WHY DONT WE FIGHT BACK??

  • Thread starter Thread starter SojournerOf78
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
dhgray:
BUT IF YOU WANT THE REAL REASON WE ARE GETTING OUR BUTTS KICKED:

I find it interesting:

ISSUEMuslemsChristian America
Abortion…NO…YES
Homosexual Union…NO…YES
Sexual Dressing…NO…YES
Defending the Faith…YES…Too busy fighting each other
Teach the Children faith…YES…That’s the Churches Job
Take care of elderly…YES…Stick them in a nursing home
Support the Faith $$$…YES…10% (if I can afford it)
Take time to PRAY…YES…Too busy making money
Evangalize/Share Faith…YES…Can’t, might offend someone
UNITY IN FAITH…YES…Only if you believe EXACTLY what I do
STRICT LAWS…YES…Individual rights over the laws of God
Teach religion in school…YES…Seperation of Church & State
I fully agree with you on these points.

Does this mean its ok for Christians to be massacred by Anti-Christian groups???

America has its troubles too though, in fact, your statistics are AMERICAN Christians, but its ok to Shock and Awe those groups that massacre Americans, just as long as theyre not massacring only Christians, is this what youre saying?
 
40.png
dhgray:
OK, let’s start in this country. Why don’t you go down to your local Pro-Choice clinic/office and start there. They are killing future CHRISTIANS.
WHY DO YOU HATE “THEM” SO?
Ive never seen a Pro-choice clinic/office in my area…but I have been in correspondence with a Pro Life advocate in order to see what I can do to contribute, may God help us all there.
Since you are in CA, go up the the Sciencetology Church, they turn people away from Christianity…HEY, where are Evangecials and Baptists, they are turning people away from the Catholic Faith?
No youre getting confused again…Scientologists, Evangelicals and Baptists are TURNING people away from the faith, not MASSACREING them, which is what I was talking about, I started this thread talking about liberating persecuted Christians by fighting against groups that are actively persecuting them.

…although Scientologists are once in a while resposible for some bizarre deaths…they are not actively persecuting and murdering any group, so they dont fall into the category of groups that are slaughtering Christians.
 
40.png
jennstall:
I’m curious, what exactly are you doing about it? Are you turning in your enlistment papers tomorrow? The US and other militaries are out fighting the heathens as we speak so maybe you could put your money where your mouth is and join them.
I planned on already being enlisted by now but circumstances beyond my control have prevented that. God willing I will be shipping out after this semester is over in December, please pray that I will be able to do my best in serving our Country.
 
I can only say without starting fight: You fight, you lose your life. Is dying for something earthly worth it? I just don’t want to start a fight with you all.
 
I’d like to make a few comments if I may.
40.png
SojournerOf78:
Last I heard us Catholics are about 1,200,000,000 strong and there are around 800,000,000 Protestants. That makes up 1/3 of the population of the earth.
How many of these “RCs” are actually practicing? Does John Gotti, Jr. count as an “RC”? How many are infants? IOW, what makes up these “RC” numbers? What makes up the “Protestant” numbers? Are Mormons, and JWs included in that number?
Why is their even persecution? Put together that is a huge ARMY!! If I was some dood in the Sudan, I wouldnt want to mess with a 2 Billion strong Army by martyring the Christians…So why arent they afraid of our numbers???
:confused: I’m afraid I missed something. Who do you think that RCs are being “persecuted” by??? :confused: I would be classified by most as a “Protestant”, and I don’t go around persecuting people-let alone brothers and sisters in the Lord. I am confused about what you are saying sis.

YSIC, becky 🙂
 
Hello everyone, I just joined the group. This is Dr. Lucia Teen from Quezon City, Philippines.

Before I proceed with my introduction, I would like to clarify that I am a male and I am not a doctor. The log in I use is just some sort of anagram of my real name. This log in or nickname also serves some security purpose…to confuse the Iglesia Ni Cristo (INC) if ever they decide to track me down.

I was born and raised in the INC. I have professed my faith in its doctrines when I was indoctrinated and baptized.

