Why can't people with SSA join a religious vocation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Archangelic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Archangelic

Guest
I am the creator of the “How can we as a Church make homosexuals feel more welcome?” thread, and was going to post this question in there, but it was closed for uncharitable and off-topic discussion (this is why we can’t have nice things! :D).

Anyway, here’s my question. Why can’t people with SSA, living a chaste life, join a religious vocation? Why can’t they be ordained priests? Is there some requirement that priests be attracted to women? What’s the sense in that?

Thank you in advance, and please, RESPOND CHARITABLY.

🙂
 
Because the church has said so?

Not trying to be facetious, but that is the basic straight dope. 🤷

Perhaps, the abuse scandal has made it imprudent to do so since it appears that SSA was the temptation that caused a lot of those priests to fall.

I think that chastity is tough for almost everyone in today’s society because there’s so much relativism in the general thought processes. That makes it easier for all of us to get messed up.

I don’t know if this helps you at all, but it’s the best I have.
 
Because the church has said so?

Not trying to be facetious, but that is the basic straight dope. 🤷

Perhaps, the abuse scandal has made it imprudent to do so since it appears that SSA was the temptation that caused a lot of those priests to fall.

I think that chastity is tough for almost everyone in today’s society because there’s so much relativism in the general thought processes. That makes it easier for all of us to get messed up.

I don’t know if this helps you at all, but it’s the best I have.
Sounds good to me. 👍 My question, not to change the topic of the thread, involves why some in the laity feel the need to question Church authority and in some cases openly defy that authority. But… back on topic… I’m sure that the Church has her reasons and that is good enough for me.
 
Placing people with SSA in community with other people of the same sex seems an imprudent way to help them manage the SSA. It is for them a near occasion of sin, sadly.
 
at risk of sounding like an idiot, but what is SSA?

Also read Revelation, alot of the Mass (and other traditions) are explained in there believe it or not.

As to your question, Id like to quote Father Corapi…

“It doesnt matter if you agree with it or not. Stop complaining. Like in the Nike commercials…Just Do It!”

I like Father Corapi. Tell it like it is, Father. 👍
 
Sounds good to me. 👍 My question, not to change the topic of the thread, involves why some in the laity feel the need to question Church authority and in some cases openly defy that authority. But… back on topic… I’m sure that the Church has her reasons and that is good enough for me.
I think some folks are like little kids who throw a fit when they can’t have what they want.:crying:

Defying authority is something that we Americans tend to hold near and dear. It’s cool to be dissident, whether we’re right or wrong.

I tend to look at the Church as someone who knows better than I how to make the world a better place, and so I listen carefully to homilies at Mass and what I read from the Vatican and try to keep my life in that context. My thinking is that that would be a good idea for others as well. 🤷
 
vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccatheduc/documents/rc_con_ccatheduc_doc_20051104_istruzione_en.html

According to this it is because people with SSA are gravely hindered from relating to men and women because the tendency towards SSA is objectively disordered.

Militant is right though, it seems to be, 'Because the church says so."​

Question: When the church puts out these…what, edicts? (if that is the correct word) Is there any commentary association with them, as in explanations about why or how these decisions were formulated, or do you just get the edict and that’s that?

Alternately, do other high ranking Catholics release dissenting opinions, or is that discouraged?
 
Placing people with SSA in community with other people of the same sex seems an imprudent way to help them manage the SSA. It is for them a near occasion of sin, sadly.
Same sex attraction. I had to look it up too, lol.
 
Question: When the church puts out these…what, edicts? (if that is the correct word) Is there any commentary association with them, as in explanations about why or how these decisions were formulated, or do you just get the edict and that’s that?

Alternately, do other high ranking Catholics release dissenting opinions, or is that discouraged?
Sometimes there is. It also helps to keep an eye on the Catholic press because they often publish articles that help clarify church teaching and other stuff.

You’ll never have to worry about a lack of dissent. Especially here in the good ole USA, but a lot of that is dealt with behind the scenes.

Sometimes I get the impression that people think that the church just goes off half cocked, which is anything but true. A good example is the book I’m reading right now. ***Light of the World, ***which was subject to misrepresentation and controversy when it first came out, but in reading it myself I see the context of His Holiness’ remarks and am blown away! (Yes, I recommend it.)
 
