Why did Christ have to die for us?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teneas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Suffer the forum, Earnest. Endure. No matter how many times you post and someone challenges you back, (in every exchange) know that truth was conveyed to someone, somehow…a seed has been planted which will make someone want to study and know more.

If I am the enemy; a false prophet; the darkness, know that I must exist so that God’s truth can disprove me and shine through. [1 Thessalonians 5:21]

So Heed your own words about being emotional and press on.

If God calls of you to post - over and over - to eventually win souls, then that is your task…regardless if it seems futile or a waste of time. It is not your will but the Father’s that is done. If He is (truly) important to you then you won’t stop.
 
This may look like a rebuke only if taken as such, but I must say that it isn’t, and is so far from what I wanted to convey that I think my posting here is a waste of time.

This was my intent: . . .
Earnest,

It did seem like a rebuke, but I was not offended.

I am a Protestant who is searching and I’ve learned a lot here from Catholics and non-Catholics. Still, there are many beliefs in Catholicism that I don’t think I could ever embrace.

I may have some less than traditional Protestant views, and in some things I agree with Catholics. Still, I have had many personal experiences with the work and power of the Holy Spirit; and I do believe the Holy Spirit speaks to the individual. I also believe that our infinite God may use passages of Scripture in an infinite number of ways.

I know the passage in Matthew Chapter 16, is interpreted by the Catholic Church as speaking to the authority of the Church. Yet, I have had experiences with this passage, as an individual; and I do believe that we can ask for the binding or loosing of things as an individual.

Matthew Chapter 16:18-19 (English Standard Version)

18And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. 19 I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."

I realize that there are many different beliefs among Protestants, and that can be a problem. Yet, there are some core beliefs that are common among many. I do have faith that God will plant my feet in the right place.

I think the two main issues that would keep me from embracing Catholicism are the role of the Pope and the role of Mary. I think this is the case for many Protestants. I have seen many misconceptions cleared up on the forums, but these remain major obstacles as far as Catholicism is concerned.

I’ve been giving all of this a lot of thought in the past few weeks.

I will say, that I have seen very insightful responses, from Catholics, regarding the topic of this thread. I started a Thread, previously, asking the same basic question of why Christ had to die. So, these two threads were very helpful.

I’m am praying about all this. I know what you mean about the forums taking so much time. These forums have been a lifeline for me, when I needed it most; but for the last few weeks, I have been thinking about taking a break from the forums. It does take a great deal of time. I need to go deeper into my study, and prayerfully consider where God wants me to be and what he wants me to do with my life.

I did appreciate your posts. So, they were not wasted effort.

May God bless you,
Anna
 
Earnest,

It did seem like a rebuke, but I was not offended.

I am a Protestant who is searching and I’ve learned a lot here from Catholics and non-Catholics. Still, there are many beliefs in Catholicism that I don’t think I could ever embrace.

I may have some less than traditional Protestant views, and in some things I agree with Catholics. Still, I have had many personal experiences with the work and power of the Holy Spirit; and I do believe the Holy Spirit speaks to the individual. I also believe that our infinite God may use passages of Scripture in an infinite number of ways.

I know the passage in Matthew Chapter 16, is interpreted by the Catholic Church as speaking to the authority of the Church. Yet, I have had experiences with this passage, as an individual; and I do believe that we can ask for the binding or loosing of things as an individual.

Matthew Chapter 16:18-19 (English Standard Version)

18And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. 19 I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."

I realize that there are many different beliefs among Protestants, and that can be a problem. Yet, there are some core beliefs that are common among many. I do have faith that God will plant my feet in the right place.

I think the two main issues that would keep me from embracing Catholicism are the role of the Pope and the role of Mary. I think this is the case for many Protestants. I have seen many misconceptions cleared up on the forums, but these remain major obstacles as far as Catholicism is concerned.

I’ve been giving all of this a lot of thought in the past few weeks.

I will say, that I have seen very insightful responses, from Catholics, regarding the topic of this thread. I started a Thread, previously, asking the same basic question of why Christ had to die. So, these two threads were very helpful.

I’m am praying about all this. I know what you mean about the forums taking so much time. These forums have been a lifeline for me, when I needed it most; but for the last few weeks, I have been thinking about taking a break from the forums. It does take a great deal of time. I need to go deeper into my study, and prayerfully consider where God wants me to be and what he wants me to do with my life.

I did appreciate your posts. So, they were not wasted effort.

May God bless you,
Anna
Don’t leave! Who will keep me in line?!
 
Sin is a choice to break the Law, Earnest…And there are consequenses to all choices, whether temporary (physical) or permanent (spiritual). And all sin is the same choice against obedience. Adam & Eve had a choice; they were not forced to eat the fruit. Addicts have choice. Satan did not force them to sin…he tempts.

Unfortunately, we [humanity] are more comfortable with a truth that says “we are victims and not to blame for our sin.” Such a view is accepted by most because it allows us to avoid the mirror; avoid responsibility.

“God never took away his grace. He cared [so loved the world] enough to send His Son because of grace. He could’ve distroyed us and started over.”

Notice what you just wrote. Sin is an act; our act; our action (choice).

[1 Timothy 3:15] But if I tarry long, that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thyself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.

This is your reference, but if this is true - that the Catholic Church follows the rules of faith - you miss Timothy’s full message. Let’s read in context:

[1 Timothy 3:12-15] Let the deacons (priests) be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well. 13 For they that have used the office of a deacon well purchase to themselves a good degree, and great boldness in the faith which is [Messiah]. 14 These things write I unto thee [about deacons (priests)], hoping to come unto thee shortly; 15 But if I tarry long, that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thyself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.

