Why is showing portrayals of prophets prohibited in Islam?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jas84173
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jas84173

Guest
I just was curious, seeing as Judaism and Christianity share all of the same prophets revered in Islam (besides Muhammad and Jesus in Judaism), why is showing the faces of say Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad prohibited in Islam? I’ve heard when biblical based films come out many Islamic majority countries ban them from being screened. I just didn’t understand why?
 
I just was curious, seeing as Judaism and Christianity share all of the same prophets revered in Islam (besides Muhammad and Jesus in Judaism), why is showing the faces of say Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad prohibited in Islam? I’ve heard when biblical based films come out many Islamic majority countries ban them from being screened. I just didn’t understand why?
First, we must see the scope of the issue:
The contemporary scholars are unanimously agreed that it is haraam to depict the Prophets (peace be upon them) in general and our Prophet Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) in particular…
There is no doubt that depicting the Prophets is a kind of disrespect towards them, because people have a great deal of respect towards them and hold them in high esteem, but depicting them detracts from that respect, especially if they are depicted in cartoons…
Undoubtedly portraying them will detract from the high esteem in which they are held by people, and viewers may begin to think of them in the image of the actors who play their roles. [Source]
There have been both stories and real instances in which Muhammad has been depicted, though usually with respect (we also can see in Islamic artwork, especially Persian artwork, that prophets often have veiled faces).
 
I just was curious, seeing as Judaism and Christianity share all of the same prophets revered in Islam (besides Muhammad and Jesus in Judaism), why is showing the faces of say Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad prohibited in Islam? I’ve heard when biblical based films come out many Islamic majority countries ban them from being screened. I just didn’t understand why?
This is another teaching that I find hard to believe. After all these people (the prophets) are actual human beings. They had lived and existed. If they were living today, there would be tons and tons of their photographs in archives and files.
 
Sunnis tend to be against it. The shi’a are very much in favour of using images of their Twelve Imams. They often have images in their homes of Ali ibn Abu Talib who was Muhammad’s cousin, and Hussain ibn Ali, who was Muhammad’s grandson. Shi’a images tend to look weird because they make their imams look effeminate. The imams are pictured with perfectly shaped eyebrows, fair skin and rosy cheeks. I doubt the real Ali was an effiminate, borderline androgynous looking man with perfect skin and silky hair.

Sunnis tend to be against images of prophets because they believe that it will lead people to excessively praising the prophets and/or idolatry. We don’t devote ourselves to anything except Allah; He’s the only one who is worth serving, glorifying and worshiping. The reason so many people get upset when someone draws Muhammad [peace be upon him] is because they think you’re trying to lead them into idolatry.
 
Sunnis tend to be against it. The shi’a are very much in favour of using images of their Twelve Imams. They often have images in their homes of Ali ibn Abu Talib who was Muhammad’s cousin, and Hussain ibn Ali, who was Muhammad’s grandson. Shi’a images tend to look weird because they make their imams look effeminate. The imams are pictured with perfectly shaped eyebrows, fair skin and rosy cheeks. I doubt the real Ali was an effiminate, borderline androgynous looking man with perfect skin and silky hair.

Sunnis tend to be against images of prophets because they believe that it will lead people to excessively praising the prophets and/or idolatry. **We don’t devote ourselves to anything except Allah; He’s the only one who is worth serving, glorifying and worshiping. **The reason so many people get upset when someone draws Muhammad [peace be upon him] is because they think you’re trying to lead them into idolatry.
There are many types of idolatry. Even money can be idolized. Do Sunni’s teach how not to idolize money?

MJ
 
There are many types of idolatry. Even money can be idolized. Do Sunni’s teach how not to idolize money?

MJ
Indeed, money can be an idol in some circumstances. Unfortunately, I don’t know much about finances from an Islamic perspective. My imam was talking about it in a sermon one time, but most of it I didn’t understand. There’s all kinds of stuff in the Qur’an about inheritance rights and there are hadiths prohibiting interest.

Sorry, but finances are not my strong point (along with marriage). I wish I was knowledgeable, but I am not.
 
