Why is Joseph always depicted as being old?

  • Thread starter Thread starter GangGreen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

GangGreen

Guest
From what I always gathered, in Ancient Israel people typically got married at a young age. I cannot imagine that Joseph would have been in his 30s or 40s when he married Mary. I always pictured him as being in his early 20s or something yet most images depict him as being a much older man.
 
Traditionally Joseph has always been believed to be an older man, a widower. The East has held on this tradition more and the notion of a younger Joseph was only introduced must later, I believe in the early Second Millennium.

Proof of this is the Protoevangelium of James, which is one of the most popular “Scriptures” of the time even though it never made it to the canon of Scripture. According to current evidence we have, it is the most widely circulated book of the New Testament of its time. It means that what is written is probably what is already generally believed by Christians of the time, also goes to show how early the reverence for Mary really began. So despite not making it to canon a couple of centuries later, it gives us a good view of what Christians of the time believed in.
 
I take the school of thought contrary to tradition (small-t not big-T). I take Joseph as being a young man. As young as Mary because he was a strong carpenter and fled with Mary and Jesus to Egypt.

Also the old-age Joseph derives from the apocryphal Protoevangelium of Saint James.
 
We simply don’t know for sure. Conjecture has it that St Joseph was older, thus not as interested in having sexual relations with Mary. However, some artists depict St Joseph as a young man, with carpenter tools and/or holding a lily. A trip to Egypt with a young wife and child could have been a hardship for an older man.

Perhaps we can ask him in heaven!!
 
As mentioned, we simply do not know exactly why he is depicted as an old men frequently. I assume to show that he, as an old man, would not be interested in sexual relations with the young Mary.

I, myself, have always pictured him to be in his early to mid-thirties when he was betrothed to Mary and Jesus was born.
 
Hello,

from the tradition I grew up with, St Joseph was young and a virgin, so I always thought it odd he was portrayed old so often! Anyway this past thread may be of interest:

Help on Joseph and Mary –
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=8680548#post8680548

take care,
amsjj 🙂

+++
Jesus, God and man,
imprisoned by love in Thy most holy Sacrament,
have mercy upon us.
  • Blessed John Henry Newman, December 22, 1851
Tú y yo sabemos por la fe que oculto en las especies sacramentales está Cristo,
ese Cristo con su Cuerpo, con su Sangre, con su Alma, y con su Divinidad,
prisonero de amor.
  • San Josemaría Escrivá, 1 junio 1974
… Our Lord Himself frequently said; and it is recorded as an
Apostolic tradition from Him by St. Justin the Martyr. He says
‘Jesus often said, “They who are near Me are near a fire”’.
  • Abp. W. B. Ullathorne, August 1st 1886
 
We simply don’t know for sure. Conjecture has it that St Joseph was older, thus not as interested in having sexual relations with Mary. However, some artists depict St Joseph as a young man, with carpenter tools and/or holding a lily. A trip to Egypt with a young wife and child could have been a hardship for an older man.

Perhaps we can ask him in heaven!!
Long trips were normative during the time. Old folks back then are probably stronger than the 20-somethings today who sit around all day posting on Forums 😃

And it was not like Joseph was ancient. Some would put his age around late 40s to 50s. A lot of active 50-somethings today are very much able to do a lot of physical tasks.
 
From what I always gathered, in Ancient Israel people typically got married at a young age. I cannot imagine that Joseph would have been in his 30s or 40s when he married Mary. I always pictured him as being in his early 20s or something yet most images depict him as being a much older man.
It depends on the images honestly. I have a few that show him as a young man. My Holy Family statue (albeit designed recently) has a young Joseph too 🙂

It all depends on which tradition you accept. I believe one tradition states that St. Joseph was old and had already had a previous family. His wife had passed away and thus he took on the role of being a guardian toward the Blessed Virgin Mary. I assume the people of the time found this tradition an easy way to explain how St. Joseph and the Blessed Mother had no marital relations.

But again, it doesn’t have to be that St. Joseph was old. There are traditions that portray St. Joseph as a young man. I too like this tradition better 🙂

So you are free to choose the one you feel comfortable!
 
Males continue to develop muscular strength into their 40s, so a Joseph that old could easily have been a “strong carpenter”.

The tradition of SJ’s older age stems from the fact that he disappears from the Gospels, presumably into death, after our LORD is twelve years old. Were he a young man, his death would be noticeable to the gospel writers. SJ’s passing going unmentioned suggests that by this point he is old.