I have been a very active officer of the INC…from the local level, to the Ecclesiastical Disctrict, to the INC Metro Manila Coordinating Committee and to the INC Central Office.

I have persecuted Catholics wherever I met them…including the internet.

I was very faithful to God, and he must have been the one who held me up high, outside and beyond the INC. I realized that I have been deceived. The INC created a very unreal image of itself and distorted everything about the Catholic Church.

I gradually stopped attending the INC worship services in the year 2000. In addition, I was very interested in knowing what the Jubilee Year was about and my Catholic friends were very kind to tell me.

In January 2001, I joined EDSA People Power 2 and was disappointed how the INC Administration could not declare a position while it was obvious that they are supporting former President Estrada. When the conflict ended, I attended my very first Catholic Mass…the Thanksgiving Mass at the EDSA Shrine officiated by Cardinal Sin.

In March 2001, after declaring to our resident minister that I have stopped believing the teachings of the INC, I left it. I did not want to join any organized religion afterwards, but I was already praying like a Catholic. I began having a devotion to the blessed mother Mary and the Holy Family.

On June 3, 2001, after reading a missallete from a mass we were unable to attend, I was convinced that the Church that Our Lord Jesus Christ established did not perish or completely apostatized. Christ built his church and the gates of hell did not prevail against it. He also promised that he will be with his church until the end of time.

On September 9, 2001, I received the last of the needed sacraments to complete my conversion. I converted to the Roman Catholic Church.

For me, the most powerful and effective way to bring people like the INCs to enlightenment…is prayer.

Pray and let others see Christ in you.

If you have questions about the INC, I may be able to answer them. Please avoid sending private messages or emails as I may not be able to reply. Answering similar questions over and over again would be very inconvenient.

If you want to know more about me, please check out everything that I have written on the following link

network54.com/Forum/84590/thread/989747884/Why+are+we+INC+members+ill+mannered%85-+April+1+2001+at+7-31+AM

This link is from the forum “The Iglesia Ni Cristo (Church of Christ) Doctrines”
The following are its addresses
ang-iglesia-ni-cristo.com.ph
network54.com/hide/forum/84590

I also have my own discussion group. Please visit
groups.yahoo.com/group/iglesianicristo1914/

There had been initial efforts to gather Catholic Apologists online, please visit the sites above to get acquainted with them. There are priests and other religious who respond to questions on my discussion group.

So far, I have been interacting with at least two group of apologists, the ones at forum/84590 and the Defensoris Fidei.

I have joined this forum to meet others.
 
It’s right and noble to fight back in defense of the innocent and persecuted, but it is quite another story to fight just for the sake of getting folks to agree with your own views, or religion or beliefs.
Be sure about what you are fighting for and why, IS it an economic cause for cheaper oil and self interest ? Is it really a threat to our national security, and “clear and present danger” ?

All too often, politicians are manipulating the press and public. Sometimes there is a huge gap between what they are telling us and what is really the true situation.

I am grateful for all who serve and put everything at risk so we can enjoy the blessings of liberty. BUT I cringe at the leaderhip who distorts the truth to further their own agenda. When a president or vice president has to distort the truth or ignores reality to send 130,000 men into harms way, one has to question their motives for doing so.

And now that the threat is clearly no longer there and never existed in the first place, one has to ask why are we still there and why are we still paying a huge price for it both in lost lives almost daily and billions of dollars per year ?

Firstoff do the Iraqis still want us there ??? And IF they do, are they willing to subsidize or reimburse the US for the cost of our continued presence ??? If the answer to either of these 2 questions is no then we need to get out and get out asap.

There is NO reason to bankrupt this country for folks do not even want us around or who are not willing to help support the troops that we are putting at risk.
 
40.png
wcknight:
It’s right and noble to fight back in defense of the innocent and persecuted, but it is quite another story to fight just for the sake of getting folks to agree with your own views, or religion or beliefs.

TRIM

There is NO reason to bankrupt this country for folks do not even want us around or who are not willing to help support the troops that we are putting at risk.
I’m curious. How did this thread become “un-closed??”

Richard
 
I have heard rumor that the Poor Knights of Christ have been recomissioned(?). Any info on that?
 
