why is the Catholic Church the only one that has a "service" every day?

  • Thread starter Thread starter distracted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You are certainly welcomed to go up to Father to get a blessing, however, you must make it CLEAR that you are NOT trying to receive Holy Communion. The universal sign that you are not receiving, but wish to get a blessing is for you to cross your arms across your chest and bow your head.
When Catholics receive Communion they are assenting to belief in EVERY teaching of the Catholic church. They are also assenting that the Pope is the head of the Church. Anglicans, while they are christian, do not assent to ALL the teachings of the Church nor do they submit to the Authority of the Pope and the Magisterium. Becoming a Catholic is not like becoming a member of the Methodist church or any protestant denomination. It is a PROCESS.

As for why we have a “service” everyday…we don’t have a SERVICE everyday. We celebrate the Eucharist everyday. Just as the Early Christians did. They did it as often as they could. If you could meet Christ, (body, blood, soul and divinity)everyday or just once a month, which would you choose? Catholics believe that we are meeting Christ everytime we have communion. Christ said that he was the true manna from heaven. “…the wilderness manna was not false bread; it was merely a sign of the imperishable eucharistic bread that the Father sends down from heaven in Jesus.”(Ignatius Catholic Study bible). The manna from heaven nourishes and sustains us in the Christian life(Catholic Bible Dictionary, Hahn, Scott,ed.; Doubleday Religion). We need to say, as the disciples did, “Lord, give us this bread always!” We do that everyday that we celebrate the Mass. We celebrate it because it is the source and summit of our faith(CCC).

CC
Give me a break, I’m not going to stop going up at communion, so just leave it out!
 
The blessing is given at the end of mass by the priest to everyone. This is the appropriate time to receive a blessing
Communion time is the appropriate time to receive the eucharist only, you get your blessing later. Some priest do invite those not receiving eucharist to receive a blessing…it is not correct to do so, but some do. And as another poster said, only a priest can confer a blessing not a EMHC.
What is a EMCH?
 
As the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is the “Source and Summit” of all Grace, it is really not optional whether it is celebrated every day or not. It is absolutely essential that it is celebrated daily, the exception being Good Friday. Thank God for His goodness and His blessings!
God Bless!
To Jesus, through Mary
What does Paul have to say about Church "Paul did say; “We are to worship God every day, not just on Saturday or Sunday”
Do you think this is why we have Mass all the days on the week
 
Hi NLM!
Twopekingguys wrote to you regarding the canon. And I thank them for that! I answer you that in every parish I have belonged to, Mass is offered daily, with the exception of Saturday. Some parishes have a daily mass on Saturday, and some do not. Here in Virginia, at the parish I attend they have daily mass at least 3 times a day with mass in the morning on Saturday, and anticipated mass for Sunday. There is quite a large group of people who attend.
I would say to you that when you really begin to realize that the mass is celebrating the unbloody, re-presentation of Christ’s once and for all sacrifice on Calvary; when you realize that Jesus is inviting you to offer yourself with Him to the Father for the remission of your sins and for the whole world; When you realize that He offers Himself, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity, as your real and substanital food, every day…
Well, how can anyone stay away?
I notice that you say that you were Catholic for many years, and now are protestant. Do you miss the mass? I ask this, because for me, I could never, ever leave the Catholic Church because of the Eucharist…
God Bless!
Your Sister in Christ,
To Jesus, through Mary
Thank you for your response. I was a bit surprised at the information provided by twopekingguys gave.This must be a new directive in the canon. I know priests in the past were obligated to say mass or concelebrate with others daily. When did that change?
No I do not miss mass at all. However having said this what I do miss at times is the pomp and ceremony associated with special feast days or special celebrations in the RCC.Yes, I can see you have a deep faith in the Eucharist. That is very good. It will indeed keep you going. Thank you for asking about my experience. We are indeed Brothers and Sisters in the same Christ. God Bless. NLM
 
“If they read the Bible”…are you kidding me? What you find at Baptist Churches is many coming together to share the Word of God and encourage each other in their daily lives with a lot of prayer!

