3
3xblessed
Guest
Background: my husband, children and I converted two years ago at Easter vigil. We came in with a really charismatic (but theologically sound; not at all radical) amazing priest, who was transferred less than a year later. I had some theological issues that were difficult for me in the conversion process, including the fact that I wasn’t sure I really believed in the concepts of transubstantiation, or the veneration of saints or praying to Mary. My husband fully believed in all of it, but I admit that I was mostly just going along with it. I really enjoyed attending Mass back then despite my doubts, because I had a great priest who truly seemed like he was imitating Christ and I loved the music.
Since that great priest was transferred out of the parish, I’m completely lost. We never really met anyone in our parish so we’ve tried a couple different parishes, finally settling on one but still not meeting anyone. We get involved in parish activities and no one talks to us at all. While the priest in our current parish is fine, he’s also not inspiring at all in the way the first priest was and frankly all the priests since that first one seem like they’re just going through the motions. Then there was the liturgy change and now they’ve taken away one of the things that was most meaningful and beautiful to me in the old Mass, the Gloria. The new one sounds ugly to my ears and all these months later I can’t get used to it. All of these factors combined have left me feeling very unhappy, feeling very out of place in the Catholic church and is only shining the spotlight on my doubts.
I pray all the time that I will find some answers and find the direction I should go, and how I can increase my faith. I find that doing so feels like it’s leading me toward a non-Catholic church. I know what the apologetics say about the “real presence”, why the Catholic church teaches what it does about Mary and the saints and confessing to a priest, etc - but I’m afraid that knowing that isn’t making me believe it. I realize that I’m not supposed to be at church for entertainment, but aren’t we supposed to be able to develop relationships with other believers? I’ve tried three different parishes, for a total of 6 months to two years each, and no one at any of the three parishes have been friendly to my family. But it’s not just about being lonely - it’s that very often I feel like an outsider in the Catholic church, maybe because I didn’t grow up in it? Maybe if I grew up in it, I’d have an easier time believing in all the doctrines. I try to believe, but honestly it just doesn’t make sense.
I just feel really lost. I have no good Catholic mentors and cannot find any. Mass services seem completely lifeless to me, despite the fact that we’re supposed to believe in the real presence of Christ in the eucharist - but if there really was Jesus in the eucharist, wouldn’t somebody seem like they were moved with emotion instead of just robotically going through the motions and rushing out of there as soon as possible? Nobody seems to have any joy, not even in the Gloria.
Honestly the overwhelming focus on politics has also been a huge turnoff, albeit a secondary one. I understand why the Catholic church is against birth control and agree with that stance, but hearing a letter from my Bishop read during Mass about why I have to side with one political party offends me and seems like a huge violation of tax exempt status. I don’t expect that view to be popular here and I’m sorry for that, I’m not trying to be offensive. But when I became Catholic I thought I was choosing a religion, not religion AND politics.
I’m disillusioned and lost, and I’ve given this a lot of time and a lot of prayer over the past year. Maybe I’m not supposed to be Catholic anyway, because I’ve never been comfortable with praying pre-written prayers, including the rosary. I pray several times a day, but only free-form prayer directly to Jesus. I do feel that I sometimes hear the voice of God as a response to prayer, and as much as I want to God to reveal that the Catholic church is truth for me, it isn’t happening. If anything my doubts about the truth of the Catholic church are increasing the more I pray and read the Bible? For the sake of family harmony it would be best if I could get back to how things were in the beginning, but how can I force myself to believe?
Since that great priest was transferred out of the parish, I’m completely lost. We never really met anyone in our parish so we’ve tried a couple different parishes, finally settling on one but still not meeting anyone. We get involved in parish activities and no one talks to us at all. While the priest in our current parish is fine, he’s also not inspiring at all in the way the first priest was and frankly all the priests since that first one seem like they’re just going through the motions. Then there was the liturgy change and now they’ve taken away one of the things that was most meaningful and beautiful to me in the old Mass, the Gloria. The new one sounds ugly to my ears and all these months later I can’t get used to it. All of these factors combined have left me feeling very unhappy, feeling very out of place in the Catholic church and is only shining the spotlight on my doubts.
I pray all the time that I will find some answers and find the direction I should go, and how I can increase my faith. I find that doing so feels like it’s leading me toward a non-Catholic church. I know what the apologetics say about the “real presence”, why the Catholic church teaches what it does about Mary and the saints and confessing to a priest, etc - but I’m afraid that knowing that isn’t making me believe it. I realize that I’m not supposed to be at church for entertainment, but aren’t we supposed to be able to develop relationships with other believers? I’ve tried three different parishes, for a total of 6 months to two years each, and no one at any of the three parishes have been friendly to my family. But it’s not just about being lonely - it’s that very often I feel like an outsider in the Catholic church, maybe because I didn’t grow up in it? Maybe if I grew up in it, I’d have an easier time believing in all the doctrines. I try to believe, but honestly it just doesn’t make sense.
I just feel really lost. I have no good Catholic mentors and cannot find any. Mass services seem completely lifeless to me, despite the fact that we’re supposed to believe in the real presence of Christ in the eucharist - but if there really was Jesus in the eucharist, wouldn’t somebody seem like they were moved with emotion instead of just robotically going through the motions and rushing out of there as soon as possible? Nobody seems to have any joy, not even in the Gloria.
Honestly the overwhelming focus on politics has also been a huge turnoff, albeit a secondary one. I understand why the Catholic church is against birth control and agree with that stance, but hearing a letter from my Bishop read during Mass about why I have to side with one political party offends me and seems like a huge violation of tax exempt status. I don’t expect that view to be popular here and I’m sorry for that, I’m not trying to be offensive. But when I became Catholic I thought I was choosing a religion, not religion AND politics.
I’m disillusioned and lost, and I’ve given this a lot of time and a lot of prayer over the past year. Maybe I’m not supposed to be Catholic anyway, because I’ve never been comfortable with praying pre-written prayers, including the rosary. I pray several times a day, but only free-form prayer directly to Jesus. I do feel that I sometimes hear the voice of God as a response to prayer, and as much as I want to God to reveal that the Catholic church is truth for me, it isn’t happening. If anything my doubts about the truth of the Catholic church are increasing the more I pray and read the Bible? For the sake of family harmony it would be best if I could get back to how things were in the beginning, but how can I force myself to believe?