Why Can't We Just Read the Bible?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Big_Dummy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Basically, he’s arguing for tradition, except he insists the Bible is “final authority.” He says if you don’t build upon sound interpretations in history, you’re always starting from scratch. Apparently he’s encountered some people who want the original Hebrew/Greek only with no commentaries or outside help in interpreting other than their own reading of the text. In one sense, he’s a step above some sola scripturists. But on another sense, he still falls short because some of the interpreters in history he puts in good tradition are “Luther” and “Calvin.” So whose tradition do you consider to be true to the Scripture?

It seems to me he’s reflecting the following in the Westminster Confession of Faith:*1.10 The supreme judge by which all controversies of religion are to be determined, and all decrees of councils, opinions of ancient writers, doctrines of men, and private spirits, are to be examined, and in whose sentence we are to rest, can be no other but the Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture.*In other words, it’s ok to examine historical sola scripturist’s interpretations, but their interpretations should be subject to your so-called “Holy-Spirit-guided” interpretation, rendering the ultimate authority as “whoever happens to be living in the present.” And then tomorrow a new sola scripturist will decide your interpretation didn’t pass muster. :rolleyes:
 
the question is, how do we interpret the Bible? Protestants interpret it individually, and that obviously causes a lot of division… the Bible says that the Church is the “pillar and the foundation of truth” - the Church interprets the Bible through Tradition.
 
Let’s put it this way:
think of the Bible as the U.S. Constitution and the Church as the Supreme Court.

If we had no Supreme Court to determine if a law or action is considered unconstitutional, then the U.S. would be nothing more than a confederate nation of states, with separate constitutional rules and interpretations. Additionally, these separate constitutions may be either strictly interpreted or liberally implied. You can see, then, how this can not work for the United States. We need some unity to hold us together as a nation, or we’d be falling apart.

This is the case for the Church. The Bible should be interpreted by her to keep unity and universalism throughout. One can easily see how many Protestant sub-denominations there are. This is because there is no authority to say what is orthodox and what is heretical.
 
In other words, it’s ok to examine historical sola scripturist’s interpretations, but their interpretations should be subject to your so-called “Holy-Spirit-guided” interpretation, rendering the ultimate authority as “whoever happens to be living in the present.” And then tomorrow a new sola scripturist will decide your interpretation didn’t pass muster. :rolleyes:
👍
 
their interpretations should be subject to your so-called “Holy-Spirit-guided” interpretation, rendering the ultimate authority as “whoever happens to be living in the present.”
Right. And, of course, if the interpretation is truly “Spirit-guided” then it cannot be in error. In other words, it must be infallible (free from error).

Protestants claim that the Pope cannot be infallible because he is “just a man.” Yet, they claim personal infallibility all the time with their “Spirit-guided” interpretations.

So it seems the only person who is NOT infallible is the Pope.

Hmmmmm.
 
The Scott – your analogy is a very good one. The Church plays an important and legitimate role in teaching and instructing Christians. It’s not just a bunch of individuals sitting reading the Bible by themselves, divorced from the teaching of the Church. But by the same token, let’s think about the judicial example you raise. It’s been scarcely over 200 years since the Constitution was ratified. In that short time (and really most of the damage has been done in in more recent years, after those who knew the framers of the Constitution had died) the Supreme Court has twisted the Fourteenth Amendment into a provision that purportedly creates a right to abortion found nowhere in its text, warped the Establishment Clause from being a federalism provision designed to prevent the federal government from intruding upon State establishments into a categorical prohibition against the States from doing anything that could be perceived as advancing religion, and manufactured countless other similarly unwarranted novelties under the guise of “construing” the Constitution. And again, it has done all that in only about 200 years (half that for the Reconstruction amendments, where most of the damage has been done). Using the analogy you raise, that would take us to about the year 300 with regard to the Christian Church (about 200 years after the completion of the last New Testament book). Take the judicial activism we’ve seen by the Supreme Court and extrapolate it for another 1,700 years or so and imagine what the “Constitution” would look like after activist Supreme Courts have at it for that long.

