Why Did God Create Such A Violent World?

  • Thread starter Thread starter homeloan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
  1. No disrespect, but you’d almost have to ignore elementary science, which IMHO would be insulting to God (He who gave us an advanced brain/memory system to give us the intellectial tools to see and learn) to believe that other lifeforms may not have predated humans.
  2. Ibid
  3. Are we not God’s playthings? Would any of us have set up a system that is predicated upon survival; “kill to eat; eat to kill”. Would we have created such powerful sexual instinct (in the animal world) that the alpha-male has to defeat all competitors to enjoy the benefits of the female herd?
Even I (given the power of God) would have set up a much more user-friendly world than He did, and I’m far, far from having the depth of love that we proclaim of the loving, merciful Father. I’ll bet you would have too!
#3 really raises some valid questions. Dog-eat-dog might not be so bad from the predator point of view, but it sure stinks for the prey. And the alpha male gene is in humans too - a lot of the worst parts of human history can be blamed on the alpha syndrome. Doesn’t seem fair of God to give out these traits that cause so much damage.
 
I appreciate your perspective, Kolbe. Struggles with faith are part of life. As we enter into the most Holy Week, yesterday’s Gospel tells of Jesus’ agony of faith in asking if perhaps the cup (his passion) could be passed.

But God gave us brains. If we approached all unanswered, complex issues with, “All of us will have the answer one day.”, we’d still be in the Dark Ages. The Plague would decimate the population time & time again. No cures for small pox, mumps, measles; no extensions of life because of heart, lung, colon, liver problems.
I am going to try and answer this as best I can.

The chuch teaches that their was no* human* death and suffering before the fall.

When I asked the same question before I found this answer quite helpfull:

We have to stop trying to Anthropmorphize nature. Nature is nature, it is morally neutral, only the gift of the logos (i.e., image of God) confers quality and morality. Otherwise there is just quantity, even the word indifferent is inappropriate because it implies that good or bad can be applied to nature. Nature just is.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=212104
 
The chuch teaches that their was no* human* death and suffering before the fall.

When I asked the same question before I found this answer quite helpfull:

We have to stop trying to Anthropmorphize nature. Nature is nature, it is morally neutral, only the gift of the logos (i.e., image of God) confers quality and morality. Otherwise there is just quantity, even the word indifferent is inappropriate because it implies that good or bad can be applied to nature. Nature just is.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=212104
Thanks, Pete, also for your link, which is included in your quote.

“Anthromorphize” wasn’t found in my Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary but “anthropic” was. It refers to the period human beings have existed on earth, thus is the thrust of our religious experience.

We are asked to believe what we learn from the Church, as well as encouraged to read Holy Scripture.

We have a wealth of theology (esp. Roman Catholic’s) that has evolved in writings, assemblies, study, etc. Our library of revelation is sourced from writings and practices dating back hundreds if not thousands of years.

Wouldn’t you think that the Almighty would have been a little more forthcoming and a little less “mysterious” about His existence & motives for setting up the world like He did?

Maybe He used the wrong guys to write down his Words, because they are so vague and contradicting, they can be interpreted and used to justify just about anything to anyone (15,000+ denominations of Christian worship). But, how could He make such a mistake? Wouldn’t that make Him fallable?
 
Thanks, Pete, also for your link, which is included in your quote.

“Anthromorphize” wasn’t found in my Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary but “anthropic” was. It refers to the period human beings have existed on earth, thus is the thrust of our religious experience.
I think what he meant by Anthropmorphize was the practice of giving human characteristics to nature. E.g nature is evil, nature is unforgiving.
 
Pete’s Slogan: “It’s probably not a good idea to listen to me if I have not provided a credible source.”

Nonsense, Pete! You’re one of God’s people.🙂 He gave you a brain, imagination, ability to communicate… that’s good enough for me.:getholy: The rest is all details…:blessyou:
 
Even I (given the power of God) would have set up a much more user-friendly world than He did, and I’m far, far from having the depth of love that we proclaim of the loving, merciful Father. I’ll bet you would have too!
Then I suggest you start creating, since you would have done a much better job. Read the book of Job and look at God’s reply to Job when he was in misery. God reminded him that he didn’t have the right to question His Maker. How can the clay pot ask the potter “why did you make me so?”.

Those who think they know better than the Almighty God had best check into their limited capabilities.

Peace…

MW
 
Wouldn’t you think that the Almighty would have been a little more forthcoming and a little less “mysterious” about His existence & motives for setting up the world like He did?