40.png
dhgray:
BUT IF YOU WANT THE REAL REASON WE ARE GETTING OUR BUTTS KICKED:

I find it interesting:

ISSUEMuslemsChristian America
Abortion…NO…YES
Homosexual Union…NO…YES
Sexual Dressing…NO…YES
Defending the Faith…YES…Too busy fighting each other
Teach the Children faith…YES…That’s the Churches Job
Take care of elderly…YES…Stick them in a nursing home
Support the Faith $$$…YES…10% (if I can afford it)
Take time to PRAY…YES…Too busy making money
Evangalize/Share Faith…YES…Can’t, might offend someone
UNITY IN FAITH…YES…Only if you believe EXACTLY what I do
STRICT LAWS…YES…Individual rights over the laws of God
Teach religion in school…YES…Seperation of Church & State
You’re exaggerating to try and make a point here. Lemme put my opn forward.

Abortion - It’s much more the secular dudes rather than the Catholics in America doing it.

Sexual dressing - What has that got to do with anything?

Defending the Faith - What do you think we’re doing here? How do you know Muslims fight with each other less often than we do while defending faith?

Support the faith with $ - Muslims are required to give 2.5%, Christians who follow tithing rule give 10%. 10% > 2.5% (bleeding obvious I know)

Take time to pray - Fair enough, but one thing they don’t have is Adoration… could 1hr per week at Adoration maybe ‘work’ better than 5 times a day facing Mecca?

Evangelise - We’ve got RCIA, CCD, etc., and lots of Protestants are out there evangelising 24/7.

Unity in faith - Muslims in different countries all believe different things. They may not have official ‘denominations’, but Muslims are nowhere near as united the CC… in fact, Muslims tell me that they think Catholics and Protestants are more similar to one another than Muslims in diff countries.

Anyway,
I can’t join the Army Reserves because I have about half the fitness required to get in.

But, if I had a sword, and I saw an enemy about to kill one of my innocent fellow Christians, do you think I’d hesitate to use the sword?
Would you, in that situation, hesitate to use the sword?
It’s not a matter of hate. It’s a matter of we can’t spare the lives of the guilty if doing so is going to cost the lives of the innocent.

Although, in practice we come across some problems. Starting a war might do more damage / evil / whatever than the evil we seek to redress, making it not a just war.

Easiest thing would be if the other countires would co-operate with us, either allow us to have people there to protect our fellow Christians, or for them, their governments, to actually protect people there, Christian and Muslim. Yet in some countries the murder of Christians goes unnoticed or even endorsed by the government, sort of like how abortion goes unnoticed by the government around here.

If only there was some way of having people who respect and want to defend the lives of all people, in the positions of power in every country in the world. Anyone got any ideas?
 
40.png
SojournerOf78:
Last I heard us Catholics are about 1,200,000,000 strong and there are around 800,000,000 Protestants. That makes up 1/3 of the population of the earth.

Why is their even persecution? Put together that is a huge ARMY!! If I was some dood in the Sudan, I wouldnt want to mess with a 2 Billion strong Army by martyring the Christians…So why arent they afraid of our numbers???

Oh maybe its because we dont really do anything and who is scared of as little sissy that welcomes persecution?..why do we act this way? Where did Jesus teach us to WILLFULLY accept persecution?? Didnt Jesus teach us to love our neighbor?? Why dont we protect eachother??

I keep running into this mindset that we just have to accept whatever befalls us WITHOUT EVEN TRYING TO OVERCOME BY THE ABILITIES GOD HAS GIVEN US…its like a roll over and take it attitude among Christians.

The Jesus I read about in scriptures, the Jesus I know said …‘Now I say to you, he that has no sword let him sell his garment and buy one’…

What else is a sword good for other than combat???

So the question is…WHY DONT WE FIGHT?
Wow, you need to talk to someone about your faith, you seem to be very far from its teachings.
For starters, sword, doesn’t have to be used to fight physically, you know like a sword of truth or light, like light prevailing against darkness. Plus if we start forcing our faith around then can we complain about what the Muslim extremists are doing. I hear a lot of that and somethings I read from “christians” makes me sick. If we start being some muscle faith then what would makes us any different then all the others? How would we be Christians if we started to force our spot on Earth, rather then let God guide us? Why would we want to be different than Christ, you know the whole purpose of life is to become Christ as humanly possibly, like St. Francis?
 
