Why pray for those in purgatory?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dje101
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dje101

Guest
Hello,

I was wondering, why does the church pray for those going through purgatory?
 
Hello,

I was wondering, why does the church pray for those going through purgatory?
Purgatory is also suffering. It is the temporary absence from God to remove all the temporal effects of sin. What do I mean by “temporal effects”? Well, when we sin, we affect ourselves and in sometimes seen, sometimes unseen ways, those around us. This would explain why in early Church history, confession was sometimes public. To remove the temporal stain, we have to do penance/receive indulgences. Those temporal effects that are not removed in this world are removed in Purgatory before the given person can be in the presence of God, who is defined as complete goodness.

The Church prays for those going through Purgatory, first and foremost, because we are instructed to pray for each other - those on Earth and in Purgatory. We are all one big family. Secondly, by praying for those in Purgatory, we reduce the debt of those in Purgatory that they owe to God and shorten their stay there. Lastly, many saints have written that when we pray for the souls in Purgatory, they pray for those who helped them enter Heaven unceasingly. Indeed, if people knew of the favours granted by the intercession of the Holy Souls in Purgatory, they would not be so easily forgotten.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
It helps it go faster. The lowest levels of purgatory are not allowed to receive prayer; I believe they’re on a timer of some sort, they have to serve a certain amount of time before they can move up to the next level. But once they’re past that, all the prayers for that soul, past and present, can help the soul move out of purgatory faster. Meaning even if the soul isn’t allowed to be helped by prayer yet, you can still pray for that soul and then when it gets to the right level it can receive those prayers.
 
Purgatory is also suffering. It is the temporary absence from God to remove all the temporal effects of sin. What do I mean by “temporal effects”? Well, when we sin, we affect ourselves and in sometimes seen, sometimes unseen ways, those around us. This would explain why in early Church history, confession was sometimes public. To remove the temporal stain, we have to do penance/receive indulgences. Those temporal effects that are not removed in this world are removed in Purgatory before the given person can be in the presence of God, who is defined as complete goodness.

The Church prays for those going through Purgatory, first and foremost, because we are instructed to pray for each other - those on Earth and in Purgatory. We are all one big family. Secondly, by praying for those in Purgatory, we reduce the debt of those in Purgatory that they owe to God and shorten their stay there. Lastly, many saints have written that when we pray for the souls in Purgatory, they pray for those who helped them enter Heaven unceasingly. Indeed, if people knew of the favours granted by the intercession of the Holy Souls in Purgatory, they would not be so easily forgotten.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
so, if you could please answer the following, i’d much appreciate it:
  1. purgatory is punishment for the temporal sins and not eternal sins?
  2. how long does purgatory last?
  3. i’ve heard that souls in purgatory are able to intercede for those on earth, is this true?
  4. what are indulgences?
 
It helps it go faster. The lowest levels of purgatory are not allowed to receive prayer; I believe they’re on a timer of some sort, they have to serve a certain amount of time before they can move up to the next level. But once they’re past that, all the prayers for that soul, past and present, can help the soul move out of purgatory faster. Meaning even if the soul isn’t allowed to be helped by prayer yet, you can still pray for that soul and then when it gets to the right level it can receive those prayers.
but doesn’t scripture say that we are cleansed by the blood of Christ? why then must we endure punishment if our sins are forgiven and Christ has taken our punishment?
 
so, if you could please answer the following, i’d much appreciate it:
  1. purgatory is punishment for the temporal sins and not eternal sins?
  2. how long does purgatory last?
  3. i’ve heard that souls in purgatory are able to intercede for those on earth, is this true?
  4. what are indulgences?
Question 1: Purgatory is punishment for the temporal sideffect(s) of sin. Whenever people sin, there is sideeffect to that sin that must be paid off, even if the sin itself was forgiven.

Question 2: No one knows for sure. No one even knows if Purgatory is within or beyond time.

Question 3: Yes, the Holy Souls intercede for us when we pray for them. Their intercession is quite powerful because they are eternally happy beyond imagination when they leave Purgatory.

Question 4: I’ll leave this for someone else to answer. It’s quite complicated, but what indulges essentially are is that they shorten the time you spend in Purgatory. Certain prayers have been granted indulgences.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
It helps it go faster. The lowest levels of purgatory are not allowed to receive prayer; I believe they’re on a timer of some sort, they have to serve a certain amount of time before they can move up to the next level. But once they’re past that, all the prayers for that soul, past and present, can help the soul move out of purgatory faster. Meaning even if the soul isn’t allowed to be helped by prayer yet, you can still pray for that soul and then when it gets to the right level it can receive those prayers.
This is not in Church teaching. You might have read it from a saint, in which case it is “private revelation” and does not have to be believed.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
Question 3: Yes, the Holy Souls intercede for us when we pray for them. Their intercession is quite powerful because they are eternally happy beyond imagination when they leave Purgatory.]
so are the souls in purgatory able to pray for us while they are IN purgatory or only after they have left purgatory?
 
but doesn’t scripture say that we are cleansed by the blood of Christ? why then must we endure punishment if our sins are forgiven and Christ has taken our punishment?
Scripture says that we are cleansed by the Precious Blood Jesus spilled for us. It doesn’t say there will be no consequence to our sin. On Earth for example, someone may steal from a shop, and then go to confession to confess their sins. But that confession, which only came about because of Jesus’ sacrifice, does not stop the person from being arrested and interrogated by the authorities. Yes, they have been forgiven, but the sideeffect of their behaviour still remains, and has to be paid for (either through community service, jail or some other form of punishment).

