Why are Catholics hated so much? (Poll)

  • Thread starter Thread starter distracted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think hate is to strong a word, maybe some do hate but most of them likely disagree with us but hate??? Most non Catholics I know don’t show any hatred towards me and I would never think of debating them on religion because that would put them in a bad position and would be pride taking over on my part. Maybe people don’t like us because we come across as self righteous by debating. I never discuss my religion or debate it with friends, its a good way to turn people off. I’m not afraid to express my religion or answer peoples questions. Maybe a lot of us like to think were hated which is a form of pride…I’m not calling anyone out on this but taking a different view. If some do “hate” us so what, worry about your own house.
 
From a series of questions on religion on a recurring Gallup poll:

What are some of the reasons why you say you have an unfavorable opinion of the Catholic religion? [OPEN-ENDED]

ASKED OF ADULTS WHO HAVE AN UNFAVORABLE OPINION OF THE CATHOLIC RELIGION

Do not agree with their views/practices/doctrine
Sexual scandal/Cover-ups/Child molestation
Partial to/belong to another religion
Idolization of saints/Virgin Mary
Is an organized religion
Hypocrisy
Dislike all religions
Views on abortion
Poor past history with the Catholic Church
Dislike their views on birth control
Not letting women be priests/Sexist
Cult-like religion
Confessions/communion issues
Issues on homosexuality
Greed of money in the church
Celibacy of priesthood/No marriage
Other
None
No opinion

Percentages add to more than 100% due to multiple responses.

The source: gallup.com/poll/1690/religion.aspx (it’s kinda far down). The poll shown at this site was taken in '06, so the rather high number of 19% for the sex scandal cover-up might not be so high now. Not surprisingly, the most generic option of “do not agree with views/practice/doctrine” came in at the highest- 26%. The rest of the options largely have to do with more specific beliefs/practices of the CC, some of which are reportedly non-existent (ie., idolization, sexism, cult-like…). Oh, but then at the end, we get to the “other” option- 14% of respondents included that one. Now that is telling. You’d have to add up all the numbers from the previous 8 options on the list in order to equal that number.

Again, this poll was taken by those who (in an earlier question) indicated that they felt either somewhat unfavorably or very unfavorably toward the CC. These views are only those of the people who happened to take this poll, and they are all Americans (United States). So for what it’s worth, there it is.
 
This is an interesting question. I’m still mulling over the answers and trying to pick the best one.

I understand that it’s difficult to provide a comprehensive answer within the character limits of the poll options, but since I don’t have those limitations for this post, I’ll be a bit beyond what is permitted for a poll option.

Catholics and non-Catholics disagree on a variety of things. When you talk about these things, it leads to conflict. And according to a saying that I’ve found to be pretty reliable, “There’s no conflict without relationship and there’s no relationship without conflict.” Conflict of almost any variety can be dealt with in a healthy way that leads to greater trust in spite of (and in a way, even because of) differences and disagreements. Conflict can also be dealt with in an unhealthy way that leads to a relationship that, in the long term, is painful and just bad. When it goes that way, it’s pretty common for people to just push each other away and discontinue the relationship. (Problem solved: No more relationship, no more conflict). Both people often wind up in a place where they’d rather have nothing than something bad. From another perspective, though, you might say they’ve given up on dealing with the conflict in a healthy way so that it leads to a good relationship. Yes, there will still be conflict along with the relationship- that absolutely goes with the territory in any relationship, and the level of conflict generally correlates positively with the closeness of the relationship. But it’s manageable conflict that can be beneficial instead of harmful.

I don’t know if this could be condensed to a viable poll option, but I might summarize it this way: This kind of hate happens because one or both parties don’t resolve their conflict in an appropriate way. Resolving conflict doesn’t usually mean you both believe the same things at the end of it. The conflict has resolved in the sense that the animosity has come to an end, but the differences are still there- and you can love each other in spite of them. In some ways, it can lead to an even closer relationship than what you can have with someone who believes all the same things you do. That’s because it takes a greater amount of trust and vulnerability in order to achieve this result through conflict resolution. And when you put more work into making a relationship work, it also tends to be more rewarding.