You sound like a very angry person and I suspect there’s a lot more behind your question than just the religious aspect.
 
This is ridiculously obvious.

We don’t fight back on our own - or as a Catholic Collective because we don’t have the authority to do so.

We, as individuals, must not obey laws that are gravely opposed to the natural law - but we are also to obey legitimate government.

President Bush and other leaders of Nations have the Authority to send the Army into action.

The Police have the Authority to enforce the Laws.

Individuals who wish to take violent action in their own hands will be breaking the Law - and the rules of our Catholic Faith.

Groups (even religious groups) that organize inorder to take up violent action are illegal cabals and opposed to the ordered society.

We must work in prayer and through our legitimate government.

This is the Rule of the the Catholic Church - to do otherwise would be a contradiction.

Please review the Catechism.

Sections 1897 - 1917

===
1899 The authority required by the moral order derives from God: “Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore he who resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment.”​

The answer is clear.

God Bless
 
I don’t quite get it. Were you saying fight back against the protestants? Or join the protestants and fight against the Muslims/other religions?

The simple reason is because God does not want us to fight against the muslims. He wants us to convert the muslims. That’s what “love your enemy” is supposed to mean. And the particular form of “love” is agape. So basically, we should be willing to die for our enemy.

There can be moments when waiving your right to self defense is a good thing. You may have more confidence in you own salvation than the salvation of your aggressor, AND perhaps you have no one else on earth that is dependent on you for their salvation, thus you could waive your right to self defense. This would then spare your enemy, buying him or her time to convert.

In those countries where Catholicism or Christianity is being oppressed, the martyrdom of the Christians may very well be working towards the ultimate conversion of millions of non-christians. It was the martyrdom of early Christians that impressed the Pagan Romans.

Sometimes it is difficult to see someone else suffering. We want to stop their suffering. This is really the false compassion that produces a false logic that leads to abortion and euthanasia. People who support these things sincerely believe they are being nice to other people. Instead God sometimes calls us to suffer with other people.

So just perhaps, instead of God wanting us to go in with guns blazing and wipe out all the oppressors in the world, God wants us to observe fasts and support our missions and do penance. What this does is unites us more closely with our suffering brethren than if we would ride in on our white stallion and conquer the oppressors.
 
dhgray,
Jesus is telling his followers that it is going to be dangerous to be his disciple. Buying a sword is said more “toung in cheek” read on:
38 “Lord,” they said, “look, here are two swords.” “Enough of that!” He told them.
Besides the fact I’ve yet to see this translation in any English Bible I’ve seen (not saying it doesn’t exist, obviously), I took a look at a Greek-English concordance and fail to see how this is a likely translation.

Hikanos means “sufficient”, “enough”, “meet”, “fit”, etc. This is born out by other passages where this same Greek word is used in the New Testament. Given this, I’m not convinced that the translation you’ve provided is accurate.
Yes I firmly back BUSH! He is a strong leader and set this country into a posture of self defense by striking at the enemy abroad, but only after the enemy drew first blood.
I’m sorry, but what did Iraq have to do with 9-11? Nothing. If the American government was serious about getting to the root of fanatical Islamist support for terrorism, they would have first went after Saudi Arabia, which is the cradle of Wahhabism, and is where practically to a man the officially named hijackers were from. Funny, that’s not what happened? In fact, the American government still officially numbers the Saudis (an anti-democratic regime where the open expression of Christianity is illegal, and where you will be murdered if you preach the Gospel or convert to Christianity, all state sanctioned) as a friend in the Middle East, along with Egypt, where Christians (esp. the Copts) are regularly lynched with tacit government approval (and where it is illegal for Christians to do anything to advance the wellbeing of their communities - you’ll even be lucky to get a building permit to fix a toilet on Church property…not an exageration.)