My brother-in-law’s Baptist Church welcomes visitors…🙂
Here is a little bit of there schedule…

Sunday…

9:00 AM Contemporary Worship

9:00 AM VKC Grades 1-4 Special Music

Vine Kids Choir Performance

10:30 AM Classic Worship

12:00 PM Open Mike

4:00 PM God’s GRACE Abound Mtg

4:30 PM Financial Peace University

5:00 PM American Sign Language - ASL

5:00 PM Connecting with Your Child

5:00 PM Discipleship 101

5:00 PM Sharing Your Faith with Others

5:00 PM Sunday School @ Night

5:00 PM AWANA Fall Schedule

5:00 PM Collegiate Biblical Financial Study

5:00 PM Crown Financial Biblical Study

5:00 PM Crown Financial Class - Led by John Rollins

5:00 PM Grief Share

5:00 PM Setting Boundaries with Adult Children

5:00 PM The Truth Project

6:00 PM Sunday School Leadership Mtg.

6:30 PM Fall Volleyball

Monday…
6:30 AM Men’s Prayer Time

7:00 AM Senior Adult Fall Celebration

9:00 AM Agape Aerobics

9:00 AM MOPS

9:00 AM MOPS Child Care

12:00 PM Men’s Noon Basketball

6:30 PM Fall Volleyball

Tuesday…
6:30 AM Ladies Prayer Time

9:00 AM International Friends

9:30 AM Food Forethought: Proof of What Is To Come

4:00 PM Men’s Ministry Fishfry

6:30 PM Fall Volleyball

7:00 PM For Ladies: Me, Myself and Lies

Mens Softball

Wednesday…
6:30 PM Prayer Service

6:30 PM Rock56 Choir & Discipleship

7:30 PM Heaven, Hell and The Afterlife

7:30 PM Singles Bible Study: The Miracles of Jesus
Thursday…
6:30 AM Men’s Prayer Time

9:00 AM Women’s Ministry Bible Study: From Simon to Peter

Friday… I think that you get the picture…🙂

God Bless!
What does it coast to go to each thing,are just a few of them lets say 30 PM Financial Peace University

5:00 PM American Sign Language
 
What does it coast to go to each thing,are just a few of them lets say 30 PM Financial Peace University

5:00 PM American Sign Language
Bill,
I am not sure what the cost is but I will try and find out for you. Speaking of daily Mass and since you have brought up money I have a question for you. What kind of stipend are you expected to give your priest if you ask him to say a Mass for you or a loved one?

God Bless!
 
Bill,
I am not sure what the cost is but I will try and find out for you. Speaking of daily Mass and since you have brought up money I have a question for you. What kind of stipend are you expected to give your priest if you ask him to say a Mass for you or a loved one?

God Bless!
I think here it is about £5, around $7.50 I guess. However the stipend, to the best of my knowledge, is not obligatory.
 
