Why are Catholics hated so much? (Poll)

  • Thread starter Thread starter distracted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You are correct sir, I was referring to the Crusades. And if you ever have the chance to express this sentiment to a Muslim who cares very much about his/her religion, I’m willing to bet that person will feel more unfavorably toward you for saying so. Perhaps not Catholics in general, but at least you.

.
for future reference i am not a sir…

& i couldn’t care less what muslims think of me. i think they are violent and destructive & don’t know much about the love of God… the jihadists… and if a religion can produce these kinds of people… well, i don’t want to hear about how not all muslims are like that…

you don’t see Cahtolics flying airliners into buildings killing thousands of people they don’t know. end o’sentence…
 
Do unto others, yada yada yada. You know how it goes. If I talked about Catholicism with this amount of disrespect, I’d have a 10-point infraction right now. You are capable of doing this without interference from the mods, but that doesn’t mean you should.

Whatever you just did there, I’m not sure exactly what I’d call it, but I think we can add it to the list.
that poster said nothing off… that is deserving of an infraction.

whatever happened to freedom of speech for crying out loud?

oh that’s right… that’s only for non-Catholics… catholics are probably just supposed to shut the h- up… that’s the way it was in the begining of US history…
 
As a Catholic resident of the Bible belt South, I believe that most contempt for the Church comes from misunderstanding and childhood indoctrination. Most of my Protestant friends misunderstand the Church’s teaching on salvation and believe we teach salvation based on works. In my experience, this causes the most problems, along with the apparent lack of Biblical evidence for Church teachings. From within the Church, misunderstanding is also a large part of the problem with “Cafeteria Catholics.” I found it impossible to accept a lot of Church teachings until they were adequately explained. In short, I don’t think the Church is hated, just misunderstood.
Ah the Bible Belt, where I live now. I was told by some woman the other day I was going to hell because I didn’t accept a Bible gift from her.
 
that poster said nothing off… that is deserving of an infraction.
I agree, and that is why I said “You are capable of doing this without interference from the mods.”
whatever happened to freedom of speech for crying out loud?
It’s still being practiced. I can raise a light objection without infringing on a person’s right to free speech. I think Voltaire said something about disagreeing with what a person says but defending to the death their right to say it. And I’m not even really disagreeing with what you say- it’s more about how you say it.

If it does anything for you, I’m not raising the objection because I am personally offended. I actually think it’s in your own best interest to be a little more tactful. If you don’t, that’s your choice. It doesn’t look good, but it’s your choice. An ironic choice, considering the thread it’s being posted on. And I do love irony. So thanks for providing some.
oh that’s right… that’s only for non-Catholics… catholics are probably just supposed to shut the h- up… that’s the way it was in the begining of US history…
You do realize you’re on a Catholic message board, right? I don’t get to make you do anything. I get to voice an opinion every once in awhile if I so choose, and the current opinion is that a couple of Catholics who’ve posted on this thread would do themselves a favor if they showed a little more tact and respect when talking about Muslims. You may ignore it if you want, and you can feel free to disagree with it. But if you tell me I’m infringing on your right to free speech, I will in turn disagree with that statement.

For future reference, this is how you can know when your freedom of speech is being violated. If Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini declares a fatwah calling for your death in response to your publication of The Satanic Verses, you’ll be experiencing a denial of your freedom of speech just like Salman Rushdie. If, however, a random person asks you if you would choose to be a little more tactful on pain of…nothing in the slightest; really, I mean it, nothing at all- that’s when you know your right to freedom of speech is doing just fine.

Also, I’m sorry for calling you sir. I probably knew that at one time and forgot. I’ll try to remember in the future.

Anyway, do what you want. You’re allowed to make poor choices. Sometimes, though, it’s good to know when it is a poor choice. But I have a feeling you’re going to go ahead and do it anyway.
 
Boo-hoo, Muslims are offended by the Crusades. They can hate Catholics all they like on account of the Crusades; they asked for it. Pity the secular leaders of the Crusades didn’t have their acts together; Islam might be a historical footnote today, otherwise.
The Crusades were a total tragedy for everyone involved. As Catholics, we should feel pity, and pray that nothing like that happens again in the name of God and the Church.
 
Boo-hoo, Muslims are offended by the Crusades. They can hate Catholics all they like on account of the Crusades; they asked for it. Pity the secular leaders of the Crusades didn’t have their acts together; Islam might be a historical footnote today, otherwise.
Somebody needs a history lesson…
 
In the words of St. Augustine, “I believe, in order to understand; and I understand, the better to believe.” - CATECHISM OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH (CCC) PARAGRAPH 158
 
The way I see it is, The more people hate and prosecute the Catholic Church the more I know that this is the true Church that Jesus established. I know that satan hates all that are closer to God there for the Church and it’s people in the Church. The day they stop is the day I’ll start thinking Hhmm somethig is not right here.
jesus g
 
and if you feel you are hated by people because you’re Catholic, check yourself, for it may be something other than being Catholic that repulses them.

Perhaps you’re just coming across in an uncharitable way which turns them off.

Jim
 
I don’t think its a simple answer as a poll. Of course theres satan and everything but from a purely human perspective there are many facets to the prism of anti-catholicism.

To put it my way, i think that anti-catholicism generally is caused mainly because the church IS an opposing and monolithic way of living that opposes the secular depravities of society and is unresponsive to worldy attempts to change its teachings. This combined with its profound otherness to protestants and especially to non-religionists lead people to misunderstand it, and therefore attack it and its adherents precisely because it withstands their worldview and opposes it. With the case of bible-belt protestants i think that previous comments describing indoctrination into anti-catholicism and the misunderstanding are valid. But for the casual observer its the simple fact that catholicism offers a viable and opposing alternative to utilitarian-relativist-modernism that in my opinion leads to the constant attacks on the Church amongst secular society and the media.

In short its just as described in John 15:19-21 simply put in non-biblical terms.
 
i know (and/or suspect) why I am so hated… but just wondering what your thoughts/sentiments are on the subject.

Choose as many as apply and please elaborate.
I don’t consider myself hated because of my Catholic roots, but rather misunderstood. Yes there are people who physically hate Catholics, but I believe that number is small as the number of highly dislike and highly misunderstood come into play.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top