B
Benadam
Guest
I have an idea. It’s my guardian idea.An angel is an idea.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ba9a2/ba9a21a68dec62fad51a2b2ae35f280c4387bf57" alt="Roll eyes :rolleyes: :rolleyes:"
I have an idea. It’s my guardian idea.An angel is an idea.
Ech! Double post!
There are a number. Genesis might be a good example, or Revelation talks about the end of time. It is also a philosophical point, but not a Catholic one, or a Christian one. It is found in most developed philosophical positions. In the West you could look at Plato or Aristotle as good starting points.Thank you for the clarification, but I personally think the idea is silly even when attributed to God. Is there scripture that supports God being “outside of time” or is this just a Catholic philosophical belief?
What they mean by “outside of time” is that God is a constant fact of reality such that time has nothing to do with it. And that God is a constant, never changing through time. And even if there were no physical universe at all, yielding no measurement of change == time, God would still exist.Thank you for the clarification, but I personally think the idea is silly even when attributed to God. Is there scripture that supports God being “outside of time” or is this just a Catholic philosophical belief?
Not really. That is if you are refering to time in relation to the realm of things that begin and end. If you are refering to eternity as a duration I can agree. There are passages written by OT author’s that are obviously attempting to express a self existant life that is the sourse of all that is. Genesis expresses an existence that is void and formless yet is existing. The author’s seem to be trying to skirt around the concept of time by expressing the notion of ‘before’ but inable to avoid it.What they mean by “outside of time” is that God is a constant fact of reality such that time has nothing to do with it. And that God is a constant, never changing through time. And even if there were no physical universe at all, yielding no measurement of change == time, God would still exist.
It all actually makes perfect sense. They just seem to want to maintain the confusion.
I don’t see how that conflicts with what I said…?Not really. That is if you are refering to time in relation to the realm of things that begin and end. If you are refering to eternity as a duration I can agree. There are passages written by OT author’s that are obviously attempting to express a self existant life that is the sourse of all that is. Genesis expresses an existence that is void and formless yet is existing.
Gen 1:1Thank you for the clarification, but I personally think the idea is silly even when attributed to God. Is there scripture that supports God being “outside of time” or is this just a Catholic philosophical belief?
I wasn’t able to distinguish in what you wrote that to the Christian there are two realms of experiencing existence. I may have misread, but your statement seemed to deny the idea of eternity as a Judeo Christian theological developement.I don’t see how that conflicts with what I said…?
Sorry for the implication.I wasn’t able to distinguish in what you wrote that to the Christian there are two realms of experiencing existence. I may have misread, but your statement seemed to deny the idea of eternity as a Judeo Christian theological developement.
Not a problem. With continued dialogue I’ll become less confused.Sorry for the implication.
I have stated many times the eternal nature of God and even why.