Why Do Protestants Shun Mary?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Charlemagne_III
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Charlemagne_III

Guest
Catholicism has always held a special place of veneration (not worship) for the importance of Mary in Christian theology.

When, why, and who were the first Protestants to begin the shunning of Mary in their theology?
 
A genuine Non-Catholic Christian would not explicitly be “shunning” Mary. They would be shunning the Catholic Teachings (and resulting devotions, whether approved or not) regarding her.

Some Catholics try to justify “worship” of Mary on the basis of the wide use of the term. I dont agree with this theology. But I recognize that ‘within’ our worship of God alone, we recognize, admire, receive inspiration through, learn of Godliness, and honor all the saints of the Lord. This is what veneration means. And within the veneration of saints, we hold a unique place for His mother. This unique place is understanding that she has merited (upon the foundation of her Son’s grace) motherhood to all who keep His commandments.

The most important and fundamental example we can have for a devotion to His mother is the Apostle whom He gave us all His mother through… St John! John followed Jesus to the cross and comforted His mother in her agony. Jesus, then, gave His mother to us through the faith of His dear Apostle. To have this faith is to gain His mother as our own.

There are those who think they have a pure devotion to Mary because they have the outward practices of devotions, but really practice superstition in their religion. Some protestants honor Mary more than some Catholics who have rosary beads, images on their walls, etc.
 
Protestants shun Mary because Catholics love her. It’s that simple.
 
I’m not sure what you mean by shunning? I don’t purposefully mean to shun her. I just feel that she is not alive and holds no special power, that she was human like everyone else, though of course a very wonderful and blessed person.
 
I’m not sure what you mean by shunning? I don’t purposefully mean to shun her.
I can understand your sentiments. I think the important devotion and ‘embrace’ of Mary by Catholics is to first acknowledge her as a unique mother to all of us who follow her Son, to believe she was not merely His biological mother but His dearest disciple, and to believe in the Church’s Teachings as from her Son. It actually does harm to have an outward devotion to Mary yet pick and choose what to follow from Apostolic faith (the Sacred Scriptures and the Catechism).
I just feel that she is not alive
She is just as alive as me and you, if not more!
and holds no special power
She holds the most holy petition to Jesus of all mankind
,that she was human like everyone else, though of course a very wonderful and blessed person.
This is true. 👍
 
I’m not sure what you mean by shunning? I don’t purposefully mean to shun her. I just feel that she is not alive and holds no special power, that she was human like everyone else, though of course a very wonderful and blessed person.
You probably don’t mind that Washington, Lincoln, and Martin Luther King Jr. get holidays set aside for them, although they were human just like everyone else. Do Protestants do as much for Mary, who in the history of the human race certainly holds a more regal place in our hearts. The Catholic Church has several days of each year dedicated to the most important person who ever said “Thy will be done.”

That Mary’s spirit is not very much alive is certainly not true if you believe in heaven.

That she held (and there is every reason to believe she still holds) a special power is evident by her persuading Jesus, against his will, to change water into wine at the wedding feast at Cana. If she can intercede for the good of the wedding guests, why should she not be able to intercede for our good today? Is she not still the mother of Jesus? And is she not still our mother, as she was given by Jesus to be the mother of John at the foot of the cross.
 
I’m not sure what you mean by shunning? I don’t purposefully mean to shun her. I just feel that she is not alive and holds no special power, that she was human like everyone else, though of course a very wonderful and blessed person.
Mary is the Queen of a Heaven ,she is very much alive and is the mediatrix ibetween us and her Son.While Mary was human and in as much need of a Savior as all of us,God chose to preemptivey cleanse her of original sin through her Immaculate Conception.
All this because she was to be the Christbearer.This alone makes her Blessed among women therefore meriting our love and honor.
 
I’m not sure what you mean by shunning? I don’t purposefully mean to shun her. I just feel that she is not alive and holds no special power, that she was human like everyone else, though of course a very wonderful and blessed person.
She is a Hidden Treasure… seek and ye shall find .🙂
 
My non-Catholic Christian friend and others seem to hate the idea that Mary is without sin and they don’t like the Saints either. They say that we are all saints. I have to admit I don’t understand this mentality well.

But it really does seem like a form of pride to me. They hate the idea that some people are holier than they are and that Mary is to be highly venerated for good reason.

It makes me angry when they call Our Lady a “vessel”.
 
Mary is the Queen of a Heaven ,she is very much alive and is the mediatrix ibetween us and her Son.While Mary was human and in as much need of a Savior as all of us,God chose to preemptivey cleanse her of original sin through her Immaculate Conception.
All this because she was to be the Christbearer.This alone makes her Blessed among women therefore meriting our love and honor.
I believe her faithfulness merited our love and honor, not merely bearing Jesus in her womb. Didnt Jesus say, “Rather, blessed are those who hear the Word of God and obey it.” 🤷
 
I believe her faithfulness merited our love and honor, not merely bearing Jesus in her womb. Didnt Jesus say, “Rather, blessed are those who hear the Word of God and obey it.” 🤷
Yes,you are correct!I had forgotten that!👍
 
When i was growing up in a southern baptist church, Mary got only a customary glimpse on Mothers day when they would have all the mothers stand and be applauded. A year before my confirmation in the CC, she spoke to me; i cried like a baby when i realized it was her. I was so upset/angry with my upbringing after that experience; that the church i grew up in tried to keep her from me. She has intervened for me through prayer on more than one occasion. Some people are truly missing a joy, a gift, given us by our Lord.
 
