Why do people push boundaries and test you?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HailStarofSea
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sometimes they just want to see if you really care about them or not. I think this is common among really close relationships. (spouses and parent-child especially) They start fights to see if you will leave them or throw them out. They lie to see if you will take their word over someone elses. They argue for no reason other than to to see if you will go along.
 
Sometimes they just want to see if you really care about them or not. I think this is common among really close relationships. (spouses and parent-child especially) They start fights to see if you will leave them or throw them out. They lie to see if you will take their word over someone elses. They argue for no reason other than to to see if you will go along.
And that sucks. I really, really hate that. Few things are capable of making me actually angry, but in such cases, I still remain calm but literally see white and begin to drawl instead of speaking normally. Obviously not talking about misguided children, which can be annoying but have some right to be, as they are not grown adults. More about romantic relationships, rather. I find it really annoying in young women, and I’m inclined to be incensed when it happens (not in the least because a potentially agreeable person is starting to act dumb, horribly dumb). I’ve heard about/from people stupid enough to cheat in order to find out if the partner will leave them for that. At that point, it’s likely that a psychic issue is at play, which is, after all, an illness like any other, but those people who don’t have a real psychic issue (personality disorder, psychic disorder, psychic illness) as an excuse are just dumb when they do that. If you’ll pardon my French.
 
And that sucks. I really, really hate that. Few things are capable of making me actually angry, but in such cases, I still remain calm but literally see white and begin to drawl instead of speaking normally. Obviously not talking about misguided children, which can be annoying but have some right to be, as they are not grown adults. More about romantic relationships, rather. I find it really annoying in young women, and I’m inclined to be incensed when it happens (not in the least because a potentially agreeable person is starting to act dumb, horribly dumb). I’ve heard about/from people stupid enough to cheat in order to find out if the partner will leave them for that. At that point, it’s likely that a psychic issue is at play, which is, after all, an illness like any other, but those people who don’t have a real psychic issue (personality disorder, psychic disorder, psychic illness) as an excuse are just dumb when they do that. If you’ll pardon my French.
It can be very harmful as well. People ruin their whole lives because of this compulsion as well as other people’s. How many spouses have destroyed their marriages and their children’s lives doing this? I know of a teenage girl who accused men of molesting her because she wanted to see if her mother would believe her or not. She could have gotten her teacher fired!
 
Thank you for this and for Schieffelin as well.

What is the best way to interact with friends who push your boundaries?
Personally, I was the type if sat down and told in a serious tone my behaviour was not welcome, I would listen. But I think I am the exception. Just make it clear you do not want to be in a room with them. But be prepared, chances are they will just go find another victim and not want to be around you because they will justify their behaviour and accuse you of being a cry baby. Once in a blue moon, they may become a better person, but chances are they won’t

CM
 
May be a cultural thing too. Different types and intensities of joking and sarcasm may be considered acceptable in different groups. ‘How you been’ doin’, you big fat smelly troll!’ can be a friendly greeting, depending on the context. In some cultures a jab is an invitation to jab back, intelligently. That’s a contest, a rivalry, all in good spirits. Not intended to hurt, just to scratch (sort of like animals ‘fight’ when they play).

But I tend to associate ‘pushing the boundaries’ more with people who seem to be actively checking how far they can take dishonesty and failure to live up to agreements, or how long they can ‘borrow’ your things without asking or returning, or put their own workload on you etc. Which is different, because it’s not play. This is natural to some extent (except the stealing), especially with regard to persons in position of authority (one does want to have a reasonably clear idea of how much those are willing to tolerate) but I think normal people probe for a moment until they find out and then stick to it, they don’t probe constantly.

More context from the OP would help. I understand this is a rant but perhaps we can still talk it over and get to some helpful conclusions.
Some people push boundaries in very subtle ways. They say something offensive. If you call them on it, they will apologize. However, the apology is insincere, because they were offensive on purpose and they will be offensive again in a similar variation very soon. These people are controversialists. Dealing with them once a year can be stimulating but any more often is stressful.
 