All this is not just taking an overly litteralistic application of your Supreme Court analogy. It is precisely the same concern that Protestants have about the Catholic approach. There’s no evil conspiracy to mess anything up, but over hundreds (and thousands) of years, problems can arise, become entrenched, and then develop lives of their own through sequential doctrinal developments building on one another – just like one modestly bad Supreme Court decision can lead to a whole line of bad judicial precedents that end up being terrible in the aggregate.

In my opinion, these sorts of considerations are exactly the sort of issues that need to be thought about, which is why your analogy is helpful. Do we need the Church to act in an institutional teaching capacity, and is it intended to serve that function? I think so, much like the American judiciary’s decisionmaking role. Does that role need to involve infallibility, and is there good, solid evidence that such infallibility was conferred upon the Church? Well, that’s what we need to think about. The Supreme Court is not infallible, and does not need to be in order to do the job it was assigned.

Best regards,

CThomas
 
The Church plays an important and legitimate role in teaching and instructing Christians. It’s not just a bunch of individuals sitting reading the Bible by themselves, divorced from the teaching of the Church.
Without getting into a discussion on which church or what your definition of the Chruch is, what happens when an individual or group of protestants disagree with what the Church teaches? What role does the Church play in that situation? Is there any authority within the Church than can bind the individual’s conscience to a matter of faith or morals if the person honestly disagrees?
 
With regard to David’s comment earlier regarding evangelical Protestants view of the Pope let me just say this.

Many evangelical Protestants who claim to be sola scriptura in their viewpoints actually form their theology around what their pastor said in his sermon the past Sunday. In fact, many evangelical Protestants while making the claim for infallibility will hold up their pastors as mini-popes whose interpretation is absolutely reliable.

The sad fact is, as the article by Michael Horton above pointed out that many Christians don’t bother to read more then one or two verses of Scripture a day and therefor don’t see the Bible as a unified whole.

Again, referring back to the article, most of us tend to come to the Bible with our “denominational glasses” on whether we are Protestant or Catholic or Orthodox. I think the first and most important answer to this problem is to actually read the Bible in the first place.

In Christ,

George Everson
 
The Scott – your analogy is a very good one. The Church plays an important and legitimate role in teaching and instructing Christians. It’s not just a bunch of individuals sitting reading the Bible by themselves, divorced from the teaching of the Church. But by the same token, let’s think about the judicial example you raise. It’s been scarcely over 200 years since the Constitution was ratified. In that short time (and really most of the damage has been done in in more recent years, after those who knew the framers of the Constitution had died) the Supreme Court has twisted the Fourteenth Amendment into a provision that purportedly creates a right to abortion found nowhere in its text, warped the Establishment Clause from being a federalism provision designed to prevent the federal government from intruding upon State establishments into a categorical prohibition against the States from doing anything that could be perceived as advancing religion, and manufactured countless other similarly unwarranted novelties under the guise of “construing” the Constitution. And again, it has done all that in only about 200 years (half that for the Reconstruction amendments, where most of the damage has been done). Using the analogy you raise, that would take us to about the year 300 with regard to the Christian Church (about 200 years after the completion of the last New Testament book). Take the judicial activism we’ve seen by the Supreme Court and extrapolate it for another 1,700 years or so and imagine what the “Constitution” would look like after activist Supreme Courts have at it for that long.

All this is not just taking an overly litteralistic application of your Supreme Court analogy. It is precisely the same concern that Protestants have about the Catholic approach. There’s no evil conspiracy to mess anything up, but over hundreds (and thousands) of years, problems can arise, become entrenched, and then develop lives of their own through sequential doctrinal developments building on one another – just like one modestly bad Supreme Court decision can lead to a whole line of bad judicial precedents that end up being terrible in the aggregate.

In my opinion, these sorts of considerations are exactly the sort of issues that need to be thought about, which is why your analogy is helpful. Do we need the Church to act in an institutional teaching capacity, and is it intended to serve that function? I think so, much like the American judiciary’s decisionmaking role. Does that role need to involve infallibility, and is there good, solid evidence that such infallibility was conferred upon the Church? Well, that’s what we need to think about. The Supreme Court is not infallible, and does not need to be in order to do the job it was assigned.

