Why did God Reverse an Earlier Decision?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tonsofquestions
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

tonsofquestions

Guest
In Judges 10:13, God is ticked off and says that He will save the Israelites no more. Yet He later does save them. Why is this? He could have been mistaken when He first heard it, since God is all knowing. He can’t have been lying, since God can’t lie. And, He can’t have changed His mind based on anything they did afterwards, because He already knew everything they were going to do before they even did it, so He would have known the statement, “I will save you no more”, would have still been false. Can anyone explain this to me?
 
In Judges 10:13, God is ticked off and says that He will save the Israelites no more. Yet He later does save them. Why is this? He could have been mistaken when He first heard it, since God is all knowing. He can’t have been lying, since God can’t lie. And, He can’t have changed His mind based on anything they did afterwards, because He already knew everything they were going to do before they even did it, so He would have known the statement, “I will save you no more”, would have still been false. Can anyone explain this to me?
Judges 10

11 The LORD replied, “When the Egyptians, the Amorites, the Ammonites, the Philistines, 12 the Sidonians, the Amalekites and the Maonites c] oppressed you and you cried to me for help, did I not save you from their hands? 13 But you have forsaken me and served other gods, so I will no longer save you. 14 Go and cry out to the gods you have chosen. Let them save you when you are in trouble!”
15 But the Israelites said to the LORD, “We have sinned. Do with us whatever you think best, but please rescue us now.” 16 Then they got rid of the foreign gods among them and served the LORD. And he could bear Israel’s misery no longer.

Simply…yes, God can change his mind. He was once going to destroy the Hebrews, but Moses pleaded to God and he changed his mind. God was going to bring terrible punishments on the people but Jeremiah (I think) said to God that it was too much and he changed his mind. God was going to destroy Nineveh but after they repented due to Jonah he changed his mind. God can change his mind if he so wills, he is God. A parent may not wish to buy his child a toy but if that child starts to behave well and do good in school he may change his mind. Jesus told the parable about the unjust judge who gave the widow a just judgment because she kept pestering him. God changes his mind.
But you have forsaken me and served other gods,** so I will no longer save you**. 14 Go and cry out to the gods you have chosen. Let them save you when you are in trouble!"

What did they do after? They stopped serving the baals and other gods. So since they changed their minds God was free to change his, since they, after that point, stopped serving the baals and other gods.

Freewill is the darndest thing:rolleyes:

Also, if you read the passage carefully you can see that they had already cried out to God for help before they got rid of the idols.
 
Judges 10

11 The LORD replied, “When the Egyptians, the Amorites, the Ammonites, the Philistines, 12 the Sidonians, the Amalekites and the Maonites c] oppressed you and you cried to me for help, did I not save you from their hands? 13 But you have forsaken me and served other gods, so I will no longer save you. 14 Go and cry out to the gods you have chosen. Let them save you when you are in trouble!”
15 But the Israelites said to the LORD, “We have sinned. Do with us whatever you think best, but please rescue us now.” 16 Then they got rid of the foreign gods among them and served the LORD. And he could bear Israel’s misery no longer.

Simply…yes, God can change his mind. He was once going to destroy the Hebrews, but Moses pleaded to God and he changed his mind. God was going to bring terrible punishments on the people but Jeremiah (I think) said to God that it was too much and he changed his mind. God was going to destroy Nineveh but after they repented due to Jonah he changed his mind. God can change his mind if he so wills, he is God. A parent may not wish to buy his child a toy but if that child starts to behave well and do good in school he may change his mind. Jesus told the parable about the unjust judge who gave the widow a just judgment because she kept pestering him. God changes his mind.
But you have forsaken me and served other gods,** so** I will no longer save you. 14 Go and cry out to the gods you have chosen. Let them save you when you are in trouble!"

What did they do after? They stopped serving the baals and other gods. So since they changed their minds God was free to change his, since they, after that point, stopped serving the baals and other gods.

Freewill is the darndest thing:rolleyes:

Also, if you read the passage carefully you can see that they had already cried out to God for help before they got rid of the idols.
I didn’t think God could change His mind.

And it doesn’t matter why He said it, He still said “I will no longer save you”. Since He was God, He would have known that they were going to get rid of the idols, and thus, would have know that the statement “I will no longer save you” was false. And yet He said it anyways. He said something that wasn’t true with full knowledge that it wasn’t true. Isn’t that the definition of lying?
 
Sometimes, the Bible isn’t God’s words.

It’s God’s record of MANKIND’S words and actions and their understanding, expressed in the best way they could at the time the writers put it down.

And the Bible should ALWAYS be understood as the Church has always understood it.
 
Sometimes, the Bible isn’t God’s words.

It’s God’s record of MANKIND’S words and actions and their understanding, expressed in the best way they could at the time the writers put it down.

And the Bible should ALWAYS be understood as the Church has always understood it.
Exactly what are you saying? Are you saying God didn’t really say that He would “save them no more”? If so, what is your reason for believing that?
 
I didn’t think God could change His mind.

And it doesn’t matter why He said it, He still said “I will no longer save you”. Since He was God, He would have known that they were going to get rid of the idols, and thus, would have know that the statement “I will no longer save you” was false. And yet He said it anyways. He said something that wasn’t true with full knowledge that it wasn’t true. Isn’t that the definition of lying?
Maybe, since he was God he knew that they wouldn’t get rid of those idols unless he informed them that they would be damned if they did not. The punishment of damnation is conditional, the Jews stopped meeting the condition; God stopped damning. What is so hard to understand about that?

God is timeless, but man is not. So, in order to be understood by out limited minds, sometimes God has to act, or speak, as if he were not timeless.
 