Some people push boundaries in very subtle ways. They say something offensive. If you call them on it, they will apologize. However, the apology is insincere, because they were offensive on purpose and they will be offensive again in a similar variation very soon.
I’m of the view that they don’t even try to fool people into the sincerity of such ‘apologies’ anymore. It just shows how much much sickening ego they have and how they strongly believe they can get away with it. They think they’re the rock star heroes and anyone else they don’t like should play the villain and the sub-par characters like they were supposed to.
These people are controversialists. Dealing with them once a year can be stimulating but any more often is stressful.
Frankly, there really isn’t any value to what they say. If you think there is, it isn’t because it’s coming out of the mouth of hypocrisy.

Believe me, I’m surrounded by such narcs and you can just see it in their attitude when you point out the hypocrisy of their so-called ‘lectures’ on being socially adept or being Mr./Ms. Personality. All pretensions of reason and ‘enlightenment’ fall down. After that, all you have left is an ugly troll who think life is all about getting together with other trolls and stepping on as many people as possible.
 
Thank you for this and for Schieffelin as well.

What is the best way to interact with friends who push your boundaries?
It just depends on exactly what they’re doing and exactly what you’re willing to put up with. If someone is pushing you because they’re a bit insecure, he/she may not realize he is doing it. If this person has a fear of abandonment you’re obviously just going to feed into that fear more if you just cut them off without any effort to understand them better. If it’s someone you care about, you have to have a frank but gentle conversation about it.

Saying something specific like “John, I really care about you but you have this habit of doing X that really bothers me, and I’m wondering if we can talk about why exactly you do that.” Now if you’re not close enough to this person to have such a discussion it may be better just to cut off contact.

I’m such a flawed person myself that it takes a lot for me to cut someone off (I would be the ultimate hypocrite if I didn’t show some patience and compassion in these situations), but I have done it before when that person was hurting my own emotional and mental health and he/she obviously had no interest in changing.
 
Some people push boundaries in very subtle ways. They say something offensive.
They’re not pushing your boundaries; they’re being rude. You deal with it the the same way you deal with other rude behaviors.
If you call them on it, they will apologize. However, the apology is insincere, because they were offensive on purpose and they will be offensive again.
Again, they’re not pushing your boundaries; they’re being passive aggressive. You deal with it the same way you deal with other passive aggressive behaviors.
These people are controversialists. Dealing with them once a year can be stimulating but any more often is stressful.
Have you been to grad school yet? 🙂

I couldn’t imagine having much of an intellectual life without conversations with people who challenge me to push my boundaries. And I doubt few people would make it through boot camp with someone (e.g., their drill sargeant) pushing their boundaries.

People and their behaviors will only get to you if you allow them to.

Luna
 
Some people push boundaries in very subtle ways. They say something offensive. If you call them on it, they will apologize. However, the apology is insincere, because they were offensive on purpose and they will be offensive again in a similar variation very soon. These people are controversialists. Dealing with them once a year can be stimulating but any more often is stressful.
Reminds me of a recent could-have-been of mine. A remarkable lady, one of a million kind, she had some powerfully annoying quirks. She would be testing and testing, which wouldn’t have been annyoing of itself, especially since I was testing and testing too, but the amounts of perceived intriguedness and energisedness in her voice when putting me in a difficult (and thus testing) situation with her behaviour were disconcerting (as if she thrived on it). Things didn’t work out.
 
Some people push boundaries in very subtle ways. They say something offensive. If you call them on it, they will apologize. However, the apology is insincere, because they were offensive on purpose and they will be offensive again in a similar variation very soon. These people are controversialists. Dealing with them once a year can be stimulating but any more often is stressful.
They apologize on the outside because they have ‘read the script’ and do what is expected. But what they are really saying is ‘Thank you. Now that I know how to hurt you I will be doing a lot more of it’

This is how I have dealt with it in the pass. (immature but effective). I hated being tall. So I would say ‘I wish I was taller’. Then people would make fun of me for being short’ I would pretend it hurt so they would continue and NEVER make fun of me for what really hurt.

