Why So Much Stuff To Become Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Wizard
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a friend who was brought up Catholic and attends mass with his family but since being “born again” and accepting Christ as his Savior in college (40 years ago) has issue with the Catholic faith. One of his “problems” is why do you need to go through RCIA to become Catholic? To him all that is necessary is to tell the person “the good news of Jesus Christ”, have him accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, say the “sinner’s paryer” and you are good to go. To be honest I do not think any answer would convince him. I don’t know if this is the right way to state it but his princples of faith are quite simple: accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, humble yourself before him, submit to his will and read the Bible to find that will. NO MORE, NO LESS! His excuse is that he is too stupid (this from a guy who is an college graduate and engineer) to understand anything deeper and God wants it to be simple.

Any (name removed by moderator)ut?
There are levels of maturity in living the Christian life. Maybe accepting Jesus as his Lord and Savior was like falling in love, going to RCIA is like getting engaged, and becoming a Catholic is like getting married? If a guy said he loved a girl but refused to show it by making a life-long commitment to her, she might have good reason to question his sincerity!

😛

So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, to equip his people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.

Then we will no longer be infants, tossed back and forth by the waves, and blown here and there by every wind of teaching and by the cunning and craftiness of people in their deceitful scheming. Instead, speaking the truth in love, we will grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head, that is, Christ.

(Ephesians 4:14-15)
 
I have a friend who was brought up Catholic and attends mass with his family but since being “born again” and accepting Christ as his Savior in college (40 years ago) has issue with the Catholic faith. One of his “problems” is why do you need to go through RCIA to become Catholic? To him all that is necessary is to tell the person “the good news of Jesus Christ”, have him accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, say the “sinner’s paryer” and you are good to go. To be honest I do not think any answer would convince him. I don’t know if this is the right way to state it but his princples of faith are quite simple: accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, humble yourself before him, submit to his will and read the Bible to find that will. NO MORE, NO LESS! His excuse is that he is too stupid (this from a guy who is an college graduate and engineer) to understand anything deeper and God wants it to be simple.

Any (name removed by moderator)ut?
Catholicism provides every mind, from the simplest to the deepest, with Gods answers to what it means to “accept” Jesus as “Lord” and “Savior”; what it means in the infinite possibility of ways, to “humble” oneself; what it means to “submit” to Him. And, especially for simple minds like his, the Church provides guidance in understanding Scripture and has it read to them every day of the week.
 
How does he know that God wants it to be simple? Where is this written?

The Bible itself is a very complex book, written over the period from Moses to St. John the Evangelist, in a wide variety of literary styles. Most of what is written in the Old Testament came down for many generations in the form of oral tradition - songs, drama, poetry, various liturgies, and memorized lists.

Further, the living out of the Christian life is not a simple thing. I am sure that he would agree that someone who claims to have accepted Christ as his saviour, but shows no evidence of it in his lifestyle, is likely to be deceiving himself. But the habits of a lifetime are difficult to break. If a person is used to sleeping in and then doing housework on Sundays, it takes a few weeks to develop the habit of Church attendance. If a couple is living together without the benefit of marriage, arrangements need to be made to repair that situation, one way or another.

RCIA provides the necessary time to develop the understanding about why change is necessary, and to make these lifestyle adjustments. It also provides sufficient time for the person to learn what all is involved, and for the person to reflect on whether he or she is really interested in taking up the Christian lifestyle.

By not rushing people into the Church, they have time to reflect and consider whether this lifetime commitment to Christ is something they are really able to take on, day in and day out for the rest of their lives.

But how many of those who get accosted on the street by an evangelist and agree to sign a Four Spiritual Laws card, show up in Church the next Sunday, and every Sunday thereafter for the rest of their lives? How many of them actually stop living in sin, and take up the lifestyle of a Christian?
This is a very good explaination. In fact, looking back I really appriciate the time the RCIA volunteers took to explain the faith to me during our classes before I converted in 2004. They actually took to time to answer questions that I had coming from a Protestant understanding of Christianity and prepared me for what it means to be Catholic. I think RCIA and having a good sponsor is great for converts to learn about the Catholic Church.