Maybe He used the wrong guys to write down his Words, because they are so vague and contradicting, they can be interpreted and used to justify just about anything to anyone (15,000+ denominations of Christian worship). But, how could He make such a mistake? Wouldn’t that make Him fallable?
Do you think your mind would be able to handle the mind of the Creator and His thoughts and ways? You assume so. It’s a bit like trying to teach a kid in kindergarten about calculus when he hasn’t understood elementary principles that are the foundation of calculus. You couldn’t handle it, oh wise one.

Peace…

MW
 
Then I suggest you start creating, since you would have done a much better job. Read the book of Job and look at God’s reply to Job when he was in misery. God reminded him that he didn’t have the right to question His Maker. How can the clay pot ask the potter “why did you make me so?”.

Those who think they know better than the Almighty God had best check into their limited capabilities.

Peace…

MW
Mystic, if I start reading Job, then I’ll start reading Numbers, then Exodus, then Matthew and those many passages of violence in Holy Scripture conjure up images of a fierce, jealous God, certainly not in the realm of “loving” as we’re told in Mass.

I smile at the certainty of your response. Reminds me of the old saying, “My way or the highway!” Of course Holy Scripture teaches us that few will find the narrow way into Heaven but many will travel the broad road to destruction.

If God is all-knowing, all-present, why would he create all of the billions of humans, past, present & future, if he was going to condemn the bulk of us to an eternity of pain & torture if we don’t sign-off on all His rules while joyously singing His praises of what He’s done for us?

One thought that really seems unfair is that all those billions of souls who have already passed on, most of them are suffering punishment now, either in Hell or in Purgatory. If I, or others like me, were to meet their destiny when we breathe our last, we are very, very lucky to have been born so late. Imagine all the pain and torture we’ve already avoided compared to those poor schmucks who’ve already died.

Does God have to threaten us with eternal torture & pain to get us to love him? That seems manipulative. It’s almost ghoulish if you really think about it.

Concerning Job, Holy Scripture acknowledged by the Church tells us this tale is symbolic, not real.

Back to my original premise: Why did God create such a violent world. Which or who/whom of any of us would have created a world so violent (if we were omnipotent, omniscient, omni-everything like God is)?
 
Do you think your mind would be able to handle the mind of the Creator and His thoughts and ways? You assume so. It’s a bit like trying to teach a kid in kindergarten about calculus when he hasn’t understood elementary principles that are the foundation of calculus. You couldn’t handle it, oh wise one.

Peace…

MW
Mystic, if I were the “wise one” I wouldn’t have questions. I would have answers. Shall I bury my head in the sand acknowledging that “all will be revealed to me in the sweet bye-&-bye?”

Isn’t that the mindset of the Church when Martin Luther, John Calvin, Zwingli, et al set in motion the Reformation?

God gave us brains. Aren’t we supposed to use them? Why would He condemn us for asking questions that are definitely more pressing than “life or death” issues because the Church tells us we’re talking eternity.

So if no one can answer these most critical questions, except God, and He chooses to be silent, isn’t this being manipulative? Why would a loving God seek to manipulate us?
 
So if no one can answer these most critical questions, except God, and He chooses to be silent, isn’t this being manipulative?
As the creation account morally conveys that it didn’t take man long to disobey God. The original disobedience presupposes a rejection, or at the very least ‘a turning away’ from the truth of the Word of God. As a consequence for this disobedience man was told we will ‘return to the ground.’

And you and I will be perfect examples of this Truth when we one day ‘return to the ground.’

Seems what is vitally important is offered.

Overall, I find creation powerul and quite beautiful. Especially pondering a universe of and billions of billions of lights years of imagination.

I guess it depends on one’s perspective. 🤷
 
God did not create a violent world, he created a perfect world with perfect people. Humans sinned against God and fell short and sin entered into the world, making it less than what was originally intended. We are no longer fully human, but have defects in our original character. It is the removal of those character defects which is the goal, and that is called sanctification, or becoming Holy.
 
Homeloan, in your profile you identify yourself as Catholic and yet try to disprove the loving God of the Catholic faith. The whole of Jesus’ proclamation of the kingdom was the love of the Father and to call Him Abba. I’m just curious how you can view God as a vindictive Creator who is contrary to His nature of Love, cf.1 John 4:8, as is proclaimed by the Church of Christ and continue to identify yourself as Catholic?

Now if you are here for clarity and are confused as to why we see God as a loving Father then your intent is quite valid. But if your intent is to disprove the Love that is God Himself then I find your identity suspect. I’m not judging you, I’m merely making an observation…teachccd
 
As the creation account morally conveys that it didn’t take man long to disobey God. The original disobedience presupposes a rejection, or at the very least ‘a turning away’ from the truth of the Word of God. As a consequence for this disobedience man was told we will ‘return to the ground.’

