S
scylla
Guest
Since this was off topic I decided to start a new thread. I like to ask questions like this as it exposes a lot and is good for discussion. Every practice should be examined per Vatican II to full express our faith. Sometime this has not been done and Vatican II has been misrepresented.
(removing altar rails, stuff like that)
Lets talk about Communion in the hand…
There are separated ecclesiastical communities that share some Christian elements, some here in the United States who have no idea that their faith traditions started just a bit ago.
I fully trust Holy Mother Church who in Her wisdom has allowed different practices, for many reasons. Sometimes prudence, sometimes pastoral, to curb abuse, many reasons.
I still seek the answer, why desire to receive in the hand? Is there a Christian reason which makes it superior to the traditional practice of receiving on the tongue. Please no antiquarianism, or human reasons, just give a Christian reason.
If there is none, that is ok, just be honest.
(Father Richard McBrien is honest enough to say that he rejects the structure of the Church and sees it as a power struggle)
Thanks,
Scylla
(removing altar rails, stuff like that)
Lets talk about Communion in the hand…
A Christian reason is a Catholic reason they are one and the same. Catholics are the original Christians the fullness of the Christian faith. I should have been more clear, as a Catholic they are synonymous for Catholics.I am not sure why on needs to have a Christian reason as well as a Catholic reason for their choice of how to receive Holy Communion.
Can we not trust the HMC, who has provided us with these options and deemed them equally appropriate methods and equally revererent?
There are separated ecclesiastical communities that share some Christian elements, some here in the United States who have no idea that their faith traditions started just a bit ago.
I fully trust Holy Mother Church who in Her wisdom has allowed different practices, for many reasons. Sometimes prudence, sometimes pastoral, to curb abuse, many reasons.
I still seek the answer, why desire to receive in the hand? Is there a Christian reason which makes it superior to the traditional practice of receiving on the tongue. Please no antiquarianism, or human reasons, just give a Christian reason.
If there is none, that is ok, just be honest.
(Father Richard McBrien is honest enough to say that he rejects the structure of the Church and sees it as a power struggle)
Thanks,
Scylla