B
bingbell484
Guest
I don’t buy the “cultural acceptance” argument. There are lots of things that cultures have accepted over the years, but remain a sin.
Slavery doesn’t lead to murder and rape?Slavery is one thing.
Covetousness can lead to many things including murder and rape.
The commandment not to steal removes the possibility of engaging in the slave trade and this has been recognized since the time of Moses. Exodus 21:16 says, “Whoever steals a man and sells him, and anyone found in possession of him, shall be put to death.”I don’t buy the “cultural acceptance” argument. There are lots of things that cultures have accepted over the years, but remain a sin.
Oh my. That doesn’t help at all. In fact, it suggests to me that maybe there isn’t a good answer to this. Slavery was “not a moral evil?” And If there are forms of slavery that exist now, does that mean I should just stop thinking about it?Slavery, as practiced by Israel, was not a moral evil. Slaves had rights and could not be abused by their owners without the owners suffering consequences of the Law. And slavery was not a life-long condition unless the slave wished it. Every seven years slaves were to be set free. If they weren’t there were also consequences in the Law for that.
In modern times we have forms of slavery although we don’t think of it as that. When people must work at a certain occupation for others because there are no options due to the covetousness of others, that too is slavery. Perhaps we should be more concerned about the evils of our own times.![]()
Wow it must have been great to have been a slave back then!!The commandment not to steal removes the possibility of engaging in the slave trade and this has been recognized since the time of Moses. Exodus 21:16 says, “Whoever steals a man and sells him, and anyone found in possession of him, shall be put to death.”
Because the Jews could not legally participate in the slave trade, they only got their forced laborers from volunteers, such as the patriarch Jacob, and prisoners of war. The Law also protected the civil rights of these “slaves” – who are more properly called servants. The law of Moses was actually very advanced for its time on this issue, and therefore I don’t think it’s fair to say that it was immoral.
Under the law of Moses servants had:
Right to life – Exodus 21:20 – Marriage rights – Exodus 10-11, Exodus 21:4 – Kinship rights – Exodus 21:3, 9; Leviticus 25:41, 47-49, 54
Protection from breach of contract and physical violence – Exodus 21:20-21, 26-27 for foreign or Hebrew servants; Exodus 21:8 for a Hebrew daughter in a marriage; Leviticus 25:39-41 for Hebrew servants.
Right to one day free from labor, participating in the Sabbath with other free servants – Deuteronomy 5:14, Exodus 20:10.
Access to liberty and freedom of movement – Leviticus 25:40-45, 48, 54 for Hebrew indentured servants; Deuteronomy 15:1, 12; 23:15 for foreign or Hebrew servants; Exodus 21:8, 11 for a Hebrew daughter in a marriage.
All servants maintained their rights unless voluntarily relinquished – Deuteronomy 15:16-17, Exodus 21:5-6.
The person who had a servant was accountable to the law for their treatment of the servant, whether the servant was a foreigner or a Hebrew – Exodus 21:20-21, 26-27.
If a person who had a servant struck the servant and knocked his tooth or eye out he had to let the servant go free – Exodus 21:26-27.
Under the Law of Moses you could purchase women and men who voluntarily sold themselves into indentured servitude but you could not sell them – Exodus 21:2, Leviticus 25:39, 42, 45, Deuteronomy 15:12.
Enslaving someone against their will or selling people into slavery was forbidden – Exodus 21:16, Deuteronomy 24:7.
Any servant who ran away was automatically allowed to go and live as they chose. It would be illegal to oppress the servant or return them to whoever they worked for – Deuteronomy 23:15. Thus it was automatically a voluntary system, because at any time you could leave and you would be free forever. It was entered into to avoid poverty or for payment of debt (which was released every seven years; Deut. 15:1, 12).
The Law of Moses protected the Hebrew indentured servants from permanent debt and if the servant was released in the year of debt-cancellation, the person who the servant had worked for had to give them generous supplies from his own store – Deuteronomy 15:13-15.
Servants were to be included in community feast, Deuteronomy 12:12; the Feast of Booths, Deuteronomy 16:13; and the Feast of Weeks, Deuteronomy 16:10.
Under the law of Moses the only income priests received was from some offerings made under the sacrificial code and from the tithe. Usually the offerings of food were only to be eaten by priests because it had been ritually sanctified and could not be eaten by a non-priest. According to Leviticus 22:10 a priest could not offer it to lodger, hired work or guest but Leviticus 22:11 makes clear that a priest could share the food with a servant.
