Why is it that, when Protestants convert to Catholicism

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tenebrae
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tenebrae

Guest
they speak well of their former churches, but when Catholics switch to a Protestant denomination, they bad-mouth the Catholic Church?
 
they speak well of their former churches, but when Catholics switch to a Protestant denomination, they bad-mouth the Catholic Church?
When a Protestant converts, they have found the truth, and are on the journey home.

When a Catholic converts, they are rejecting the truth, and bad-mouthing is their way of trying to convince themselves that they did the right thing, for bad-mouthing is just a way to make others seem smaller to make yourself feel better about your bad decision or action.
 
When a Protestant converts, they have found the truth, and are on the journey home.

When a Catholic converts, they are rejecting the truth, and bad-mouthing is their way of trying to convince themselves that they did the right thing, for bad-mouthing is just a way to make others seem smaller to make yourself feel better about your bad decision or action.
:sad_yes:

Exactly. Former Protestants make some of the best Catholics, because they know what they are gaining.

I have a personal pet peeve - when people say, “I’m a recovering Catholic,” I just want to

:slapfight::nunchuk::knight2:

That really offends me.
 
they speak well of their former churches, but when Catholics switch to a Protestant denomination, they bad-mouth the Catholic Church?
Because when a Protestant finds the Truth in the Catholic Church they take a more positive outlook on everything for what they’ve gained, and when a Catholic leaves the Church they take a negative outlook (naturally) on everything because of what they’ve lost (even if they don’t realize it).
 
You ask an interesting question. As a revert who was an active Evangelical for nearly 20 years I would have to say more often than not your observation is correct. I, myself, was extremely critical of the Catholic church when I was Evangelical and I have greatly sorrowed over that. My husband and I have taken a lot of flack for coming back to the Church from some of our old friends - sadly Evangelicals who are former Catholics as we were - but it has lead to some interesting discussions and actually has them thinking some things over.

In my case, as in many of our friends, there was a real lack of knowledge and understanding of the Church’s teachings and beliefs. We fell into that group of post 1965-up to John Paul II where even some of us in Catholic schools were exposed mostly to “sloppy agape”, i.e. heavy on liberal social issues, no talk whatsoever of sin, repentance, holiness, etc. Some of us went through 12 years of Catholic education with not even a serious talk on the Eucharist. I could go on but you get the idea. Most of us left the church, screwed up our lives with sin and finally when someone talked about a relationship with Jesus as attainable we jumped at a simple concept - repent and be saved - not realizing the Church stood for that all along, because it hadn’t been expressed that way to us. Then I think every grudge ever held comes to light AND some people feel angry that they WEREN’T told that growing up. So they become hypercritical of the Church without even knowing many of the teachings they complain about - where they came from, why they exist. At least this has been my experience.
 
Ditto what other posters said. It is tough to paint broad strokes but there are some general trends I’ve noticed.

A couple thoughts from my experience:
  1. When Catholics I’ve met go to Protestant churches, they often complain about how the Mass is boring, or “the rules” or something that shows they did not fully understand their faith or didn’t take the effort to do so.
  2. When Protestants become Catholic, it is because their zeal and seeking of the truth that perhaps was inspired by their former Christian churches, but realized to fulfill their desires they became Catholic. Peter Kreeft says it well: “To become the best Protestants they can be, they will have to become Catholic.”
  3. I have to be careful to even make these generalizations. One of my friends converted from Catholicism to become an evangelical Christian and she is very devout and a seeker of truth and for now, she seems to have found it in her church. However, she puts many Catholics to shame with her piety and love of God. She also does not speak badly about the Church, so she is a striking exception to the stereotype. Although I do believe she’ll become a Catholic again, I think she left the Church for the “right” reasons.
God bless,
Bryan
 
I have a personal pet peeve - when people say, “I’m a recovering Catholic,” I just want to

:slapfight::nunchuk::knight2:

That really offends me.
LMAO!!! Love the smileys.

I will say it doesn’t automatically offend me, mainly because many of the people I have talked to who describe themselves as “recovering Catholics” usually have some awful stories about how they were raised. Basically, their parents did NOT do a good job modeling God’s love, and in doing, so, drove their children away.
 