Best regards,

CThomas
Three things you are forgetting (unintentionally, I’m sure) is that the Supreme Court analogy is just that–an analogy, not a perfect representation of the Magisterium and the Bible. The second thing is that the Supreme Court was never given the charism of infallibility in matters of the law. However, the Apostles were given that charism by Christ himself. The third thing is the NT was written and compiled by the Church. It is a product of the Church, not vice versa. And the OT is the witness to God’s creative act and authority over men, which he passed on to Moses and his successor–the Christ, who in turn passed it on to the Church. So, the Church cannot go wrong in its interpretation of God’s written word, since it is the guardian of it and the only authority God established to teach it and preach it.
 
Good point Della, if the church is so corrupt, how can it maintain the manuscripts of the Bible without corruptting them? He should be thanking the catholic and orthodox churches for maintaining the biblical manuscripts. Proof of the correctness of the manuscripts one need only point out how close the Isaiah manuscript in the dead sea scrolls are to modern manuscripts written by catholics, orthodox and Jewish scholars.
 
Della, thanks for the response. I appreciate the points you make, but I do need to point out that they beg the question under discussion. To say that the two are different because the Church, unlike the judiciary “cannot go wrong in its interpretation of God’s written word” is the very point in dispute, and thus really should not be cited as a distinction without independent support. As a side note, the statement that the New Testament “is a product of the Church” is ambiguous. In one sense, this is trivially true – the documents were written by Christians, and hence were produce by the Church. But I hope you don’t mean that this is true in the sense that it was the Church’s selection of which documents to include in the canon that rendered them scripture, as if they just picked, say, the Gospel according to Matthew out of a hat and might just as easily have picked, say, the Infancy Gospel, which then would have been part of the Bible instead. Of course, Christians recognized the books of the Bible as scripture before there was any formal Church action taken to recognize them, and did so based upon their apostolic authorship (or supervision). It’s certainly not the case that people were sitting around wondering whether, say, John or Acts or Romans were inspired documents until a formal promulgation was issued by the Magisterium. I don’t think any of the foregoing is really in dispute by any side to this debate.

Best regards, and thanks again for the kind response.

CThomas
 
Murphy – thanks for the response. I believe that the Christian Church has a legitimate teaching and disciplinary authority. No question. The question is whether it is infallible. I have not yet found any adequate evidence to support that conclusion, and (what I believe to be) many very good reasons to suppose it is not. So if you believe that the Church has those roles but is fallible, the key is to maintain controls, to the extent possible, by putting God’s word at the forefront and always striving (inevitably imperfectly) to conform teachings, beliefs, and conduct to those divinely ordained standards. That’s my answer to your question in a nutshell. For what it’s worth, I think it is representative of the mainstream of Protestant Christian thought (although there are a diversity of opinions, of course).

Best regards.

CThomas
 
Della, thanks for the response. I appreciate the points you make, but I do need to point out that they beg the question under discussion. To say that the two are different because the Church, unlike the judiciary “cannot go wrong in its interpretation of God’s written word” is the very point in dispute, and thus really should not be cited as a distinction without independent support. As a side note, the statement that the New Testament “is a product of the Church” is ambiguous. In one sense, this is trivially true – the documents were written by Christians, and hence were produce by the Church. But I hope you don’t mean that this is true in the sense that it was the Church’s selection of which documents to include in the canon that rendered them scripture, as if they just picked, say, the Gospel according to Matthew out of a hat and might just as easily have picked, say, the Infancy Gospel, which then would have been part of the Bible instead. Of course, Christians recognized the books of the Bible as scripture before there was any formal Church action taken to recognize them, and did so based upon their apostolic authorship (or supervision). It’s certainly not the case that people were sitting around wondering whether, say, John or Acts or Romans were inspired documents until a formal promulgation was issued by the Magisterium. I don’t think any of the foregoing is really in dispute by any side to this debate.

Best regards, and thanks again for the kind response.