Granted, it’s a whole lot easier to develop good relationships with people in the absence of great amounts of conflict. However, if you’re going to develop a really close relationship with anyone, you have to come to terms with each others’ differences and work through a few conflicts on some level. (The easiest place to find testimony to that effect is from the marriages of pretty much any person you’ll ever talk to). If you have a total absence of conflict with another person, it probably means your relationship isn’t very close. When there’s a lot of differences and a lot of potential for conflict, that certainly makes it a lot more difficult. But if you place a comparably high value on your relationship with that person and they’re nice enough to return the favor, I’d say it’s worth it to do what it takes to make it work.

All of that probably applies best to non-Catholics who (sometimes) hate Catholics (though sometimes they come across that way but deny that they actually do). As far as non-religious folks who hate Catholics, I’d guess it’s mostly because transubstantiation makes you a really easy target for someone who regards the world from a naturalistic perspective. In their eyes, you’re…well, delusional is the word I see the most. Muslims who hate Christians are probably a lot more likely to hate Catholics than non-Catholics, for obvious reasons…(Starts with a C, ends in S, 8 letters)…Same goes for Jews, with a special animosity reserved for Spanish Catholicism. In the course of examining the entire spread of people who might hate Catholics, there’s a half-dozen different reasons just based on who it is you’re talking about. But my initial answer deals with what I would guess is most often applicable to the kinds of people you’ve experienced in your own life.
…(Starts with a C, ends in S, 8 letters)… means??? :confused: Please explain… Crusades?? if so, the Catholics were right… but then, uh… that goes without saying… 😃

i think its interesting that Cathlics are far more willing to be friends with protestants than vice versa…

what could that possibly mean??
 
I’m pretty sure I can. Want me to vote for you by proxy?
Doesn’t matter so much really, they are all pretty good in their own right as to why we are hated.

Can I not vote cause I am on a trial membership? If so, how in the heck do I get off that title?!
 
i think its interesting that Cathlics are far more willing to be friends with protestants than vice versa…

what could that possibly mean??
Don’t really think that is true here in the US…I’ve been walking with the Lord for almost 40 years and can count on one hand those I met were unfriendly to catholic christians
 
As a Catholic resident of the Bible belt South, I believe that most contempt for the Church comes from misunderstanding and childhood indoctrination. Most of my Protestant friends misunderstand the Church’s teaching on salvation and believe we teach salvation based on works. In my experience, this causes the most problems, along with the apparent lack of Biblical evidence for Church teachings. From within the Church, misunderstanding is also a large part of the problem with “Cafeteria Catholics.” I found it impossible to accept a lot of Church teachings until they were adequately explained. In short, I don’t think the Church is hated, just misunderstood.
Misunderstanding can lead to anger or hatred.
 
Seriously, I know it’s off topic, but do you guys know why my title says “trial membership”? I figure I haven’t registered right or something, but not sure what to do. Can anyone help me? Then it’s back to topic for me! 🙂
 
In answer to the OP, having grown up Protestant I would say it was indoctrinated in me all of my life just from things I overheard. Then, people have said to me that they can’t stand the thought of someone being in charge of them telling them they have to go to church or they have to confess their sins. They think that confessing to God is good enough. Way too many rules for them. From what I’ve experienced, it comes down to ignorance and a closed mind to learn anything about the Catholic church. I’ve been on both sides of the fence and I’m glad I’m on this side now. 😉
 
Remember the great quotes from the great Fulton J. Sheen
That is an excellent quote from an excellent man; if more people saw the Church as it truly is, not how they’ve been misled into seeing it, the churches would find themselves packed to the gills every day, not just every Sunday.
 
It’s not always easy being Lutheran, either. Evangelicals and fundamentalist — and even some mainline protestants don’t like you because you are “too Catholic.” Catholics don’t like you because you’re “too (or another) protestant”.🤷
 
This is why Catholics are hated.
John 15:19-21
19If ye were of the world, the world would love his own: but because ye are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you.
20Remember the word that I said unto you, The servant is not greater than his lord.** If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you;** if they have kept my saying, they will keep yours also.
21But all these things will they do unto you for my name’s sake, because they know not him that sent me.
 
Don’t really think that is true here in the US…I’ve been walking with the Lord for almost 40 years and can count on one hand those I met were unfriendly to catholic christians
if you were to start telling people all the wonderful things about the RCC, you would soon be hated by all, as Jesus said we would be… (Mark 13?)
 
