Why did God create dinosaurs

  • Thread starter Thread starter newearth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S-Jam,

Well, how about that…your “thoughts” had an answer. There are no coincidences. Glad to be of help. Keep up those “thoughts” of yours 🙂
I am guessing this question is only a matter of concern for the young earth believers that read the bible only literally. But, is not a thing a catholic must believe.
 
I am guessing this question is only a matter of concern for the young earth believers that read the bible only literally. But, is not a thing a catholic must believe.
Precisely. A Catholic is free to believe that Earth is old or young. The Church in her wisdom recognizes this as a question for science. Unfortunately, there are far too many Catholics who don’t understand the Church’s teaching on this, or any scientific topic for that matter.
 
Precisely. A Catholic is free to believe that Earth is old or young. The Church in her wisdom recognizes this as a question for science. Unfortunately, there are far too many Catholics who don’t understand the Church’s teaching on this, or any scientific topic for that matter.
Thank you Geoformeo,

This is why I love the catholics so much. They are willing to have open views to science, not a total distrust for it, or a Jack Chickish view of it. I have only met intelligent catholics in real life, that have no fear of science, or an over distrust for it.

Everyone should be a skeptic in a certian sense. But, to deny things outright while at the same time trying to tell me that the sun spun around and did this dance, is asking more of me than I am of anyone here.
 
“God created everything for man, but man in turn was created to serve and love God and to offer all creation back to Him:” Paragraph 358, Catechism of the Catholic Church. Use this handy link

Blessings,
granny

These two websites contain TV ads about Catholicism. The first is from one of the Dioceses which is using them. The second is general information.
Often readers including myself do not always pay attention to the links placed here by others to help make their point. But this time I went to the link to the diocese advertisement and hit the You-tube presentation on “Do Catholics worship saints?” There I got a good explanation by a local priest: Saints are roll models, Mary expecially knew Jesus; they are all good people who can pray for us when we ask them to do so as they are now very close to Jesus who we do worship as one of the three persons in God; Catholicism is a practical religion.

Thanks for the links. 🙂 It’s reassuring as that is what my wife and I do every day like praying to St. Anthony to help find lost or misplaced items; our guardian angel and travel prayer and so on; they are now very close to Jesus where we all want to be some day. Believe me they are a big help as I suspect many of you have learned. For example both my wife and I fell together trying to negotiate a sidewalk curb with her walker at night last November; neither of us were hurt. The person who picked us up came out of nowhere whom I believe was a guardian angel who also must have broke my very hard fall and picked us both up then quickly left the scene. We had just said the St. Michael travel prayer and guardian angel prayer just 10 minutes before we arrived for this school play. Two witnesses verified the presence of this “stranger” one of whom was an elderly man with a cane as his daughter who saw us fall said, “Let’s try and help them dad” only to remark a few seconds later to the complete stranger, “Oh, You’re not my dad!”

God does indeed have a major roll for all the critters he has made and they are here to guide us for a purpose if we but take a few minutes to reflect about them including dinosaurs (dragons and beomoths of Job 40, I think) some of whom were as long as several species of whales.🙂
 
Hi folks, why, for the same reason he made me, you , and the whole world, because he wanted to. The great thing is we are in his image and he loves us with a FATHERS LOVE. Blessings. Garland
 
I have often theorized that maybe God made the dinosaurs but then decided he wanted to create something “in his own image”. And if dinosaurs were still here he would have to watch us struggle to survive while being constantly hunted by massive predatory animals.
 
Do you have evidence to support this opinion? just curious what caused you to take such a a firm stance against this.
There is far more scientific evidence, not to mention scripture and Jesus’s own words and that of the early church fathers for a World-wide flood here on earth the there is for a flood on Mars which NASA is now suggesting. Isn’t it a bit obvious? Or do you think I have to explain the obvious to Strawberry Jam?😃
 
There is far more scientific evidence, not to mention scripture and Jesus’s own words and that of the early church fathers for a World-wide flood here on earth the there is for a flood on Mars which NASA is now suggesting. Isn’t it a bit obvious? Or do you think I have to explain the obvious to Strawberry Jam?😃
Please, feel free to explain the obvious to me.😃

I have no fear of changing my view if you are able to provide evidence that is sufficient enough to back your claims.

