Why did Mary have to be without sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mesl4
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mesl4

Guest
Why does “full of grace” or “highly favored one” lead people to believe she was sinless? According to the dictionary it means:

(in Theology).
a. the freely given, unmerited favor and love of God.
b. the influence or spirit of God operating in humans to regenerate or strengthen them.
c. a virtue or excellence of divine origin: the Christian graces.
d. Also called state of grace. the condition of being in God’s favor or one of the elect

or in general terms"
  1. elegance or beauty of form, manner, motion, or action.
  2. a pleasing or attractive quality or endowment.
  3. favor or good will.
  4. a manifestation of favor, esp. by a superior: It was only through the dean’s grace that I wasn’t expelled from school.
  5. mercy; clemency; pardon: an act of grace.
  6. favor shown in granting a delay or temporary immunity.
Oh. Maybe I just answered my question as to why people believe that. But I still don’t know why that had to be the case? If Jesus had been born to someone in the normal state, would the outcome be any different? Or, did she have to be that way because God united w/her and he does not unite w/sin? That would make sense.

Also, if he made her that way, why not make us all that way?
 
… Or, did she have to be that way because God united w/her and he does not unite w/sin? That would make sense…
I agree with that idea…

I once had an idea that Mary had to be sinless - not because she gave birth to Jesus - but because she was the spouse of the Holy Spirit.

Eve was the spouse of Adam at her creation, and she was sinless.

The Church was the spouse of Jesus at Her creation, and She was sinless.

So, why not Mary be the spouse of the Holy Spirit at her creation and be sinless? :twocents:

(I think also Israel can be considered the spouse of the The Father… but my scripture references need work.)
 
Why does “full of grace” or “highly favored one” lead people to believe she was sinless? According to the dictionary it means:

I think these type of question come from the misconception that Catholics have gotten their theology from an interpretation of scripture. 1st century writings have always depicted Mary as sinnles. It comes from Tradition. Did she have to be sinnless.? This is like asking if God has to be triune? The answer to both of these is because its the way it is. Because God chooses it this way.
 
Why does “full of grace” or “highly favored one” lead people to believe she was sinless? According to the dictionary it means:

(in Theology).
a. the freely given, unmerited favor and love of God.
b. the influence or spirit of God operating in humans to regenerate or strengthen them.
c. a virtue or excellence of divine origin: the Christian graces.
d. Also called state of grace. the condition of being in God’s favor or one of the elect

or in general terms"
  1. elegance or beauty of form, manner, motion, or action.
  2. a pleasing or attractive quality or endowment.
  3. favor or good will.
  4. a manifestation of favor, esp. by a superior: It was only through the dean’s grace that I wasn’t expelled from school.
  5. mercy; clemency; pardon: an act of grace.
  6. favor shown in granting a delay or temporary immunity.
Oh. Maybe I just answered my question as to why people believe that. But I still don’t know why that had to be the case? If Jesus had been born to someone in the normal state, would the outcome be any different? Or, did she have to be that way because God united w/her and he does not unite w/sin? That would make sense.

Also, if he made her that way, why not make us all that way?
Mary is the Ark of the New Convenant. When we look at Exodus 25:11-21 we see that the old Ark which carried God’s Commandments was made from the most pure Gold possible. Great care was taken in it’s creation because it was to house God’s word. How much more important would be the new Ark which was to House the WORD - God made flesh? Also, to say that Mary was sinful, is to say that God would let the finger of Satan touch His Son made flesh. This is simply not possible.
 
Basically for two reasons.
  1. Because it was fitting that the vessel carrying God be free from sin; and
  2. Because it pleased God to make it so.
 
mesl4;4040994:
Why does “full of grace” or “highly favored one” lead people to believe she was sinless? According to the dictionary it means:
I think these type of question come from the misconception that Catholics have gotten their theology from an interpretation of scripture. 1st century writings have always depicted Mary as sinnles. It comes from Tradition. Did she have to be sinnless.? This is like asking if God has to be triune? The answer to both of these is because its the way it is. Because God chooses it this way.
This was going to be my answer. We do not believe Mary was sinless because of something written in scripture, but because this truth was given to the Church by God.

Now as to why God chose that Mary should be sinless, it makes perfect sense that if in Jesus Christ God was going to unite himself fully and perfectly with humanity (and thus with all creation), that this unification would unite his perfect, uncorrupted divinity with perfect, uncorrupted humanity. Humanity as he intended it, before the Fall.
 
