Why I'm Not Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter ValiantDomain
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

ValiantDomain

Guest
My story is one of continually searching for the one faith and religion which gives me a sense of comfort, sustenance, etc. and one which fits my own faith and beliefs like a glove. I was raised Protestant in the United Church of Christ. Sometime in the Spring of 2004 I started feeling a certain identification and closeness with the Catholic Church; however, it wasn’t until the following Spring that I felt convinced enough to pursue Catholicism. After deciding to become Catholic, I almost immediately went and purchased a rosary, a Catholic Bible, and even my own copy of the Catechism which I began reading whenever I had a chance. I also started the process of finding a parish to attend and the process of how one became Catholic.

In college, I majored in Religious Studies. Not only did I study religion, but I spent several semesters studying the New Testament, the origins of Christianity, the history of the early Church, and even some time studying the lives of the earliest saints. In a manner of speaking, I knew more about Catholicism than a lot of living Catholics today (in my personal opinion). In fact, during college I used to like to take walks up to the nearby Catholic Church and pray a Hail Mary in front of the garden Mary statue.

I found a parish I greatly enjoyed and decided this is where I’d like to attend RCIA in order to become a Catholic; however, I soon learned (to my dismay) that this parish had so-called “parish boundaries” and, unfortunately, I lived outside those boundaries. So, I began attending another parish, extremely enjoyed it too, especially when I learned some friends were also attending, but again, to my dismay, I found out that the RCIA courses were held on Wednesday nights.

You see, beginning in the Fall of 2005, I began graduate school to receive my MBA. I don’t know why or how, but for the past three semesters that I’ve attended, I’ve *always *had a course on Wednesday night. In fact, it’s extremely rare for anyone who attends this university **not **to have at least one course on Wednesday evenings. This conflicted with my desire to attend RCIA. Even though I tried working something out between the two parishes so that could attend RCIA on Monday nights at one parish while attending weekly Mass at the other, it was decided that I would have to wait until later. This is where I began to grow frustrated!

For one, I *really *wanted to be able to receive the Eucharist. In my studies and in the period of time that I decided I wanted to become Catholic, I learned an exceptionally lot more about Catholicism and the Catholic faith! It wasn’t as if for me to accept the Eucharist would be like be stepping in line at a cafeteria because I realized the full significance of the Eucharist. Secondly, I hated not being able to receive the Eucharist. I would still occasionally walk to the front in order to be blessed; however, after a while, I became really self-conscious and disliked having to cross my arms like the 3-4 year olds, but I also disliked having to remain in the pew so those receiving the Eucharist could trip all over me trying to get in and out. Plus, I wouldn’t be able to attend RCIA until the Fall of 2008, which seems like an eternity to wait to receive the Eucharist and be able to participate **fully **in the life of the Church when I personally felt ready.

After some time, I grew more and more reluctant to continue going to the parish because I wasn’t able to receive the Eucharist for the reasons outlined above until I stopped going altogether. Regardless, my faith has stuck with me all this time. I’ve continued to feel drawn to the Catholic faith and to a life in the Church, but every time I think about giving it another shot, the same bitter feelings resurface. I’ve spoken with many Catholic friends during the time I stopped attending, but no one seems to be able to fully empathize with my plight and give me any advice worthy of solving the problem (if there is a solution at all!). I have been told “to get over myself,” and I have been told numerous times why the *RCIA *process is in place - but it’s not the RCIA process I’m totally against so much as it is the fact this particular parish, which happens to be one of the only two larger parishes in my area, is unwilling to change days or allow me some other method of completing the necessary education.

Recently, I’ve started attending the parish again…with a slightly less heavy heart. I’m still disappointed that I’m denied access to the Eucharist when I love the Eucharist so much…or at least the concept behind it. I’ve been told by so many people, “You’ll make a good Catholic,” or, “You so sound like a Catholic,” but how can I ever become Catholic and participate in the life of the Church when I barred from doing so because of situations which are essentially out of my hands? I must complete grad school! Am I to be punished for this?
 
There are a couple of things that struck me from your testimony. The first is your feelings. I sympathize with your obvious frustration. Nevertheless, you need to consider what is going on here. You have “particular” circumstances that are presenting themselves as hindrances to your participation in RCIA. These obstacles and circumstances are testing your faith and love of Jesus.

I had a recent reminder of how tough things can really get by re-reading the book of Job. What hassles and trials satan put Job through. You are struggling as did Job but with different elements in your personal journey. Do not lose heart, the Lord is with you every step of the way. I will put you in my prayers and I’m sure others will also. Take comfort and solace in these prayers and continue to pray yourself.

Is there a solution? Maybe so. I would suggest that you try once again to see if the parish will somehow accomodate you even if it means special RCIA tutoring. If they will not do so, approach the bishop and ask if there is some kind of dispensation available to you from taking RCIA because of your circumstances. Tell the bishop your story and ask him to examine your knowledge, understanding, and readiness to be recieved into the Church. You may find that he will arrange for your entrance with or without RCIA if he believes that you satisfy the requirements for knowing the faith and committing yourself to the faith without reservation.