I am not in any argument with Jesus, or his words. Just interpretations of them.
 
There is far more scientific evidence, not to mention scripture and Jesus’s own words and that of the early church fathers for a World-wide flood here on earth the there is for a flood on Mars which NASA is now suggesting. Isn’t it a bit obvious? Or do you think I have to explain the obvious to Strawberry Jam?😃
Actually, Philipp, I am quite interested in your supposed “far more scientific evidence” for a global flood, because there is none. And can you specifically cite Jesus’ own words regarding the Flood and the ECFs? Apparently I, too, am in need of the obvious explained to me. By the way, Luke 17:26-27 is not a reference to a global flood. It is a reference to those who surrounded Noah at the time.

Was there a Noah’s Flood? Yes, there was, and much scientific evidence backs that up. But it was not a GLOBAL flood, but a localized one that created what is the modern day Black Sea. The area affected by this flood would have been “the whole world” to Noah and his family. I highly suggest you read about it in the book “Noah’s Flood” by geologists William Ryan and Walter Pitman. It is an incredible account of the scientific evidence for Noah’s Flood at the appropriate time and place in history. Though not a religious book, it also provides the archaeological evidence that verifies the Bible as containing historically accurate accounts. Definitely food for thought.
 
In the Sikh religion they also have a story of a major flood, but instead of an ark a man built a temple on a mountain top. This story includes a divine message and two of every animal.
 
In the Sikh religion they also have a story of a major flood, but instead of an ark a man built a temple on a mountain top. This story includes a divine message and two of every animal.
Jonny,

Yes, and there are flood myths in just about every ancient culture. The “Noah’s Flood” book I referenced above addresses the reason for this. There is archaeological evidence that beneath the modern Black Sea there used to be a giant freshwater lake that a number of groups of people used to live around. The “Flood” was an influx of salt water from an overflowing Mediterranean Sea, and forced these groups of peoples to flee in every direction. They all would have experienced that same event, but would have recorded it and handed it down differently.
 
i was reading the catholic ansers forums about Why did God create dinosaurs. and all the ansers were wrong… at age 18 i got the roman catholic bible and read the whole old testament till i was 21… and i know i saw the part in there where god made the beast to punnish man… or beheemoths. - beast… one of them…
Just saw “Sue” the dinosaur in Chicago. Simply a magnificent creature.😃

Considering that we humans are the pinnacle of God’s creation…
 
That’s an admittedly cute way to say it. I’ll have to remember that one (and borrow it?) if I ever believe.
LOL! Thanks! 🙂 If you ever believe, it’s yours for the borrowing! 🙂
You don’t even have to give it back when you’re done with it. 😛
 
BUT Thistle suggest that Truth Seeker and scripture are wrong. He (she} says that man and dinosaur did NOT exist at the same time. So who’s right? Well let’s see what modern research science has to say:)

In a recent book published and released on November 6, 2009 by the National Research Council of Italy entitled, “Evolutionism: The Decline of an Hypothesis” there is a report by a number of scientists that dinosaurs and man have indeed coexisted based on C-14 dating of dinosaur femur bone collagen from Montana. They repeated the testing on dinosaur bioapatite and obtained concordant C-14 ages all in the range of 23,000 to 30,000 C-14 years. Thus those alleged 65,000,000 to 225 million years since dinosaurs supposedly became extinct perhaps only exist in the minds of some men. 😃

There are even fossil dinosaur and human footprints together, discovered in a river bottom and pristine ones under tons of rocks and just recently confirmed by cat-scan of the Delk footprint. :eek:

Did anyone visit the links in the above? Therre is a lot of useful scientific discoveries which contradict the current paradigm or hypothesis of origins, evolution of life from non-life or bacterium billions of year ago including the FACT that dinosaurs are over 2000 times younger than what evolutionists claim? That time falls into what Catholics could consider as the period of creation ex-nihilo by God.

As for the obvious evidence for a possible flood of Noah it is well known by everyone that about 80 % of the earth is covered by water up to even 5 miles in depth in some ocean trenches; BUT Mars has NO water; right (?) yet NASA’s geologic studies of Mars suggest water once existed there. Furthermore the earth has 1000’s of feet of deep sedimentary rock strata with huge graveyards of all sorts of fossil animals and sea life forms. Plus there are 150 or so known asteroids impactions in those sedimentary rocks as on Mars and of course our moon. Thus since dinosaurs coexisted with man why couldn’t there have been a mighty global flood on earth as there might have been on Mars? All cultures world-wide have references to this flood but they do not appear as accurate as the Old and New testament.