Mary is the Ark of the New Convenant. When we look at Exodus 25:11-21 we see that the old Ark which carried God’s Commandments was made from the most pure Gold possible. Great care was taken in it’s creation because it was to house God’s word. How much more important would be the new Ark which was to House the WORD - God made flesh? Also, to say that Mary was sinful, is to say that God would let the finger of Satan touch His Son made flesh. This is simply not possible.
Tietjen has it exactly correct.

The Ark of the Covenant and Eve (before the fall) are prefigurements of Mary; they are “types” of Mary. Mary, in order to be ‘blessed above all woman’ must be above Eve - who was created perfect but fell into sin. The Ark made of pure gold carried The Law (Ten Commandments), Aaron’s rod (symbol of the authority of the High Priest - a type of Christ) and manna (prefiguring of The Body Christ). The Arc being pure (and emblematic of Mary’s virginity) carried the sentence of death for anyone who tried to touch it in an inappropriate manner (2 Samuel 6:7).

See from the Old Testament how sinlessness is associated with virginal purity - as refined silver and gold. The Arc is to Mary as Mary is to the new Eve.
*
Psalm 66:10 For You have tried us, O God;
You have refined us as silver is refined.

Psalm 11:7 The words of the Lord are pure words: as silver tried by the fire, purged from the earth refined seven times.

Isaias 48:10 Behold I have refined thee, but not as silver, I have chosen thee in the furnace of poverty.

Zechariah 13:7-9
“Awake, O sword, against My Shepherd,
And against the man, My Associate,”
Declares the LORD of hosts.
“Strike the Shepherd that the sheep may be scattered;
And I will turn My hand against the little ones.
8 “It will come about in all the land,”
Declares the LORD,
“That two parts in it will be cut off and perish;
But the third will be left in it.
9 “And I will bring the third part through the fire, Refine them as silver is refined, And test them as gold is tested. They will call on My name, And I will answer them; I will say, ‘They are My people,’ And they will say, ‘The LORD is my God.’"*

Jesus, likewise is the new High Priest and the new Adam and is prefigured by Melchizedek and by Arron.

The bottom line is the new children of God are spiritual offspring of the new Adam and the new Eve - Jesus and Mary. By cooperating with God’s grace made possible by Jesus’ sacrifice and Mary’s cooperation to “let it me done according to thy will” and her willfully joining in Christ’s suffering at the foot of the cross we are a new Divine species - a new creation.

The cross of wood is the new doorway to The Kingdom. As in passover where the doorway was sprinkled with the blood of the lamb and the lamb and unleavened bread is eaten we have Jesus, the lamb of God being converted from unleavened bread (The Eucharist) and even. Jesus blood is sprinkled on the cross (the door posts) just as in passover as we flee from bondage (son) to travel to the promised land (heaven). The cross is the doorway to The Kingdom. “No one enters except through the narrow gate”. Even the drinking of the 4th passover cups of wine, 3 at the last supper and the 4th on the cross (sponge dipped in bitter wine) is a replay of passover. All of scripture is fully integrative and symmetrical from old to new testament.

We are all now on our pilgrimage to Heaven as we cross through the baptismal waters (the parting sea), wander in the dessert and suffer many trials and trust God to get us home. We take “our daily bread” as manna from God (Eucharist) and drink from The Rock (Christ’s graces available through His Church established through Peter - The (little) Rock).

This is why Mary has to be sinless - she is the Arc of the Covenant. She is our mother. Even Noah’s arc carrying the family of God’s remnant (the Church) is prefigured here.

James
 
Why does “full of grace” or “highly favored one” lead people to believe she was sinless? According to the dictionary it means:
(in Theology).
a. the freely given, unmerited favor and love of God.
b. the influence or spirit of God operating in humans to regenerate or strengthen them.
c. a virtue or excellence of divine origin: the Christian graces.
d. Also called state of grace. the condition of being in God’s favor or one of the elect
Hi
First of all you are right in the fact that “Grace” doesn’t mean “Sinless”. I ask once on a thread where Catholics got sinless from Grace and could not get a good answer.

Secondly, Mary did not have to be sinless. Mary was, is, and probably always will be the most Godly woman to have lived. I’ve heard the whole ark of the covenant argument, but God can do anything. To say that he could not be born from a body that has sin in it, is limiting what he can do.
 
Hi
First of all you are right in the fact that “Grace” doesn’t mean “Sinless”. I ask once on a thread where Catholics got sinless from Grace and could not get a good answer.