Death of a servant caused by a domestic animal had to be compensated – Exodus 21:32 – but the death of non-servants did not have to be compensated unless the animal was previously known to be a danger (see Exodus 21:28-29).
dmar198 gives a fuller account of slavery in Israel. But this answer is the answer because slavery, in and of itself, is not wrong. People can bind themselves to others in life-long servitude if they wish. What is wrong is forcing people into such a state of life against their will and against the Laws of God, and then treating them like mere property with which owners can do whatever they wish. This is where the morality of slavery comes into play–if it is imposed, is against the Laws of God, and how slaves are treated.Oh my. That doesn’t help at all. In fact, it suggests to me that maybe there isn’t a good answer to this.
Well, I appreciate that, but slavery was and is a great moral evil. I am Catholic and not trying to be unchristian, but the fact that Jesus really never spoke out against it surprises me. I don’t accept that divorce is worthy of specific mention but not the enslavement of others.The commandment not to steal removes the possibility of engaging in the slave trade and this has been recognized since the time of Moses. Exodus 21:16 says, “Whoever steals a man and sells him, and anyone found in possession of him, shall be put to death.”
Because the Jews could not legally participate in the slave trade, they only got their forced laborers from volunteers, such as the patriarch Jacob, and prisoners of war. The Law also protected the civil rights of these “slaves” – who are more properly called servants. The law of Moses was actually very advanced for its time on this issue, and therefore I don’t think it’s fair to say that it was immoral.
Under the law of Moses servants had:
Right to life – Exodus 21:20 – Marriage rights – Exodus 10-11, Exodus 21:4 – Kinship rights – Exodus 21:3, 9; Leviticus 25:41, 47-49, 54
Protection from breach of contract and physical violence – Exodus 21:20-21, 26-27 for foreign or Hebrew servants; Exodus 21:8 for a Hebrew daughter in a marriage; Leviticus 25:39-41 for Hebrew servants.
Right to one day free from labor, participating in the Sabbath with other free servants – Deuteronomy 5:14, Exodus 20:10.
Access to liberty and freedom of movement – Leviticus 25:40-45, 48, 54 for Hebrew indentured servants; Deuteronomy 15:1, 12; 23:15 for foreign or Hebrew servants; Exodus 21:8, 11 for a Hebrew daughter in a marriage.
All servants maintained their rights unless voluntarily relinquished – Deuteronomy 15:16-17, Exodus 21:5-6.
The person who had a servant was accountable to the law for their treatment of the servant, whether the servant was a foreigner or a Hebrew – Exodus 21:20-21, 26-27.
If a person who had a servant struck the servant and knocked his tooth or eye out he had to let the servant go free – Exodus 21:26-27.
Under the Law of Moses you could purchase women and men who voluntarily sold themselves into indentured servitude but you could not sell them – Exodus 21:2, Leviticus 25:39, 42, 45, Deuteronomy 15:12.
Enslaving someone against their will or selling people into slavery was forbidden – Exodus 21:16, Deuteronomy 24:7.
Any servant who ran away was automatically allowed to go and live as they chose. It would be illegal to oppress the servant or return them to whoever they worked for – Deuteronomy 23:15. Thus it was automatically a voluntary system, because at any time you could leave and you would be free forever. It was entered into to avoid poverty or for payment of debt (which was released every seven years; Deut. 15:1, 12).
The Law of Moses protected the Hebrew indentured servants from permanent debt and if the servant was released in the year of debt-cancellation, the person who the servant had worked for had to give them generous supplies from his own store – Deuteronomy 15:13-15.
Servants were to be included in community feast, Deuteronomy 12:12; the Feast of Booths, Deuteronomy 16:13; and the Feast of Weeks, Deuteronomy 16:10.
Under the law of Moses the only income priests received was from some offerings made under the sacrificial code and from the tithe. Usually the offerings of food were only to be eaten by priests because it had been ritually sanctified and could not be eaten by a non-priest. According to Leviticus 22:10 a priest could not offer it to lodger, hired work or guest but Leviticus 22:11 makes clear that a priest could share the food with a servant.
Death of a servant caused by a domestic animal had to be compensated – Exodus 21:32 – but the death of non-servants did not have to be compensated unless the animal was previously known to be a danger (see Exodus 21:28-29).
