I
IamDust
Guest
Can someone give a little blurb about Proverbs 16:9 within context and how it pertains to free will and or predestination? Thank you!
"A man’s mind plans his way, but the LORD directs his steps."Can someone give a little blurb about Proverbs 16:9 within context and how it pertains to free will and or predestination? Thank you!
I agree - Chapters 306-308 of the CCC address this:How about this:
God’s plans don’t fail-His will will be done-so any evil, whether it be the fall of angels or man or any events thereafter, have occurred because He allows it. Our wills are quite radically free but still less free than His relatively speaking and, in any case, we’re free enough to be accountable for our actions. God won’t force us to do anything but He does work on our wills because they’re the problem-He wants them to be one with His perfect will. But He won’t force the issue so concepts such as a potter molding clay, man being drawn by God, or “We love Him because He first loved us”, are seen in scripture. But this is a process that we can cooperate with -or not.
Are you guys Thomists or Molinists?
I used to very stanch Thomist but then my priest would keep saying “no Catholics don’t really believe in predestination any more, we believe simply in prescience” so I sort of backed away.
On later reflection I think he is simply quite under-educated in the complexities of Catholic doctrine because Thomism (in terms of Predestination) is fine…
As a note on Catholic Predestination:
Thomism emphasizes Grace, God does things knowing how we react to them, so in that sense He sets our destiny while still allowing our freewill.
Molinism emphasizes Freewill, God does not interfere with our spiritual decisions but mealy knows of them.
Anyway now I’m sort of unsure either way: Does God cause or direct, albeit passively or indirectly, someone to accept Him, at heart and mind (ordinarily), as lord by acting in certain ways which would cause effects which He knows we will respond do in a certain way but still with Freewill? (what do we really mean by “freewill” then?)… or does God mealy offer the calling of Himself to all men but not interfere, at all, in their decisions to love/hate Him while seeing all time/space at once? (is it even possible for God to not even slightly affect one’s decision? - or is it possible that God’s Divine plan could have ever failed since His plan is affected by us, such as Judas for example?)
Great point.That’s like asking when Americans came to Earth from Venus - the question assumes the truth of something that has not been shown to be true; that is in fact not true at all. (Though sometimes one wonders…)
But, of course, the only doctrine that matters is that which is derived from the Bible, and not tradition.The same applies here. Predestination (of which there are several conceptions) is taught by St.Paul. Even the CC teaches it, as does its theological tradition.
Actually, it does teach nearly that. The Bible states that ALL OF US are born into this world on the path for hell and damnation. It’s just that SOME OF US are predestined to be saved from that path.Predestination does not = the doctrine that God predestines (better: pre-ordains) the reprobation of the non-elect by a positive Divine decree.
Calvinist - as far as is compatible w/ Catholicism
(which is pretty far, on this topic anyway - on others, less far)
While I lean more towards Thomism - particularly on the issue of unconditional election - I wouldn’t consider Molinism semi-pelagian. Arminianism equates prescience with predestination. In Molinism, predestination is much more than prescience and the order of grace or the world God has actualized is solely based on His free good pleasure. God is absolutely sovereign and has aboslute freedom in how He choses to exercise that sovereignty. Though Molinism is not free from problems.Molinism is semi-Pelagian - it makes God’s sovereign liberty subject to man’s choosing: it does not let God be utterly absolute. Only if God is totally Sovereign, totally at liberty to do exactly as He wills, totally totalitarian in every imaginable respect (& all respects that are not imaginable), is there a from basis for creaturely freedom.
All after the fact.Some never do… .but because it is their free choice.
God bless you, John J. GillettePredstination in Catholicism involves more than just God’s foreknowledge of our choices. BTW, welcome to Catholic Answers Forums!Paul states that we are “predestined.” This means that God knew before we were born that we would use our free will to choose Him and to obey Him until we died. Romans 8:29 He predestined each of us using His foreknowledge. He condemned those by His foreknowledge who did not choose to believe in Him and obey Him.
Please see members.cox.net/studyhisword/Predestined.pdf for a Biblical study on this topic.
God bless you, John J. GilletteThe above links are good resources for a Catholic understanding of predestination. There is a difference between Catholic predestination and Calvinism and also between Catholic predestination and Arminianism (i.e. election merely based on foreknowledge of man’s choices). Catholics are not Calvinist or Arminian.Predestination is officially taught by the Catholic Church, though not the Calvinst version:
thecatholicfaith.com/Teachings/predestination.htm
thesumma.info/predestination/index.php
The Catholic Thomist View:
ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/TULIP.htm
Molinist Catholic View:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molinism
newadvent.org/cathen/10437a.htm
God bless,
Michael
You have some excellent questions, Coco. You ask: “What is the point of giving us free will if He already knows what we are going to do, and if He predestined us for heaven?”I remember my mother telling me when I was young that God knew if we would go to heaven or not. He knows what you are going to do even before you do it. I am having trouble understanding this. What is the point of giving us free will if He already knows what we are going to do, and if He predestined us for heaven? This makes me think that He not only allows evil, but actually creates souls to become evil? I am positive this is wrong, but I am having trouble understanding this. How can you teach others about God’s love for all and His desire for all souls to be near Him, when it is already written in stone who is in and who is out? If there is predestination, where is the HOPE? I have read some of the sites that people have posted here, but am still struggling.
You have some excellent questions, Coco. You ask: “What is the point of giving us free will if He already knows what we are going to do, and if He predestined us for heaven?”
He never gave us free will. But he did give us a will that can choose. The difference is that free will is an illusion. Only God has true free will, because he is completely unfettered by any power that could possibly control or mitigate his actions or will.
Man is not born with free will, but is born under the control of Satan, subject to his will. Christ came to the earth to pay the ultimate penalty which frees us from this curse. What is Christ freeing us from if we have free will to do it ourselves?
There are many in this forum who wrongly teach that we have free will, but we don’t. Our will is either subject to the Devil, or it is subect to the Father in heaven. This is determined by who we align ourselves up with.
You also state that “This makes me think that He not only allows evil, but actually creates souls to become evil?” Actually, that’s pretty close to the truth.
The Bible teaches that God has concluded EVERYONE to be under sin, in order that He might offer EVERYONE salvation. (Romans 11:32)
Everyone knows John 3:16, but John 3:18 says: “Whoever believes in Christ is not condemned, but whoever does not believe is condemned already…” In other words, we ALL stand condemned from the moment of our birth, until we choose Christ.
I hope this answered your questions.
Hi Michael,Are you a Calvinist Baptist or an “Arminian” Baptist?
God Bless,
Michael