Here’s what Wikipedia says:
Aniconism in Islam is a proscription in Islam against the creation of images of sentient beings. The most absolute proscription is of images of God in Islam, followed by depictions of Muhammad, and then Islamic prophets and the relatives of Muhammad, but the depiction of all humans and non-human animals is discouraged in the hadith and by the long tradition of Islamic authorities, especially Sunni ones. This has led to Islamic art being dominated by Islamic geometric patterns, calligraphy and the barely representational foliage patterns of the arabesque; but figurative art still has a strong tradition, especially on a small scale in private works for the home or palace.
The avoidance of idolatry is the main concern of the restrictions on images, and the traditional form for religious cult image, the free-standing sculpture, is extremely rare, and there are no large examples of humans.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aniconism_in_Islam
 
First, we must see the scope of the issue:

There have been both stories and real instances in which Muhammad has been depicted, though usually with respect (we also can see in Islamic artwork, especially Persian artwork, that prophets often have veiled faces).
Yep, a lot more common to show in Shia Muslim countries, which Iran happens to be mainly Shia
 
Indeed, money can be an idol in some circumstances. Unfortunately, I don’t know much about finances from an Islamic perspective. My imam was talking about it in a sermon one time, but most of it I didn’t understand. There’s all kinds of stuff in the Qur’an about inheritance rights and there are hadiths prohibiting interest.

Sorry, but finances are not my strong point (along with marriage). I wish I was knowledgeable, but I am not.
Ok thanks. Is there an equivalent “love of money is the root of all evil” in Sunni Hadith’s ?

MJ
 
why is showing the faces of say Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad prohibited in Islam?
As others have already pointed out, it isn’t, at least not universally. In Sunni Islam, it is prohibited to show the face of, at least, Muhammed, but that’s not the case in Shia Islam. You could, perhaps, say that Sunni Islam can be likened to (certain strands of) Calvinism.

For many depictions, primarily Persian or Iranian, see Wikipedia. This one is my favourite. You can see the similarities to many icons.
 
Shi’a images tend to look weird because they make their imams look effeminate. The imams are pictured with perfectly shaped eyebrows, fair skin and rosy cheeks. I doubt the real Ali was an effiminate, borderline androgynous looking man with perfect skin and silky hair.
Maybe this is an attempt to make them look youthful?
 
I always thought the official religion of Persia was Zoroastrianism? I believe Islam did regard Zoroastrians as people of the book as well and aloud them to remain in their faith. I am not sure but I believe the Ahmidiyyah Muslim community actually believes Zoroaster to have been a predecessor prophet as well. Although most Orthodox Muslims view Ahmidiyyah as heretical and “not Muslim”. I always kind of viewed them as the Mormons of Islam where they identify as being Muslim but others in the faith say they aren’t. I actually always saw a lot of similarities of the lives of Muhammad and Zoroaster.
 
Ok thanks. Is there an equivalent “love of money is the root of all evil” in Sunni Hadith’s ?

MJ
None that I’m aware of. There is a relevant verse of the Qur’an, though. It’s not specifically about money, but it can easily be applied to it: “Have you seen he who has taken as his god his [own] desire, and Allah has sent him astray due to knowledge and has set a seal upon his hearing and his heart and put over his vision a veil?” (surah 45:23)

In other words, those who take money as their god are astray. How can money be someone’s god/idol? many persons make money their god because they love it more than they love the One True God.
 
This makes it look like idolatry in Islam deals with statues and pictures alone and not about all worldly vs spiritual realms. I look forward to hearing from Drac any Sunni teachings that may possibly deal with the latter.

MJ
Well, an idol doesn’t have to be a statue. It can be, but not in every case. For example, from the Islamic perspecive, worshiping Krishna is a form of idolatry, just as taking money as your god is a form of idolatry (we muslims call this “shirk”). As I just posted earlier, an idol can be anything you love more than God.

Idolatry is a complex issue because it can take many forms. If I pray to a statue, that is idolatry. If I love money more than I love God, that is also idolatry (though of a lesser kind). There is major shirk, which is the worship of a false god and lesser shirk, which is when you take money as your god (or anything else that you place in God’s place).
 
Didn’t Christianity go through a phase like this around the time Islam sprung up?

I vaguely remember some sort of theological controversy regarding Icons and Statues in Eastern Roman/Byzantine Empire - although I haven’t the foggiest notion as to why it occurred.
 
Well, an idol doesn’t have to be a statue. It can be, but not in every case. For example, from the Islamic perspecive, worshiping Krishna is a form of idolatry, just as taking money as your god is a form of idolatry (we muslims call this “shirk”). As I just posted earlier, an idol can be anything you love more than God.

Idolatry is a complex issue because it can take many forms. If I pray to a statue, that is idolatry. If I love money more than I love God, that is also idolatry (though of a lesser kind). There is major shirk, which is the worship of a false god and lesser shirk, which is when you take money as your god (or anything else that you place in God’s place).
Drac what I asked for is the Sunni teaching from a reliable and official source that explains idolatry its forms in particular worldly vs Spiritual. Because there is always this battle between the latter which the Church taught and is very well aware of. And everyday this is happening.

That’s why we have to work on being Holy everyday.

MJ
 
Forgot to add: If worshipping Krishna is idolatry then pls provide the Sunni teaching that calls out on Krishna. Tks.

MJ
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top