Why can't prayers be scientifically proven?

  • Thread starter Thread starter honestquestions
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I clicked the first url, which took me to a forum, clicked the first link showing in it at the top which offered no medical study but rather the words of the pope, so I went back to the forum scrolled quickly through that page and could not see any other links or long text which discussed such a study. Therefore, after feeling the credibility has just lowered, I didn’t take more time to click the second link.
Perhaps the answer was in the thread itself. :)😉
 
This refers to the same study to which I cited the post before yours, and it does not conclude that knowing somebody is praying for you makes you worse.
Your link must be showing something mine is not. Maybe I am in need of glasses, after all it is my birthday in 40 minutes, and getting older has it’s benefits as well as drawbacks.
 
I deeply apologize for my late reply to your answer, but I have not had much time for CA lately! So, once again, I am very sorry that this reply is so late! 😦
Granting all prayers is not a proof of the effective nature of prayer.
Then what would be proof to you of the efficacious results of prayer?
We can all agree that the catholic church claims God grants prayers that are in his will.

His will is to allow for suffering.
Yes. God does allow suffering. God allows suffering because our first parents chose suffering.
He has the perfect set up then. Even a prayer you would think would be in his will like saving a good single parent from cancer so they could raise their child would be in his will. But wait, it may not be. Perhaps a greater good can come of their death you may say.
God’s primary concern is the salvation of the soul. A greater good may come out of the death of the parent. Who can say? You and I do not see all things, therefore we do not see as clearly as God.
A parent prays for their child’s saftey while they are off at university. They get gang raped at a party. You would think the parent’s prayer was in God’s will.
A person’s child getting gang-raped has nothing to do with God. God has given us free will. He will not prevent a person (or a group of people) from executing their free will, even if that free will leads to a grave sin.
Let’s not forget that God did not even execute his authority to prevent the execution of the free will of the executioners of his Only Begotten Son.
But, wait. Perhaps a greater good can come out of this you may say.
No. Not everything that happens results in a greater good, especially in the aforementioned scenario. However, God has given us this world and free will as gifts. What we do with these gifts is our choice, not God’s.
I can go on for the entire course of human history this way. Loaded with all sorts of sufferings meant for some greater good. How much more suffering is for this so called good? And how good will it really be?
Not all suffering is toward a greater good. For example, the tragedy of the Holocaust did not effect any “greater good”. It was a tragic and grave misuse of human free will, given to us by God, in order to destroy human life. It had nothing to do with God, other than that God allowed the perpetrators to exercise their free will.
In the case of cancer, disease, epidemics, etc… some of that we can only say “was the will of God”, who is all-knowing and therefore truly does know far better than you or me what is for the greater good. However, many of these things also fall under the misuse of human free will. If a power-plant manager exercises their free will and decides to poison a city’s drinking water with toxins and nuclear waste, and the inhabitants of the city proceed to develop severe illnesses, whose fault is that: the power-plant manager’s or God’s? I could go on and on through all of history with examples of tragedies being caused by misuse of God’s gifts to us.
 
“And going on a little further, he fell upon his face, praying, and saying: My Father, if it be possible, let this chalice pass from me. Nevertheless not as I will, but as thou will”
(Matt 26:39)

“Many people would be ready to accept suffering as long as they were not inconvenienced by it” (St Francis de Sales)

“I have had crosses in plenty - more than I could carry, almost. I set myself to ask for the love of crosses - then I was happy” (St John Vianney)

Pope Benedict XV1 was recently asked to explain suffering. He answered it is a great mystery.

To pray as one ought one needs baptism into the Body of Christ. Christ suffered, why should we choose the opposite?
 
We are beginning to stray a bit from the OP into the related idea of the Will of God (as it relates to prayer requests).

I cannot help but to interject here with a reference to one of my favourite books, Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence
It is quite obvious that He who hath founded the earth by wisdom and hath established the heavens by understanding8 could not show less perfection in governing His works than in creating them. So, as He is careful to remind us, if his Providence continues to have care of all things,9 it is in measure and number and weight,10 it is with justice and mercy.11 Neither can any man say to him, Why dost thou so?12 For if He assigns to His creatures the end that He wills, and chooses the means which seem good to Him to lead them to it, the end He assigns them must be good and wise, nor can He direct them towards their end other than by good and wise means. Therefore do not become foolish …
  1. GOD CONTROLS ALL EVENTS, WHETHER GOOD OR BAD
Nothing happens in the the universe without God willing and allowing it. This statement must he taken absolutely of everything with the exception of sin. ‘Nothing occurs by chance in the whole course of our lives’ is the unanimous teaching of the Fathers and Doctors of the Church, ‘and God intervenes everywhere.’
This wonderful little book dives into the topic of God’s will verses what we experience as ‘evil’.

In prayer we must always conform to the Holy Will of God, Who alone knows what is best for our immortal souls, and not simply expect to get a ‘yes’ to every request.
(The analogy that I thought of when I was quite young is comparing God to a good parent. A good mother or father will not always say ‘yes’ to each request for another cookie – the parents know how many cookies are good for their little children.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top