CThomas
Firstly, what “independent support” for the Church’s stance on infallibility would you accept? Why not the words of Jesus himself–or are they too ambiguous, as well? Who else did he mean when he told the Apostles that the Holy Spirit would lead them into all truth and guide them? Who else did he mean when he commissioned the Apostles to be his witnesses to the whole world? It’s your position that begs those questions. 🙂

And the books of the Bible were compiled by the Church because there was dispute over what should be included in the canon. That’s plain historical fact. It was the Catholic Church that did that. It was ordered by a pope and accomplished because of that order. It wasn’t considered to be that big a problem, though until the Reformers started to object to some books not yet formally included in the OT canon, and thus the decision of the Council of Trent to make them a formal part of it. That’s the Church in action–reacting to the needs of the times, just as Jesus intended that it should.

As to Scripture being the standard against which all beliefs need to be tested, where did that idea come from? It certainly isn’t in the Bible, nor is a tenet of Sacred Tradition. It’s a Protestant idea that came into existence with the Reformation. No one believed that for 16 centuries in Church history. The Scriptures are a large part of Sacred Tradition, but they are not the whole of it. And yes, they are definitely consulted whenever the Magisterium rules on matters of faith and morals, but they are not and never were a “proof text” for doctrine/dogma. That’s a complete invention with no historical basis at all.
 
Della, good to hear from you again. On your first question (what would I accept as valid evidence), I’m not dogmatic about it. I’m open to any sort of argument, so long as it is persuasive. It need not be super-explicit or ridiculously straightforward – I’m open to looking seriously at any argument and accepting it if it makes a good point. The two biblical passages you allude to don’t do it for me, for reasons you are undoubtedly familiar with if you’re interested in apologetics. For what it’s worth, I am not Protestant out of bias or due to birth. I was raised a non-Christian, and when I became Christian I tried my best to study whether Catholicism was the correct form of Christianity. I didn’t (and don’t) feel any animus against Catholicism, but simply was not persuaded. I don’t say that because it makes me necessarily correct (I’m the last to claim infallibility!), but only to rebut the implication (I think) of your question that I am dogmatic and biased.

Anyway, as to your second point, which has to do with the Bible, I assume we agree that there was dispute only over a few of the NT books, and that the vast majority of them were recognized as scripture before any Church action was taken to so designate them. By itself, that shows – to my mind – that the Church did not cause them to be scripture by its decisions. Most NT books were recognized as such in the absence of such action. And, to the extent the Church had a role in facilitating the process of reaching consensus on the few in dispute, it did not do so arbitrarily, but by determining which really did enjoy apostolic authority by virtue of their authorship. That is, they ascertained true facts about the NT books that were true simply by virtue of who wrote them. I don’t believe anyone suggests that, say, Second Peter wasn’t scripture until the Church declared it to be, at which time it turned into scripture. It was always scripture, from the moment it was written, right?

Last, you ask me to justify the claim that scripture is “the standard against which all beliefs need to be tested.” I’m afraid you’re asking me to justify a belief I don’t hold. I can’t imagine anyone thinking that all beliefs need to be tested against the Bible. What does the Bible teach about, say, American history? What does it teach about quantum electrodynamics? What does it teach about modern English grammar? There are countless things about which the Bible is silent. I can’t imagine someone saying that all beliefs need to be tested against scripture. I would only suggest that if one believes that the Bible was inspired by God, and that the NT was written by the apostles of Christ, then you should want to be consistent with it in your theological views, to the extent you can. I’m sure we both agree on that point.

