well there are other concerns I have encountered on here that are NOT covered well.
I see several of the above posters chose to joke about this thread.
Try reading some questions and and answers on here from a variety of threads…there is a TON of different answers and viewpoints.
There really is no black and white. ANd that is a reflection of everyday catholics.
People all do what they want to do,believe what they want to believe.
It is my OPINION that nobody really follows the Chatecism to the T. And actually, I count myself in that category.
I’m sorry if my joking around bothered you. You are right that the “absolutely correct” answers that we “must believe” often are numerous and contradictory on any given statement.
I think this is part of the way we try to “intellectualize” our faith. We all are so concerned with being right or wrong, we often fail to miss the nuances of what the Church actually teaches on any given issue. Not only that, but some refuse to accept Church teachings when they go against what they believe (for example those who insist Genesis MUST be interpreted literally – even though neither the Church, nor CA apologists say it does) but when Church teachings agree, they beat others over the head with it and tout 100% compliance to Rome.
Jesus never said we have to believe in this Church teaching and that to get to heaven. He told people how to behave toward each other and how to think about each other – the law is written on our hearts and He activated it. The early Christians had no Bible, precepts of the Church, encyclicals, councils, etc, and were mostly illiterate, and they carried on the faith just fine. Why is it that we now have rules and regulations that far exceed what the Torah must have looked like, and so many of us think we can “earn” or “learn” our way to heaven by knowing and following all of them? You really can’t put “love” down on paper in a set of rules and regulations. You can point somebody to “love,” but you can’t replace it with rules and teachings, or Jesus would not have needed to come at all.
As children, most of us were taught what to think, not how to think. Also, most of us were trained inadequately, if at all, to deal with people with different viewpoints. When we are young, if we say anything that sounds odd or unexpected, we are scolded and/or made fun of. Soon we learn the best strategy is to say what we think is expected, rather than reach for our own honest opinion. In this way I believe that most of us, as children, are actually “vaccinated” against honesty – it’s easy to pick a side and argue it but to actually be open to learning while doing so – priceless.
Alan