It is unbelievable how these threads can move away from the original question in such a dramatic way. It would be nice if everyone focused more on the initial question. As for the original question here is what I know. Once ordained, Priests must say mass everyday. That was the way it was anyway ( please correct me if I am wrong). Because of this rather than say mass alone, in some parishes mass is open to the people.However because of the shortage of Priests MANY parishes no longer have weekday masses. Who cares what time this occurs? I have seen weekday masses at 7 am, 8 am, 12 noon ,5 pm and 7 pm and everything in between. The time has no baring on anything except attendance. As for the $$$$ issue which was laughed at, don’t be so quick to laugh. EVERY mass the priest says is said in memory of someone. In some cases the mass is in memory of 3 or 4 individuals. A mass where I live costs $10.00 x 3= $30.00 or more.
This is absolutely false - first, the priest still has to say Mass every day even if no one has bought a Mass card, and second, one Mass card gets you one Mass. You cannot have more than one Mass card per Mass, so the maximum the priest can get (if he gets his Mass cards for free; my understanding is that the cost of the card itself is usually the same as any typical greeting card, and I recently paid $15.00 for a birthday card) is $10.00. (His secretary makes more per hour than that, I guarantee you.)
Mass is a revenue generating activity within the church. I have attended weekday masses which have lasted barely 15 or 16 minutes.
A lot depends on the priest, and the temperment of the parish itself. For myself, I tend to be drawn to longer Masses, both on the weekdays and on Sundays - the ones I go to on weekdays are typically 35-40 minutes, and the Sunday Masses I go to usually last a little over an hour.
Well, our sermons last about 35 to 45 minutes and at times longer.
I’ve seen Catholic priests give retreats where they preached for 90 minutes at a time, and longer.
We are expected to have a time of private devotion daily.
So are we. Morning Prayer and Evening Prayer (readings from the Psalms, and a few short prayers) is the minimum expectation, and most people add a Rosary to that, as well.
 
This is absolutely false - first, the priest still has to say Mass every day even if no one has bought a Mass card, and second, one Mass card gets you one Mass. You cannot have more than one Mass card per Mass, so the maximum the priest can get (if he gets his Mass cards for free; my understanding is that the cost of the card itself is usually the same as any typical greeting card, and I recently paid $15.00 for a birthday card) is $10.00. (His secretary makes more per hour than that, I guarantee you.)

A lot depends on the priest, and the temperment of the parish itself. For myself, I tend to be drawn to longer Masses, both on the weekdays and on Sundays - the ones I go to on weekdays are typically 35-40 minutes, and the Sunday Masses I go to usually last a little over an hour.

I’ve seen Catholic priests give retreats where they preached for 90 minutes at a time, and longer.

So are we. Morning Prayer and Evening Prayer (readings from the Psalms, and a few short prayers) is the minimum expectation, and most people add a Rosary to that, as well.
Not so fast. I am speaking about Canada. Perhaps things are different in RCC’s in other countries Let me say that when I speak of a mass card I am not referring to the actual paper card which usually goes to the family of the deceased to tell them you had a mass said.Those are usually free.What I am saying is when you ask to have a mass said in memory of someone, the cost is $ 10.00. That is a fact.Unless a priest lived in a very small and poor parish, he receives more mass requests than he can actually say. Most times when that happens, dozens and sometimes hundreds are sent to religious orders where mass requests may not be as frequently received. This generates funds for the monastery.Hundreds of mass requests come from the funeral homes when people die. Usually a friend of the family will sit at the funeral home and visitors give the $10.00, receive a receipt and a card is given to the family . YES, a priest can and does say mass for more than one dearly departed at one time. I one parish I attended, he would actually read the names out loud during the mass itself.I questionned this practice once and was told that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is so great that it can indeed be offered for more than one person at one time.
As for the lenght of the mass,I was giving an example of some of our local churches. They would indeed vary.Yes, I have also attended retreats where sermons lasted quite a long time as they should during retreats.God Bless. NLM
 
Not so fast. I am speaking about Canada. Perhaps things are different in RCC’s in other countries.
I am also in Canada, and yet my experiences are quite different. It probably has to do with the sorts of parishes that we are naturally drawn to, since although I have heard of parishes like the ones you’re describing, they’re not in neighborhoods where I would think of going - I tend to stick to working-class areas of the city.
YES, a priest can and does say mass for more than one dearly departed at one time.
IF he is doing this, he is doing so absolutely against Church law.
I one parish I attended, he would actually read the names out loud during the mass itself.I questionned this practice once and was told that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is so great that it can indeed be offered for more than one person at one time.
:rolleyes: He is still breaking Church law.
 
In Canada the amount is $10.00 and it is obligatory.God Bless. NLM
Actually, it isn’t. I’ve had Masses said that I didn’t pay anything for. The trick is to ask the priest directly, rather than going through the office.
 