Best regards,

CThomas
 
Della, good to hear from you again. On your first question (what would I accept as valid evidence), I’m not dogmatic about it. I’m open to any sort of argument, so long as it is persuasive. It need not be super-explicit or ridiculously straightforward – I’m open to looking seriously at any argument and accepting it if it makes a good point. The two biblical passages you allude to don’t do it for me, for reasons you are undoubtedly familiar with if you’re interested in apologetics. For what it’s worth, I am not Protestant out of bias or due to birth. I was raised a non-Christian, and when I became Christian I tried my best to study whether Catholicism was the correct form of Christianity. I didn’t (and don’t) feel any animus against Catholicism, but simply was not persuaded. I don’t say that because it makes me necessarily correct (I’m the last to claim infallibility!), but only to rebut the implication (I think) of your question that I am dogmatic and biased.
I’m sorry I gave the impression you are dogmatic and biased–it’s not at all what I intended. Sorry about that. 😊 I asked what you would consider valid evidence because I really wanted to know. I don’t see an answer to that question in your response, but I do not demand that you answer. This is a discussion forum and not the Inquisition, after all. 😉 It’s a question you may want to thrash out for yourself, though. And, if you’d like to start a new thread on why you were not convinced by the Church’s claims, we’d be happy to discuss it with you. 🙂
Anyway, as to your second point, which has to do with the Bible, I assume we agree that there was dispute only over a few of the NT books, and that the vast majority of them were recognized as scripture before any Church action was taken to so designate them. By itself, that shows – to my mind – that the Church did not cause them to be scripture by its decisions. Most NT books were recognized as such in the absence of such action. And, to the extent the Church had a role in facilitating the process of reaching consensus on the few in dispute, it did not do so arbitrarily, but by determining which really did enjoy apostolic authority by virtue of their authorship. That is, they ascertained true facts about the NT books that were true simply by virtue of who wrote them. I don’t believe anyone suggests that, say, Second Peter wasn’t scripture until the Church declared it to be, at which time it turned into scripture. It was always scripture, from the moment it was written, right?
I agree. The Church never intended, by forming the canon, to say that it had the authority to declare as God’s word whatever it included in the canon. It was, rather, saying that we know these are Scripture, because of certain criteria that makes it God’s word, therefore we include it in the canon. What some people think, though is that the Bible is a proof text, because it is Scripture. That is not the Bible’s purpose, I just wanted to make it clear that the Church does not and never has viewed it that way.
Last, you ask me to justify the claim that scripture is “the standard against which all beliefs need to be tested.” I’m afraid you’re asking me to justify a belief I don’t hold. I can’t imagine anyone thinking that all beliefs need to be tested against the Bible. What does the Bible teach about, say, American history? What does it teach about quantum electrodynamics? What does it teach about modern English grammar? There are countless things about which the Bible is silent. I can’t imagine someone saying that all beliefs need to be tested against scripture. I would only suggest that if one believes that the Bible was inspired by God, and that the NT was written by the apostles of Christ, then you should want to be consistent with it in your theological views, to the extent you can. I’m sure we both agree on that point.
Best regards,
I have to say that I definitely got the impression that you hold Scripture up as the final standard in matters of faith and morals. Since you say that’s not the case, I believe you, of course. So, that begs the question, what standard do you hold to test what is and what isn’t sound teaching in matters of faith and morals. Once again, you don’t have to answer me. It’s a question for your own researches. As for me (and I say this in all humility knowing that I have no special insight from God) that I found my answer to both questions I’ve posed in the Catholic Church after understanding what the Church is, the Bible’s place within it, and the authority Christ gave to it as his very Body and Witness on earth. These aren’t my claims–they’re the claims of the Church. If they are right and true, which I am convinced they are, then they deserve my allegiance, which I have given and never regretted it in any circumstance of my life since. Just a bit of personal witness there as a former Episcopalian turned Pentecostalist who came home to the Catholic Church 21 years ago. 🙂
 
Della – thanks for the response. I’m undoubtedly the one that owes an apology. Tone can be hard to read over these message boards. It sounds like we may not be as far apart on some of these questions as I had thought. I’m not sure how to answer your question more specifically about what it would take to convince me. It’s like asking you, e.g., “What would it take to convince you that the claims of Islam are true?” I’m not sure how I would answer that, other than to say some good, valid evidence and arguments that I’ve never seen before. (This is not to equate Catholicism with Islam – it’s just an example trying to show why I find the question difficult to answer.) Certainly if I saw an argument grounded in the biblical texts that I found persuasively supported the Catholic claims of magisterial infallibility, I would accept that conclusion. Not sure how else to answer. Happy to consider any argument you would care to present, and I promise I will give it sincere and careful consideration.

On the last point, when you add in “on matters of faith and morals,” that does get closer to my view of the Bible, although I have the sense that the phrase “faith and morals” may be a technical term to Catholics, so I would want to be careful about using that term without being very clear about what exactly it connotes. Certainly I can’t think of any higher or better source than the revealed word of God in the OT and the NT. My main quibble with your initial formulation was the unlimited scope – as noted, there are surely all manner of things about which the Bible simply does not give us information.