Secondly, Mary did not have to be sinless. Mary was, is, and probably always will be the most Godly woman to have lived. I’ve heard the whole ark of the covenant argument, but God can do anything. To say that he could not be born from a body that has sin in it, is limiting what he can do.
You speak like you have some kind of self appointed teaching authority. You are completely wrong that grace can not make a person sinless. What do you think baptism does? Good Lord please learn the basics.

Mary did not “have to be” sinless? What do you mean? Do you mean Mary did not “have to be sinless” in order for your logic and your private interpretation of scripture to work? For that matter Jesus did not “have to” die on the cross either - he could have just come to earth and said “hey all - free pass to heaven - follow me”. God does not “have to” do anything - not even make sense of your arguments when there is none. Did you notice your own contradiction? “God can do anything” but God could not and would not let Mary be sinless. Why do you try to limit what God can do and contradict yourself?

You are spewing a teaching of man and a modern doctrinal tradition born of the errors of the Protestant reinterpretation of scripture. Mary being sinless does not take away at all from Jesus’ stature - He is afterall Divine and Mary is a created creature.

Maybe we should change the topic title. How about “If God can do anything why can’t Protestant’s be made to believe the truth?”

James
 
Hi
First of all you are right in the fact that “Grace” doesn’t mean “Sinless”. I ask once on a thread where Catholics got sinless from Grace and could not get a good answer.

Secondly, Mary did not have to be sinless. Mary was, is, and probably always will be the most Godly woman to have lived. I’ve heard the whole ark of the covenant argument, but God can do anything. To say that he could not be born from a body that has sin in it, is limiting what he can do.
To say that he could not keep Mary from sin is also limiting what he can do. To say that he cannot keep his Church from teaching error about Mary is also limiting what he can do.
 
You speak like you have some kind of self appointed teaching authority. You are completely wrong that grace can not make a person sinless. What do you think baptism does? Good Lord please learn the basics.

WOOOW CF, pull back on the reigns a little bit. No need to make personal attacks. The point I was making was that “Grace doesn’t mean Sinless”
You are spewing a teaching of man
 
To say that he could not keep Mary from sin is also limiting what he can do. To say that he cannot keep his Church from teaching error about Mary is also limiting what he can do.
Hi Mike
I did not say that God could not keep Mary from sin. Go back and read my post.
 
Oh. Maybe I just answered my question as to why people believe that. But I still don’t know why that had to be the case? If Jesus had been born to someone in the normal state, would the outcome be any different? Or, did she have to be that way because God united w/her and he does not unite w/sin?
That doesn’t answer why she was a Virgin, though. A virgin who marries doesn’t sin.

I think to understand why she had to be without the stain of original sin, you need to understand her role in salvation, and also covenant theology from the OT.

One of my favorite names for Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant.
 
WOOOW CF, pull back on the reigns a little bit. No need to make personal attacks. The point I was making was that “Grace doesn’t mean Sinless”
Sorry, but you come across like you think you know more than everyone here and its clear that everyone here is running scriptural circles around you. You are not even in the ball park much less the contest. You would be more effective to desist with the absolute statements and try to ask questions and maybe learn something.

Being “full of grace” implies sinless. If Mary is full of grace there is no room for sin. Take that together with “blessed are you among all women” and the fact that Eve was created without sin. Then it becomes child’s play to see that Mary had not never sin to be “blessed among all ALL women” in order for her to be above Eve. Can you contradict this scripturally? No, its impossible.
Isn’t this exactly what “Tradition” is? A teaching of man.
Sometimes yes, sometimes no and sometimes that tradition is the tradition of godly men and Christ “the Son of Man”. Why is that a problem?

THE ENTIRE BIBLE WAS PUT TOGETHER FROM
TRADITION!!! HELLO?

EVERY book, prophet and statement in the bible is passed to us from tradition. The bible did not spontaneously create itself out of thin air. Nor did the bible authorize itself to be produced. THE CATHOLIC CHURCH authorized itself to put together what IT considered to be the inspired word of God for IT’s purposes. It was never EVER put together with the intention of it being a self-help do-it-yourself guide to salvation. You sola scripturists just don’t get it do you? NO WHERE in the bible does the bible authorize itself to be assembled and published. Where did that authority come from? It came from The Catholic Church. Get with the times - sola scriptura IS DEAD THEOLOGICALLY. It had been beaten to pulp a thousand times by apologetics. Even mainline conservative Protestants accept that now. Why don’t you?

You need follow only one tradition - the apostolic tradition.

