Why doesn't circumcision contradict natural law?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dobereiner
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dobereiner

Guest
Life-saving amputations and operations that remove organs don’t contradict natural law because the biological functions of individual organs are subordinate to keeping the entire body alive or healthy.

We are not supposed to cut off healthy organs, however, so why does circumcision not stand in contradiction to the natural law in this regard?

What am I missing?
 
Because it doesn’t hinder the body’s function–healthy urinating or the ability to engender children. Circumcision merely takes away a part that serves no necessary function–it doesn’t destroy any natural bodily function.
 
Because it doesn’t hinder the body’s function–healthy urinating or the ability to engender children. Circumcision merely takes away a part that serves no necessary function–it doesn’t destroy any natural bodily function.
So why did God put a foreskin on the penis if it serves no necessary function? Did He make a mistake?
 
So why did God put a foreskin on the penis if it serves no necessary function? Did He make a mistake?
Some people argue it increases sexual pleasure. But given He told the Jews to circumcise, I’d guess there’s other factors too. (And some say the circumcised penis is easier to keep clean.)
 
So why did God put a foreskin on the penis if it serves no necessary function? Did He make a mistake?
Unnecessary merely because it does not hinder natural function if removed. But it’s not unnecessary in the sense that it has no function of its own. As to why it’s a part of the human male anatomy–that you’ll have to ask a competent medical professional----or God. 😉
 
I’ve heard it said that the Jewish explanation is that God left man incomplete by not removing the skin, he left it as a sign man must work to complete himself to be pleasing in God’s eye.

Go figure…
 
Anyone who thinks a foreskin has no function should try living with one for awhile. I assure you, mine has function.

Circumcision arose in areas where the climate makes a foreskin more of a hindrance than a benefit - namely it’s hard to keep it hygienic in an ancient desert environment. I’m sure God knew well enough that if you just remove it, you’ll save a lot of issues. It’s like an apendix or a mangled limb - when the part becomes a problem it’s removed.
 
Life-saving amputations and operations that remove organs don’t contradict natural law because the biological functions of individual organs are subordinate to keeping the entire body alive or healthy.

We are not supposed to cut off healthy organs, however, so why does circumcision not stand in contradiction to the natural law in this regard?

What am I missing?
preventative medicine, although not required for non-Jews (of the Old Covenant, per Christian perspective)
 
One thing to note there does appear to be some medical advantages to circumcision. For example, there ia statistically significant decrease in UTI in boys as foreskin requires more proper cleaning which doesn’t always happen with young boys. There are other things too but some of them are still somewhat debated in the medical community (like lower rates of transmission and susceptibility to HPV).

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1477524/
Relevant article

Though largely the point is moot as there is no Catholic mandate for it so now it is more or less up to the parents to decide
 
Anyone who thinks a foreskin has no function should try living with one for awhile. I assure you, mine has function.
I’ve been living without one for as long as I can remember. I don’t think I have ever said to myself, “Darn, I wish I had a foreskin.”
 
Isn’t the real question: Why doesn’t circumcision for Christians violate the MORAL law? How is circumcision not bodily mutilaton (in the absence of medical necessity)?
 
Isn’t the real question: Why doesn’t circumcision for Christians violate the MORAL law? How is circumcision not bodily mutilaton (in the absence of medical necessity)?
But it has been shown to be medically beneficial. It’s no different from having an appendectomy, a tooth pulled, or one’s ears pieced, none of which is bodily mutilation.
 
But it has been shown to be medically beneficial. It’s no different from having an appendectomy, a tooth pulled, or one’s ears pieced, none of which is bodily mutilation.
So if someone had all their teeth pulled for no good reason, that wouldn’t be considered bodily mutilation?
 
So if someone had all their teeth pulled for no good reason, that wouldn’t be considered bodily mutilation?
Hyperbole, much? 😉 Medical necessity trumps other considerations. Since God commanded circumcision for Israel, it hardly makes sense to call it mutilation–especially since it has been shown to be beneficial for men’s health.
 
Arguments over circumcision is such a first-world problem, it’s laughable. It should just be left to the freedom and conscience of the child and his parents.

Where I came from, the answer was simple. If you weren’t circumcised, you were mocked and laughed at. The native term for “uncircumcised” is derogatory.

I’m circumcised, am thankful I’m circumcised, and as I was circumcised as an infant, and I have absolutely no memory or trauma of the event.

Circumcise, don’t circumcise. It’s morally neutral. No big deal. No worse than a haircut, ear piercing, etc.
 
especially since it has been shown to be beneficial for men’s health.
Whether it’s beneficial or not is a hotly debated issue and Europeans are horrified that many Americans still circumcise their male children (although the numbers have been going way down and now only about 56% of male newborns in the US are circumcised). With proper hygiene, being uncircumcised is not a problem. Some males who have been circumcised as children now feel that their parents mutilated them and that this has made sex less pleasurable.
 
Whether it’s beneficial or not is a hotly debated issue and Europeans are horrified that many Americans still circumcise their male children (although the numbers have been going way down and now only about 56% of male newborns in the US are circumcised). With proper hygiene, being uncircumcised is not a problem. Some males who have been circumcised as children now feel that their parents mutilated them and that this has made sex less pleasurable.
And I have to ask. So what?

How does the issue of mutilation come into all this?

Oh, I know!

It doesn’t. 🤷
 
I’ve been living without one for as long as I can remember. I don’t think I have ever said to myself, “Darn, I wish I had a foreskin.”
Sure, I didn’t mean to imply that not having one was bad or wrong. Just that it does serve a function. I’ll spare the details, though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top