If anything I have said is against the Catholic Church, let it be anathema.
 
I have a friend who was brought up Catholic and attends mass with his family but since being “born again” and accepting Christ as his Savior in college (40 years ago) has issue with the Catholic faith. One of his “problems” is why do you need to go through RCIA to become Catholic? To him all that is necessary is to tell the person “the good news of Jesus Christ”, have him accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, say the “sinner’s paryer” and you are good to go. To be honest I do not think any answer would convince him. I don’t know if this is the right way to state it but his princples of faith are quite simple: accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, humble yourself before him, submit to his will and read the Bible to find that will. NO MORE, NO LESS! His excuse is that he is too stupid (this from a guy who is an college graduate and engineer) to understand anything deeper and God wants it to be simple.

Any (name removed by moderator)ut?
Well, one thing for your friend in particular, If he was confirmed, he is still Catholic and only needs to go to confession to get back in the state of grace. So for him, its really no work at all.

If he is worried about others having to work so hard to become Catholic, remind him that if you want to get something out of your faith, you must put something into to it. Its no different than anything else, other than the fact that your eternal soul rests on what you do. If someone only wants to say the Sinner’s prayer and nothing more, they are not going to be a good adherent to any faith. We believe that the Catholic Church teaches the fullness of truth. It only makes sense that we convey that in a meaningful way to people who want to join. If they aren’t willing to learn those truths and partake of the sacraments, what is the point in being Catholic anyway? That is the whole purpose of the church: to convey those truths and to administer the sacraments to the faithful.
 
I have a friend who was brought up Catholic and attends mass with his family but since being “born again” and accepting Christ as his Savior in college (40 years ago) has issue with the Catholic faith.
“brought up Catholic” has become a code phrase for NOT being brought up Catholic.

IOW, what you describe is another Catholic who may go through the motions, and doesn’t know his faith…
  • He was baptized therefore he was born again…THEN.
  • He was probably confirmed, which means he was sealed with the Holy Spirit…THEN.
  • He goes to mass which means he receives Jesus literally, body blood soul and divinity at each Eucharist.
BUT he is clueless of what’s even going on. His woeful lack of education is a huge tragedy. But it’s correctable.

As Peter says (2 Pet 1: that follows) He needs to be catechized…from the beginning for his own good.
TW:
One of his “problems” is why do you need to go through RCIA to become Catholic?
knowledge of our faith is not a suggestion it is required. And we must add knowledge of our faith in ever increasing amounts so our faith doesn’t become ineffective.

2 Pet 1:

5 For this very reason, make every effort to add to your faith goodness; and to goodness, knowledge; 6 and to knowledge, self-control; and to self-control, perseverance; and to perseverance, godliness; 7 and to godliness, mutual affection; and to mutual affection, love. 8 Forif you possess these qualities in increasing measure, they will keep you from being ineffective and unproductive in your knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ. 9 But whoever does not have them is nearsighted and blind, forgetting that they have been cleansed from their past sins. 10 Therefore, my brothers and sisters, *make every effort to confirm your calling and election. For if you do these things, you will never stumble, 11 and you will receive a rich welcome into the eternal kingdom of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. *

Your friend should take notice of Perer’s conditional statements. They have IF in the sentence. He needs to start studying his faith… properly. That doesn’t mean being fed slogans from those seperated from the faith.
TW:
To him all that is necessary is to tell the person “the good news of Jesus Christ”, have him accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, say the “sinner’s paryer” and you are good to go.
Given his lack of knowledge, Peter would say he needs to start studying immediately.
TW:
To be honest I do not think any answer would convince him. I don’t know if this is the right way to state it but his princples of faith are quite simple: accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, humble yourself before him, submit to his will and read the Bible to find that will. NO MORE, NO LESS! His excuse is that he is too stupid (this from a guy who is an college graduate and engineer) to understand anything deeper and God wants it to be simple.