Well, I appreciate that, but slavery was and is a great moral evil. I am Catholic and not trying to be unchristian, but the fact that Jesus really never spoke out against it surprises me. I don’t accept that divorce is worthy of specific mention but not the enslavement of others.The commandment not to steal removes the possibility of engaging in the slave trade and this has been recognized since the time of Moses. Exodus 21:16 says, “Whoever steals a man and sells him, and anyone found in possession of him, shall be put to death.”
Because the Jews could not legally participate in the slave trade, they only got their forced laborers from volunteers, such as the patriarch Jacob, and prisoners of war. The Law also protected the civil rights of these “slaves” – who are more properly called servants. The law of Moses was actually very advanced for its time on this issue, and therefore I don’t think it’s fair to say that it was immoral.
Under the law of Moses servants had:
Right to life – Exodus 21:20 – Marriage rights – Exodus 10-11, Exodus 21:4 – Kinship rights – Exodus 21:3, 9; Leviticus 25:41, 47-49, 54
Protection from breach of contract and physical violence – Exodus 21:20-21, 26-27 for foreign or Hebrew servants; Exodus 21:8 for a Hebrew daughter in a marriage; Leviticus 25:39-41 for Hebrew servants.
Right to one day free from labor, participating in the Sabbath with other free servants – Deuteronomy 5:14, Exodus 20:10.
Access to liberty and freedom of movement – Leviticus 25:40-45, 48, 54 for Hebrew indentured servants; Deuteronomy 15:1, 12; 23:15 for foreign or Hebrew servants; Exodus 21:8, 11 for a Hebrew daughter in a marriage.
All servants maintained their rights unless voluntarily relinquished – Deuteronomy 15:16-17, Exodus 21:5-6.
The person who had a servant was accountable to the law for their treatment of the servant, whether the servant was a foreigner or a Hebrew – Exodus 21:20-21, 26-27.
If a person who had a servant struck the servant and knocked his tooth or eye out he had to let the servant go free – Exodus 21:26-27.
Under the Law of Moses you could purchase women and men who voluntarily sold themselves into indentured servitude but you could not sell them – Exodus 21:2, Leviticus 25:39, 42, 45, Deuteronomy 15:12.
Enslaving someone against their will or selling people into slavery was forbidden – Exodus 21:16, Deuteronomy 24:7.
Any servant who ran away was automatically allowed to go and live as they chose. It would be illegal to oppress the servant or return them to whoever they worked for – Deuteronomy 23:15. Thus it was automatically a voluntary system, because at any time you could leave and you would be free forever. It was entered into to avoid poverty or for payment of debt (which was released every seven years; Deut. 15:1, 12).
The Law of Moses protected the Hebrew indentured servants from permanent debt and if the servant was released in the year of debt-cancellation, the person who the servant had worked for had to give them generous supplies from his own store – Deuteronomy 15:13-15.
Servants were to be included in community feast, Deuteronomy 12:12; the Feast of Booths, Deuteronomy 16:13; and the Feast of Weeks, Deuteronomy 16:10.
Under the law of Moses the only income priests received was from some offerings made under the sacrificial code and from the tithe. Usually the offerings of food were only to be eaten by priests because it had been ritually sanctified and could not be eaten by a non-priest. According to Leviticus 22:10 a priest could not offer it to lodger, hired work or guest but Leviticus 22:11 makes clear that a priest could share the food with a servant.
Death of a servant caused by a domestic animal had to be compensated – Exodus 21:32 – but the death of non-servants did not have to be compensated unless the animal was previously known to be a danger (see Exodus 21:28-29).
St. Paul condemns human trafficking in 1 Timothy 1:10 - “for slave traders and liars and perjurers…[are] contrary to sound doctrine.” St. John condemns human trafficking in Revelation 18:13. Galatians 3:28 and Ephesians 6:8-9 assert the equality of slaves. I think it’s important to recognize that the reason slavery is prohibited today is because of Christianity.Well, I appreciate that, but slavery was and is a great moral evil. I am Catholic and not trying to be unchristian, but the fact that Jesus really never spoke out against it surprises me. I don’t accept that divorce is worthy of specific mention but not the enslavement of others.
I won’t post on this anymore. I was hoping that there was some explanation that truly makes sense. I’ll keep looking.
I agree that the abuses that often came with slavery are evils, but permanent servitude entered into of one’s own free will is not. Please see my 2nd post in this thread.Slavery was, is and always will be a great evil. Anyone who says otherwise doesn’t know what they are talking about.
