The Scott – your analogy is a very good one. The Church plays an important and legitimate role in teaching and instructing Christians. It’s not just a bunch of individuals sitting reading the Bible by themselves, divorced from the teaching of the Church. But by the same token, let’s think about the judicial example you raise. It’s been scarcely over 200 years since the Constitution was ratified. In that short time (and really most of the damage has been done in in more recent years, after those who knew the framers of the Constitution had died) the Supreme Court has twisted the Fourteenth Amendment into a provision that purportedly creates a right to abortion found nowhere in its text, warped the Establishment Clause from being a federalism provision designed to prevent the federal government from intruding upon State establishments into a categorical prohibition against the States from doing anything that could be perceived as advancing religion, and manufactured countless other similarly unwarranted novelties under the guise of “construing” the Constitution. And again, it has done all that in only about 200 years (half that for the Reconstruction amendments, where most of the damage has been done). Using the analogy you raise, that would take us to about the year 300 with regard to the Christian Church (about 200 years after the completion of the last New Testament book). Take the judicial activism we’ve seen by the Supreme Court and extrapolate it for another 1,700 years or so and imagine what the “Constitution” would look like after activist Supreme Courts have at it for that long.
All this is not just taking an overly litteralistic application of your Supreme Court analogy. It is precisely the same concern that Protestants have about the Catholic approach. There’s no evil conspiracy to mess anything up, but over hundreds (and thousands) of years, problems can arise, become entrenched, and then develop lives of their own through sequential doctrinal developments building on one another – just like one modestly bad Supreme Court decision can lead to a whole line of bad judicial precedents that end up being terrible in the aggregate.
In my opinion, these sorts of considerations are exactly the sort of issues that need to be thought about, which is why your analogy is helpful. Do we need the Church to act in an institutional teaching capacity, and is it intended to serve that function? I think so, much like the American judiciary’s decisionmaking role. Does that role need to involve infallibility, and is there good, solid evidence that such infallibility was conferred upon the Church? Well, that’s what we need to think about. The Supreme Court is not infallible, and does not need to be in order to do the job it was assigned.
Best regards,
CThomas