J
jmcrae
Guest
The difference is that each of the Protestant churches teaches different, incompatible doctrines at the official level (it’s coming from their head offices), whereas whatever differences in doctrine you are seeing in Catholic churches are not coming from the Vatican, but from someone’s personal opinions - they are not following the teachings of the Catholic Church.Take the claim that there are thousands of denominations and interpretations of Scripture in protestant churches. When we apply the same criteria to the catholic church as being one unified whole and everyone interprets the scriptures the same we find otherwise. There are just as many different interpretations in the catholic church as in protestant churches.
So, for example, when a Fundamental Baptist talks about the Seven Fundamentals, he isn’'t giving his personal opinion - he’s quoting from the official teachings of the Fundamental Baptists. When a Methodist talks about the Wesleyan Quadrilateral (which contradicts the Seven Fundamentals on several key points related to salvation) he, too, isn’t giving his personal opinion - he is quoting from the official teachings of the Methodist Church.
But there are lots of uneducated Fundamental Baptists who don’t know what the Seven Fundamentals are, and there are lots of uneducated Methodists who don’t know what the Wesleyan Quadrilateral is, and when they speak, they are just giving their personal opinions - these aren’t the Protestants that we’re talking about when we say that “Protestants disagree” - no. Rather, we are talking about the Protestants who do know their theology, and the teachings of their Church - and what we see is that the official doctrine of each Protestant church differs (often quite radically) from other Protestant churches.
When a Catholic gives his personal opinions on something, that contradicts the teachings from the Vatican, he isn’t teaching as a Catholic - he’s just giving an opinion, the same as uneducated Protestants who don’t know what their churches teach, either.
It’s only when what he is saying actually conforms to what the Vatican teaches that he is promulgating Catholic doctrine, and every Catholic who does that, is saying the same things - sometimes in different words, but the meaning will be the same.
When we criticize Protestants for being all over the map with their theology, we aren’t talking about the uneducated ones who are just giving their opinions. We are talking about the educated Protestants who are promulgating the official teachings of their church. It’s the official teachings of Protestantism that are all over the map. Personal opinions are just personal opinions - but comparing the official, educated teachings of Protestants to the uneducated opinions of some Catholics is like trying to compare apples and oranges - it’s not the same thing. We expect personal opinions to be all over the place, but what we find with Protestantism is that it’s the official teachings that are all over the place; not just the uneducated opinions of the laity.