Oops - wanted to finish my thought, but was afraid I’d lose my posting…! I’d have to agree that when Catholics come back or convert they have put much time and thought, prayer and often study into becoming Catholic - they do have a realization of what they are gaining and are joyful and grateful to be coming home. We are in touch with old friends regularly, tho not often, and we have a great deal of affection for each other. The best thing we all can do is know our faith well enough so when some one says something off-the-wall because they don’t know any better, we have the truth to share in love. And pray for those who don’t see the beauty of the gift of the original true Church Jesus left.
 
When a Protestant converts, they have found the truth, and are on the journey home.

When a Catholic converts, they are rejecting the truth, and bad-mouthing is their way of trying to convince themselves that they did the right thing, for bad-mouthing is just a way to make others seem smaller to make yourself feel better about your bad decision or action.
👍
when people say, “I’m a recovering Catholic,”
Personally, I’ve always thought that’s a pretty good one-liner, because of the -olic endingmakes it a really well crafted joke.
 
Ditto what other posters said. It is tough to paint broad strokes but there are some general trends I’ve noticed.

A couple thoughts from my experience:
  1. When Catholics I’ve met go to Protestant churches, they often complain about how the Mass is boring, or “the rules” or something that shows they did not fully understand their faith or didn’t take the effort to do so.
  2. When Protestants become Catholic, it is because their zeal and seeking of the truth that perhaps was inspired by their former Christian churches, but realized to fulfill their desires they became Catholic. Peter Kreeft says it well: “To become the best Protestants they can be, they will have to become Catholic.”
  3. I have to be careful to even make these generalizations. One of my friends** converted from Catholicism to become an evangelical Christian** and she is very devout and a seeker of truth and for now, she seems to have found it in her church. However, she puts many Catholics to shame with her piety and love of God. She also does not speak badly about the Church, so she is a striking exception to the stereotype. Although I do believe she’ll become a Catholic again, I think she left the Church for the “right” reasons.
God bless,
Bryan
Just a short correction. A Catholic cannot convert to anything else. Once baptised a Catholic you remain a Catholic forever no matter how you feel, what you do, and even if you turn your back on the Church.
There are no former Catholics. There are only two types of Catholic. Those in a state of grace and those in a state of mortal sin.
 
Just a short correction. A Catholic cannot convert to anything else. Once baptised a Catholic you remain a Catholic forever no matter how you feel, what you do, and even if you turn your back on the Church.
There are no former Catholics. There are only two types of Catholic. Those in a state of grace and those in a state of mortal sin.
Very true, and something a lot of people don’t get. I didn’t, I thought I was no longer a Catholic when I was lapsed.
 
When a Protestant converts, they have found the truth, and are on the journey home.

When a Catholic converts, they are rejecting the truth, and bad-mouthing is their way of trying to convince themselves that they did the right thing, for bad-mouthing is just a way to make others seem smaller to make yourself feel better about your bad decision or action.
Well put:)
 
In my case, I was raised Catholic and had fond memories of it. I was educated in Catholic schools and was very devout and enjoyed the Church.

My life was very turbulent as a child and teen. I made an error in blaming God for the misfortunes that befell me and my family and I became Agnostic.

Later, I joined a Pentecostal group for 5 years (long story) and was only 6 months away from finishing seminary and completing my ordination when alarm bells went off inside. God was showing me that what I had been taught was wrong. I only realized some things were wrong, but the basics of salvation did not make sense anymore to me, so I had to leave that group. I could not in good conscience preach to others what I had been taught. It took 20 years of searching for me to deprogram myself and satisfy my mind about things. Finally, the vestiges of their inculcation were overcome.

AMong other things, I missed the sacred silence and the church calendar that was lacking in the Pentecostal group. I was tired of the extreme Legalism and sought peace… so here I am 🙂
 
It doesn’t always work that way.
More often than not, but you’re right, I’ve seen some tasteless remarks of converts concerning their former faith traditions, and even towards the folk still in them. :o
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top