Maybe, since he was God he knew that they wouldn’t get rid of those idols unless he informed them that they would be damned if they did not. The punishment of damnation is conditional, the Jews stopped meeting the condition; God stopped damning. What is so hard to understand about that?

God is timeless, but man is not. So, in order to be understood by out limited minds, sometimes God has to act, or speak, as if he were not timeless.
If that was what He wanted to say, He could have said “I will not save you unless you get rid of the idols”. But that’s not what He said, He didn’t make a condition, He made a flat out statement, with full knowledge that that statement wasn’t true.
 
If that was what He wanted to say, He could have said “I will not save you unless you get rid of the idols”. But that’s not what He said, He didn’t make a condition, He made a flat out statement, with full knowledge that that statement wasn’t true.
Just because you would “like” to see it differently, does not mean the way it is stated is wrong. Maybe He is instructing you to stop depending on you own understanding and trust Him and His spokes-persons.
 
God didn’t change His Mind. He knew the Israelities would turn away from false gods when He warned them He would no longer save them, so He warned them, they turned away, and He saved them.

The same goes for a coming chastisement. He would know even if He warned mankind that not everyone would listen, but for the sake of those few who would listen, He’d issue a warning of the coming chastisement so they could be saved.
 
I didn’t think God could change His mind.

And it doesn’t matter why He said it, He still said “I will no longer save you”. Since He was God, He would have known that they were going to get rid of the idols, and thus, would have know that the statement “I will no longer save you” was false. And yet He said it anyways. He said something that wasn’t true with full knowledge that it wasn’t true. Isn’t that the definition of lying?
One of the advantages of belonging to the one true faith is that we are not shackled by the false doctrine of Sola Scriptura. This thread is a perfect example of the perils of pulling a couple of scriputre verses out of the Bible and coming to profound theological conclusions based on ones personal interpetation of them. Of course God doesnt change his mind! The author of these verses is making a point about the perils of disobeying God. he is perhaps a bit hyperbolic but that does not chage the basic message.
 
Just because you would “like” to see it differently, does not mean the way it is stated is wrong. Maybe He is instructing you to stop depending on you own understanding and trust Him and His spokes-persons.
You’re right. I have made the decision to completely stop using my own understanding and put total faith in the one true God, despite all evidence to the contrary. From now on, I will worship the one true God, The Flying Spaghetti Monster! I know, it doesn’t make any sense, but I’m not using things like logic and deduction, after all, the Devil gave us those things to prevent us from having faith in the One true God, the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Thank you, for reminding me that understanding is worthless, and that blind faith in something that makes no sense and is inherently contradictory is the true path to heaven.
 
You’re right. I have made the decision to completely stop using my own understanding and put total faith in the one true God, despite all evidence to the contrary. From now on, I will worship the one true God, The Flying Spaghetti Monster! I know, it doesn’t make any sense, but I’m not using things like logic and deduction, after all, the Devil gave us those things to prevent us from having faith in the One true God, the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Thank you, for reminding me that understanding is worthless, and that blind faith in something that makes no sense and is inherently contradictory is the true path to heaven.
Please excuse me for replying to you-i didnt see your “religion”.

bye.
 
You need to remember that God is in constant revelation to all mankind through the Jews. He is speaking simultaneously here to the Jews as well as to future Christians.

From a Christian context the message is clear. It is this:
'God is unchanging in His call to perfection - “He will not have His people have any other gods before Him”. This is a matter of fidelity and sincerity. We need to think in terms of a marriage - God is transforming humanity and pushing them ever toward “being Holy as your Father is Holy” since he wants humankind to be “His People”. God is saying that there is NO other relationship that can stand in eternity since these things the Jews are doing are temporal and passing and a form of infidelity and insincerity. God’s nature itself is incompatible with insincerity and infidelity. It is not a matter of God being willing to accept His people with grave faults and imperfections - He simply CAN NOT be insincere to His own nature. If ever there was a thing God could not do it would be to change His nature and He wants to impress the Jews that He WILL NOT and CAN NOT enter into an eternal relationship if they as His people let themselves become sordid, unchaste, insincere - less than perfect in their fidelity to God alone.

The other consistent message is ‘“REPENT” from grave sins and defects that are incompatible with My nature’. God is saying quite literally here that His Nature is unchanging in its ability to receive unto Himself those who repent even when they themselves are gravely deficient and dead to him in the gravity of those sins. Repentance is consistent with “He who makes all things new”. So in the same breath God is condeming the “dead in sin” Israel as incompatible with His nature but is also saying “It is My unchanging nature to always receive back My People who were once alive to Me and now are dead in sin and who have called on My Mercy to repent and turn their whole heart to Me again and be healed and made whole again.”

But the other aspect that God is teaching here is the gravity of some kinds of sins (mortal sins) which will have eternal and unreconcilable consequences without God’s Mercy and without having a conscience that even desires to petition God’s Mercy and instead marries itself to Satan and actually hates God by its own free choice.
 
I didn’t think God could change His mind.

And it doesn’t matter why He said it, He still said “I will no longer save you”. Since He was God, He would have known that they were going to get rid of the idols, and thus, would have know that the statement “I will no longer save you” was false. And yet He said it anyways. He said something that wasn’t true with full knowledge that it wasn’t true. Isn’t that the definition of lying?
Wow…you just…completely dismissed my explanation and really didn’t seek to create a real point by point rebuttal to my arguments.

When I say God can change his mind you have a problem. When others say he cannot you have a problem. Do you really have tons of questions or tons of accusations?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top