People were selling their own brothers into slavery for profit, killing their own brothers to gain an inheritance, drinking blood and eating human flesh, having sex with their mothers and fathers and siblings and animals, and sacrificing children to the god Molech. It got so bad that God was going to wipe out the entire creation in the flood. God spared Noah but Noah’s son “uncovered his father’s nakedness” right after the flood ended - that means that he had sex with his mother.
It was bad. The Mosaic law given by God was the first attempt to control what was an out of control situation. The law of Moses were the first controls on these behaviors. The ten commandments are more than controls however - they are a set of moral imperatives which man was never to transgress. The ten commandments were a line in the sand which no man was to cross.
Slavery was always bad. God’s rules about slavery were the first controls on what was an out of control situation. Slavery was ended - that’s what the Book of Philemon is about. Ones’imus was sent back as a free man.
Perhaps this is why he was parted from you for a while, that you might have him back for ever, no longer as a slave but more than a slave, as a beloved brother, especially to me but how much more to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord. So if you consider me your partner, receive him as you would receive me. (Philemon 1:15-17)
-Tim-
Hmmm, yes.Ummm…notsomuch:
When a man strikes his male or female slave with a rod so hard that the slave dies under his hand, he shall be punished. If, however, the slave survives for a day or two, he is not to be punished, since the slave is his own property. (Exodus 21:20-21 NAB)
When a man sells his daughter as a slave, she will not be freed at the end of six years as the men are… (Exodus 21:7-11 NLT)
However, you may purchase male or female slaves from among the foreigners who live among you. You may also purchase the children of such resident foreigners, including those who have been born in your land. You may treat them as your property, passing them on to your children as a permanent inheritance. You may treat your slaves like this, but the people of Israel, your relatives, must never be treated this way. (Leviticus 25:44-46 NLT)
…etc, etc, and so on.
.
Are you suggesting that all the slaves in Israel were there because they chose to be?I agree that the abuses that often came with slavery are evils, but permanent servitude entered into of one’s own free will is not. Please see my 2nd post in this thread.![]()
So that makes it ok?You think you aren’t a slave? Slavery works on several levels. Just because you get paid doesn’t mean you aren’t bound to someone/something else for your means of survival. Ask yourself, how do spend most of your days?
Ecclesiastes 5:7
“If you see oppression of the poor, and violation of rights and justice in the realm, do not be shocked by the fact, for the high official had another higher than he watching him and above these are others higher still.”
We are all slaves to someone. Its who you make the master of your heart that counts. (and this is where covetousness comes in - Who does your heart serve?)
Except that it didn’t end.Slavery was, is and always will be a great evil. Anyone who says otherwise doesn’t know what they are talking about.
People were selling their own brothers into slavery for profit, killing their own brothers to gain an inheritance, drinking blood and eating human flesh, having sex with their mothers and fathers and siblings and animals, and sacrificing children to the god Molech. It got so bad that God was going to wipe out the entire creation in the flood. God spared Noah but Noah’s son “uncovered his father’s nakedness” right after the flood ended - that means that he had sex with his mother.
It was bad. The Mosaic law given by God was the first attempt to control what was an out of control situation. The law of Moses were the first controls on these behaviors. The ten commandments are more than controls however - they are a set of moral imperatives which man was never to transgress. The ten commandments were a line in the sand which no man was to cross.
Slavery was always bad. God’s rules about slavery were the first controls on what was an out of control situation. Slavery was ended - that’s what the Book of Philemon is about. Ones’imus was sent back as a free man.
Perhaps this is why he was parted from you for a while, that you might have him back for ever, no longer as a slave but more than a slave, as a beloved brother, especially to me but how much more to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord. So if you consider me your partner, receive him as you would receive me. (Philemon 1:15-17)
-Tim-
The meaning of the word back then and the meaning of the word for us now is different. Back then, most spaves were either people who had fallen into debt or prisoners of war. The only other option with the prisoners of war was to kill them; people did not have the resources then to build prisons for them as we do now.Well, I appreciate that, but slavery was and is a great moral evil. I am Catholic and not trying to be unchristian, but the fact that Jesus really never spoke out against it surprises me. I don’t accept that divorce is worthy of specific mention but not the enslavement of others.
I won’t post on this anymore. I was hoping that there was some explanation that truly makes sense. I’ll keep looking.
Slavery in ScriptureI don’t buy the “cultural acceptance” argument. There are lots of things that cultures have accepted over the years, but remain a sin.