Why does God allow people to be blind and deaf?

  • Thread starter Thread starter GeordieJosh
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

GeordieJosh

Guest
Hello,

I am a recent convert to the faith and I never been happier. An atheist friend of mine asked a question about the faith, and I would appreciate some help in answering. He asked me why God allows people to be deaf and blind? How can the child know God? Is this not proof of a cruel and capricious world, devoid of the love of God and a divine plan.
 
First of all, it’s important to note that such physical ailments are merely the result of natural causes. It is part and parcel of the material world that God decided to make—that is a world void of a perpetual miracle.

Secondly, God’s allowance of suffering is a mystery. The Catechism of the Catholic Church acknowledges this in paragraph 309.

Now, by acknowledging it as a mystery does not mean it is unreasonable.

For example, we know by faith that all human suffering is a result of the fall. If Adam and Eve had remained in Divine intimacy with God, then all humans would have been free from suffering (see Catechism of the Catholic Church 376).

Furthermore, it is perfectly in accord with God’s goodness to permit suffering if there is a greater good that He knows and wills to bring about. For example, I allow my wife to cause suffering to the children when she pours peroxide on their cuts even when I have the power to stop her. But this doesn’t account against my goodness because I know of the greater good that will come from the permitting this form of suffering. Similarly, because there is no good that God cannot bring about due to His omnipotence, His permission of suffering does not count against His goodness.

For a further explanation of the problem evil, you might want to purchase Trent Horn’s book Answering Atheism.

Here are some articles that serve as snippets of what Trent covers in the book:
catholic.com/blog/matt-fradd/the-problem-of-evil

catholic.com/blog/trent-horn/why-horrible-suffering-does-not-disprove-gods-existence
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top