Why should Mary only appear to the good?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Crown_of_Stars
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Crown_of_Stars

Guest
I just thought of this tonight, actually. All of the visions we’ve known about Mary (Children of Fatima, Bernadette at Lourdes, etc.)…it was important that She appeared to holy or very good people…But why hasn’t She appeared in warning apparitions to the wicked? Unless She has, but I just don’t know of it?
 
Alphonse Ratisbonne
Though nominally a Jew, he was a radical infidel, a scoffer at religion, and, after the conversion of his brother Theodor, a rabid enemy of everything Catholic. On his intended tour to the Orient, he came to Rome, where on 20 January, 1842, he was miraculously converted to Catholicism in the Church of S. Andrea delle Fratte by an apparition of the Blessed Virgin.
 
Would think it’s because most “bad” people are either going to use it to their own advantage, for their own purposes, to serve their own will, or are just not going to care. Same reason God won’t always reveal Himself to people. St. Louis de Montfort said this; “God the Father has not told Mary to dwell in them because they are, alas, other Esaus”.
 
not true my mothers mom was a secular jew and she swore mary appeared to her in dreams my mothers fathers mother claimed to have seen her as well after falling from a tree as a child and she was a fortune teller someone not spiritual at all i think mary can appear to all of us when god decides we need her i know my jewish grandma had devotion to mary after that ive heard of mary appearing to people from all faiths and backgorunds from saintly to wicked our lady is truly a mother to all in that sense
 
can i add that some of my grandpas sisters who converted to protestantiam and mormonism also believe mary can appear to people but not that shes special in anyway
 
not true my mothers mom was a secular jew and she swore mary appeared to her in dreams my mothers fathers mother claimed to have seen her as well after falling from a tree as a child and she was a fortune teller someone not spiritual at all i think mary can appear to all of us when god decides we need her i know my jewish grandma had devotion to mary after that ive heard of mary appearing to people from all faiths and backgorunds from saintly to wicked our lady is truly a mother to all in that sense
Thankyou for sharing that! To read of a personal account is very special. My own grandmother (who is devoted to Mary though) has said she’s seen Her, but she’s not sure if it was just a dream. Mary didn’t speak to her, my grandmother said she just saw Her. I hope she truly did. At first, she said, she was afraid and started to throw Holy Water on Her…until she realized who she was!
 
I was just at La Salette in France, where Mary appeared to 2 children, The 2 children weren’t particularly good or holy. Mary asked one of the children if she said her prayers, and she said she didn’t.
 
St John of the Cross was asked to examine a particular nun who claimed to be receiving visions of the Blessed Mother.

Upon examination, St John determine that the nun was not being truthful about the visions, which she admitted to.

The criteria St John used was that when an actual vision from heaven is true, there is a profound transformation of the person toward holiness and devotion.

Also, it doesn’t require that a person be holy or without sin for them to receive a vision from heaven.

St Paul was on his way to persecute Christians when Jesus appeared to him.

I think God knows the people who will do most good for others, when they receive the gift of seeing Jesus or the Blessed Mother.

From my experience of being a Catholic for 64 years, no apparition was done for the visionaries themselves, but for the good of the Church. The visionaries were always given a message to share, or sent on a mission in service to the Church. Also, the visionaries usually suffered throughout their life during and after the visions ceased.

Jim
 
I was just at La Salette in France, where Mary appeared to 2 children, The 2 children weren’t particularly good or holy. Mary asked one of the children if she said her prayers, and she said she didn’t.
I don’t know if it is true or not but I remember reading something about Marian apparitions one time. There are a lot more of them than I knew. And I remember that a majority of the apparitions were not to good or bad people…but to children versus adults. A majority of them are to children.
 
Would think it makes sense that Mary appears to children rather than adults a majority of the time. Most adults have lost their innocence; it’s too easy for them to twist things, even unintentionally. And to add to Jim, children have their life ahead of them, to serve the Church, to help propogate whatever mission needs to be carried out. Most adults have lost that shot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top