CM
 
Incidentally, awakening a man’s jealousy by granting some favours to a different man is a tactic not foresworn by even some women who actually subscribe to much loftier principles on an overall basis, and I suppose there is a male equivalent of such behaviour too, although I can’t think of anything specific. I don’t really want to lose myself in argument against the outlook that considers this kind of behaviour acceptable (but I will fight to the death against it if I need to) but I really hate it. Personally, I’d much rather be in a relationship with someone who didn’t feel that kind of need or were able to reign it in (I can tolerate much in a person whom I see struggling to improve), although I think that to some extent everybody does it, just normally not to such extremes.

I suppose people need to convince themselves empirically that the other person (friend or love interest) will not withdraw affection (which entails investments) once he or she discovers the quirks or faults, e.g. moodiness, occasional foul moods, laziness, addictions, annoying but not criticial habits. Or attitudes, beliefs etc. that are hard for others to take, e.g. the Catholic beliefs on sexual morality from the point of view of a secular person, as in where you make your objection to premarital sex known without a direct conversation but by weaving it in so that a person whom you are only starting to date or considering dating can decide that he or she isn’t interested (better sooner than later).

This may follow a similar mechanic as the boundary pushing we talk about but simply involve less intensity of such action, less persistency in it (less tenacity as well), as well as not involving seriously immoral actions (let’s say a smoker lighting a cigarette to witness first-hand how a non-smoker romantic interest will react, which is something I could very much see myself doing, although I’d normally observe reactions rather than provoking situations).

Like I said above, normal people just stop at some point, they probably also won’t cross certain lines (such as hurting someone on purpose, saying a direct lie, breaking a promise to test reaction, let alone cheating on a romantic partner) and do things which are too evil, too unfair, too destructive. Then again, normal people make blunders once in a while, they are certainly capable of doing something really dumb just to see if they will still be loved or accepted…

I suppose the most critical difference is that some people do this testing for an acceptable reason (e.g. exposing people to your normal behaviour as opposed to testing their tolerance of the extreme things which you might feel like doing and which you know are immoral), they observe the due limits of this (again, not crossing certain lines), and finally settle with the results, while others probe constantly and are always on the push, often just to see if they can get away with it or whatever will happen or to assert their freedom and ability to get away with things or have things their way (NPD behaviour?). I’m not a psychologist but I’d hazard a guess that it has something to do with self-esteem and a need for affirmation (e.g. a child who so strongly feels a need to be believed that he will stage a lie to see if the parents believe it, a spouse who cheats to see if the other spouse will still be so loving as now is probably similar to that child, I don’t know, arrested emotional development?).
This is how I have dealt with it in the pass. (immature but effective). I hated being tall. So I would say ‘I wish I was taller’. Then people would make fun of me for being short’ I would pretend it hurt so they would continue and NEVER make fun of me for what really hurt.
No need! That’s pretty attractive in a woman, at least to some men.
I couldn’t imagine having much of an intellectual life without conversations with people who challenge me to push my boundaries. And I doubt few people would make it through boot camp with someone (e.g., their drill sargeant) pushing their boundaries.
That’s a different thing from what we first talked about. Doesn’t involve them being jerks to you to see how much they can get away with. The drill sergeant is closer to it but not when he’s just pushing the recruits to try harder, only when he tests their tolerance for abuse that go against the regs and the law (e.g. cussing their mothers etc. like we see in films).
 
