Why are Protestants opposed to Crucifixes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Metaron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Steadfast, what is drawing yo to the Lutheran Church? Are you attracted to LC-MS?
I’m already drawn…

My wifer and children are Lutheran and I have a good understanding of Lutheran doctrine most of which I accept.

I am, probably, about 87.9% Lutheran.

I like best the Law-Gospel distinction and their practical irenicism without compromise of faith.
 
Opposition to the crucifix is, really, a theological inconsistency.

If Protestants believe that the sacrifice of Christ was an atonement in blood and that it represents the satisfaction of the justice of God, it’s inconsistent to have a problem with the representation of that sacrifice, especially if one is going to prefer an empty cross.

The empty cross didn’t save anybody.
I see your point and do agree. I think the point of the empty cross is just symbolization of Christianity but the crucifix shows exactly where our salvation comes from.
 
I’m already drawn…

My wifer and children are Lutheran and I have a good understanding of Lutheran doctrine most of which I accept.

I am, probably, about 87.9% Lutheran.

I like best the Law-Gospel distinction and their practical irenicism without compromise of faith.
Dont the lcms say the pope(s) have been THE anti-christ?

I thought I read that. Is it true? If so, its a compromise of faith. And poor bible interpretation.

Do you believe that?
 
Yeah, most Anglican churches have crucifixes, though not all. Some have a resifix. or some have a highly ornate plain cross. I know because I used to be Anglican after I left Protestantism with dissatisfation.
I’m having some dissaitsafction within Catholicism myself at the present. I wish it were different.
 
Dont the lcms say the pope(s) have been THE anti-christ?

I thought I read that. Is it true? If so, its a compromise of faith. And poor bible interpretation.

Do you believe that?
I think most Lutherans wouldn’t be so hasty as to conflate the office with the man.

I do believe the papacy to be anti-christian, though in the last forty years it’s improved considerably.
 
Huh…? I’m going through RCIA right now. What’s to be dissatisfied over? :confused:
many things at all levels but I’m sure that the church has gone through these things before. They have just never involved me before.
 
“Many things, at all levels…” How vague. I guess you’re just having a personal vendetta against our holy Church right now. Whatever that is, the Church has been through hard times, emerging intact, everytime.
 
Um, I didn’t deny that the papacy is antichrist, that Lutherans believe it or even that I personally do.

Rather the opposite in each case actually.

The point was that Lutherans rarely speak of The Pope as Antichrist in some eschatological End Time teh Evil Dude sense, but rather of the office he holds as being Anti-Christian.

Since Vatican II though even this has been harder to maintain as much more than an academic point.
 
“Many things, at all levels…” How vague. I guess you’re just having a personal vendetta against our holy Church right now. Whatever that is, the Church has been through hard times, emerging intact, everytime.
I’m really beginning to have some question about that. It seems to me that the church always agrees that everything is a-ok but that surely isn’t the view from te outside. I personally know a man who was repeatedly molested and threatened about telling for about a 5 year period by his parish priest. After the sexual abuse allegations broke through to the proper folks involved (like some 8 years later), the priest (who had moved or was moved on to anoter parish) acted in a shrewed and condesending way toward this man and his family and claimed that he didn’t even know him very well (which was a straight up lie). It took monumental perseverance and effort on this guy’s part to try and get some justice out of this travesty with no help from the the church that he called his spiritual home his whole life.

This could have happened anywhere, I agree. But the real crux of this is that the Church isn’t just anywhere; it is what Jesus started and gave us. This should have never had to go this far for anyone who was abused. The Church should be rightfully held to a much higher standard than any earthly institution and it saddens me that in the eyes of so many Catholics it is not. The perspective is that this happens everywhere and this huge problem is just one of the many. This really bothers me.
 
Um, I didn’t deny that the papacy is antichrist, that Lutherans believe it or even that I personally do.

Rather the opposite in each case actually.

The point was that Lutherans rarely speak of The Pope as Antichrist in some eschatological End Time teh Evil Dude sense, but rather of the office he holds as being Anti-Christian.

Since Vatican II though even this has been harder to maintain as much more than an academic point.
:eek:

Do you believe the way you do based on the scriptural citations in that link???

Because if you do, I think you need to read the scriptures again!
 
That is the Brief Statement of 1932 and is not confessionally binding for Missouri Synod Lutherans.

The Brief Statement was written as a composite of doctrine and it had to do mainly with bilical inerrancy though it also went into other points, but any way.

Here is the confessional bit. From the Formula of Concord.
 
Another example of the fact that it is Catholic is really the only reason some Protestants are against it (crucifix, sign +, and many other sacramentals). They’ll come up with a “theological” reason, but the underlying reason, and the only reason, they don’t like it is because it’s Catholic. In most cases it’s just part of their tradition…hate all things Catholic.
 
Another example of the fact that it is Catholic is really the only reason some Protestants are against it (crucifix, sign +, and many other sacramentals). They’ll come up with a “theological” reason, but the underlying reason, and the only reason, they don’t like it is because it’s Catholic. In most cases it’s just part of their tradition…hate all things Catholic.
Exactly. My father the rabid Fundamentalist (Got to love 'im though) openly admitted that he was against the sign of the Cross and sacramentals are because they’re too Catholic, and thus they are vile and “superstitious” in his view.
 
That is the Brief Statement of 1932 and is not confessionally binding for Missouri Synod Lutherans.

The Brief Statement was written as a composite of doctrine and it had to do mainly with bilical inerrancy though it also went into other points, but any way.

Here is the confessional bit. From the Formula of Concord.
Thanks for your reply. The reason I ask is my dad’s family is from a long line of Lutherans - German Evangelische Kirche. My grandfather was an extremely intelligent pastor, he could converse in Greek, Latin, English and German. He came to the US in 1912, coming from the Eastern part of German, which is rich in Lutheran Tradition - Wurms, etc. As an adult, looking back, he reminds me of ML, intelligent, arrogant, yet full of faith. After Granfather died, 3 of his five children converted to Catholicism with all their children. My father never had a chance, but I believe he was ready after the break-up at Concordia Seminary in the 1970’s. He was very hurt by all the dissidence, He remained MO-Synod until his untimely death (murdered in our home) April 9, 1975. My dad was a role model of piety for me. He loved his church, but it wasn’t the same anymore for him. I loved listening to him sing German Lutheran hymns on Sunday mornings. He would say “Der Herr ist auferstanden” every Sunday morning. He wasn’t afraid to announce to all the world. My mother and us kids were Catholic, and NEVER did she try to convert him, rather encouraged him to attend his own church. We therefore never practiced a lot of Catholic traditions in our home, Rosary, Perpetual Help devotions. My mom didn’t want a rift in the home, to her credit. I kind of felt cheated in that respect.

My cousins still have their Lutheranism in their blood, but they love their holy Catholic Church int a way that was never expressed in our home.

Your story is the flip side of my experience.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top