Why is polytheism older than monotheism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Holly3278

Guest
Hey everyone. I was thinking about this earlier and I hope my question makes sense to everyone. Anyway, I always figured that since God created Adam and Eve and since Adam and Eve knew God then they also knew that He is only one God and not many and therefore the earliest religion would be monotheistic. However, that doesn’t seem to be the case. It seems that the oldest religions are polytheistic. Could someone please explain to me how this is and if I have gone wrong in my logic somewhere? I really appreciate any help you can provide. I am not very smart and so I would like to get this cleared up in my mind with your help.
 
I won’t bog you down on my own theories regarding the rise of polytheism and the existence of our First Parents. However, I can say that much of what I know of secular anthropology tells us that mankind all has roots in monotheism. Likely sun worship. You can see echoes of this in atheistic films like Zeitgeist. While not a bastion of Theological infallibility, it does seem plausible. Also, you have to take into account that the whole mortal conception of a god has evolved over at least six thousand years, almost certainly longer than that. Most primitive cultures would have probably had what we might call a henotheistic outloo, that is to say, a belief in an overarching principle/deity with many subordinates, most often linked to natural phenomenon.
Actually, I lied. I will bog you down with my own theory. There were two key stories from the Holy Writ that prompted me to accept monotheism and further on, Catholicism. The most important is the Story of the Tower of Babel.
It could come about this way, when Adam and Eve were repulsed from the Garden, they travelled east, setting up little nooks and enclaves of people, they begat their many ancestral lines and society began to form. They each travelled about with the Name of God on their lips. But they would have, in all likelihood, kept close together for safety and community and all that jazz. At Babel, we are told, that God descended to scramble the languages of the peoples and scatter them. The Name enters the mouth through linguistic means, it stands to reason that the Name, Yahweh, would have been confounded, as would have the names for God. If you trace the Indo-European and Indo-Asian languages back as far as they’ll take you, you’ll find that the names for God coincide. The English Os, the Nordic As, all relate back in time. The Latin god Jupiter’s name is derived from something like Diu-Pater, meaning the father of the gods. The Viking god of bravery, Tyr’s name traces into the Indo-European name Tiwaz, or from Tiu and Az, a god of gods. The Indians, whom I know much less about, have something called a Daiyuz, I’m probably spelling this wrong, but has the same Indo-European cognate for God. Much of this information is parroted by the infinitely conflicted “theologians” of the Asatru religion. Their theology is rubbish and their conclusions are generally misapplied, but their scholarship is not without merit. Granted, it isn’t a flawless theory, but many scholars I’ve read seem to believe that all languages flow back in time to a point in which all man was located in one location before Great Migration, or whatnot. Anyway, the point of my mildly insane rant is to attempt to show that your Faith needn’t be hampered by an understanding of modern science, or anti-science for that matter.

God bless,
 
I think the answer is in progressive revelation.

The idea that God revealed truths to us over a very long period of time.

He didnt in day one teach everyone everything.

In the OT the Jews were taken from a pagan culture and taught them first through the prophets. Teaching them the basics.

IN the NT we have the revelation of God’s son. Jesus life fulfils and completes the earlier revelation in the OT.

Treading on dodgy ground in the next one 🙂 but Mosaic laws were replaced, expanded or reversed. For example the animal sacrifices done away with. Being replaced with the new covenant of God’s love towards us.
 
@John Carlton:

Linguistic deviation does not explain how people who “knew” that there was only one God would invent pantheons of Gods.

Also, since your God reputedly desires all human beings to worship Him, why would He inflict a punishment on humanity that thwarts this goal? It seems that your “explanation” requires God to be extraordinarily inept.

That makes your “explanation” blasphemous, in addition to being non-historical, non-biblical and - I’m sorry about this - ridiculous.

@Dave B:

A similar problem to John’s. Your hypothesis only works if God is inept. Besides which, you didn’t answer Holly’s question.

Blasphemy. Sorry.

@Holly3278:

The Genesis creation story is not considered to be literally true by mainstream theologians. You are supposed to glean moral and “spiritual” wisdom from it, not historical and scientific facts.

Biblical literalism is a Protestant repudiation of centuries of - largely Catholic - scholarship.
 
I understand that we are not supposed to take the Genesis story literally but the Church does accept that Adam and Eve really did exist and that they really were the first people with immortal souls.
 
Nicko, to answer directly. In Romans 1 we learn that God allowed mankind to worship false gods. But ppl really knew the real God existed but chose to ignore Him. It was through the faith of the Jews that God sent the prophets to reveal truth to the people.
 
Earlier on it made the most sense to worship individual deities because to them (early humans) individual things kept their world turning. The sun gave light, the moon symboled darkness, the water life, fire death, and the sky was just a vast, endless heaven that no one could reach. Perhaps back in those times individual deities were worshiped because it was simple to think each thing was controlled by one person as that would make the most sense in the real world. If God(s) were placed into a more human form they would have ranks and specialties just like how the nomads had hunters AND gathers- to them it was easier to have different people directed at differernt tasks.