Incidentally, awakening a man’s jealousy by granting some favours to a different man is a tactic not foresworn by even some women who actually subscribe to much loftier principles on an overall basis, and I suppose there is a male equivalent of such behaviour too, although I can’t think of anything specific.
Hey Chev, allow me to think for you
  • flirting with the waitress
  • looking over other women even if it is a magazine
  • talking about how gorgeous an ex was
And by the way, over the years, I have come to accept being tall 🙂
 
Hey Chev, allow me to think for you
  • flirting with the waitress
  • looking over other women even if it is a magazine
  • talking about how gorgeous an ex was
I’m glad you brought that up. While I’m a shameless flirt, I don’t:
  • flirt with the waitress (BUT: ‘Hi, Cynthia, looking good there as always,’ is frankly something a woman, especially a lady, should be able to take without envy, this isn’t much different from, ‘your sister/mother is (nearly) as beautiful as you are’);
  • look over other women (it’s a matter of courtesy and doesn’t even require your companion to be a love interest);
  • talk about how gorgeous an ex was (last thing a date needs to hear from us, really, very impolite and poor style).
BUT I’ve been on the receiving end of some of the above from women. Flirting with other men, e.g. sales staff to get discounts, looking at other men like you don’t exist while walking or sitting with you, talking about lovely exes or friends or random guys who happened to hit on them today (with all sorts of troubling vibes in voice), in fact, I could give you demotivational stories until we ran out of beer. But I doubt I’d even look at beer after two or three of those stories.
And by the way, over the years, I have come to accept being tall 🙂
Good. No offence intended but women have a knack for disliking their attractive traits and liking their… less particularly attractive ones. 😛 But I guess men are the same. Things women have liked in me have always made me uncomfortable.
 
Hey Chev, allow me to think for you
  • flirting with the waitress
  • looking over other women even if it is a magazine
  • talking about how gorgeous an ex was
And by the way, over the years, I have come to accept being tall 🙂
Like this!
Make them ex-friends.

I mean that.
You do have a “vengeance”. 😉 Is this really enough to make someone an ex-friend or boyfriend over?
 
Like this!

You do have a “vengeance”. 😉 Is this really enough to make someone an ex-friend or boyfriend over?
Ha ha, it’s just an expression. And yes, it definitely is enough to make them an ex-friend. Someone who doesn’t respect my boundaries is telling me, “You do not matter to me.” I get the message, very clearly. I don’t have time for selfish, narcissistic or other personality-defected people. They create chaos and cause pain. I don’t need them. I don’t want them. I do hate it that they find victims, but all I can do is keep them as far away from my life as I can.
 
Some people have an urge to see how far they can push your limits? Why? Is there any redeeming quality to this characteristic?
There are different ways that people push boundaries to test each other. Some of them have been mentioned here. But I think pushiness goes deeper than mere rudeness.

What I think is that it is part of our animal nature to want to establish a pecking order. All animals do this. Human children naturally do this. And adults do it too. The more naturally competitive a person is, the more he/she is likely to push boundaries to establish rank and to gain every possible advantage. In the animal world, the wisest, and the strongest spend a lot of time putting the would-be-social climbers in their place. This sort of thing goes on in the human world too. It’s a natural survival instinct.

As reasoning beings and as Christians we have the opportunity to recognize and overcome our baser instincts and to temper our actions when they get out of hand. I think we have to teach our children to recognize that there is a time and a place for competition but we have a higher calling than to achieve greatness in this life.

But I think it’s unrealistic not to recognize that we have the instinct to thrive and prosper. That instinct is God-given. It is our reason that gives us the choice about whether or not that prosperity is at the expense of others.
 
Why do people push my boundaries and test me?

Probably because theyve got some mileage from me with that behavior in the past. People who fail a couple of times to test my limits dont usually try again. The folks who are repeat offenders are also probably repeat succeeders. This would only be a big deal if their breaches were causing me to somehow behave with decreased virtue ( from the minimal amounts i do possess) or to sin. If their " getting over on me" doesnt result in a moral failure on my part or doesnt result in some harm to them, then what do i really care? Only thing lost is my pride.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top