Why are there so many Varied Viewpoints on CA

  • Thread starter Thread starter lisahiku
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

lisahiku

Guest
Why so many viewpoints if all catholics are supposed to beleive the same stuff?
I read a question on here,an there are many different replies and answers .
Someone will quote scripture and Canon Law to back up their point.

Someone else will totally disagree with THAT point.

Why so much confusion ?
that being said, I know there isn’t a perfect answer.
I just got done reading a thread about dying in mortal sin. Some people said God can forgive and have mercy. Really? this is news to me, because i was taught UN-REPENTED mortal sin upon death means ETERNAL punishment.

Anyway, just wonderng…
 
I think this is a natural response to people with scholarly views on religion. They disagree for some of the most nuanced reasons. Here people from all over the globe, and different cultures, get to meet in these forums and find out we weren’t all cut out of the same cookie cutter, which is disturbing because before we had the technology, we all just assumed all the cookies in the rest of the world looked and tasted like those around us.

Plus, here people discuss things they’ve held in concern for decades but never said anything to those around them, and yet they will discuss them with perfect strangers on the Internet.

Jesus taught us to love one another, and mostly hung around people who were illiterate. They didn’t have all the knowledge we have now, and guess what? They didn’t need it. I learn a great deal about not only Catholic teachings, but the behavior of people here, that I benefit from even scholarly arguments. Jesus taught us to go beyond (notice I didn’t say ‘replace’) their dualistic-thinking about right/wrong, true/false, and get into greater truths which is the love and inclusiveness, not the divisiveness of “who’s right?”
from Matt 11:25 or Luke 10:21:
“I give praise to you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, for although you have hidden these things from the wise and the learned you have revealed them to the childlike."
Go for the things that matter, loving God and one another, and see how much of that you can glean from the posts. In between some of the sometimes harsh rhetoric, you can feel a heart of gold. It’s hidden, though, behind “intellectualism” I’ll call it. Like the bushel over the light. 😉

Alan
 
Lisa, you may find yourself less confused if, in a situation you describe, you trust those replies that are supported by the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Canon Law, papal encyclicals, and inspired scripture, rather than those that are unsupported opinion.

From the Catechism of the Catholic Church
scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s1c1a8.htm

1861 Mortal sin is a radical possibility of human freedom, as is love itself. It results in the loss of charity and the privation of sanctifying grace, that is, of the state of grace. If it is not redeemed by repentance and God’s forgiveness, it causes exclusion from Christ’s kingdom and the eternal death of hell, for our freedom has the power to make choices for ever, with no turning back. However, although we can judge that an act is in itself a grave offense, we must entrust judgment of persons to the justice and mercy of God.
 
** From the Catechism of the Catholic Church**

**Contrition **
Code:
1451 Among the penitent's acts contrition occupies first place. Contrition    is "sorrow of the soul and detestation for the sin committed, together    with the resolution not to sin again."[50]
1452 When it arises from a love by which God is loved above all else, contrition is called “perfect” (contrition of charity). Such contrition remits venial sins; it also obtains forgiveness of mortal sins if it includes the firm resolution to have recourse to sacramental confession as soon as possible.[51]

** **50 Council of Trent (1551): DS 1676.
51 Cf. Council of Trent (1551): DS 1677
.

vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p2s2c2a4.htm

That is to say, if a person honestly repents and genuinely intends to go to Confession at earliest possible time, then suddenly dies before receiving the Sacrament, then God will accept that repentance, but these intentions must be authentic and as immediate as possible
 
I think you are all missing the point. There is a divergence of opinion on these boards because everyone fails to agree with me! If people could just grasp this central point, there would be no more argument! 😃
 
I think you are all missing the point. There is a divergence of opinion on these boards because everyone fails to agree with me! If people could just grasp this central point, there would be no more argument! 😃
:bowdown:
 
I think you are all missing the point. There is a divergence of opinion on these boards because everyone fails to agree with me! If people could just grasp this central point, there would be no more argument! 😃
Greetings Hokomai,

As long as your statements are supported by Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the Teaching Authority of the Catholic Church known by the Magisterium of said Church, then we will be in agreement. 😃

God bless.
Anathama Sit
 
Greetings Hokomai,

As long as your statements are supported by Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the Teaching Authority of the Catholic Church known by the Magisterium of said Church, then we will be in agreement. 😃

God bless.
Anathama Sit
See! There you go again!😃
 
Basically, there are a lot of issue that the Church leaves open to personal opinion. The Church doesn’t define how one should vote but gives principles. Outside of the sacraments and breviary for those oblidged to pray it, the Church doesn’t say how we should pray (although certain things can be said for ways of praying that are not Christian).

Each person here comes as they are. A reasonable number of posters are connected with a religious community or authorized lay group in the Church and will hold the general position of that group. For instance: A Carmelite, a Benedictian, and a Jesuit will have their tradition of prayer that varies.

There are also a few non-Catholics but I think some disagreement must be expected from them.

Among us Catholics, nothing should be disagreed which is defined by the magisterium but the dogmatic definitions are much less than many people think. There is a certain thinking with the Church too that chould go on. Anybody with an hour and a Bible could find two apparently contradictory statements but that’s why we have a Pope.

(Others have covered your specific concern well.)

God bless you all!

In Christ,
Br Matthew, LC
 
well there are other concerns I have encountered on here that are NOT covered well.
I see several of the above posters chose to joke about this thread.

Try reading some questions and and answers on here from a variety of threads…there is a TON of different answers and viewpoints.

There really is no black and white. ANd that is a reflection of everyday catholics.

People all do what they want to do,believe what they want to believe.