This seems rather unfair, for one to be born into a ‘diesease’ and to not be able to discern a vocation.

What about those who refuse to accept their SSA, or those who believe that it has passed on?
 
This seems rather unfair, for one to be born into a ‘diesease’ and to not be able to discern a vocation.

What about those who refuse to accept their SSA, or those who believe that it has passed on?
That SSA is a disease (or inborn), per se, remains unestablished.

Also, the vocational discernment process is a lengthy one, precisely so that personal factors such as this will come to light.

ICXC NIKA
 
This seems rather unfair, for one to be born into a ‘diesease’ and to not be able to discern a vocation.

What about those who refuse to accept their SSA, or those who believe that it has passed on?
Even if this theory is ever proven, it does not change that this idea of “fair” is a purely human construction. God has no obligation to make us the same. He chose Mary. He chose the Jews. He chooses who he will. If someone is not given an opportunity for vocation, then that simply is not something God chose them for. It is enough that he gives us grace to obtain heaven.
 
This seems rather unfair, for one to be born into a ‘diesease’ and to not be able to discern a vocation.

What about those who refuse to accept their SSA, or those who believe that it has passed on?
Those who are sure their S.S.A. have passed on have reached what the Church calls ‘affective maturity’. This is a state of mental cognizance that recognises the true purpose of sexuality in God’s creation. When you have reached affective maturity, it means you are no longer focused on sexuality, outside opinions, or the vice of human respect. This state of the soul is one of Christian virtue, where the man totally conceives himself in an ordered fashion. He knows where he stands with God, what the purpose of life is, and has faith in God.

The argument is that S.S.A. prevents a man from living in affective maturity. God made things for production, reproduction, and the wondrous spread of His creation. Since homosexuality produces nothing but an insulated couple (at best), we can logically assume that God does not approve of the practice. It’s simply not in line with what we see in history, geology, biology, and reality. Things grow and produce; homosexuality is static, and reduces things over time. To feel natural as a homosexual, then, is to have not reached “affective maturity”, because the homosexual still feels he is rightly ordered.

Affective maturity is an issue for hyper-sexual heterosexuals, by the way. It’s a general human state that must be reached by anyone before considering the religious life. You cannot be a spiritual father or brother to confused people if you yourself are confused about life and God and faith. Beyond that, however, I think the Church says this: if you are able to say you conceive of yourself as a “person”, not a “homosexual”, and have reached this level for 3 or more years, with prayer and worship, you have reached affective maturity. The same goes for heterosexuals: if you can identify as a PERSON, not a sex-drive, or a “heterosexual”, or a “bar-hopper”, you have reached affective maturity.

The Church says accepted homosexuality is specifically against affective maturity, because it takes an immature understanding of the human person (i.e. “I am a homosexual”) and enshrines it as truth. Live as a single human being, a child of God, not a child of Harvey Milk or Stonewall. That realisation and central focus of the mind is maturity. Homosexuality, actively accepted and lived, is not mature because it is against all we see and know in life.
 
I am the creator of the “How can we as a Church make homosexuals feel more welcome?” thread, and was going to post this question in there, but it was closed for uncharitable and off-topic discussion (this is why we can’t have nice things! :D).

Anyway, here’s my question. Why can’t people with SSA, living a chaste life, join a religious vocation? Why can’t they be ordained priests? Is there some requirement that priests be attracted to women? What’s the sense in that?

Thank you in advance, and please, RESPOND CHARITABLY.

🙂
The following is from Pope Benedict’s declaration regarding Homosexuals and Holy Orders from 2005.

Vatican “instruction” of 2005-NOV:

“Concerning profoundly deep-rooted homosexual tendencies, that one discovers in a certain number of men and women, these are also objectively disordered and often constitute a trial, even for these men and women. These people must be received with respect and delicacy; one will avoid every mark of unjust discrimination with respect to them. These are called to realize the will of God in their lives and to unite to the Sacrifice of the Lord the difficulties that they may encounter.”

"The church, while deeply respecting the people in question, cannot admit to the seminary and the sacred orders those who practice homosexuality, present deeply rooted homosexual tendencies or support so-called gay culture.’’

