Why so many Protestant denominations

  • Thread starter Thread starter pete_29
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why so many different opinions of truth amongst Catholics? This seems to strike along those same lines.
Good point. There are many different truth claims in the catholic church as there are in protestant churches. There are many things in the church that you can believe or not believe. The idea that the catholic church is one unified whole in which everyone is believing the same thing is just not true. Even it has failed in itself the prayer of unity that Christ prayed.
 
Good point. There are many different truth claims in the catholic church as there are in protestant churches. There are many things in the church that you can believe or not believe. The idea that the catholic church is one unified whole in which everyone is believing the same thing is just not true. Even it has failed in itself the prayer of unity that Christ prayed.
A small point. I notice that you don’t capitalize Catholic. I detect a little hatred there maybe.:hmmm:
 
Good point. There are many different truth claims in the catholic church as there are in protestant churches. There are many things in the church that you can believe or not believe. The idea that the catholic church is one unified whole in which everyone is believing the same thing is just not true. Even it has failed in itself the prayer of unity that Christ prayed.
Show me a contradictory teaching by the magesterium of the Catholic Church in union with Rome and the earthly shpeherd of the flock, the pope.

i eagerly await your response and your sources.
 
Show me a contradictory teaching by the magesterium of the Catholic Church in union with Rome and the earthly shpeherd of the flock, the pope.

i eagerly await your response and your sources.
Isn’t it true that Trent condemned protestants and today the catholic church considers them "separated brethren?
Is it also true that at one time all those outside the catholic church were condemned but that is not true today?
 
Show me a contradictory teaching by the magesterium of the Catholic Church in union with Rome and the earthly shpeherd of the flock, the pope.

i eagerly await your response and your sources.
From the Council of Trent
CANON VI.–If any one denieth, either that sacramental confession was instituted, or is necessary to salvation, of divine right; or saith, that the manner of confessing secretly to a priest alone, which the Church hath ever observed from the beginning, and doth observe, is alien from the institution and command of Christ, and is a human invention; let him be anathema.
history.hanover.edu/texts/trent/trentall.html

From the Catechism of the Catholic Church
1447 Over the centuries the concrete form in which the Church has exercised this power received from the Lord has varied considerably. During the first centuries the reconciliation of Christians who had committed particularly grave sins after their Baptism (for example, idolatry, murder, or adultery) was tied to a very rigorous discipline, according to which penitents had to do public penance for their sins, often for years, before receiving reconciliation. To this “order of penitents” (which concerned only certain grave sins), one was only rarely admitted and in certain regions only once in a lifetime. During the seventh century Irish missionaries, inspired by the Eastern monastic tradition, took to continental Europe the “private” practice of penance, which does not require public and prolonged completion of penitential works before reconciliation with the Church. From that time on, the sacrament has been performed in secret between penitent and priest. This new practice envisioned the possibility of repetition and so opened the way to a regular frequenting of this sacrament. It allowed the forgiveness of grave sins and venial sins to be integrated into one sacramental celebration. In its main lines this is the form of penance that the Church has practiced down to our day.
vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P4C.HTM
 
One of the titles of Satan is “The Scatterer”.

“The Scatterer” is also the etymology for the word “diablo” (devil).
 
Isn’t it true that Trent condemned protestants and today the catholic church considers them "separated brethren?
Is it also true that at one time all those outside the catholic church were condemned but that is not true today?
One of the things my brother liked about Vatican II was knowing that his “Shinto-Presbyterian friends” were not doomed to hell.
The term used by both the Cathecism and Vatican II are “separated brethern.” Those who are members of non-Catholic denominations are not responsible for the decisions made by their ancesters. A friend of mine took a trip to Italy with some non-Catholic friends. When her friends referred to themselves as “Protestant,” the priest who was acting as tour guide asked them what they were protesting against.
In his encyclical on the Eucharist, Pope Benedict XVI uses the term “reformed brothers and sisters.” There is a recognition that members of the various Christian denominations seek relationship with Jesus Christ; that each seeks to follow God’s will even if imperfectly. The Trinitarian Baptism is recognized by those of other denominations seeking full union with the Catholic Church. Eucumenism involves dialogue leading to the fulfillment of Christ’s prayer “that all may be one.”
Even before Vatican II, Catholics (at least I was) were taught about the Baptism of Desire. It is God who judges the hearts of men so that even if a person living in the jungle never heard the Word of God and yet lived a righteous life he could be saved and enter paradise. Such is the God who loves more than we could ask or imagine.
 
