Why does God allow this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter iaskquestions
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

iaskquestions

Guest
Why does God allow women to be insulted?

“One man among a thousand I found, but a woman among all these I have not found.” (Ecclesiastes 7:28)

“Better is the wickedness of a man than a woman who does good :eek: ; and it is a woman who brings shame and disgrace.”
 
One more,

“It is these who have not defiled themselves with women, for they are chaste; it is these who follow the Lamb wherever he goes; these have been redeemed from mankind as first fruits for God and the Lamb,” (Rev 14:4)
 
Because really they aren’t insults.

I’m a woman and in the context of these Scriptural writings it does not necessarily follow that God is ‘dissing’ women.

It’s hard for the women of today who have been pretty well reared to consider all men throughout history as monsters bent on enslaving and degrading women not to look at passages like these (or even contemporary works) without frothing at the mouth about the rampant unfairness of it all.

Let’s see more of the context of Chapter 7 which itself is about mortification, penance, and seeking wisdom.
21 For there is no just man upon earth, that doth good, and sinneth not. 22 But do not apply thy heart to all words that are spoken: lest perhaps thou hear thy servant reviling thee. 23 For thy conscience knoweth that thou also hast often spoken evil of others. 24 I have tried all things in wisdom. I have said: I will be wise: and it departed farther from me, 25 Much more than it was: it is a great depth, who shall find it out? 26 I have surveyed all things with my mind, to know, and consider, and seek out wisdom and reason: and to know the wickedness of the fool, and the error of the imprudent: 27 And I have found a woman more bitter than death, who is the hunter’s snare, and her heart is a net, and her hands are bands. He that pleaseth God shall escape from her: but he that is a sinner, shall be caught by her. 28 Lo this have I found, said Ecclesiastes, weighing one thing after another, that I might find out the account, 29 Which yet my soul seeketh, and I have not found it. One man among a thousand I have found, a woman among them all I have not found. 30 Only this I have found, that God made man right, and he hath entangled himself with an infinity of questions. Who is as the wise man? and who hath known the resolution of the word?
First it appears he is referencing back obliquely to ‘a woman’ (not all women and perhaps not even a mortal woman. Wisdom itself is often portrayed as ‘feminine’–an antithesis to the feminine wisdom could likewise be this ‘bitter’ woman who keeps one from finding wisdom). Also remember, he finds the whole subject of finding wisdom difficult. In a time when women were not educated in the way men were, being more notable for practical education as opposed to ‘metaphysics’, it would not be considered ‘insulting’ to note that among men, 1 out of 1000 could even consider such a weighty subject but a woman had not been found by THIS WRITER to discourse on the subject.
Here is the commentary from Douay Rheims on one of your quotes:
14 For better is the iniquity of a man, than a woman doing a good turn, and a woman bringing shame and reproach. 15 I will now remember the works of the Lord, and I will declare the things I have seen. By the words of the Lord are his works.
14 “Better is the iniquity”… That is, there is, commonly speaking, less danger to be apprehended to the soul from the churlishness, or injuries we receive from men, than from the flattering favours and familiarity of women.
And that is a true and reasonable statement. Remember the context of THIS chapter was on the necessity of choosing a good wife and not letting oneself be swayed by a woman who might look pretty but turn out to be wicked. The chapter did not by any means state that ALL women were wicked.

As for the Revelations quote. . . fornicators who engage in sexual relations are defiling themselves, even if it is by mutual consent. Sex is to be a gift between husband and wife; otherwise, it is defiling.

The chaste man by definition has not engaged in unlawful sexual actions and therefore has not defiled himself. Simple, and not only NOT insulting to women, it’s actually pretty positive. Might make a man think twice about trying to seduce or rape a woman, to know that HE is the one who has defiled himself. (You note it doesn’t say that the WOMAN is defiled but rather that the man has defiled himself.)
 
Scripture honours women like Judith, Esther, Ruth, Rebecca.
The first two I’ve mentioned have books in the bible named for them
 
“Better is the wickedness of a man than a woman who does good; and it is a woman who brings shame and disgrace.”
{42:9} Filia patris abscondita est vigilia, et solicitudo eius aufert somnum, ne forte in adolescentia sua adulta efficiatur, et cum viro commorata odibilis fiat:
{42:9} The vigilance of a father for his daughter is hidden, and his concern for her takes away his sleep. For perhaps, in her adolescence, she might be brought into adulthood. Or when she lives with her husband, she might become hateful.

{42:10} nequando polluatur in virginitate sua, et in paternis suis gravida inveniatur: ne forte cum viro commorata transgrediatur, aut certe sterilis efficiatur.
{42:10} In her virginity, she might be defiled, and then she may be found to be pregnant in her father’s house. Or perhaps, when she lives with her husband, she might stray, or at least become barren.

{42:11} Super filiam luxuriosam confirma custodiam: ne quando faciat te in opprobrium venire inimicis, a detractione in civitate, et obiectione plebis, et confundat te in multitudine populi.
{42:11} Keep a close watch over a self-indulgent daughter. Otherwise, at some time, she might bring you into disgrace before your enemies, and into disrepute in the city, and into reproach among the people, and so she may confound you before the multitude of the people.

{42:12} Omni homini noli intendere in specie: et in medio mulierum noli commorari:
{42:12} She should not choose to gaze upon the beauty of every man, and she should not choose to spend her time in the midst of married women.

~ This passage is advice concerning how one’s young unmarried daughter should behave, in order to retain chastity. So, the verb was changed in translation to the third person singular, feminine, from the second person singular imperative. Looking at the attractiveness of every man is harmful to her chastity. So is spending time with married women, who might talk about marital relations, perhaps even in a crass manner.

{42:13} de vestimentis enim procedit tinea, et a muliere iniquitas viri.
{42:13} For a moth goes forth from garments, and iniquity over a man goes forth from a woman.

~ Iniquity pertaining to men, i.e. sins committed because of her attraction to a man, proceeds from a woman. Again, this advice pertains to a young unmarried daughter and is in the context of the previous verse about avoiding sins related to attraction of a young unmarried daughter to men.

{42:14} Melior est enim iniquitas viri, quam mulier benefaciens, et mulier confundens in opprobrium.
{42:14} Yet iniquity over a man is better for her than if a married woman, seeking to benefit her, instead leads her into confusion and disgrace.

~ Yet the iniquity of a man [sins of women pertaining to men] is better than a woman [an older married woman] seeking to benefit [the younger unmarried woman] and yet confusing her to her disgrace.

~ The sense of verse 14 is that even though the problems a daughter might encounter, which are warned against in verse 13, are harmful, there is a worse situation, that of married women influencing your daughter, leading her into confusion and disgrace. This passage is not saying that men’s sins are better than women’s sins. Rather, it is advice as to how to advise and govern a young unmarried daughter. If she hangs around older women, they might think to ‘help’ her by giving her advice about men which is not fitting to someone who is young and unmarried, so instead of benefiting her, they would lead her into confusion and disgrace. In other words, hanging around older married women might corrupt your virgin unmarried daughter, since they might talk about men in a licentious manner.
 
“It is these who have not defiled themselves with women, for they are chaste; it is these who follow the Lamb wherever he goes; these have been redeemed from mankind as first fruits for God and the Lamb,” (Rev 14:4)
This expression would include women who defile themselves with men, and any sexual sins at all.

The group of persons being described are all virgins. And as the Council of Trent taught, virginity is better than marriage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top