What is a EMCH?
It’s EMHC= Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion…not a priest, but a lay person. The priest is the Ordinary Minister of Holy Communion. A lay person is the extra ordinary minister because they are only suppose to be used in extraordinary…i.e. emergency circumstances…however, it has become a normal practice at every mass in many parishes.
 
I am also in Canada, and yet my experiences are quite different. It probably has to do with the sorts of parishes that we are naturally drawn to, since although I have heard of parishes like the ones you’re describing, they’re not in neighborhoods where I would think of going - I tend to stick to working-class areas of the city.

IF he is doing this, he is doing so absolutely against Church law.

:rolleyes: He is still breaking Church law.
What do you mean parishes we are naturally drawn to ? I live in a middle to upper class neighborhood.Are you not expected to attend the church in your neighborhood? Why would the rules of the church change from church to church? I don’t understand. He may be breaking laws but it is THE truth. God Bless. NLM
 
Actually, it isn’t. I’ve had Masses said that I didn’t pay anything for. The trick is to ask the priest directly, rather than going through the office.
So if you know the “trick” you can get out of paying to have a mass said? Where is the sacrifice element on your part ? What do you give up in this transaction? It would be exactly the same as lighting a votive candle and putting no money in the box to pay for it. Again the sacrifice element. NLM
 
Here is a link on this topic that may be helpful.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=292341

I totally agree with you on receiving a blessing, but I don’t believe that it is actually what the Roman Catholic Church says is correct at Communion.

God Bless!
Point well taken,
I submit to the Teaching authority of the Church and await further clarification from the Congregation on this.

This is why I am NOT the Pope. :o
CC
 
YES, a priest can and does say mass for more than one dearly departed at one time. I one parish I attended, he would actually read the names out loud during the mass itself.I questionned this practice once and was told that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is so great that it can indeed be offered for more than one person at one time.
This concept contributed to the “Chantry Priests” problem of days gone by.

There were (generally before the Protestant Reformation) many chapels set up without congregations, staffed by priests who said private Masses. Unfortunately, many of these men were not really good priests, could not have preached a sermon if they had to, and often used Latin so bad it was unintelligible. In fact they were often illiterate, or nearly so. They were not ‘pastors’ in any sense, but they were ordained priests, and something of a scandal.

This practice gave the rich an unfair advantage in that they could sponsor a place like that and have Masses said for themselves “in perpetuity”, or until the money ran out. They were sacramental vending machines, but since there were ordinarily no living congregations to receive the Holy Eucharist the concept was something of a magic act. Expecting, or even hoping such a scheme would influence the Divine is similar to conjuring. The Mass is foremost a community of believers communing with the Divine.

BTW, there is really only one Mass (or Qurbono/Divine Liturgy/Soorp Badarak), it is universal… a cosmic reality outside of time, which we participate in our own way as creatures in time. So I would say the priest was right, the Mass is always said for many around the world and around the clock. It cannot be limited in scope, so it hardly matters whether he accepts one intention per Mass or many.

I object to the setting of a “price”. The argument that there should be some sacrifice on the part of the petitioner is compelling enough that I will not go to the mat over it, but no sacrament can be sold. A free will donation of any amount should be sufficient (even a penny, or even a “widow’s mite”), and an affordable amount may be suggested (although no freely offered amount is too much, the sacrament is priceless), but the sacrament should never be refused to a person over money. I think Trent may have addressed this, but I just don’t remember. 🤷
 
So if you know the “trick” you can get out of paying to have a mass said? Where is the sacrifice element on your part ? What do you give up in this transaction? It would be exactly the same as lighting a votive candle and putting no money in the box to pay for it. Again the sacrifice element. NLM
I should think that the amount of volunteer work I do around the church is sufficient to supply any “pay back” element that may be considered necessary; however, my offering consists of a broken heart, and a contrite spirit, cf. Isaiah.

As far as I know, the donations for the votive candles are also voluntary.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top