Why Is It So Hard To Join

  • Thread starter Thread starter Theophilus76
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This doesn’t say they don’t go through RCIA. It says they go through RCIA as adapted for their needs. It’s not the catechumenate, but they still need “instruction in the Catholic tradition” and “a degree of probation within the Catholic community.” And that is what RCIA provides for them, in addition to the various liturgical rites.

Unfortunately many parishes do not differentiate between those who are already Christians and those who are not, but RCIA is available for both groups.
They need a course of instruction adapted to their needs and circumstances. They do NOT need the RCIA, because they have been initiated through baptism. It is often convenient for the pastor that they participate in the weekly catechism classes that are called the RCIA classes, but those are not the RCIA per se. RCIA is exactly what it says - it’s a rite, and it’s a rite that culminates with baptism at the Easter Vigil.
 
They need a course of instruction adapted to their needs and circumstances. They do NOT need the RCIA, because they have been initiated through baptism. It is often convenient for the pastor that they participate in the weekly catechism classes that are called the RCIA classes, but those are not the RCIA per se. RCIA is exactly what it says - it’s a rite, and it’s a rite that culminates with baptism at the Easter Vigil.
Take a look at the ritual text starting with paragraph 400. There are rites for those already baptized which are different from those for catechumens.
 
Take a look at the ritual text starting with paragraph 400. There are rites for those already baptized which are different from those for catechumens.
I am aware that it is possible, as I have gone through the rite as a sponsor both with catechumens and candidates. The wording of the instructions states that this may be done for pastoral reasons, but the bishops have made it clear that this is not preferred.
 
If you’re really interested in the history of baptism in the Church, Kavanaugh’s “The Shape of Baptism: The Rite of Christian Initiation” is a good resource, as is Johnson’s “The Rites of Christian Initiation: Their Evolution and Interpretation”.
thanks, I am interested in this.
 
Theophilus, those who are posting are right that an already baptized person isn’t required to go through RCIA are correct. That isn’t how it is normally done. I also remember reading a testimony from somone in your situation who petitioned the Bishop and was allowed to enter the church before RCIA was concluded. But, sometimes the Lord wants us to be obedient to those he has placed in authority over us, and by that I mean the Pastor.

I went to mass for over 3 years waiting to receive the Eucharist. 2.5 years of this was after I completed RCIA. It wasn’t a normal situation, but came about because my decision to enter the church was made when I was in the midst of a divorce. After the divorce was finished, the Pastor decided I needed an annulment, which was incorrect. He knew that but insisted he wanted me to wait.

At first I would cry when everyone was going for communion. Later, I started to just feel as if I was wandering around in the desert with no food. I found a Psalm during that time…“Blessed are those who wait on the Lord”. I chose my CAF name, “WaitingForJesus” because that was what I was doing. It was a difficult test. I kept praying and talking to the Pastor. He kept saying NOT YET.

The Pastor told me to pray for spiritual communion during the Eucharist, and I would recommend you do this. My simple prayer when everyone else was going up was: “Lord, I wish to receive you with the purity, humility, and devotion of your mother and the fervor of the Saints”. My sponsor pointed out that I should offer up my despair for the conversion of others who don’t believe in the Lord’s real presence in the Eucharist. And, I started to like it. Eventually the Lord changed that priest’s mind and it came about in a way that I had no doubt as to his involvement. I assure you the joy I felt after that was worth the wait!!! I grew so much closer to the Lord during that time through Eucharistic adoration and other prayer, that I now look back on that trial as a blessing.

Your wait will be OK. It may even be outstanding. I promise.
 
When I was involved with RCIA, we did fast track one woman, with the full approval of the priest. She was 90. 😃
 
RCIA Question

I too spoke to my local Priest about joining the Catholic church but I missed the first RCIA meeting because of ill health.

Does anyone know if these programmes occur once a year? If not, when can I next “sign up”? I’m really eager to join.
 
I do not understand why I have to spend a certain amount of time determining if the Catholic Church is right for me.

“Please, someone let me in,” only to see multitudes of people starring out the windows at me shaking their heads saying, “Poor soul. He doesn’t know the door only unlocks once a year.”
RCIA is not about you figuring out if the CC is right for you. It is about learning what the church teaches. It takes a bit of time to learn the basics. The RCIA is just the beginning of the whole journey you have embarked upon.