Regardless of the outcome, you must remain steadfast and patient. Read the book of Job…you will marvel at what Job went through and how he endured it. You are as it states in Luke 9:23. You are a person that wishes to be a disciple of Jesus. And Jesus says that if anyone wishes to come after me then he “must deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me.” The path is strewn with obstacles to prevent you from taking the narrow road, but by God’s grace you will endure and see it through.

I hope this helps.
 
All I could say is that God works in a mysterious way, some people like it, some don’t. Just keep praying in faith and don’t lose hope.

I have a friend, who’s been attending RCIA for about 3-4 years. Her parents do not want to sign the form, thus she’s can’t be baptised. And yet she’s still attending the classes although she knows that it may take years before she can be baptised.

One of the reason why the parents do not want to sign because they are afraid that she would change religion again when she get married, so they ask her to wait till she gets married!

Just have faith in God, there’s nothing impossible for Him. Just be prepared. 🙂

Romans 5:5
Hope does not disappoint us, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us.
 
I can sympathize with your desire to receive the Eucharist, and the realization that you’re unable to do so. By the second half of the year, it hit me really hard that I was seen as “not good enough” when I’m majoring in theology, and people who stated that they’re only Catholic because their parents are are somehow more worthy to receive because they were Baptized into the right Church. There were weekends I just wouldn’t go to Mass because the week before had just been really bad and I knew sitting in the pew by myself would just make me really angry.

That was definitely a dark point in my faith. I guess the only thing I would really suggest is to turn everything over to God, and just trust that this is where God wants you to be.
 
You mentioned that you had to stop going to a certain parish because of “parish boundaries.” I’m guessing that the people who told you that are just plain wrong. Many years ago, the church rules said that you had to stay within your “parish boundary.” This rule has changed (because of some Canon Law, I think). I think that you should be able to sign up for RCIA in any parish that you please. I hope this helps.
 
Valiant,
Take Pax’ advice and try again. If this doesn’t work this time. Do contact the Bishop’s office to work things out. Let us know what happens. Trust me, we do care and want you to know and participate in the fullness of faith.

May God bless and protect us,
JLC
 
Hi-

Thanks for sharing your story. I hope you will be edified here at CAF.

It reminded me of the time in my life when I realized I had been essentially living a lie - you see I converted to Catholicism but because of my lack of knowledge or unwillingness to know the truth, I did something that, once I realized the truth, kept me from receiving the Eucharist until I could rectify the situation within the “eyes” of the Church.

It was painful because it was essentailly a second cenversion, one where I was totally open and now knowledgable about the truths and gifts of our faith. Now I was really set on fire with love for the Eucharist because I fully realized in my heart, mind, and spirit what the Catholic Church stood for, and what the Eucharist really was.

Yet, I couldn’t receive.

Week after week I had to watch everyone else get in line for Communion. It was a great struggle but I had to believe that ultimately it wasn’t about me or my struggle, but rather a chance to test myself and rely on God’s great providential knowledge and care for me.

God may be asking you to be patient, maybe to offer yourself as a sacrifice for others. I was told by a priest to offer that time up as a sacrifice for those too ashamed to go to Confession or for those not able to willing to get Communion. Who knows what that sacrifice and those prayers meant in the lives of others?

I just ask that you not see this struggle as punishment but as a time for reflection, a time for sacrifice. This too shall pass and who are we to demand that we not be tested by God? Maybe with enough prayer and time, a resolution may be found through the Holy Spirit. Maybe there seemingly won’t but once you are fully in Communion with the Church and can receive, maybe abundant blessings will be shown for your patient obedience to your call. Who knows? But don’t put God to the test. Trust in Him that He has called you in His time.

God Bless.
 
All I have to say are a few things.

Don’t let people stand in the way of you and God. If people in the Church have caused you resentment, you only please the devil when you retain that resentment.

Pray. Not just the rosary, or stuff like that, but talk to God. Tell God how you feel, and how you long to join Christ’s Church. Tell him that you are upset with how things have gone so far, and listen to what He has to say.

Go to eucharistic adoration. Surely no one would stop you from that.

God knows you want the truth, and He knows your heart. He will certainly not let your life go by without granting you the chance to enter His Church.

Good luck, and may Christ’s peace be with you always as you continue your journey.
 
Valiant,

I am sure that you’ll make a good Catholic indeed. However, try to face this ordeal as a test, “as through fire.” 😉

Many Protestants have difficulty to embrace the authority given to the Church by Jesus Christ, used to making their churches on the go. Not presuming to know you, this perhaps doesn’t describe you to any degree, and I apologize. Yet, if not for this reason, I suspect that the Holy Spirit is truly testing your will and faith by throwing so many obstacles on your way. If you haven’t considered this, give it a thought in prayer.

FWIW, I am a cradle Catholic who attended Sunday Mass for over 5 years and daily Mass for several months without being able to receive Our Lord in the Eucharist. I know how you feel about being “singled out”, but my hunger for the Lord grew quite a bit over this period and has actually led me to daily Mass and to try to live ever closer to our Lord in other aspects of my life.

