Why don't Jews still practice animal sacrifices?

  • Thread starter Thread starter d_floyd77
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Messiah will take care of that…there isn’t anything too big for him to handle, believe me. 🙂
I can accept that. But, would this not mean that we will see whose religion is correct: Judaism or Islam? I can hear Michael Buffer now: And in this corner, harboring thousands of years of travails, the Chosen Ones, the Covenant Bearers, The Children of Isreal…and in the Red Corner, wearing Red shorts with a Gold Crescent,…
 
I read on a Jewish website that in Isreal there is a small group of rabbis who practice the method of sacraficing so that when the temple is rebuilt, they will not have lost the art.

A more important question is how will the temple be rebuilt when there are “squaters” on the mount claiming ownership…
I watched Rosalind Moss one day on EWTN and she was talking about how before 70AD there would have been so much sacrifice that the blood was flowing down the temple stones.There was maybe 20 million (I would like to find out how many for sure) Jews, so she said if you can imagine 50 thousand of lamb calves , or more, brought to the stones that one day a year. She said the blood would have just been pouring down like a river all around the stones and the ground. It would have just been flowing down the hill.
 
Well, as I understand it (as a Catholic who knows a little about Judaism) the Jews who have the citron (called an *etrog *in Hebrew – a required element of a ritual celebrating the Jewish Thanksgiving Sukkot] are Hasidic Jews, which is a type of Orthodox Jew (often called ultra-Orthodox, or *Haredi *in Hebrew.)

The Jews released from prison are, of course, secular Jews.
I’m not sure if you are referring to the movie or are discussing an aspect of Judaism. All services during Sukkot use the etrog. I assume that what you are saying was that in the movie, the jews using the etrog were Hasidic Jews.
 
Well, as I understand it (as a Catholic who knows a little about Judaism) the Jews who have the citron (called an *etrog *in Hebrew – a required element of a ritual celebrating the Jewish Thanksgiving Sukkot] are Hasidic Jews, which is a type of Orthodox Jew (often called ultra-Orthodox, or *Haredi *in Hebrew.)

The Jews released from prison are, of course, secular Jews.
Hmm! Thanks I wasn’t sure what the cousins part had to do in the movie as they were the new secular Jew and the attitude was bad towards them because they were escaped from prison. (Ushpitzin) The movie shows the different aspects of the what I call schisms of the Judaism. And I thought the couple seemed orthodox but different, but they never mentioned the Messiah or Jesus Christ but did mention prayer a lot, and the fact that they don’t have to be in a synagogue to pray.
 
I read on a Jewish website that in Isreal there is a small group of rabbis who practice the method of sacraficing so that when the temple is rebuilt, they will not have lost the art.

A more important question is how will the temple be rebuilt when there are “squaters” on the mount claiming ownership…
A Holy Termination of Tenancy Notice?
 
I can accept that. But, would this not mean that we will see whose religion is correct: Judaism or Islam? I can hear Michael Buffer now: And in this corner, harboring thousands of years of travails, the Chosen Ones, the Covenant Bearers, The Children of Isreal…and in the Red Corner, wearing Red shorts with a Gold Crescent,…
Perhaps the solution will be a peaceful one in which God’s pleasure for both people is evident.
 
I watched Rosalind Moss one day on EWTN and she was talking about how before 70AD there would have been so much sacrifice that the blood was flowing down the temple stones.There was maybe 20 million (I would like to find out how many for sure) Jews, so she said if you can imagine 50 thousand of lamb calves , or more, brought to the stones that one day a year. She said the blood would have just been pouring down like a river all around the stones and the ground. It would have just been flowing down the hill.
Even assuming the numbers are correct and all 20 million lived withing walking distance of the Temple, they would not all be offering sacrifices. That’s not to say that Temple worship would not shock the sensabilities of most people today. Aside from the noise and sights of animals being slaughtered, I’m sure by the end fo the day, many of the priests were pretty tanked on wine.
 
Well I did a little researching and I think the guess is 4 million Jews at 70AD.My mistake quite a far off. I think that is what Rosalind did say. Still there would be so much blood flowing down from all the sacrificing on the stones. I have never been to a slaughter house and I’m with Hashem that I could not stomach it. My dad got a chicken from a farmer one time when I was young and he killed it in the basement, but it was for food but it was icky to pick the feathers off.
He must have got blood around the basement a bit but it was not a sprinkling or throwing blood all over speaking prayers ritual type thing. Ugh!
 