It is my OPINION that nobody really follows the Chatecism to the T. And actually, I count myself in that category.
 
well there are other concerns I have encountered on here that are NOT covered well.
I see several of the above posters chose to joke about this thread.

Try reading some questions and and answers on here from a variety of threads…there is a TON of different answers and viewpoints.

There really is no black and white. ANd that is a reflection of everyday catholics.

People all do what they want to do,believe what they want to believe.

It is my OPINION that nobody really follows the Chatecism to the T. And actually, I count myself in that category.
I’m sorry if my joking around bothered you. You are right that the “absolutely correct” answers that we “must believe” often are numerous and contradictory on any given statement.

I think this is part of the way we try to “intellectualize” our faith. We all are so concerned with being right or wrong, we often fail to miss the nuances of what the Church actually teaches on any given issue. Not only that, but some refuse to accept Church teachings when they go against what they believe (for example those who insist Genesis MUST be interpreted literally – even though neither the Church, nor CA apologists say it does) but when Church teachings agree, they beat others over the head with it and tout 100% compliance to Rome.

Jesus never said we have to believe in this Church teaching and that to get to heaven. He told people how to behave toward each other and how to think about each other – the law is written on our hearts and He activated it. The early Christians had no Bible, precepts of the Church, encyclicals, councils, etc, and were mostly illiterate, and they carried on the faith just fine. Why is it that we now have rules and regulations that far exceed what the Torah must have looked like, and so many of us think we can “earn” or “learn” our way to heaven by knowing and following all of them? You really can’t put “love” down on paper in a set of rules and regulations. You can point somebody to “love,” but you can’t replace it with rules and teachings, or Jesus would not have needed to come at all.

As children, most of us were taught what to think, not how to think. Also, most of us were trained inadequately, if at all, to deal with people with different viewpoints. When we are young, if we say anything that sounds odd or unexpected, we are scolded and/or made fun of. Soon we learn the best strategy is to say what we think is expected, rather than reach for our own honest opinion. In this way I believe that most of us, as children, are actually “vaccinated” against honesty – it’s easy to pick a side and argue it but to actually be open to learning while doing so – priceless.

Alan
 
well there are other concerns I have encountered on here that are NOT covered well.
I see several of the above posters chose to joke about this thread.

Try reading some questions and and answers on here from a variety of threads…there is a TON of different answers and viewpoints.

There really is no black and white. ANd that is a reflection of everyday catholics.

People all do what they want to do,believe what they want to believe.

It is my OPINION that nobody really follows the Chatecism to the T. And actually, I count myself in that category.
Just to show that I too cab be serious: in my experience many Catholics have reservations about Church teaching. This is shown in surveys about contraception etc. Catholics also come and ago during their lives - somethings they accept the lot, sometimes less, sometimes none. They also acquire ideas from elsewhere. I’d guess that for about 20% of the posters on here their most important source of general points of view is Fox News. There is also a big variation in opinion about what is important and what is not, and to what extent. To some people the hand gestures of a priest at Mass cause as much upset as news of a new famine does to others. So people argue and debate.
 
I think you are all missing the point. There is a divergence of opinion on these boards because everyone fails to agree with me! If people could just grasp this central point, there would be no more argument! 😃
If you are 100% in agreement with the Magisterium, then this is correct.

The overabundance of viewpoints is what frustrates me about CA as well. There are so many heretics, who are in favor of contraception, sodomy, and whatever else while claiming to be Catholic, and even with the rest, if you ask any question, you get wildly difering answers, so you get to pick the one you like best (in which case, why ask the question?). So much for one holy Catholic Church!

Am I the only one who thinks the forums are way too liberal?
 
Am I the only one who thinks the forums are way too liberal?
I think they are way too literal. We argue shades of meanings of words and judge whether a bow or a sign of the cross is more “devout” but really Jesus was way more touchy-feely than He was an intellectual as far as the way He communicated with the people. He knew it all but wanted to touch hearts and transform minds, not just appeal to calculating minds.

Alan
 
Why so many viewpoints if all catholics are supposed to beleive the same stuff?
I read a question on here,an there are many different replies and answers .
Someone will quote scripture and Canon Law to back up their point.

Someone else will totally disagree with THAT point.

Why so much confusion ?
that being said, I know there isn’t a perfect answer.
I just got done reading a thread about dying in mortal sin. Some people said God can forgive and have mercy. Really? this is news to me, because i was taught UN-REPENTED mortal sin upon death means ETERNAL punishment.

Anyway, just wonderng…
God can forgive and have mercy at the last moment of their death, if they respond to the grace He gives them to have repentance. Perhaps the person who wrote otherwise failed to mention that. Some people give incomplete answers that have to be qualified to be correct.
 
my understanding the person that DIES in a state of mortal sin (without being repentant goes to HELL ) wow…I actually wrote the word HELL. You sure don’t hear that word anymore or even read about it on these forums.
You see “excluded from God’s kingdom” “everlasting punishment”

whatever happened to hell?
 
Yeah, what the hell happened to Hell? 😃

Seriously, most people don’t like to think that Hell is real or that anyone can go there. But I’m glad there’s a Hell. Otherwise, Hitler would be in Heaven. That’s a disgusting thought!

People who think there’s no Hell are claiming to know more than Jesus.
 
Yeah, what the hell happened to Hell? 😃

Seriously, most people don’t like to think that Hell is real or that anyone can go there. But I’m glad there’s a Hell. Otherwise, Hitler would be in Heaven. That’s a disgusting thought!

People who think there’s no Hell are claiming to know more than Jesus.
How do you know Hitler isn’t in Heaven? :heaven:

Alan
 
The only definite answers we can get come from the Church,

but in another light,

I love you as a brother and I share your viewpoint that we share a love and worship of God.

I hope one day I could pray the Rosary with you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top