The original question here (why so many denominations) is brilliant. Why haven’t the many Protestants asked that themselves? Some do and make their way to the Catholic Church. I think 500 years of dissent is sooo ingrained that Protestants can’t think outside the box of what they have been taught. They pretty much all have been taught that the Catholic Church is wrong on things. The Protestant churches cannot justify their existance without doing so, even if some are as respectful as possible to the Catholic Church. Protestant followers accept this because they were taught it. I have also observed many Protestants have incorporated a kind of cultural snobbishness toward Catholics and their beliefs – but I’m sure they don’t even realize it; it is so ingrained. Hence the great divisions over time. At least inter-chruch diaglogue is going on. Many are becoming convinced of the truth of some of the Church’s teachings. Ironically, the gay bishop issue, is driving many Episcopelians and Anglicans back toward Rome.
 
One of the things my brother liked about Vatican II was knowing that his “Shinto-Presbyterian friends” were not doomed to hell.
The term used by both the Cathecism and Vatican II are “separated brethern.” Those who are members of non-Catholic denominations are not responsible for the decisions made by their ancesters. A friend of mine took a trip to Italy with some non-Catholic friends. When her friends referred to themselves as “Protestant,” the priest who was acting as tour guide asked them what they were protesting against.
In his encyclical on the Eucharist, Pope Benedict XVI uses the term “reformed brothers and sisters.” There is a recognition that members of the various Christian denominations seek relationship with Jesus Christ; that each seeks to follow God’s will even if imperfectly. The Trinitarian Baptism is recognized by those of other denominations seeking full union with the Catholic Church. Eucumenism involves dialogue leading to the fulfillment of Christ’s prayer “that all may be one.”
Even before Vatican II, Catholics (at least I was) were taught about the Baptism of Desire. It is God who judges the hearts of men so that even if a person living in the jungle never heard the Word of God and yet lived a righteous life he could be saved and enter paradise. Such is the God who loves more than we could ask or imagine.
Where have the Trents curses been revoked against Protestants?
 
there are only like 7 or 8 main Protestant denominations.
Are there 7 or 8? What is a main denomination? Certainly there are a top 10 in terms of members but there are no way in heck only " 7 or 8". Look at the facts and please, I wish there weren’t so many either…it should be embarrassing.
 
Are there 7 or 8? What is a main denomination? Certainly there are a top 10 in terms of members but there are no way in heck only " 7 or 8". Look at the facts and please, I wish there weren’t so many either…it should be embarrassing.
Hi

There is no use in quaralling, if there are seven or eight or 32000plus ripped apart denominations of Catholics or Christians, the main point is uniting again in one United Christendum and working for this selflessly and whole heartedly. This is a home work to be done or a pre-condition of Second Coming of Jesus. Do the Catholics and Protestant now don’t believe in Jesus’ Second Coming?

If they don’t believe in this of late; they should confess it openly. Othewise thereis no point in being sluggish or lousy. Sorry for the strong words.

Thanks
 
Are there 7 or 8? What is a main denomination? Certainly there are a top 10 in terms of members but there are no way in heck only " 7 or 8". Look at the facts and please, I wish there weren’t so many either…it should be embarrassing.
Main ones?? Lutheran, Anglican, Methodist are 3. There is a huge difference beyween and Anglican and a 3rd Southern Missionary Baptist Reformed. The concept difference is huge as well.
 
There are some many protestant denominations because protestantism is a false religion.
 
actually, the invented doctrine of sola scriptura, never heard of before Luther is the reason for the divisions within Christendom. It is the lack of proper God given authority. The pillar and foundation of Truth is the Church, and Christ instituted one Church and called it to be one as He and the Father are one. One flock, one shepherd, not One shepherd, many flocks.
 
Are there 7 or 8? What is a main denomination? Certainly there are a top 10 in terms of members but there are no way in heck only " 7 or 8". Look at the facts and please, I wish there weren’t so many either…it should be embarrassing.
In terms of size, that is correct. Sure there are smaller denominations just like there are smaller Catholic and Orthodox churches which have broken off as well.
 
Hey jbake,

Some protestant churchs allow homosexual marriage is that supported by the Bible? Most of all protestant churchs allow birth control and that is against Holy Scripture. True love for Holy Scripture is not picking and choosing the verses one likes and forgetting the other verses. I think that is what protestantism does.
 
In terms of size, that is correct. Sure there are smaller denominations just like there are smaller Catholic and Orthodox churches which have broken off as well.
I thought the subject was the number of denominations and not the size of the congregation. What does the term denomination mean to any of you? To me it is a denomination with the freedom to set the parameters of belief for the members. If that is true then there are a lot of denominations…as suggested by the DIFFERENT names for the denom.
I was not aware that the Catholic and Orthodox Churches were having a current problem with “breaking off”. Do we need a thread about why there are so many Catholic or Orthodox denominations?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top