If you buy the official government line on the “war on terror”, I’ve got a bridge you might be interested in buying…
However, I do believe that arbitary killing is wrong. You are advocating killing anyone who threatens Christianity.
Unless I totally misread the O.P., who is talking about “arbitrary killing”? He’s talking about defending/liberating viciously persecuted Christian populations in the Islamic world, who frankly no one cares about.

It’s funny - when the Serbians were allegedly “ethnic cleansing” the Albanians (so called “Kosavars”) who were trying to forcefully seperate the cultural/religious heart-land of Serbia (keep in mind that you Americans fought your own war against “successionism”, in which millions died), NATO (read America, since they in effect dictate NATO policy) had no problem with bombing Serbia, littering the country with depleted Urainium munitions, etc. Interestingly enough, they were in effect helping not simply Muslims (Albanians), but groups like the KLA (Kosovo Liberation Army) who are in fact militant Islamists who are well known to circulate in the same “world-Jihad” circles as Osama bin Ladin. Funny, America basically siding with Islamists against a historically Christian people (yes, the Serbs did bad things, but it was hardly a one sided affair); but the point is, the Americans intervened where they officially perceived human rights abuses.

Yet the well known problem of Christian persecution in Turkey, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, etc. (basically wherever Muslims have the upper hand), which includes forced conversions to Islam, murder of converts or people publically expressing the Christian faith, denial of basic human rights to Christians, slavery (yes, slavery - Christians are commonly kidnapped and made slaves by Muslims in Africa), rape, theft, etc… none of this seems to “count”. Yet, Bush still has time to criticize Russia, for fighting Islamist-Jihadi seperatists in Chechnya!

So again, who is talking about “arbitrary killing”? How about simply putting the Mohammedans on notice, that if they keep treating Christians like dogs, they will face dire consequences? How is that any less legitimate than meddling in Kosovo, or pursuing the stated aims of the military invasion of Iraq?
 
40.png
CantorRick:
I’m curious. How did this thread become “un-closed??”

Richard
Not sure what you mean, was this thread closed at some point ???

The OP seems to be advocating for all Christians and Catholics to rise up and fight off Muslims and other non-Christian threats with violence. Everyone knows that this is NOT what Jesus taught. HE never advocated a militant response to our enemies.

Such a response is contrary to everything that Jesus and His Church has always stood for.
 
BryP and BlackJaque - You should know, the Church actually says that self-defence is legit. The OP is not talking about us doing what they do (persecuting them like they persecute us), he is talking about a defensive operation where we go to protect people who are being denied basic human rights.

You can die for your enemy if you really want to, but we’ve got a God-given right to look after ourselves and our brethren and perhaps we should be asserting that right.
 
Flopfoot,

I’m fully aware that the Church teaches that self-defence is legit. I’ve quoted the CCC paragraphs several times on these boards w/ respect to gun ownership and other such threads.

My point is that people in other countries who are practicing and believing their faith may be voluntarily waiving that right to self-defense.

Responsibility and authority go hand in hand. While it may sound noble to make yourself responsible for our Christian brethrens’ safety, in reality this is usurping an authority that is not given to us.

If, for instance, China is openly hostile to the Christian faith, but at the moment China has no Christians within her borders she is not oppressing anyone. There is no need to go to war. However, if we as Christians take on the responsibility to go to war to liberate oppressed Christians all over the world - we would then have to face the problem of converting China.

Do we send a missionary to bring the Gospel to the Chinese people? If we do, then we know full well that the Chinese gov’t will oppress our missionaries and anyone they convert. Which puts an obligation of war on our shoulders. Since we must avoid war, and we’ve erroneously usurped the responsibility to fight other people’s battles, we now have the authority to tell the missionaries “No you can’t go to China, because if you do, you will be dragging us into war, and that is not fair to us.”

But if the missionaries plead that they understand that what they are getting into may lead to their torture and martyrdom, and we should not take on any responsibility for their defense - shouldn’t we let them go to China?
Look, it is already apparent that our deposing Sadam Hussein only made things worse for many Christians in Iraq. What makes us think liberating more Christians will help.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top