heart as well as in mine.
 
In the grand scheme of things, we are ants. What is our suffering in relation to the infinite nature of God?

The fact that we place so much emphasis on our suffering and how it makes us feel is part of the weakness of human pride, in my opinion.
 
I know more about suffering than I will ever tell or relate. The view that Americans are privileged is indicative of what you really don’t know about this country or its people. The very poor, the near poor and the so-called low class and middle-class are abundant. What is seen and accepted on TV and through the media is not the true picture. Even we Americans would do well to read between the lines. As The Lord said, “Ther poor will always be with us.” I don’t know your own circumstances, where you live, or your sufferings. I will pray for you-weather you want me to or not. Let there be peace in your heart as well as in mine.
Sure, out of the whole statement I made, you can cherry-pick the Privileged American piece to take the attention off of the rest. I also feel bad for the Americans that suffer, but most “normal” people think suffering is having a dog die, or missing a promotion at work. So the statement was made to draw attention to intense, prolonged, unnecessary suffering.
 
In the grand scheme of things, we are ants. What is our suffering in relation to the infinite nature of God?

The fact that we place so much emphasis on our suffering and how it makes us feel is part of the weakness of human pride, in my opinion.
Yeah weakness of pride. When someone is so miserable, that all they want to do is die to relieve their suffering, what pride that must take…
 
Life is suffering, we’re told to take up our cross and carry it.

Poverty, suffering, and discomfort are the default setting for humanity. It was only through pushing through and dealing with it that we’ve since been able to elevate ourselves to a level of material comfort that we as a species are able to look at our natural state in horror.
 
I feel bad for you, laylow. I wish I could help you in your bitterness and hostilities. I absolutely will pray for you. If you wish to PM me and continue this conversation I have a ready ear. Peace.
 
I feel bad for you, laylow. I wish I could help you in your bitterness and hostilities.
Hmmm…if stating facts means you are bitter and hostile then guilty as charged. However, I have gone by different definitions of those words my whole life, so confusion remains.
 
Life is suffering, we’re told to take up our cross and carry it.

Poverty, suffering, and discomfort are the default setting for humanity. It was only through pushing through and dealing with it that we’ve since been able to elevate ourselves to a level of material comfort that we as a species are able to look at our natural state in horror.
Sure, dodge the question as usual.
 
I didn’t reply to a question, I replied to a statement
Yeah weakness of pride. When someone is so miserable, that all they want to do is die to relieve their suffering, what pride that must take…
But if you can’t fathom how someone being so preoccupied with their own suffering that they focus on nothing is else prideful and selfish then idk what to tell you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top