And you and I will be perfect examples of this Truth when we one day ‘return to the ground.’

Seems what is vitally important is offered.

Overall, I find creation powerul and quite beautiful. Especially pondering a universe of and billions of billions of lights years of imagination.

I guess it depends on one’s perspective. 🤷
Cath, I don’t disagree with anything you’ve said if we’re just sticking with Holy Scipture, thus, the Church, et al.

The question we should all ask is, "Why would God, the creator of all, including the universe; God, who is acknowledged as omnipotent (unlimited power), omniscient (infinite awareness & understanding), omnipresent (present in all places at all times), and omnificent (unlimited in creative power), why would He create such a violent world?

If God is omniscient, He has infinite awareness, thus He would have known that man would disobey from the “get-go”. So why would He tempt them by planting a “tree-of-knowledge” right in their midst? Isn’t that being highly manipulative? For what purpose??

Worse yet, sexually speaking, why would He have made Eve, the woman, be the bad-girl, who successfully tempted Adam, who was helpless in resisting her female allure? This Bible Story has cause untold hardship and suffering for females.

If God is omnificient (unlimited in creative power), then He could have created Heaven instead of Earth and created those of us He wanted to spend eternity with and left the rest of us unborn (or uncreated). Then the vast majority of us wouldn’t have to spend eternity suffering in a firey furnace where the worm never dies, suffering in agony for the miserable few years we got to spend on this violent planet.

Isn’t there a better answer to this other than, “you must have faith”. Surely, there are better answers…
 
From the microscopic to the gigantic, it seems that most all life forms created have either existed as predator or prey. Predators kill prey violently; with mammals, there is much blood and gore. Why did God create such a violent world?:confused:
Regarding non-human life forms:

Violence is nothing to worry about in the “animal kingdom.” It is not evil, but merely nature. Just as the green grass grows, so too does the lion kill. There is nothing wrong with this. The food chain is good.

Regarding Man:

It is actually impossible for God, who is omnibenevolent, to will anything other than good. When God created the world, therefore, “it was good” (Gen. 1:4).

Where things got messy for the world was at the Fall – Original Sin (Gen. 3:1-7). The responsibility for this falls upon the shoulders of Man, not God. God could not have wanted our first parents to reject Him; but they, because they were created in the image and likeness of the Lord – the one truly free Being – possessed that degree of freedom. With it, humanity made a choice… not the correct one to be sure, but made it was. Mankind, and his world, has been stained and enslaved by that decision ever since.

There is Good News, of course: Christ, who came so that we might cleanse and free ourselves. This is the redemption of the Cross.
 
Mystic, if I start reading Job, then I’ll start reading Numbers, then Exodus, then Matthew and those many passages of violence in Holy Scripture conjure up images of a fierce, jealous God, certainly not in the realm of “loving” as we’re told in Mass.
Have you actually read those? If so, then you would understand more of God’s divine plan. What did He do to those nations who worshipped other gods? Those nations and people who refused to accept Him, but instead turned to false gods knew that what they were doing was wrong. They are without excuse.
I smile at the certainty of your response. Reminds me of the old saying, “My way or the highway!” Of course Holy Scripture teaches us that few will find the narrow way into Heaven but many will travel the broad road to destruction.
It’s not a matter of my way or the highway. It’s a matter of the Divine Creator who has been shunned by those with wandering hearts that refuse to acknowledge Him. Actually, my view is that God will restore all things to Himself, including those who rebelled against him, past, present and future.
If God is all-knowing, all-present, why would he create all of the billions of humans, past, present & future, if he was going to condemn the bulk of us to an eternity of pain & torture if we don’t sign-off on all His rules while joyously singing His praises of what He’s done for us?
You know neither the plan of God nor the Holy Scriptures. God will restore all things to Himself. The crux of that plan to restore all things was sending His precious Son to earth to destroy the works of the Devil. If He sent His Divine Son to destroy the works of the Devil, will He not also finish what He started? I don’t believe in the eternity of hell, nor the traditional understanding of it. The concept of hell that I see in Scripture is that it is a purifying state meant to eventually bring all people to Him. It’s not a punishment. It’s a corrective measure.
One thought that really seems unfair is that all those billions of souls who have already passed on, most of them are suffering punishment now, either in Hell or in Purgatory. If I, or others like me, were to meet their destiny when we breathe our last, we are very, very lucky to have been born so late. Imagine all the pain and torture we’ve already avoided compared to those poor schmucks who’ve already died.
See above.
Does God have to threaten us with eternal torture & pain to get us to love him? That seems manipulative. It’s almost ghoulish if you really think about it.
He doesn’t threaten us with that. He tells us the consequences of our actions. There’s a difference. If you tell your child not to touch the hot stove because they’ll get burned, is that threatening or preventative maintenance?
Concerning Job, Holy Scripture acknowledged by the Church tells us this tale is symbolic, not real.
I don’t accept their interpretation of it. Even if it was, how does that change the message?
Back to my original premise: Why did God create such a violent world. Which or who/whom of any of us would have created a world so violent (if we were omnipotent, omniscient, omni-everything like God is)?
He didn’t. You assume that what you see is because of God. It isn’t. It’s because of rebellion against God’s divine plan. Simple. Like I said, if you think you can do a better job, then by all means go for it. Start creating a new earth and do what you like. This is about as intelligent an idea as a basketball player telling his coach that he doesn’t know what he’s talking about, even though the coach has far more years of experience and a more level head than the arrogant basketball player who thinks he’s God’s gift to sports.