The door doesn’t ‘unlock’ once a year. It is never locked. Again, the church requires that people who want to convert know enough about the faith so they are prepared. You might think that you are ready right now but perhaps the priest knows better. They deal with converts all the time. There is a reason for this, so please trust their judgement and be patient.
 
RCIA is not about you figuring out if the CC is right for you.
This point I must disagree with you on. As a catechist for our RCIA team, I have to make sure that the catechumens are indeed willing to accept all the teachings of the Church. I make it understood that they are embarking on a life changing path in which they must be obedient to the teachings of the Church. Some do decide that this is not the path that they wish to embark on.
 
Unfortunately many parishes do not differentiate between those who are already Christians and those who are not, but RCIA is available for both groups.
My wife and I experienced this. But we came to understand that perhaps we were intended to walk along with those not yet baptised to be of help to them.
 
RCIA Question

I too spoke to my local Priest about joining the Catholic church but I missed the first RCIA meeting because of ill health.

Does anyone know if these programmes occur once a year? If not, when can I next “sign up”? I’m really eager to join.
Ideally RCIA is available year round so people can start at different times. But the actual decisions are made in individual parishes. Check with your parish to see what they do.
 
My wife and I experienced this. But we came to understand that perhaps we were intended to walk along with those not yet baptised to be of help to them.
That was nice of you! Not many people can be so understanding & helpful.
 
RCIA Question

I too spoke to my local Priest about joining the Catholic church but I missed the first RCIA meeting because of ill health.

Does anyone know if these programmes occur once a year? If not, when can I next “sign up”? I’m really eager to join.
Talk with your RCIA director or even, if needed, the priest again. Maybe you can find some way to make up for what you had to lose.
 
RCIA Question

I too spoke to my local Priest about joining the Catholic church but I missed the first RCIA meeting because of ill health.

Does anyone know if these programmes occur once a year? If not, when can I next “sign up”? I’m really eager to join.
Typically, these programs will meet weekly or possibly bi-weekly throughout a 6-12 month period preceding the Easter Vigil. It’s early enough in the process that you should have no problem getting in. You might have a little catching up to do, but I would doubt it’s a problem. That said, call the parish ASAP and enroll in the program.
 
My wife and I experienced this. But we came to understand that perhaps we were intended to walk along with those not yet baptised to be of help to them.
I also had to do the full RCIA program although I had been an active Episcopalian. What a good way to understand what happened.👍
 
My wife and I experienced this. But we came to understand that perhaps we were intended to walk along with those not yet baptised to be of help to them.
I was already baptized so technically I didn’t have to do the whole of RCIA but our diocese prefers everyone to be in RCIA. I can tell you this, I was a bit pouty about it at first but as we went along I learned so much about not only the Catholic Church and its doctrines and dogma, but about myself as well. It was a humbling experience and one I now know was best for me. Seeing others growing in their faith along side me was one of the most thrilling things in my life and it was a privilege to walk this journey with them. At the Easter Vigil you could have seen the glow from our faces from the moon. Not for a nanosecond do I regret the months I spent in RCIA.
 
I always got the impression that in the early church, people were baptized then instructed.
Perhaps at the very beginning, but I’m sure they saw lots of people being baptized one day and then falling back into sin the next, simply because they had not taken the time to learn. So by the end of the First Century it was about 3 years, with a fourth year of Mystagogia after the reception of the Sacraments.
 
I’m considering joining the Catholic Church. I’ve read several articles about what it takes to join, and was really motivated to talk to a priest about this. I just had a meeting with someone at the church closest to my house; he was not a priest, but this was the only person who would reply to my email. I told him I was ready to join; I would do it today. He told me that the RCIA program is what I needed. As I understand it, this would delay my entry into full communion with the church for almost a full year.

What?? Why is it so hard to join? Why in the world would Catholics want to keep people out until an appointed time in the future? You have the most blessed sacrament of all, and I make full accent to all the Catholic Church teaches, but I cannot receive any sacraments until the next scheduled boarding date? What is the purpose of this delay? What will happen if I die between now and then? Don’t I need these sacraments to receive Christ fully in my life? If these things can wait a year, then why would I need them at all?

I know it’s a lot of questions, but I’m a little put out. It’s like an employer who wants you to start a job, but you won’t be paid until some time next year; but please come anyway.
I went through RCIA and loved everything about it. We are all born Catholic so no need to feel like yournot. RCIA teachs alot of great spirtual stuff. Try it out I promise if your being real about wanting to become Catholic you need to learn all that the Catholic church has that takes time. Hope this helped
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top