Why is Doubting Thomas always criticized for his scepticism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bohm_Bawerk
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think Thomas is revered by a saint by the church. On the sight of the resurrected Jesus he first showed disbelief, I guess in shock, but then called Jesus, “My lord and My God”.
 
Because he had to see before he would believe. Read John 20:29

DaveBj
 
Because he had to see before he would believe. Read John 20:29

DaveBj
I suppose that God allowed St.Thomas to doubt that Christ rose from the dead because he reflects our own doubts and fears.How many of us at times feel a doubt that God is not hearing our prayers or that Christ has not the power to heal this or that person.Since early childhood “doubting Thomas” has been instilled into our very minds & souls.Even in the English language everyone knows what a “doubting thomas” is!
It is only upon reading the writings and devotions of our Eastern separated Churches that I have learnt another different slant on St.Thomas.They focus in the fact the he revealed and affirmed the truth that Christ did rise from the dead;showing his crucified glorified Body .It is St.Thomas that felt the holes in his Masters’ hands ,side and feet;at the direct invitation of Jesus.From earliest childhood I have been taught this great aspiration and faith pray of St.Thomas,the Apostle–My Lord and My God.and Lord I believe,help my unbelief.It also gave Christ the opportunity to teach us one of His final teachings that we need a “blind” faith that looks at Christ “through,glass darkly”–to see with the eyes of Faith–the faith that St.Thomas points to.
 
Well I believe that karoleck, above pretty well covered it.

For myself, when I read your question the first thing thing that I thought was “who criticizes St Thomas?”
Yes we have the saying “doubting Thomas” but this is really no different from saying someone is from Missouri (The “show me” state)
But I know of no one who actually “criticizes” Thomas.

The story of Thomas is one of inspiration and not criticism.

We all have doubts from time to time and we all seek answers and ask God to “show us” in some way or another that He is there…cares…and loves…

Peace
James
 
Who’s criticizing? I’ve never heard such a thing.

It is not a specifically eastern teaching that it was providence that Thomas needed to put his hand in Jesus’ side. That’s always been my understanding as a Latin Rite Catholic.

In fact, I believe Judas Iscariot fulfilled his God-given role in the whole story. No Judas, no Good Friday…or Easter Sunday. 😉
 
The story of Doubting Thomas is the greatest cause for hope. His actions show that the entire Bible - and all of history, really - is geared toward humanity, as a gift from divinity. God Himself laments Thomas’ rationalism, and begs him to come forward with faith. The whole point of the story of humanity is that we must have faith in God. From Psalms to Genesis to Revelation, faith is our solid rock. Peter was made the Rock of the Church for his faith in God, and in unashamedly confessing what the Father had revealed to him about Jesus.

The Lord is master of the faithful, and disdains the unfaithful. He casts out those who have no faith, and spits out those with lukewarm faith. Thomas is given a sort of friendly thrashing by Christian history because his faith was not strong enough until he had “seen the evidence”. I think the Lord gave us this scene explicitly for atheists, whom He knew would do what they are doing now - not because there’s no free will, but because He made each of us and knows His little ones perfectly. 🙂

Thomas is a saint now because he repented of his skepticism and went far and abroad to proclaim his master’s good news. Augustine is a saint because he overcame his effeminate lust for sexual intercourse, and became a model of virtue. Peter is a saint because his cowardly personality was finally overcome after Maundy Thursday, and he went about in faith forever. You cannot be a saint unless you started off a sinner. Thank God.
 
I thought Thomas had only said that he would believe if he could put his fingers in Christ’s wounds. However, when confronted with the risen Lord he believed without have to touch the wounds. I don’t believe the Gospels record him ever putting his fingers in the wounds, even when offered by Christ.

So, I’m not sure Thomas is really a model of doubting. He laid out one condition for believing, but without that condition being meant he believed anyhow. Modern skeptics say “I will only believe when …” and if that can’t be meant they simply refuse to believe. Thomas didn’t do that.

ChadS
 
Yes we have the saying “doubting Thomas” but this is really no different from saying someone is from Missouri (The “show me” state)
But I know of no one who actually “criticizes” Thomas.
But it is a bit of a bum rap.

Of course, the only reason we never speak of “doubting Peter” or “doubting John” is because they believed every word Mary told them on her return from the sepulcher.

Oh wait – No they didn’t! They took off running to see for themselves… 😉

tee
 
I thought Thomas had only said that he would believe if he could put his fingers in Christ’s wounds. However, when confronted with the risen Lord he believed without have to touch the wounds. I don’t believe the Gospels record him ever putting his fingers in the wounds, even when offered by Christ.

So, I’m not sure Thomas is really a model of doubting. He laid out one condition for believing, but without that condition being meant he believed anyhow. Modern skeptics say “I will only believe when …” and if that can’t be meant they simply refuse to believe. Thomas didn’t do that.

ChadS
My sentiments exactly.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
He may be criticized, but we still call him Saint Thomas.
Hmm; I would say that those who criticize Saint (Doubting) Thomas might as well criticize themselves for how many zillion timers (“WE”) have doubted or lost Faith in our struggling journey on the narrow road or Dark Night of the Soul.

Was it not Jesus who said to all of us when He spoke about the Mustard Seed ("You of so Little Faith, "I assure you, if you had faith as small as a mustard seed you could say to this mountain, ‘move from here to there,’ and it would move. Nothing would be impossible."

The Mountains that Jesus is referring to that heed our Faith and cause Doubts is the clutter and illusions of this world and all its allurements filling our heart that remove or side-track our focus on Jesus.

As for me I can’t count the many inumerable I’ve needed to remind myself of these thoughts as well as contemplating on the parable of the Mustard Seed.

Peace
Chris
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top