:blessyou:
 
All I have to say are a few things.

Don’t let people stand in the way of you and God. If people in the Church have caused you resentment, you only please the devil when you retain that resentment.

Pray. Not just the rosary, or stuff like that, but talk to God. Tell God how you feel, and how you long to join Christ’s Church. Tell him that you are upset with how things have gone so far, and listen to what He has to say.

Go to eucharistic adoration. Surely no one would stop you from that.

God knows you want the truth, and He knows your heart. He will certainly not let your life go by without granting you the chance to enter His Church.

Good luck, and may Christ’s peace be with you always as you continue your journey.
I love the idea here of Adoration! Good one!

Please try it if you have not already. It is such a wonderful thing.🙂
 
try to get an appointment with the pastor of the parishes near you to discuss your situation–not the secretary, not the lay director of religious education, the pastor. Most priests will bend over backwards to help you.

Also inquire if your college has a Catholic Campus Ministry. Often the classes are conducted there, although you will probably celebrate the sacraments at a nearby parish, but the schedule will be more friendly to academic life.

third take comfort in the counsel of the Rule of St Benedict, which dictates that new prospective monks are to be turned away 3 times before being accepted in order to test their vocation and their resolve.

Those in your parish running RCIA are doing their best to meet everyone’s needs. I have never turned anyone away and have found a creative solution for everyone who had a schedule or other conflict with our program. However, with the exception of two highly motivated candidates, only two of the people for whom we came up with a special plan stuck it out for more than a month or two.

There is a great value in changing your schedule to make RCIA a priority, and it is probably a necessary part of the conversion process. You can continue the study part through catechismclass.com (bearing in mind that even if you found a parish class you could attend it is still tough if you are also going to school). But eventually you will have to connect with a parish for the appropriate rites and sacraments. Continue to do what you are doing to participate in parish life, and offer up your hunger for the Eucharist for those who are permanently separated from Christ by sin, by life circumstances or by persecution.
 
I read briefly that you are going for your MBA - does the university you attend have a Newman Center? You may be able to contact a priest there to help you.
 
Thanks to all who have so far responded. There have been a lot of good replies here. I have been told before that this is a test of faith, and it’s an answer which I, in the past, haven’t much cared for simply because I never understood why I should be tested when I knew that I wished to become Catholic! But the story of Job teaches us much about life’s difficulties, and I believe it is a story I’ve overlooked.

I also plan on speaking to the priest soon. I will keep after him.

Thanks again to those who have so far responded for all your kind words. 🙂
 
Thanks to all who have so far responded. There have been a lot of good replies here. I have been told before that this is a test of faith, and it’s an answer which I, in the past, haven’t much cared for simply because I never understood why I should be tested when I knew that I wished to become Catholic! But the story of Job teaches us much about life’s difficulties, and I believe it is a story I’ve overlooked.

I also plan on speaking to the priest soon. I will keep after him.

Thanks again to those who have so far responded for all your kind words. 🙂
If you had a valid baptism you are considered a candidate, not a catechumen. The reason I bring this up is that you could be privately instructed by a priest and received at any time. You do not have to wait for the right RCIA program to come along. Talk to one of the priests in your area or contact the diocese about receiving private instruction for reception and confirmation. And God bless you on your journey!
 
Thanks to all who have so far responded. There have been a lot of good replies here. I have been told before that this is a test of faith, and it’s an answer which I, in the past, haven’t much cared for simply because I never understood why I should be tested when I knew that I wished to become Catholic! But the story of Job teaches us much about life’s difficulties, and I believe it is a story I’ve overlooked.

I also plan on speaking to the priest soon. I will keep after him.

Thanks again to those who have so far responded for all your kind words. 🙂
Think of it in this way…
Maybe it’s not God that’s keeping you from being Catholic…
Satan is real, and he does whatever is in his power in this broken world to keep us from Christ.
FIGHT for your right to be one with Christ in the Eucharist. Get pushy with that priest (in a nice way of course! :D) and have him make special arrangements for you! Don’t give up!

God bless! You WILL make a great Catholic!
 
i never realized how fortunate I was to have a monsignor that gave me private instruction according to my schedule. I may have had a similar experience if not for him.
 
I too am sorry you’ve had to be put aside and I know that can lead to frustration when you want something so bad but are having to wait for the process. All of the these challenges before you allow us to strengthen our resolve. We must always remember is “thy will be done” and only at time will He see to you and your needs. Be patient in the Lord. I am sure that through everything that you have explained God will bring you through.
 
Valiant,
I am sure by the time this is all through you are going to be a Catholic with a deeper appreciation of what the Eucharist is then some who have taken it for granted.

God bless,
Jon
 
Valient part of the reason for you to be challenged in your faith…is the fact that you came here and told us your story. It was for me heartwarming and faith bolstering for me so I guess that you trials are for a reason, part of which is to bolster our faith as well. See you are being used by god for other Catholics right here and today> Thank you for coming to this board and sharing with me. It has made me a better person and Christian.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top