Paul says that much Christian teaching is to be found in the **tradition **which is handed down by word of mouth (2 Tim. 2:2). He instructs us to “stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter” (2 Thess. 2:15).
The word of God is both spoken and orally taught by tradition. If you only follow written word you are only getting a part of the WHOLE word of God.

More here: catholic.com/library/Scripture_and_Tradition.asp
I do believe the truth, God word in the Bible.
See above. First of all your reading comprehension and logic and holistic understanding of scripture is severely lacking and secondly. I am very worried about your salvation. God’s word is not just the bible - if you do not have the apostolic oral tradition and teachings you believe what somone else taught you.

James
 
Hi
First of all you are right in the fact that “Grace” doesn’t mean “Sinless”. I ask once on a thread where Catholics got sinless from Grace and could not get a good answer.

Secondly, Mary did not have to be sinless. Mary was, is, and probably always will be the most Godly woman to have lived. I’ve heard the whole ark of the covenant argument, .
In the case of Mary, it certainly implies sinlessness. The term “kecharitomene” implies she was completely, perfectly, enduringly endowed with grace. When Gabriel addressed her in this fashion, “full of grace” or “kecharitomene”, one has to remember that man was still fallen from grace: the redemption had not yet occurred - yet, here is one who is full of “kecharitomene” - the only point in Scripture where someone is addressed as such. One could not possess such grace if they were still alienated (with the rest of humanity) from God. And until the Redemption, the only way to share in this unity would be if, indeed, Mary were sinless And the only way for Mary to have been sinless, is if she enjoyed the effects of Redemption a priori the Crucifixion, i.e., Immaculately conceived in the womb by the preventative saving grace of her Son.
but God can do anything.
Except shield Mary from Original Sin?
To say that he could not be born from a body that has sin in it, is limiting what he can do.
Can do? Or WOULD do?

Really, we could stretch that logic to the Incarnation itself. God COULD have redeemed humanity without taking on the flesh, without going to the Cross, too. If nothing is impossible with God, He could have also pulled a “Groundhog Day” and “re-played” the temptation of the serpent in the garden until Adam and Eve got it right, and just avoided this whole “sin” thing that’s plagued us ever since.

It’s much more compelling to believe that a sinless God would choose an immaculate vessel to being nourshed and carried in for nine months, than one who had a nature entirely contrary to His essence (love). The salutations of Gabriel and Elizabeth, as well as the ark prefigurement support this belief. There’s only conjecture to support the notion that she was a sinner like everyone else.
 
See above. First of all your reading comprehension and logic and holistic understanding of scripture is severely lacking and secondly. I am very worried about your salvation. God’s word is not just the bible - if you do not have the apostolic oral tradition and teachings you believe what somone else taught you.
This is not helpful to the conversation. We don’t like it when Protestants condescend to our “imperiled” salvation, let’s not do it to them, too.
 
This is not helpful to the conversation. We don’t like it when Protestants condescend to our “imperiled” salvation, let’s not do it to them, too.
If Protestants think they are entitled to their own private interpretation of scripture as the rule of God (a form of personal relativism) to the point where they need to go public with their private errors and bring others to their ruin then I am certainly entitled take my private worries about their salvation public as well. It is also our clear duty to warn others when they are in contradiction to apostolic teaching and especially when The Church has officially warned them. Also, “it is not helpful” to let somone go down the slippery slope with their errors and take others with them.

I am sure you are familiar with Pope Benedict XVI’s published document Dominus Iesus. The document, ratified by Pope Paul II, described the Catholic Church as the church that Jesus Christ established circa 30 CE and describes other “Christian” denominations as not "churches in the proper sense (but ecclesial communities)." This was in response to growing acceptance among Protestants and other non-Catholics of “relativistic theories which seek to justify religious pluralism.” He portrayed members of other religions as “gravely deficient” relative to Roman Catholics who, alone, have “the fullness of the means of salvation.” That is not to say that non-Catholics can’t be saved (since God in His Mercy can do anything) but it sure casts extreme doubt on how many are saved - if any.

You might want to re-consider if its “helpful” to make endless appeals to reason with those who have repeatedly demonstrated that they are closed to reason and are rather committed to inventing their own salvation theology that suits their own private agenda. There is only 1 thing that gets through to people with seared consciences and suffering the false-euphoria brought on by self-revelation and delusion - The Holy Spirit. My own opinion is that it is “helpful” to soften up the stubborn hubris a bit to quicken the pace…

James
 
There are some great points being made here.

All I ask is since we are talking about our Mother, could we please be a little more civil and a little more humble just as she would have been.

Thanks!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top