…she is very much alive and is the mediatrix ibetween us and her Son.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^Because of the teaching on this^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

“For there is one God, and one mediator of God and men, the man Christ Jesus”
(Douay-Rheims Bible in 1Tim2:5)

Actually shunning is not the correct term, we choose not to worship her. I know RC teaching states it is not worship, but when the frequency and fervency of the focus on Mary is as it is reflected in modern Roman Catholicism, it is seen for all practical purposes as worship. As others have stated, we honor her as the woman chosen by God to carry His Son, but that is generally where it stops.
 
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^Because of the teaching on this^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

“For there is one God, and one mediator of God and men, the man Christ Jesus”
(Douay-Rheims Bible in 1Tim2:5)

Actually hate is not the correct term, we choose not to worship her. I know RC teaching states it is not worship, but when the frequency and fervency of the focus on Mary is as it is reflected in modern Roman Catholicism, it is seen for all practical purposes as worship. As others have staed, we honor her as the woman chosen by God to carry His Son, but that is generally where it stops.
Gebriah,the biblical term used for the Queen Mother,as is was common practice that the people would go to her imploring her to intercede to her son,the King.The same holds true for our Mother Mary.Again,for the umpteenth time,re this issue in other threads.Christ performed his first miracle at Cana at his mother’s request.He refuses his mother nothing.
 
I think it’s mainly ignorance…Martin Luther held our Blessed Mother in much the same way as Catholics do…even John Wesley believed in the perpetual virginity of Mary…yet over time as Protestantism moved farther away from the Catholic faith misunderstanding and straight out false teaching about Catholicism grew…I think it is especially more so today among Evangelical/Fundamentalist Protestants…I wonder how some Protestants will react when they get to heaven if our Lord were to ask them what they think of his mother…" well…it’s like this Lord…she may be have been chosen by your father (God) out of all his created beings to give birth to you…his son and our Savior…and she…the one who all generations shall call blessed… your mother…but to me she meant…and means nothing"…I wonder how that would go down with Jesus:D
 
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^Because of the teaching on this^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

“For there is one God, and one mediator of God and men, the man Christ Jesus”
(Douay-Rheims Bible in 1Tim2:5)

Actually shunning is not the correct term, we choose not to worship her. I know RC teaching states it is not worship, but when the frequency and fervency of the focus on Mary is as it is reflected in modern Roman Catholicism, it is seen for all practical purposes as worship. As others have stated, we honor her as the woman chosen by God to carry His Son, but that is generally where it stops.
Yes, her “co-mediatrix” can be taken as contradicting 1Tim 2:5 if not understood in genuine faith. And I will admit that BOTH protestants and Catholics can abuse the Truth behind it. The answer lies in the fact that Christ is also truly a mystical body which is one unified family of many members. Mary’s motherhood is a unique role in some ways, but not entirely different than all believers. We can all cooperate in Jesus’ sole mediation to God when we do His will. We are doing the work of Christ. We can all make intercession to God for others by prayer and honoring our prayers by our obedience to Him in our lives. Mary was first in cronological order and in order of grace given to her by her proximity to Him, in which she maintained until the end.

If your appreciation for Mary stops at the mere fact that God chose her to bear Jesus in her womb, you are missing much of Scripture. She is our mother in the faith of a family in Christ. To fully honor Christ is to receive her as a mother whom we have the holy prayers of intercession and recourse.
 
I think it’s mainly ignorance…Martin Luther held our Blessed Mother in much the same way as Catholics do…even John Wesley believed in the perpetual virginity of Mary…yet over time as Protestantism moved farther away from the Catholic faith misunderstanding and straight out false teaching about Catholicism grew…I think it is especially more so today among Evangelical/Fundamentalist Protestants…I wonder how some Protestants will react when they get to heaven if our Lord were to ask them what they think of his mother…" well…it’s like this Lord…she may be have been chosen by your father (God) out of all his created beings to give birth to you…his son and our Savior…and she…the one who all generations shall call blessed… your mother…but to me she meant…and means nothing"…I wonder how that would go down with Jesus:D
Agree!
 
Some non-Catholics think praying to the saints in heaven is ineffective. Some non-Catholics even think it is sinful, interpreting the prohibition in Deuteronomy 18:11 against being "a medium … or a necromancer, or, as the New American Bible puts it, being “one who consults ghosts and spirits or seeks oracles from the dead,” as a prohibition against praying to the saints in heaven for their Christian intercession on our behalf.
 
Very interested in this topic.

Lifelong Catholic with some issues myself about the “co-mediatrix” title.

That’s all I have to say for now.
 
I honestly don’t know. I have a friend who worked as a teacher in a Catholic school for a time, and loved that she has freedom to pray there. There were prayers in the daily assemblies, and she would join in with most, but never the Hail Mary, and her words to me were ‘I’m not praying to a dead woman’. This friend believed in healing miracles and all sorts of crazy charismatic phenomena, but the idea that we could ask saints to pray for us, or speak to Mary as our mother was ridiculous to her.

For myself, I used to listen to preachers talk about her as a bit part player in the story of redemption, almost an after thought, necessary to the Christmas story but largely an irrelevance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top