A
andrewstx
Guest
I think it is a difference in cultures than anything else. Catholics seem quiter in general. We spoke and sang in tounges but quietly.Really??? Do tell?
In reality, raising one’s hands is quite different from “throwing oneself around” and “gyrating”. One involves the lifting of one’s hands. The other involves, well “gyrating.”
And another thing, “gyrating” is a word with some negative connotations. It suggests “suggestive” movements, and it is ridiculous to say that any one moved to worship God with their whole body, mind, and soul is “gyrating” provocatively.
There is a time and place for everything. Sometimes its good to wait on the Lord in the stillness and splendor of His holiness. Other times, it is good to lift up your voice and dance before the Lord.
I’m sorry to burst everyone’s bubble, but when David was before the very presence of the Lord he did offer God praise by “leaping and dancing.” Of course, not everyone could tolerate such openness and vulnerability. David’s wife told David he was “vulgar,” but David was not phased or troubled. He told his wife, “I will make myself yet more contemptible than this, and I will be abased in your eyes.” (2 Samuel 6:16-23)
Who said that praise to God had to be dignified or acceptable to the sensibilities of bystanders?
I’m sorry for making a big deal about this. But I find it odd that so many people have so many ideas about what is the proper and right ways to worship God that in reality often contradict examples we are shown in Scripture. If its good enough for King David to praise God in a dance and a shout, why not for me?
Perhaps it comes from Catholicism in Americas Irish roots. Irish learned to be quiet in church during penal days.
I am very sure things would be more lively in Hispanic parishes.