In answer to the OP, having grown up Protestant I would say it was indoctrinated in me all of my life just from things I overheard. Then, people have said to me that they can’t stand the thought of someone being in charge of them telling them they have to go to church or they have to confess their sins. They think that confessing to God is good enough. Way too many rules for them. From what I’ve experienced, it comes down to ignorance and a closed mind to learn anything about the Catholic church. I’ve been on both sides of the fence and I’m glad I’m on this side now. 😉
me too… welcome Home…🙂

yes, i think it is ignorance a lot of the time… should have had that as option in poll…

but what really irritates me is when pepole do not wnat to be disabused of their ignorance of the Church’s teachings… they just go merrily along, not giving a rip whether or not they are in the “right” Church… and there is only ONE…

OK… true, i don’t know that they are doing this… just seems like it… have to remind myself that i never know what anyone is thinking…

but still, there are so many who just close their minds to the faith… so sure they are right about what htey’ve heard… when all they have heard is some non-Catholic’s opinion on it… 😦
 
…(Starts with a C, ends in S, 8 letters)… means??? :confused: Please explain… Crusades?? if so, the Catholics were right… but then, uh… that goes without saying… 😃
You are correct sir, I was referring to the Crusades. And if you ever have the chance to express this sentiment to a Muslim who cares very much about his/her religion, I’m willing to bet that person will feel more unfavorably toward you for saying so. Perhaps not Catholics in general, but at least you.
i think its interesting that Cathlics are far more willing to be friends with protestants than vice versa…
what could that possibly mean??
That could be true. I don’t know if it is, though. And I don’t think you do, either. If it were, however, I’m not entirely sure what it would mean.

If I run across any sort of poll that can shed light on the question, I’ll let you know. 😃 I’m not quite sure what I would do in order to find out worldwide data, though. Gallup polls tend to only cover the US, and that’s hardly central to Catholicism. Protestantism, maybe. (And that really is a maybe). Catholicism, definitely not.
 
This is why Catholics are hated.

Quote:
John 15:19-21
19If ye were of the world, the world would love his own: but because ye are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you.

20Remember the word that I said unto you, The servant is not greater than his lord. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you; if they have kept my saying, they will keep yours also.

21But all these things will they do unto you for my name’s sake, because they know not him that sent me.

Wouldn’t you think that applies to all christians rather than just the roman catholic ones…?
Our Bishop that is over India/Nepal had members of ours and other churches lost their lives/houses from radical muslim/Hindu terrorism targeted at christains(some were Catholic) a few years ago…
 
Boo-hoo, Muslims are offended by the Crusades. They can hate Catholics all they like on account of the Crusades; they asked for it. Pity the secular leaders of the Crusades didn’t have their acts together; Islam might be a historical footnote today, otherwise.
 
Boo-hoo, Muslims are offended by the Crusades. They can hate Catholics all they like on account of the Crusades; they asked for it. Pity the secular leaders of the Crusades didn’t have their acts together; Islam might be a historical footnote today, otherwise.
Do unto others, yada yada yada. You know how it goes. If I talked about Catholicism with this amount of disrespect, I’d have a 10-point infraction right now. You are capable of doing this without interference from the mods, but that doesn’t mean you should.

Whatever you just did there, I’m not sure exactly what I’d call it, but I think we can add it to the list.
 
I have yet to be encountered by an anti-Catholic or persecuted by one since converting to Catholicism. I know they are out there. I have heard and read many horror stories. And I come from a Protestant Church. Every so often I run into the Pastor or a few members, still very good friends with them, but they are always trying to persuade me to return. 😃

I actually visited my old Church about 1 year and 3/4 ago, lol, everyone was running up to me, happy to see me, including one gentleman who is by far an anti-Catholic (by simple mis-understanding and standing witness to a bad priest, as he claims). Even he was happy to see me and we all chated, went downstairs and chatted for a while, though mainly after a time it was just the pastor, an old friend and me. The Pastor actually spoke a few positive things about Catholicism, so it was really neat, our conversations. But we debated a little, friendly of course.

A good friend of mine at work, who when I first met him, was kind of a fiery type against the Church, he is Protestant, and when first talking to him he did not know what I was, then i told him. He had a funny look on his face, like “ahhhh man, not Jason!!” But the more we chatted the more he realized there is nothing wrong the Church, he doesn’t agree entirely, obviously, but I think because of our conversations, (we’d go over the Bible, I would talk about Church history, the construction of the Bible, certain councils against heresies, and the like) he grew to respect the Catholic church and told me himself he does not have a problem with it AND was thinking of leaving his own Church for another Protestant church Because his pastor is extremely anti-Catholic, and now my friend is not. Praise be to God!! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top