Why do we have to live by faith?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bohm_Bawerk
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bohm_Bawerk

Guest
With the “war in Heaven”, it is often said that the angels who rebelled could not be forgiven because they had full knowledge of God’s glory and were therefore an abomination to Him. If angels were not pardoned because they had full knowledge of God, doesn’t that logically mean that Humans who don’t live by faith (be it Atheists, Agnostics or those of other denominations/religions) can be pardoned by God, since these groups of people never really had full knowledge of God?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
With the “war in Heaven”, it is often said that the angels who rebelled could not be forgiven because they had full knowledge of God’s glory and were therefore an abomination to Him. If angels were not pardoned because they had full knowledge of God, doesn’t that logically mean that Humans who don’t live by faith (be it Atheists, Agnostics or those of other denominations/religions) can be pardoned by God, since these groups of people never really had full knowledge of God?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
Please give your sources regarding the War in Heaven. I have heard the tradition, those angels who wanted to be as God were the ones tossed out. They were guilty of the sin of Pride.
 
Please give your sources regarding the War in Heaven. I have heard the tradition, those angels who wanted to be as God were the ones tossed out. They were guilty of the sin of Pride.
I’ll try and look it up where I read it and post it later. Yes, the angels were tossed out and became demons instead. Some people ask how come the rebellious angels can’t be forgiven, and it is said they can’t be forgiven because they had full knowledge of God and His glory. They therefore brought their banishment upon themselves, and that they were a massive disgrace to God. Humans aren’t that fortunate to have experienced God, since they have the stain of Original Sin, and are therefore inherently alienated from God.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
I’ll try and look it up where I read it and post it later. Yes, the angels were tossed out and became demons instead. Some people ask how come the rebellious angels can’t be forgiven, and it is said they can’t be forgiven because they had full knowledge of God and His glory. They therefore brought their banishment upon themselves, and that they were a massive disgrace to God. Humans aren’t that fortunate to have experienced God, since they have the stain of Original Sin, and are therefore inherently alienated from God.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
The angels cannot be forgiven because they are elect. The disposition of their will (toward or away from God) once changed lasts forever. That being the case those angels who chose against God do not and will not every want to be right with God or reconciled to Him. Since in their free will they chose against God then it would be against that free will for God to forcibly bring them back to Him. Humans however only have fixed wills after death, so while on earth we can move toward or away from God. After death the will enters the realm of the eternal, so whatever it was before it died remains the way it will be forever. Hence, it is never too late to repent on earth, but once you die you’re stuck. You wont want to be reconciled with God.

As for Atheists and such, well, there is a difference between not having knowledge of God, and refusing to acknowledge the fact that He exists.
 
Jesus,our Lords peace be whit You.
We don’t have to live by faith,God has given us a free will to choose,and we can do what ever we want,but why would we choose to NOT living by faith? No matter if we believe or not,God is real and if we choose not to believe He is still real,so why live whithout faith,is there anyone who wants to choose hell and not heaven? And to Your questions,do You realy believ,do You want to believ or do You just want to test our faith? Because if Your faith is real,why ask theese questions? (I guess I will get tossed out from this forum because of this ansver but I defend my faith,my beleive and God to the end and hope to save a few souls doing so.) A true Christian don’t ask things like Your questions,or try to “understand”,we get all the ansver one day in heaven (or hell) and that is why the only thing we need to do is live our life the way God wants us to. By picking and looking for things that don’t fit our faith we do a sin. God don’t wants us to ask why,he loves us,we have a free will,and whit that will comes also the choises we make,and I choose heaven,if I can. Because in the end You see,all thats matter is how we have lived our life on earth.
Blessings,
Totterman
 
Jesus,our Lords peace be whit You.
We don’t have to live by faith,God has given us a free will to choose,and we can do what ever we want,but why would we choose to NOT living by faith? No matter if we believe or not,God is real and if we choose not to believe He is still real,so why live whithout faith,is there anyone who wants to choose hell and not heaven? And to Your questions,do You realy believ,do You want to believ or do You just want to test our faith? Because if Your faith is real,why ask theese questions? (I guess I will get tossed out from this forum because of this ansver but I defend my faith,my beleive and God to the end and hope to save a few souls doing so.) A true Christian don’t ask things like Your questions,or try to “understand”,we get all the ansver one day in heaven (or hell) and that is why the only thing we need to do is live our life the way God wants us to. By picking and looking for things that don’t fit our faith we do a sin. God don’t wants us to ask why,he loves us,we have a free will,and whit that will comes also the choises we make,and I choose heaven,if I can. Because in the end You see,all thats matter is how we have lived our life on earth.
Blessings,
Totterman
I think I’m perfectly free to ask as many questions as I want. My questions aren’t polemical (which is why it says “Catholic” in the Religion space rather than “Atheist”). It’s also important for me to understand as many things about as Catholicism as I possibly can, as I only came back to the Catholic faith a few months ago.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
Please give your sources regarding the War in Heaven. I have heard the tradition, those angels who wanted to be as God were the ones tossed out. They were guilty of the sin of Pride.
It’s in Revelation 12.
 
With the “war in Heaven”, it is often said that the angels who rebelled could not be forgiven because they had full knowledge of God’s glory and were therefore an abomination to Him. If angels were not pardoned because they had full knowledge of God, doesn’t that logically mean that Humans who don’t live by faith (be it Atheists, Agnostics or those of other denominations/religions) can be pardoned by God, since these groups of people never really had full knowledge of God?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
non Christians can be saved only if they are invinsibly ignorant AND tried to live a good life… invinsible ignorance means they are ignorant through no fault of their own. If they were offered a grace to believe in God but rejected it, that is a sin. Invinsible ignorance is not as common as many people think… as it says in the Bible, we are without excuse because all of creation testified to God’s glory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top