Why are people upset about this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter convert999
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
  1. He won’t do face-to-face confession; he always uses the little rooms.
    • This one would actually bug me. The only reason I can think of is that the priest may fear he is unable to separate what he hears in the confessional from his interactions with his parishioners if he does face to face confession. To me that is a problem. Spiritual direction is an important aspect of the sacrament in reconciliation to me. I have a couple of priests who have heard several confessions from me. This gives me comfort as I do not have to go over “old ground” with them and they can help me to spot trends and issues in my life that I might not see. Furthermore, the the sacrament becomes more than just confessing and assigning of penance, it becomes spiritual direction, which to me is extremely important. If I had a priest who was unwilling to do face to face confession, I probably would seek somewhere else to do my confessions or, perhaps find another parish. This one is the only legitimate reason for concern that from my own perspective. Of course, others have differing views and they are free to go to another parish should they desire to do so. I cannot say they are wrong for doing so as I do not know their heart.
I don’t think this is necessarily the reason… maybe the priest is just more traditional.

At my FSSP parish, we only had behind the screen confessions. Yet the priest recognized me whenever I came for confession, because he recognized my voice. He was spiritually directing me and met with me also outside of Confession to talk about my spiritual life. But the reason face to face confessions weren’t offered is because it’s a traditional parish.

God bless
 
I don’t think this is necessarily the reason… maybe the priest is just more traditional.

At my FSSP parish, we only had behind the screen confessions. Yet the priest recognized me whenever I came for confession, because he recognized my voice. He was spiritually directing me and met with me also outside of Confession to talk about my spiritual life. But the reason face to face confessions weren’t offered is because it’s a traditional parish.

God bless
Perhaps. It would still bug me enough that I would likely choose to go to confession elsewhere. Whether I would choose to leave the parish over it is another matter.
 
Perhaps. It would still bug me enough that I would likely choose to go to confession elsewhere. Whether I would choose to leave the parish over it is another matter.
You can attend Mass wherever you please, but you could not leave the parish if it is geographically your home parish. You would still necessarily be tied to that parish for any required Sacraments. Any family Weddings or Funerals would have to be celebrated in the home parish unless a special dispensation is granted by the bishop. People should understand that although he more than likely could use a little social refinement, he needs the love and caring of his new congregation to feel at home. Don’t bail on the guy when he needs you all the most. I’m sure if you let these things pass and pull together as a congregation, the closeness that you are used to will return sooner than you think.
,
 
Don’t bail on the guy when he needs you all the most. I’m sure if you let these things pass and pull together as a congregation, the closeness that you are used to will return sooner than you think.
,
Which is why I suggested earlier that the parishioners ask to sit down with him to share their questions and concerns and give him an opportunity to express his reasoning behind the decisions he is making.
 
Parish life would be so much more Christ-like if people would sit around discussing how to make the new priest’s life easier, rather than harder.
Perhaps you can bring up ways to help the priest during your meetings. Don’t confront them, simply suggest a few things. “Since Father is new to the area, why don’t we put together a book of coupons to some local attractions?” Then “Since Father is new to the parish, why don’t we get our husbands to help him polish all those candle sticks he’s using now.” 😉
 
We’ll see how it goes tonight – I offered to iron his vestments yesterday because his alb looked like he slept in it. The lady who did it for the last priest just quit doing it. I’m planning to do it before our meeting starts since it’s easier to do it there. That ought to start some conversation. I’m actually hoping someone will step up and offer to do the altar cloths (sorry I don’t know the right names) since I hate ironing. 😃

P.S. In spite of his abrupt manner, he had no problem accepting my offer. In fact he asked me if I baked too. He is actually personable one-on-one. It’s when he’s in a group that the regrettable statements start. Example: a bunch of us women were cleaning the kitchen when he walked in and said, “It’s great to see women doing what they’re good at.” I said, “What do you mean, Father?” and he replied, “Well I know you’re all good at other things too.” Unfortunately it was too little, too late. He’s just nervous and I don’t know why they can’t see that. :mad:
 
We’ll see how it goes tonight – I offered to iron his vestments yesterday because his alb looked like he slept in it. The lady who did it for the last priest just quit doing it. I’m planning to do it before our meeting starts since it’s easier to do it there. That ought to start some conversation. I’m actually hoping someone will step up and offer to do the altar cloths (sorry I don’t know the right names) since I hate ironing. 😃

P.S. In spite of his abrupt manner, he had no problem accepting my offer. In fact he asked me if I baked too. He is actually personable one-on-one. It’s when he’s in a group that the regrettable statements start. Example: a bunch of us women were cleaning the kitchen when he walked in and said, “It’s great to see women doing what they’re good at.” I said, “What do you mean, Father?” and he replied, “Well I know you’re all good at other things too.” Unfortunately it was too little, too late. He’s just nervous and I don’t know why they can’t see that. :mad:
He may have a sarcastic wit!😃
 
I try to be as charitable as possible, but unfortunately I don’t think he was being sarcastic.😃
 
I try to be as charitable as possible, but unfortunately I don’t think he was being sarcastic.😃
In fairness, he was probably just trying to say “much appreciated ladies, you know how it is when men try to clean a kitchen”.

…but everyone here probably already knew that. :o
 
We have a new priest, and many people have left our parish. The reasons they give don’t make sense to me, and I suspect it’s because I don’t understand the symbolism of some things. Here’s what people object to: 1. He has a row of candles on the altar, in the front, which people say is wrong. 2. He does the Kyrie in Greek. 3. He often chants the prayers. 4. He restarted the practice of lighting candles for prayer intentions. 5. He won’t do face-to-face confession; he always uses the little rooms.

Many people are saying all these things are wrong. I actually like a lot of them, except for the tiny confessionals. (I’m a little claustrophobic.) I don’t understand why people feel so strongly about them. Can you clarify?
Coming from a parish that was traditional and then priest assignments changed to a very liberal “feeling” priest, I later found out that the former priest had specifically been sent to the parish to reform the congregation due to a pattern of liturgical abuses. It was not widely accepted and eventually the traditional priest was re-assigned to an old established parish that had a reputation for being traditional.

We actually registered in another parish with an equally traditional priest. I could not accept replacing the crucifix with a star and removing the stations of the cross.

So it is very possible that the new priest was asked to make some changes to bring the mass back into the proper form.

God Bless You
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top