Thanks again for your polite response, and regards.

CThomas
 
Della – thanks for the response. I’m undoubtedly the one that owes an apology. Tone can be hard to read over these message boards. It sounds like we may not be as far apart on some of these questions as I had thought. I’m not sure how to answer your question more specifically about what it would take to convince me. It’s like asking you, e.g., “What would it take to convince you that the claims of Islam are true?” I’m not sure how I would answer that, other than to say some good, valid evidence and arguments that I’ve never seen before. (This is not to equate Catholicism with Islam – it’s just an example trying to show why I find the question difficult to answer.) Certainly if I saw an argument grounded in the biblical texts that I found persuasively supported the Catholic claims of magisterial infallibility, I would accept that conclusion. Not sure how else to answer. Happy to consider any argument you would care to present, and I promise I will give it sincere and careful consideration.
Thank you for your gracious reply. 🙂 I bolded the words above because I think this the crux of the matter. If I am mistaken, the rest of my words may be irrelevant, but I’ll take a stab it it anyway. The Church’s authority to magisterial infallibility doesn’t stand or fall on the biblical text. If it did it would definitely be ambiguous. Certainly the Church refers to particular verses (not taken out of context for that purpose, which is very important to note), but no verses are used by the Church as proof texts. The Bible is the witness to the authority of the Church, not the proof of it. This is a very important distinction. We have to remember that the Church existed in the persons of the Apostles long before one word of the NT was written. Indeed, Jesus never commissioned a collection of writings nor did he give any directions that any such writings would speak for him. He ordained Apostles and commissioned them–men–to be guided by the Holy Spirit. It is the Church that is the “household of God which is the church, the pillar and bulwark of the truth”, as St. Paul tells us in 1 Tim 3:15. For many years I too thought everything I should believe had to have an explicit reference in Scripture. That’s simply not the case because Scripture is a part of Sacred Tradition from which it sprang, not the other way around. This is extremely important for if the Church is what is claims to be then we owe it our obedience as the Body of Christ, his voice on earth.
On the last point, when you add in “on matters of faith and morals,” that does get closer to my view of the Bible, although I have the sense that the phrase “faith and morals” may be a technical term to Catholics, so I would want to be careful about using that term without being very clear about what exactly it connotes. Certainly I can’t think of any higher or better source than the revealed word of God in the OT and the NT. My main quibble with your initial formulation was the unlimited scope – as noted, there are surely all manner of things about which the Bible simply does not give us information.
Thanks again for your polite response, and regards.
Yes, the phrase “matters of faith and morals” is a Catholic one–because the Church claims no more authority for itself than that. It does not decide matters of science or history or philosophy, etc. All those things may play a part in the sorts of issues it does have authority in, of course, but they are not within the purview of Church matters, per se. I didn’t intend to imply any more scope than that–once again the limits of the written word within the post limits of this forum came between us. I hope I have clarified things and been helpful. 🙂

All the best,
Della
 
Thanks, Della. Your message was helpful indeed, and in light of it I will amend the bolded language to read as follows: “Certainly if I saw an argument, whether or not grounded in the biblical texts, that I found persuasively supported the Catholic claims of magisterial infallibility, I would accept that conclusion.”

Thanks again, and best regards.

CThomas
 
Thanks, Della. Your message was helpful indeed, and in light of it I will amend the bolded language to read as follows: “Certainly if I saw an argument, whether or not grounded in the biblical texts, that I found persuasively supported the Catholic claims of magisterial infallibility, I would accept that conclusion.”

Thanks again, and best regards.

CThomas
You’re welcome. So, what you may want to ask yourself is why the evidence we have isn’t persuasive. None of us can go back in time to see events for ourselves. We must rely on the witness of history. The best witness to Church history is the Church Fathers. Wading one’s way through them all would be quite the task, although reliable scholars have done so. Their conclusions are that the Church’s claims are valid. I’m no expert in this area, though. You may want to start a thread to ask for resources regarding the Church Fathers.

All the best,
Della
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top