In the Old Testament, God forgave King David. However, as punishment, his child had to die…

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
Because while they can pray for others, they cannot pray for themselves.

Unlike those of us on earth, who can pray for ourselves and others, and unlike those in heaven, who pray for others and have no need to pray for themselves, having ‘fought the good fight’, those in purgatory have need of prayer (since they are not yet in heaven and are purifying themselves ’ as through fire’ as Scripture tells us) and cannot pray for themselves.

Do you pray for other people? If so, why not pray for the souls in purgatory? Aren’t they people? Aren’t we supposed to pray for our neighbor?
 
so are the souls in purgatory able to pray for us while they are IN purgatory or only after they have left purgatory?
Both in and out of Purgatory. When they leave Purgatory, they become saints because they have entered Heaven.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
Both in and out of Purgatory. When they leave Purgatory, they become saints because they have entered Heaven.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
so then how bad could purgatory really be if they have time to pray DURING their punishment
 
so then how bad could purgatory really be if they have time to pray DURING their punishment
They can pray for others, but they can’t pray for themselves. Purgatory is bad because imagine seeing just a small glimmer of God’s glory, only for God to then immediately disappear and to be told that you will only meet God in the next 100 years because you are not good enough.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
They can pray for others, but they can’t pray for themselves. Purgatory is bad because imagine seeing just a small glimmer of God’s glory, only for God to then immediately disappear and to be told that you will only meet God in the next 100 years because you are not good enough.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
so for people, like Jeffrey Dahmer, who supposedly accepted Christ, if he really did, then his purgatory will be a LOT longer than yours or mine?
 
so for people, like Jeffrey Dahmer, who supposedly accepted Christ, if he really did, then his purgatory will be a LOT longer than yours or mine?
I don’t know who that is (I’m not American…) 😊. No one can say for sure what one’s eternal fate is. That is between the person and God. We can only speculate, but I wouldn’t be surprised if our speculations were by and large wrong.

We only know a small number of people in Heaven, that is, the saints who have been canonized by the Church. Apart from that, the fate of those in the afterlife is a mystery.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
I don’t know who that is (I’m not American…) 😊. No one can say for sure what one’s eternal fate is. That is between the person and God. We can only speculate, but I wouldn’t be surprised if our speculations were by and large wrong.

We only know a small number of people in Heaven, that is, the saints who have been canonized by the Church. Apart from that, the fate of those in the afterlife is a mystery.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
so then is the idea of purgatory mandatory for all catholics to accept or, since one can only speculate, is it up to the believer?

PS Jeffrey Dahmer was a really, really, really, really, REALLY, really bad guy who killed about a dozen people, then when in prison, said he accepted Christ and was baptized by a minister.
 
so then is the idea of purgatory mandatory for all catholics to accept or, since one can only speculate, is it up to the believer?

PS Jeffrey Dahmer was a really, really, really, really, REALLY, really bad guy who killed about a dozen people, then when in prison, said he accepted Christ and was baptized by a minister.
No, Purgatory is **required *to be believed in by Catholics. It is a teaching of the Church since the early days, and is found in the Bible itself (the example I gave of King David; the Book of Maccabees talking about how we should pray so that people may be “loosed from their sins” and many other places). What I mean is that no one knows where a person is - whether they are in Heaven, Purgatory or Hell. We can only speculate. What we know is that Heaven, Purgatory and Hell exist, and that is that.

*Disregarding canonized saints

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
The question arises, if you can pray for a person’s salvation in purgatory, then why did Jesus have to die on a cross? That makes it sound like that Jesus maybe died for some sins but not all sins. On the contrary, “For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.” (Romans 6:23) “Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name (Jesus) under heaven given to men by which we must be saved.” (Acts 4:12) “That if you confess with your mouth, “Jesus is Lord,” and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you confess and are saved.” (Romans 10: 9,10) And probably the most important scripture in the Bible, “For God so loved the world that He gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.” All of these scriptures mention salvation, but no mention of a time of purification or holding period.
 
The question arises, if you can pray for a person’s salvation in purgatory, then why did Jesus have to die on a cross?
Actually, Purgatory is salvation. It is not Hell, which is when someone is eternally damned. Purgatory is basically a period of purification so that they can withstand God’s goodness; after all, God is described as a “consuming fire”, and Jesus instructs us to be perfect like our Father in Heaven is perfect. What better way for perfection than for a short time out being purified like gold?

Look at what happened in the Book of Exodus. Moses wanted to see God, but God didn’t show Himself, because anyone who sees God in His infinite glory will die. Heck, anyone that saw an angel would faint or go insane, as seen in the Book of Daniel when King Nebuchadnezzar goes berserk for seven years.

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top