But the Catholic Church doesn’t allow deacons (priests) to marry.

Well true history would surprise you, Earnest. Peter is the rock…who holds the keys of Messiah’s church, but there were a few twists and turns in the story before we reach today’s Church.

Notice that you speak of “choices”, Earnest. This is the very act of suffering as Messiah suffered; to choose God beyond our “natural” inclination (if you will) of sinning. You disagree what I’ve said and yet say the same thing in another way.

Again, who said anything about being alone? The only thing I can conclude is that you mean “without the Catholic Church”?

If you’re going to quote scripture for your benefit, please do so in context to know what Messiah was talking about. The conversation starts at Matthew 22:24 and ends at Matthew 22:32. Please - everyone - read what exactly Messiah is talking about before assuming. Messiah is speaking very practically about the Law.

I like the way you explain your point, but the current definition of suffering; the one you understand as “pain, etc.” is not the definition of “suffering” used by Messiah.

From the lips of the One who gave the Keys to Peter:

[Matthew 19:13-14] Then were there brought unto him little children, that he should put his hands on them, and pray: and the disciples rebuked them [the kids]. 14 But [Messiah] said, “Suffer little children, and forbid them not, to come unto me: for such is the kingdom of heaven.”

Notice that the meaning of “suffer” - taken from the past language of the bible - is to “endure”. So let’s reread.

[Matthew 19:13-14] Then were there brought unto him little children, that he should put his hands on them, and pray: and the disciples rebuked them [the kids]. 14 But [Messiah] said, “Endure little children, and forbid them not, to come unto me: for such is the kingdom of heaven.”

To Suffer is To Endure. Messiah wants us to suffer against Sin; against our rebellious nature to break the Law. In that endurance - the same The Messiah endured - we make ourselves worthy, NOT by our own strength, but through the 2 Keys of the Kingdom:

[Rev.14:12]
  1. Obedience of the Law
  2. Faith in and of Messiah
Joshua 27,

I wanted to write more to you yesterday, but was not feeling well. So, I never got back to you.

I can see that you are very passionate about your beliefs and I respect that. I just can’t agree that sin is not suffering. I do agree that we will suffer for Christ, and that it is an honor to do so. But, when things are going well; I don’t think that means we are necessarily sinning.

I think there can be suffering in both sin, and obedience to Christ. However, I don’t see it as an “either or.” Maybe I’m still not understanding what you saying.

Anna
 
Joshua 27,

I wanted to write more to you yesterday, but was not feeling well. So, I never got back to you.

I can see that you are very passionate about your beliefs and I respect that. I just can’t agree that sin is not suffering. I do agree that we will suffer for Christ, and that it is an honor to do so. But, when things are going well; I don’t think that means we are necessarily sinning.

I think there can be suffering in both sin, and obedience to Christ. However, I don’t see it as an “either or.” Maybe I’m still not understanding what you saying.

Anna
Suffering is something that exists with or without sin. Sometimes sin leads to that suffering, sometimes DEVOTE holiness leads to it.

Saint Faustina was constantly suffering, and it was because of her closeness to Christ himself. It was through that suffering that she was able to bring us the word of the Divine Mercy.

I embrace suffering as a thing of holiness. I have been told time and time again that “Christ does not want us to suffer”, and while this much is true, he will allow it. He will allow our suffering so that his name can be given glory. Suffering, or better said, surviving, and moving forward despite the suffering, is a blessing. It brings glory to God our father. It is through this suffering that some of us, not all, are blessed with a more accurate idea of Christ’s own suffering.

Sin does lead to suffering. Suffering sometimes is not caused by sin, but by holiness and the ultimate grace Christ wishes to instill in the person.
 
People said in recent posts that you suffer from holiness and sin. I will prove it with scripture.

Then they sat on the ground with him for seven days and seven nights. No one said a word to him, because they saw how great his suffering was.

Job 2:13

As you see, Job is suffering because he chose to remain holy and righteous.

Look upon my suffering and deliver me, for I have not forgotten your law.

Psalms 119:153

The psalmist is suffering because he is keeping His Law. But it could also mean “endure”. Even with both, he’s suffering.

*The LORD is righteous,
yet I rebelled against his command.
Listen, all you peoples;
look upon my suffering.
My young men and maidens
have gone into exile. *

I believe Jeremiah is suffering because he rebelled against the Lord.

These are the only passages I found so far, but I am sure there are many others.
 
People said in recent posts that you suffer from holiness and sin. I will prove it with scripture.

Then they sat on the ground with him for seven days and seven nights. No one said a word to him, because they saw how great his suffering was.

Job 2:13

As you see, Job is suffering because he chose to remain holy and righteous.

Look upon my suffering and deliver me, for I have not forgotten your law.

Psalms 119:153

The psalmist is suffering because he is keeping His Law. But it could also mean “endure”. Even with both, he’s suffering.

*The LORD is righteous,
yet I rebelled against his command.
Listen, all you peoples;
look upon my suffering.
My young men and maidens
have gone into exile. *

I believe Jeremiah is suffering because he rebelled against the Lord.

These are the only passages I found so far, but I am sure there are many others.
👍 Nice post. Suffering is from both sources. Sin and holiness. Christ was the holy of holies, and he suffered greatly. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top