"Those people find themselves, in fact, in a situation that presents a grave obstacle to a correct relationship with men and women. One cannot ignore the negative consequences that can stem from the ordination of people with deeply rooted homosexual tendencies.’’

"If instead it is a case of homosexual tendencies that are merely the expression of a transitory problem, for example as in the case of an unfinished adolescence, they must however have been clearly overcome for at least three years before ordination as a deacon.’’

“If a candidate practices homosexuality or present profoundly deep-rooted homosexual tendencies, his spiritual director, like his confessor, must dissuade him, in conscience, from proceeding towards Ordination.”

“It would be gravely dishonest if a candidate were to hide his own homosexuality to enter, notwithstanding everything, to Ordination. An attitude so inauthentic does not correspond to the spirit of truth, allegiance, and availability that must characterize the personality of he who believes to be called to serve Christ and His Church in the priestly ministry.”
 
This seems rather unfair, for one to be born into a ‘diesease’ and to not be able to discern a vocation.

What about those who refuse to accept their SSA, or those who believe that it has passed on?
The fact that a person may be prevented from Holy Orders or Religious life does not prevent their discerning a vocation. For some people their vocation is indeed single life. They can be very active and supportive in that way.
 
The fact that a person may be prevented from Holy Orders or Religious life does not prevent their discerning a vocation. For some people their vocation is indeed single life. They can be very active and supportive in that way.
Singlehood is not a vocation. It is the default setting. Singlehood could be the state in which one lives their vocation, but it is not a vocation in and of itself.
 
Those who are sure their S.S.A. have passed on have reached what the Church calls ‘affective maturity’. This is a state of mental cognizance that recognises the true purpose of sexuality in God’s creation. When you have reached affective maturity, it means you are no longer focused on sexuality, outside opinions, or the vice of human respect. This state of the soul is one of Christian virtue, where the man totally conceives himself in an ordered fashion. He knows where he stands with God, what the purpose of life is, and has faith in God.

The argument is that S.S.A. prevents a man from living in affective maturity. God made things for production, reproduction, and the wondrous spread of His creation. Since homosexuality produces nothing but an insulated couple (at best), we can logically assume that God does not approve of the practice. It’s simply not in line with what we see in history, geology, biology, and reality. Things grow and produce; homosexuality is static, and reduces things over time. To feel natural as a homosexual, then, is to have not reached “affective maturity”, because the homosexual still feels he is rightly ordered.

Affective maturity is an issue for hyper-sexual heterosexuals, by the way. It’s a general human state that must be reached by anyone before considering the religious life. You cannot be a spiritual father or brother to confused people if you yourself are confused about life and God and faith. Beyond that, however, I think the Church says this: if you are able to say you conceive of yourself as a “person”, not a “homosexual”, and have reached this level for 3 or more years, with prayer and worship, you have reached affective maturity. The same goes for heterosexuals: if you can identify as a PERSON, not a sex-drive, or a “heterosexual”, or a “bar-hopper”, you have reached affective maturity.

The Church says accepted homosexuality is specifically against affective maturity, because it takes an immature understanding of the human person (i.e. “I am a homosexual”) and enshrines it as truth. Live as a single human being, a child of God, not a child of Harvey Milk or Stonewall. That realisation and central focus of the mind is maturity. Homosexuality, actively accepted and lived, is not mature because it is against all we see and know in life.
What about a homosexual who wants nothing to do with the lifestyle?
 
Singlehood is not a vocation. It is the default setting. Singlehood could be the state in which one lives their vocation, but it is not a vocation in and of itself.
Not quite, I think. Some people do feel called to the single life, as an affirmation - not as a default, an accident, or a compensation. They may come to this realization after having discerned that they are not called to religious life, but are called to a celibate single life, and in that life may dedicate themselves to self-giving service such as one of the service professions (social work, non-profit work, education, advocacy work, lay ministry, or even overseas medical work). And naturally that would not be limited to Catholics, of course.
 
What about a homosexual who wants nothing to do with the lifestyle?
From the document:

"If instead it is a case of homosexual tendencies that are merely the expression of a transitory problem, for example as in the case of an unfinished adolescence, they must however have been clearly overcome for at least three years before ordination as a deacon.’’

🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top