Peace…

MW
 
Mystic, if I were the “wise one” I wouldn’t have questions. I would have answers. Shall I bury my head in the sand acknowledging that “all will be revealed to me in the sweet bye-&-bye?”
You still don’t understand. You may not intend it to be so, but you sit and question your Maker as if He should somehow peek down from Heaven to give you the answers you already have in your faith. Your Catholic faith shares these things, yet you seem to despise Him. It reminds me of Jesus speaking to the religious rulers of his day. He told them if they didn’t believe Moses, then why should they believe Him? He said the words of Moses condemns them. Your church has given you the answers. Yet you fail to listen to them.
Isn’t that the mindset of the Church when Martin Luther, John Calvin, Zwingli, et al set in motion the Reformation?
God gave us brains. Aren’t we supposed to use them? Why would He condemn us for asking questions that are definitely more pressing than “life or death” issues because the Church tells us we’re talking eternity.
I’m not Catholic and don’t see what I have said correlates to a “mindset” of the Church before the reformation. It’s the truth you reject. God gave us brains so that we may use them to His glory, not so that we should get mired in scholasticism and endless speculation. It’s a waste of brain power to endlessly search for answers that are either already defined or are mysterious in nature. Isn’t that illogical to define the mysterious when the definition of mysterious defies explanation?

He doesn’t condemn for asking questions. He condemns when we’ve been given the answers already and refuse to believe His word that He has already spoken. If you had faith in God then life and death wouldn’t be an issue. If you lack faith, ask God to give it you.
So if no one can answer these most critical questions, except God, and He chooses to be silent, isn’t this being manipulative? Why would a loving God seek to manipulate us?
What makes you think He is silent? He has spoken to us in these last days through His Son and through the prophets of old before Him. He has spoken through your conscience, through His church, through the Holy Word of God. And yet you still ask questions. What else do you want Him to do to show you? Would you prefer a circus act? Would you prefer He bow down to His creation and explain Himself? If my children demand answers to questions that they have no right of knowing and wouldn’t understand anyway then I have no obligation to tell them.

Peace…

MW
 
Cath, I don’t disagree with anything you’ve said **if ** we’re just sticking with…
The truth?

That qualification I’ll agree with.

God speaks through His Church via Holy Scripture; through the Sacraments; through sacred Tradition and also through nature. Even the natural family has truths revealed.

Creation itself is good. Whatever the precise primeval event was, and how we lost harmony with nature and animals does not as important as the simple fact God asked for one thing, faithfulness. God has been faithful to His Word. Perfectly so. He warned of consequences. And they’re quite evident. 🤷

No, on earth we’re not perfect. And it’s not surprising some people see creation as a violent. I believe many lack hope.

Though the human being has the capacity for a state of perfection in Christ.
At the end of time, the Kingdom of God will come in its fullness. After the universal judgment, the righteous will reign for ever with Christ, glorified in body and soul. The universe itself will be renewed:
The Church . . . will receive her perfection only in the glory of heaven, when will come the time of the renewal of all things. At that time, together with the human race, the universe itself, which is so closely related to man and which attains its destiny through him, will be perfectly re-established in Christ.
Or more poetically expressed,
Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth. The former heaven and the former earth had passed away, and the sea was no more.

I also saw the holy city, a new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband.

I heard a loud voice from the throne saying, "Behold, God’s dwelling is with the human race. He will dwell with them and they will be his people 4 and God himself will always be with them (as their God).

He will wipe every tear from their eyes, and there shall be no more death or mourning, wailing or pain, (for) the old order has passed away."
Rev 21:1,4
Without God…well…may be that’s why there appears to be evidence the universe is expanding? It’s certainly helpful to keep us away from the rest of creation for now? 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top