As one of my favorite Public TV hero’s said many times on the 1/2 hour serials than ran for many years - It’s elementary Watson! 😃
 
In a recent book published and released on November 6, 2009 by the National Research Council of Italy entitled, “Evolutionism: The Decline of an Hypothesis” there is a report by a number of scientists that dinosaurs and man have indeed coexisted based on C-14 dating of dinosaur femur bone collagen from Montana. They repeated the testing on dinosaur bioapatite and obtained concordant C-14 ages all in the range of 23,000 to 30,000 C-14 years. Thus those alleged 65,000,000 to 225 million years since dinosaurs supposedly became extinct perhaps only exist in the minds of some men. 😃
Oh boy, here we go. First, C-14 dating has an upper limit of around 50,000 years. Trying to date anything older than that by this method will give erroneous results because it’s half life is so short (5730 years) that it will be practically undetectable. Any “results” noted using C-14 on things millions of years old are due to contamination (air, skin, etc.). Second, how could they have used this test with the mineral apatite, which is calcium phosphate (Ca5(PO4)3(OH,F,Cl)), and contains no carbon? Third, just curious, what age dates did they get when they dated the bone using U-238 or K-40?
There are even fossil dinosaur and human footprints together, discovered in a river bottom and pristine ones under tons of rocks and just recently confirmed by cat-scan of the Delk footprint. :eek:
So let me get this straight…they found dinosaur and human footprints together at the BOTTOM OF A RIVER? Don’t you think that there just might have been some erosion taking place by the running water? How in the world would the “footprints” stay preserved? And has a single human bone ever been found in association with dinosaur bones? No. Don’t you think that if the entire population of humans but Noah and his family were destroyed in the flood, alongside all species of dinosaur, that their bones would be found TOGETHER in sedimentary deposits?
As for the obvious evidence for a possible flood of Noah it is well known by everyone that about 80 % of the earth is covered by water up to even 5 miles in depth in some ocean trenches; BUT Mars has NO water; right (?) yet NASA’s geologic studies of Mars suggest water once existed there. Furthermore the earth has 1000’s of feet of deep sedimentary rock strata with huge graveyards of all sorts of fossil animals and sea life forms. Plus there are 150 or so known asteroids impactions in those sedimentary rocks as on Mars and of course our moon. Thus since dinosaurs coexisted with man why couldn’t there have been a mighty global flood on earth as there might have been on Mars? All cultures world-wide have references to this flood but they do not appear as accurate as the Old and New testament.
I hate to be so nitpicky, but the Earth is 70% covered with water. Mars DOES have water, albeit as ice in its ice caps. There is also the possibility that there is liquid water in its subsurface. Yes, Mars had water. But what makes you think that it was a “flood?” It would have been an ocean just like ours, or rivers just like ours. But the fact of the matter is that most of Mars was devoid of water, evidenced by the amount of basalt containing the mineral olivine present on Mars. I really don’t know what bearing Mars has on this discussion anyway.

One final question. No human bones have ever been found in association with dinosaur bones. And dinosaur bones are found in strata far below (older) than any that contain human remains. If the sedimentary rock and fossil records were produced by Noah’s Flood, do you propose that humans tread water for 150 days, so that their bones settled in the top of the fossil and rock record, while the dinosaurs all died and sank to the bottom immediately? I’m just asking you to use some common sense here. Unfortunately, this is the kind of stuff that drives people away from the faith, rather than drawing them in.
 
Geofermeo,

You may just be the angel I asked God to show himself to me in.

God showed me one thing today. That a believer in him is not bound to ignore reality.
 
S-Jam,

I’m here to do His will! 👍
Changing my sig line when I can find the right way to say what I am feeling right now.

I’m happy to know that faith and reason can actually be applied and allowed, without fear.

It really helps me to keep this an open question, and even inspires me more, to more than I thought when I woke up this morning.

You are a real defender of faith in my eyes. In every sense of the word of what a real defender is.

Defending reason with belief.

It can be compatible, as I see now in your helping me understand that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top