I won’t bog you down on my own theories regarding the rise of polytheism and the existence of our First Parents. However, I can say that much of what I know of secular anthropology tells us that mankind all has roots in monotheism. Likely sun worship. You can see echoes of this in atheistic films like Zeitgeist. While not a bastion of Theological infallibility, it does seem plausible. Also, you have to take into account that the whole mortal conception of a god has evolved over at least six thousand years, almost certainly longer than that. Most primitive cultures would have probably had what we might call a henotheistic outloo, that is to say, a belief in an overarching principle/deity with many subordinates, most often linked to natural phenomenon.
Actually, I lied. I will bog you down with my own theory. There were two key stories from the Holy Writ that prompted me to accept monotheism and further on, Catholicism. The most important is the Story of the Tower of Babel.
It could come about this way, when Adam and Eve were repulsed from the Garden, they travelled east, setting up little nooks and enclaves of people, they begat their many ancestral lines and society began to form. They each travelled about with the Name of God on their lips. But they would have, in all likelihood, kept close together for safety and community and all that jazz. At Babel, we are told, that God descended to scramble the languages of the peoples and scatter them. The Name enters the mouth through linguistic means, it stands to reason that the Name, Yahweh, would have been confounded, as would have the names for God. If you trace the Indo-European and Indo-Asian languages back as far as they’ll take you, you’ll find that the names for God coincide. The English Os, the Nordic As, all relate back in time. The Latin god Jupiter’s name is derived from something like Diu-Pater, meaning the father of the gods. The Viking god of bravery, Tyr’s name traces into the Indo-European name Tiwaz, or from Tiu and Az, a god of gods. The Indians, whom I know much less about, have something called a Daiyuz, I’m probably spelling this wrong, but has the same Indo-European cognate for God. Much of this information is parroted by the infinitely conflicted “theologians” of the Asatru religion. Their theology is rubbish and their conclusions are generally misapplied, but their scholarship is not without merit. Granted, it isn’t a flawless theory, but many scholars I’ve read seem to believe that all languages flow back in time to a point in which all man was located in one location before Great Migration, or whatnot. Anyway, the point of my mildly insane rant is to attempt to show that your Faith needn’t be hampered by an understanding of modern science, or anti-science for that matter.
God bless,