Let me start by stating I have a great love for Our Lady and believe in what the Church teaches. However, this thread did bring a question to my mind for which I do not have the answer. According to tradition Mary was consecrated to the Temple and had vowed to remain a virgin, right? She married Joseph as a protection and he would honor her vow, right? So, my question is, when it became known that Mary had concieved, wouldn’t that have been a scandal? Not talking about the whole “betrothal” issue, but rather that she had taken a vow and “apparently” broken it. We know that she maintained the vow… but what about the people around her? Others in the Temple? Townspeople?
I had always heard from a rather fundamentalist friend that Mary was known in a very unflattering way after Jesus was conceived because she and Joseph had not yet taken their household. (in fact the word that she used was so disrespectful that I refuse to use it here). Anyway, I always counteracted that with the fact that Mary was able to enter the Temple to present Jesus so she couldn’t have been known in that way, she had to be “clean” to enter the Temple.
I agree with other posters on the necessity of Mary’s marriage to Joseph on a number of levels. Just curious as to what kind of reaction Mary got from the people at the Temple when it became known she was with child. Any ideas?