ICXC NIKA
 
What I was taught in religious education classes in school is that women in Mary’s time would have been 12 or 14 years old as a coming of age, when they where married off.
This is because once they matured they would have been target for rape and abuse.Thus needing an older husband that could provide and support family needs. Where the husband would have been in his late 20’s early 30’s
I think it is ridiculous though to see St. Joesph drawn as a deprecated old man,
I actually wanted to ask this myself after going to an adoration chapel and seeing a picture of St. Joe who made Gandolph look young and fit
 
What I was taught in religious education classes in school is that women in Mary’s time would have been 12 or 14 years old as a coming of age, when they where married off.
This is because once they matured they would have been target for rape and abuse.Thus needing an older husband that could provide and support family needs. Where the husband would have been in his late 20’s early 30’s
I think it is ridiculous though to see St. Joesph drawn as a deprecated old man,
I actually wanted to ask this myself after going to an adoration chapel and seeing a picture of St. Joe who made Gandolph look young and fit
Please, don’t call ridiculous an Eastern Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox and Ancient Western tradition
 
The human body aged hard in that place and time; although our LORD was killed as a young man, at HIS age of 30-39 HE would already have outlived 90% of HIS age group.

So a 52 year old Joseph would have seemed old by modern standards.

ICXC NIKA
 
Was he not chosen as an older man to protect her virginity & not to violate it?🤷
 
The human body aged hard in that place and time; although our LORD was killed as a young man, at HIS age of 30-39 HE would already have outlived 90% of HIS age group.

So a 52 year old Joseph would have seemed old by modern standards.

ICXC NIKA
I think this is a misrepresentation of the historical statistics. While the average age is indeed around 30-ish at the time, it is not because people die at that age. It is because of high infant mortality rates, many young men dying of plagues and war and other brutality of the time, etc. But people who live through these do live longer. There was hardly any air pollution, foods were not processed and contained no artificial ingredients as we have today, etc. Despite the lower standards of sanitation compared to today, people were more resistant to such conditions. St. Peter wasn’t much younger than Jesus, yet he lived about 30 years more after the Resurrection, and only died because of martyrdom. St. John was about 11 or 12 at the start of Jesus’ ministry, and he lived to the 90s, which is about 60 years later.
 
Just butting in. Tekton (‘one who works with his hands’) does not necessarily mean ‘carpenter’ as in ‘woodworker’, although that itself is also another old pious belief.
 
Just butting in. Tekton (‘one who works with his hands’) does not necessarily mean ‘carpenter’ as in ‘woodworker’, although that itself is also another old pious belief.
From biblestudytools.com:

Tekton

The KJV New Testament Greek Lexicon
Strong’s Number: * 5045 **
Original Word Word Origin
tevktwn from the base of (5098)
Transliterated Word TDNT Entry
Tekton None
Phonetic Spelling Parts of Speech
tek’-tone
* Noun Masculine
*Definition
a worker in wood, a carpenter, joiner, builder
a ship’s carpenter or builder
any craftsman, or workman
the art of poetry, maker of songs
a planner, contriver, plotter
an author

ICXC NIKA
 
From biblestudytools.com:

Tekton

The KJV New Testament Greek Lexicon
Strong’s Number: * 5045 **
Original Word Word Origin
tevktwn from the base of (5098)
Transliterated Word TDNT Entry
Tekton None
Phonetic Spelling Parts of Speech
tek’-tone
* Noun Masculine
*Definition
a worker in wood, a carpenter, joiner, builder
a ship’s carpenter or builder
any craftsman, or workman
the art of poetry, maker of songs
a planner, contriver, plotter
an author

ICXC NIKA
To give an expanded version of my earlier reply:

The word tekton is related to the word techne (τέχνη, ‘craft’, ‘skill’, ‘art’; cf. technology). It is thought to derive from the Proto-Indo-European root *tek[sup]s[/sup] which generally signified ‘to work with an axe’ or ‘to fashion’. However, the Greeks have been using the axe (/labrys**pelekys) to fashion not just wood, but also stone, since ancient times. It therefore seems accurate to describe tekton as essentially meaning a craftsman who used strong tools to fashion hard and lasting materials, be it wood or stone or metal.