Well I did a little researching and I think the guess is 4 million Jews at 70AD.My mistake quite a far off. I think that is what Rosalind did say. Still there would be so much blood flowing down from all the sacrificing on the stones. I have never been to a slaughter house and I’m with Hashem that I could not stomach it. My dad got a chicken from a farmer one time when I was young and he killed it in the basement, but it was for food but it was icky to pick the feathers off.
He must have got blood around the basement a bit but it was not a sprinkling or throwing blood all over speaking prayers ritual type thing. Ugh!
I think I’m going to go back to being a vegetarian (I was one for 12 years, from 1983-1995).
 
I think I’m going to go back to being a vegetarian (I was one for 12 years, from 1983-1995).
You are probably more healthy for it. I am liking fish more these days. I just gross out picturing people cutting off a chicken head and then flinging that thing around and splurttering blood all around while doing a chicken dance, and maybe drinking the blood. Just yuk! If I were you I wouldn’t watch any more of those movies. I guess circumscion doesn’t seem so wicked after all that dead chicken talk. Some of those Indianna Jones movies are kind of grossed out too with all the cultish stuff he uncovers.
 
You are probably more healthy for it. I am liking fish more these days. I just gross out picturing people cutting off a chicken head and then flinging that thing around and splurttering blood all around while doing a chicken dance, and maybe drinking the blood. Just yuk! If I were you I wouldn’t watch any more of those movies. I guess circumscion doesn’t seem so wicked after all that dead chicken talk. Some of those Indianna Jones movies are kind of grossed out too with all the cultish stuff he uncovers.
After watching the disgusting Henry VIII (The Tudors) gorge himself on that poor swan, I never want to eat anything formerly alive again!

What will I do when animal sacrifice is restored on the Temple Mount???:o
 
A Holy Termination of Tenancy Notice?
With an angel to serve it?

The occupancy was public, but permission was not granted. This is a tricky one. I know all the best lawyers are Jewish, anyway, so it wil be an uphill battle for the Muslims.😛
 
Perhaps the solution will be a peaceful one in which God’s pleasure for both people is evident.
More than likely, some of His displeasure will be, too. I just wanted a celestial “Let’s get ready to rumble” one time.
 
Forgive us for posting Catholic beliefs in a Catholic website. 🙂

Jim
I’m used to associating with ecumenically-minded Catholics offline (in some of the work I do), and they always preface things with, “As I/we believe”…so I’m more used to that. I tend to do the same when I reference my own views, even when I’m on Jewish forums.
 
I’m used to associating with ecumenically-minded Catholics offline (in some of the work I do), and they always preface things with, “As I/we believe”…so I’m more used to that. I tend to do the same when I reference my own views, even when I’m on Jewish forums.
I understand, but keep in mind, this is a Catholic website and we(well some of us), believe in Catholic doctrine.

But welcome to the forum. 🙂

Jim
 
Well I did a little researching and I think the guess is 4 million Jews at 70AD.My mistake quite a far off. I think that is what Rosalind did say. Still there would be so much blood flowing down from all the sacrificing on the stones. I have never been to a slaughter house and I’m with Hashem that I could not stomach it. My dad got a chicken from a farmer one time when I was young and he killed it in the basement, but it was for food but it was icky to pick the feathers off.
He must have got blood around the basement a bit but it was not a sprinkling or throwing blood all over speaking prayers ritual type thing. Ugh!
Keep in mind that many of the sacrifices were also used as food. The majority, in fact.
 
OK, so now on the issue of Jewish Sacrifices, we read that Jesus is a priest in the order of Melchizedek. As I understand it, Melchizedek, offered sacrifices of bread and wine, not animal.

I’ve never been able to find much information about Melchizedek, and how it is, he got away with non-animal sacrifices in his day?

Jim
 
After watching the disgusting Henry VIII (The Tudors) gorge himself on that poor swan, I never want to eat anything formerly alive again!

What will I do when animal sacrifice is restored on the Temple Mount???:o
Hashem, You know when I was young I had a hard time hooking a worm on a hook.🙂 it seemed like they had pain when I stabbed them.They were messy too. But LOL how can you catch a fish.😛 But there was purpose, (for that worm) always one in God’s plan as we are mortal we must eat.

Did I take that worm to an altar and have it blessed before fishing ? NO It is God’s creature and it had a purpose to to feed and be feed.

We are all God’s creatures, in the food chain, and we are top I think anyways:p

We are to eat creatures whether fish or grubs icky or even fried wormsyuk!! did a teacher ever do the to you? Maybe if we add veggies:thumbsup: :rolleyes:

Anyways we are not to worship the created and hold it up higher than the creator. The blood of a chicken is not important anymore. I just wouldn’t go. Can you back out ?
Blessings
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top