Who Can Convoke a Council/Synod?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AndrewRaZ
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AndrewRaZ

Guest
First, I apologize if this is in the wrong place.

I remember reading somewhere that an emperor convoked a council, which immediately decided that the emperor does not have the authority to convoke a council. However, I can’t find which council that was. I thought it was the first Council of Nicea, which was convoked by Constantine, but there were a number of of other councils and synods that were also convoked by emperors.

Does anyone know?
 
but there were a number of of other councils and synods that were also convoked by emperors.
The first seven Councils were convoked by the Emperor. The eighth (Constantinople 4) was convoked jointly by the Emperor and the Pope. The ninth (Lateran 1) and all subsequent Councils were convoked by the Pope alone.

So, if a Council were to restrict an Emperor from convoking a Council, it seems that it would be either the eighth or the ninth.

Well, it wasn’t Constantinople 4. Lataran 1 increased the autonomy of the Holy See by prohibiting the Emperor from naming the Pope (as was done in the early days). But it did not restrict the Emperor from calling a Council.

Oddly enough, I am unable to find ANY modern Canons regarding the convocation and administration of a Council. My copy of Canon Law includes editorial content and commentary. At the end of Part 2, Section 1 (just after Canon 367) is a list of 21 Councils with their dates. It’s just a list - there is no additional text. I don’t know if this list is part of Canon Law proper or if it is part of the additional editorial content of my book.

However, although the teaching office of the Church is part of the Deposit of Faith, the manner in which a Council is called (or a Pope named, etc) is not. A Council is not Ecumenical because of who convoked it, but because of who comes (the Bishops) and who accepts it (the Pope).

I suppose you could convoke a Council. Rent a big place, send out invitations to the Bishops, and see what happens. If a bunch of Bishops show up, and the Pope approves, you’ve got yourself an Ecumenical Council.
 
I did notice that a number of the councils were convoked by emperors, which was part of the reason I was a little confused. Thanks for your help.

I just seem to remember hearing that story. It’s rather like the town clerk that convened a council to determine an efficient way to save money on the town budget. The council decided the best solution was to fire the town clerk.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top