Those who are sure their S.S.A. have passed on have reached what the Church calls ‘affective maturity’. This is a state of mental cognizance that recognises the true purpose of sexuality in God’s creation. When you have reached affective maturity, it means you are no longer focused on sexuality, outside opinions, or the vice of human respect. This state of the soul is one of Christian virtue, where the man totally conceives himself in an ordered fashion. He knows where he stands with God, what the purpose of life is, and has faith in God.
The argument is that S.S.A. prevents a man from living in affective maturity. God made things for production, reproduction, and the wondrous spread of His creation. Since homosexuality produces nothing but an insulated couple (at best), we can logically assume that God does not approve of the practice. It’s simply not in line with what we see in history, geology, biology, and reality. Things grow and produce; homosexuality is static, and reduces things over time. To feel natural as a homosexual, then, is to have not reached “affective maturity”, because the homosexual still feels he is rightly ordered.
Affective maturity is an issue for hyper-sexual heterosexuals, by the way. It’s a general human state that must be reached by anyone before considering the religious life. You cannot be a spiritual father or brother to confused people if you yourself are confused about life and God and faith. Beyond that, however, I think the Church says this: if you are able to say you conceive of yourself as a “person”, not a “homosexual”, and have reached this level for 3 or more years, with prayer and worship, you have reached affective maturity. The same goes for heterosexuals: if you can identify as a PERSON, not a sex-drive, or a “heterosexual”, or a “bar-hopper”, you have reached affective maturity.
The Church says accepted homosexuality is specifically against affective maturity, because it takes an immature understanding of the human person (i.e. “I am a homosexual”) and enshrines it as truth. Live as a single human being, a child of God, not a child of Harvey Milk or Stonewall. That realisation and central focus of the mind is maturity. Homosexuality, actively accepted and lived, is not mature because it is against all we see and know in life.