S
sw85
Guest
Well, so what? Does Catholicism represent the one true faith or not? If it does than everyone who disagrees is wrong, so who cares what they think?Forgive me if this sounds like a dumb question.
I understand why the Church thinks same-sex marriage or relations are wrong and I can agree with the Church on this teaching. If everyone in the entire world felt this way about same-sex marriage, that would be great and there would be no debate over this.
However, people think differently are were raised differently with a diverse pool of ideas and beliefs. Not everyone is a devout Catholic–
Well, yes, you feel like the bad guy because our enemies have control of the culture and have worked tirelessly to make everyone who opposes them feel like the bad guy. Our enemies also murder babies and make us feel bad about “judging” the murderers. We’re not bad guys. They’re bad guys. Forget 'em.that’s why we have this separation of Church and State. I honestly feel like “the bad guy” for fighting against gay marriage.
As for separation of church and state, well, that hardly applies here. We’re not talking about religious establishment. You’re allowed to vote according to your faith.
You do have the right, because you have the duty to do it. Chastising sinners is a spiritual work of mercy, and God desires mercy.I don’t feel like I have any right to tell other non-beleivers how to live their lives.
OK, but we’re not doing that. The Westboro nuts are doing that.The LGBT community have gone through enough **** already and I feel bad trying to oppose their desires to get married (no matter how wrong it would be) by telling them that I’m against it because of my personal and faith beliefs.
Maybe the question isn’t “WHY must we fight?”, but more “HOW must we fight?” because I don’t think holding protests or telling people they are “going to hell” is the right way to do things…
What we can do is simply what we’ve always done: speak the truth. The truth is that homosexuality is a grave moral evil and the state subsidization of homosexuality through gay “marriage,” which is a vacuous ontological error, compels you to participate to some extent in that evil. God Himself makes this clear to us, and reason reveals it by its study of natural law. We can also point to the fact that there is not a “right” to gay “marriage,” has never been, that no one has ever anywhere said such a “right” existed until about five minutes ago and all the people who insist such a “right” obviously exists are the same people who deny every metaphysical basis from which “rights” could be said to arise.
Well, no, it isn’t. That’s a liberal conceit, not a Catholic one. As witnessed by the fact that every Catholic society in history until about five minutes ago was firmly reactionary and had no problem firmly stating that X was truth and that anyone who denied X was a menace to the public order.you are right. i agree with you completely. marriage is a civil matter. for us, its spiritual as well, but not everyone follows our ways. its wrong to try to force our ways unto others.
My legs are not necessary for me to be a man. It doesn’t follow that my legs are irrelevant to my being a man. It certainly doesn’t follow I should cut my legs off and drag myself around on stumps. Get it?Children are not a necessary component of marriage. They may be a necessary component for most Catholic marriages, but in most countries, a civil marriage does not include any obligation to have children.
When other people’s choices are evil, stupid, and insane, no, I don’t respect them and I’m not obligated to. I’m obligated to call those choices evil, stupid, and insane and to warn people off of them. Do you let folks drink arsenic because, hey, it’s their body and their choice and it’s just as valid as any other choice of drink?You are not a bigot for supporting marriage in its “natural” from. I respect your choice for a natural marriage. I am also “naturally” married. If someone calls you a bigot, it’s probably because you do not respect other people’s choices.
Maybe this would be relevant if you could point to anyone, anywhere, who has ever said that legislating gay “marriage” into existence would result in the sky literally immediately falling.Same-sex marriage became legal in 2003 in my country, and I can asure you, the sky hasn’t fallen here either. Nor has it in any way affected me or anyone else I know.