That’s just my thinking, sorry if it is incorrect.
 
I will tell you what I have heard the Jews say on this subject. What follows is a very, very basic paraphrase of rabbinic sources which describe the rise of idolatry. Keep in mind that I am not personally “endorsing” these views, but simply offering one perception which might interest your speculation.

Although, in the beginning, all of mankind was indeed monotheistic, they slowly began to take up for themselves intermediaries. Since God is the source of all things, giving honour to the sun becomes a way to give honor to God.

Over time, however, people began to forget God, and to instead focus solely upon what was once merely an intermediary. The sun itself may thus be honoured as a power independent of God.

Abraham, rabbinic tradition says, began to realise the error of all of this: that whilst our existence here is supported in many ways by many things, there is an ultimate cause behind all of them who is their source, who is a being, and who is the only being which may be rightly worshiped.

If you’d like some more information on the Jewish view of this – since it may be interesting to you – I’d recommend you listen to this: You shall have no other gods. What “other gods”?, which is a presentation by R’ Jonathan Rietti.
 
Although, in the beginning, all of mankind was indeed monotheistic, they slowly began to take up for themselves intermediaries. Since God is the source of all things, giving honour to the sun becomes a way to give honor to God.

Over time, however, people began to forget God, and to instead focus solely upon what was once merely an intermediary. The sun itself may thus be honoured as a power independent of God.
To me… this is what I basically always assumed. Most people seem to assume that once you KNOW something that you never A) get confused again or allow your understanding to get muddled B) that people can’t be later deceived or tempted into sin or simply to justify their mistakes and finally C) that from generation to generation…things don’t ever backslide or get misrepresented.

I can DEFINITELY see how over time… expressing thanks and appreciation for the Sun, which God created, and which gives warmth and light could lead to worshipping the Sun, itself over several generations and even more so over thousands of years.

I think it is completely within human nature to confuse those 2 things or try and marry them together.
 
Earlier on it made the most sense to worship individual deities because to them (early humans) individual things kept their world turning. The sun gave light, the moon symboled darkness, the water life, fire death, and the sky was just a vast, endless heaven that no one could reach. Perhaps back in those times individual deities were worshiped because it was simple to think each thing was controlled by one person as that would make the most sense in the real world. If God(s) were placed into a more human form they would have ranks and specialties just like how the nomads had hunters AND gathers- to them it was easier to have different people directed at differernt tasks.

That’s just my thinking, sorry if it is incorrect.
Don’t be sorry you may be right. The thought processes of the origins of mankind has the brain less developed and therefore, less insightful. They probably did not know that with so many forces working for and against them that there could be a unified force or souce that is God. They thought that the world was so vast and uncontrollable it took many gods to work things, all of course from human thought processes.
mdcpensive1
 
Consider that it only took Christians 1500 years to start splintering and acquiring false beliefs about Christ and His Church, and this with two things the earliest humans didn’t have - Scripture and the Church.

We’re a fallen people. We get everything wrong at every opportunity.
 
It seems that your “explanation” requires God to be extraordinarily inept.
I’m curious, how would you see God handling things better? To claim that someone is inept is to have better solutions in mind. What might those have been?
Biblical literalism is a Protestant repudiation of centuries of - largely Catholic - scholarship.
When I hear about e.g. Biblical literalists claiming that of course humans and dinosaurs existed at the same time, I just wince. I certainly wouldn’t adopt a faith that was so at odds with legitimate science, and I can understand why others wouldn’t either. The problem is that, absent the authority of the Church, they must search for another authority, and biblical literalism is a simple rule, easy to apply consistently. It’s only weakness is that it isn’t true. :rolleyes:
 
@John Carlton:

Linguistic deviation does not explain how people who “knew” that there was only one God would invent pantheons of Gods.

Also, since your God reputedly desires all human beings to worship Him, why would He inflict a punishment on humanity that thwarts this goal? It seems that your “explanation” requires God to be extraordinarily inept.

That makes your “explanation” blasphemous, in addition to being non-historical, non-biblical and - I’m sorry about this - ridiculous.

@Dave B:

A similar problem to John’s. Your hypothesis only works if God is inept. Besides which, you didn’t answer Holly’s question.

Blasphemy. Sorry.

@Holly3278:

The Genesis creation story is not considered to be literally true by mainstream theologians. You are supposed to glean moral and “spiritual” wisdom from it, not historical and scientific facts.

Biblical literalism is a Protestant repudiation of centuries of - largely Catholic - scholarship.
Nicko, what moral and spiritual wisdom do you glean from Genisis? There was nothing in the OP which indicated biblical literalism, just acknowledgement that Adam and Eve were the first humans, which we as Catholics are required to believe.
 
Consider that it only took Christians 1500 years to start splintering and acquiring false beliefs about Christ and His Church, and this with two things the earliest humans didn’t have - Scripture and the Church.

We’re a fallen people. We get everything wrong at every opportunity.
The Eastern Church has not splintered as the Western Church has for unknown reasons only God knows.

mdcpensive1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top