AFH, I think Petergee’s point is: how do you know your interpretation is correct and the other person is wrong? Both of you are reading the Bible, praying to the Holy Spirit, and trying to discern the truth. Yet you come to opposing answers.
Surely many Protestant ministers have studied the Bible carefully and prayed to the Holy Spirit for guidance. Yet they too end up teaching opposing doctrines.
On another thread, I asked you a question which you never gave an answer to–at least I never saw your answer. I had originally asked what to do if a friend was sinning against me by teaching false doctrine about Baptism to my children. The Bible says in Matthew 18 to take it to the church. I asked you which church to take it to. You said to take it to the church I happened to belong to. I then pointed out:
But I’m afraid this doesn’t help at all. How do I know the church I’m attending will give me the right answer about Baptism? As I pointed out, some teach Baptism is for everyone; some say it is not for infants. Some teach that Baptism is regenerative; others say it is merely symbolic. Some teach Baptism is not necessary at all. They all claim to be guided by the Holy Spirit.
Because I want my children to have the truth, it’s absolutely essential they be taught the correct doctrine about Baptism. But all these churches have different doctrines! All these churches go by the Bible and claim to be guided by the Holy Spirit,
but they can’t all be right because they teach opposing doctrines!
What if I’m saying Baptism is regenerative and is for infants, but my friend says it isn’t regenerative and infants should not be baptized? (And that’s what he’s teaching my kids!) How do I trust whatever church I happen to be attending to give me the right answer? That church might say my friend is right, and I am wrong. However, if I happen to attend a different church, it might say I’m right and he’s wrong!
Now, when Jesus said “take it to the church,” surely He didn’t mean for me to take it to a church that’s going to give me a wrong answer. Surely Jesus wants us to have the truth. As I’ve pointed out, simply *taking it to the church I happen to attend *is no guarantee that church will teach me the correct doctrine.
So I have to ask again: Which church do I take it to?
Or, to put it another way: Is there a church I can trust to teach me the correct doctrine? Because if there isn’t, why would Jesus tell me to “take it to the church”?
Link to other thread:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=1751958#post1751958