In Homer, tektones seems to denotes shipbuilders, housebuilders, and masons. As it is, tekton is too general a word: in order to denote which type of ‘artisan’ one is speaking, one should specify which material said tekton specializes in: for example, something like ‘tekton of wood’. We can see this in the Septuagint translation of 2 Samuel (5:11): “And King Chiram of Tyre sent messengers to Dauid and cedar wood and craftsmen of wood and craftsmen of stones (τέκτονας ξύλων καὶ τέκτονας λίθων, tektonas xylōn kai tektonas lithōn), and they built Dauid a house.”

Historically speaking, a woodworker would probably not have had much to do in a place like Nazareth. Peasants did not own too much furniture (at most, a family might own a low table, but not much else), and good wood was scarce in the area (high-quality timber was imported, and would obviously hardly have turned up in a rural hamlet like Nazareth). In fact, wood was mainly used only to make utensils and tools and some architectural features like roof beams, doors, and door frames. On the contrary, stone was more important, because it was used as building material and even as tableware alongside pottery (cups, mugs, bowls, etc.) If Joseph and Jesus were ‘craftsmen’, their area of expertise would not have probably just been limited to woodworking: they would have worked as stonemasons, housebuilders (plenty of opportunities with Sepphoris close by - at least while it is still being built), repairmen fixing things like farming implements or boats. Heck, they may have also dabbled in a bit of farm work.

The tradition that Joseph and Jesus were specifically woodworkers who made ploughs and yokes, attested as early as Justin Martyr and the Infancy Gospel of Thomas, may have been motivated by a desire to draw a symbolic parallel between the wooden yoke and the wood of the cross.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

 
=GangGreen;10133673]From what I always gathered, in Ancient Israel people typically got married at a young age. I cannot imagine that Joseph would have been in his 30s or 40s when he married Mary. I always pictured him as being in his early 20s or something yet most images depict him as being a much older man.
Here’s a site to check out:
http://www.ewtn.com/library/MARY/THEOINTR.HTM

The Church does not have as FAR as I know; a firm teaching on this matter.

I have read that this may well have been a second marriage for St. Joseph, and that he may have had other children from a first wife and marriage?[deceased wife]

He is depicted as “Older” I SUSPECT for the following reasons:

His primary role and duties were that of Protector and provider; both more likely fulfilled by one expereinced. And also because Mary was to reamin a Virgin by her desire to do so. Therefore Joseph would of had to cooperate willingly with that reality. It is assumed; that being “Old[er]” this would be easier for him:shrug: I have not found that to be necessarly true in all cases.

God Bless,

pat/PJM
 
It was widely believed in the early Church that Joseph was an elderly man due to writings of the time. Mary was believed to be a virgin and remained a virgin all of her life a belief we still have as Catholics. Joseph being an older man would not be likely to seek sex with her. He was also widely believed to be a widower with grown children which accounted for scriptural references to Jesus having siblings.
 
It was widely believed in the early Church that Joseph was an elderly man due to writings of the time. Mary was believed to be a virgin and remained a virgin all of her life a belief we still have as Catholics. Joseph being an older man would not be likely to seek sex with her. He was also widely believed to be a widower with grown children which accounted for scriptural references to Jesus having siblings.
Joseph did not have children from a prior marriage. Support for this deduction is made available by the accounts of Joseph and Mary’s travels first to Bethlehem and then to Egypt. Luke tells us that Joseph and Mary travelled from Nazareth to Bethlehem “to be taxed” (Luke 2:5). If Joseph had no fewer than six children from a previous marriage, we would presume them to travel with him as a family. The fact that Luke points out simply Joseph and Mary shows that at the time of their betrothal Joseph had no children. It is hard to accept as true that a godly man like Joseph would walk out on his children to marry Mary. Support for this deduction is provided also by Matthew’s account of the flight into Egypt. An angel instructs Joseph in a dream, saying, “Arise, and take the young child and his mother, and flee into Egypt, and be thou there until I bring thee word” (Matthew 2:13). After the death of Herod, the same angel tells Joseph: “Arise, and take the young child and his mother, and go into the land of Israel: for they are dead which sought the young child’s life” (Matthew 2:20). In both illustrations, the travelling party consisted only of Joseph, Mary, and the child Jesus. There is no suggestion of the six children that Joseph supposedly had from a prior marriage. Did Joseph leave them forsaken in Nazareth for several years until he and Mary came back from Egypt with Jesus?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top