Any (name removed by moderator)ut?
Rather than be obedient to the faith already given once and for all to the saints, he’s mixing his own inventions as he goes along.
 
I have a friend who was brought up Catholic and attends mass with his family but since being “born again” and accepting Christ as his Savior in college (40 years ago) has issue with the Catholic faith. One of his “problems” is why do you need to go through RCIA to become Catholic? To him all that is necessary is to tell the person “the good news of Jesus Christ”, have him accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, say the “sinner’s paryer” and you are good to go. To be honest I do not think any answer would convince him. I don’t know if this is the right way to state it but his princples of faith are quite simple: accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, humble yourself before him, submit to his will and read the Bible to find that will. NO MORE, NO LESS! His excuse is that he is too stupid (this from a guy who is an college graduate and engineer) to understand anything deeper and God wants it to be simple.

Any (name removed by moderator)ut?
I would like to think of a job analogy here. Would you enter a company that you know absolutely nothing about: what they are, what they work on, what working conditions are like there, etc.? 😉

“God wants it to be simple.” In a sense, yes, this is true. But then again, what do you think the book of Leviticus is all about? 😃

At least four of the five books of the Torah have God speaking to Moses how this or that should be done: He is very specific how big this box should be, what materials are needed for the Tabernacle, and what animals should be used for certain sacrifices. Heck, He even tells the Israelites what animals they can or cannot eat! Anyone in their right minds would say: “that’s not simple!” Let’s be honest: God Himself is being very complex here! Why does He burden His people with all this stuff when He can make things more simple and just say: “Yeah Moses, you can make that Ark in whatever shape you like. Oh, and tell the Israelites I’m making it less complicated for them, so I’ve decided to pare down the Ten Commandments into one.” 😃

Because one is ‘stupid’, or claims to be, does not mean they absolutely can’t comprehend anything. I take the view that all humans can at least ‘comprehend’ one or two stuff (at a minimum) regardless of their actual IQ. Though, it is also the case that many human beings have a tendency to be lazy in things that they don’t like. Many of us often find subjects we don’t particularly care about to be tedious and dull and make little to no effort to learn about them. I should know; I use the same excuse at math, since “I’m too stupid to learn about and understand algebra.” My suggestion is: why not entice him to learn about the faith of his childhood instead of say, force-feeding it down his throat? That way, he would have more motivation to learn about it. You don’t need to engage into very long discourses or have him read volumes: small bits and pieces about what the Faith actually is would be enough for the moment.
 
You should also tell him this: the Bible is itself not a ‘simple’ work. Many people make the mistake that the Bible must be some sort of roulette wheel or ouija board which they can shake and twist around to ascertain God’s will, or that it must be similar to a modern-day work and thus read it in a modern-day lens without taking into consideration that it is an ancient work.

Be honest: the Bible is not a modern-day newspaper that you can just pick up and read without any proper context. If there is one negative idea that the whole doctrine of Sola Scriptura has brought upon us, it is the idea that the Bible is a low-context work, as if the sacred authors have provided all of the contextual information needed to understand it.

The Bible is a product of a different time and culture than the ones most of us live in. It was written in what anthropologists call a ‘high-context’ society. In such societies people presume a broadly shared, well-understood, or ‘high’ knowledge of the context of anything referred to in conversation or in writing. Readers were required and expected to fill in the gap" because their background knowledge was a given: the writers do not have a need to explicate things in detail because the readers already know the context, and thus extended explanations were unnecessary.

In contrast, many modern societies, such as in modern America, are what is called ‘low-context’. We assume little or no knowledge of the context of a communication, expecting the writer or speaker to spell it all down clearly for us. The problem with reading a high-context work in a low-context society is that it often tends into hyperliteralism and various (wacky) interpretations; this is one of the reasons why the ‘Reformation’ occurred.

We can see the difference between high- and low-context in the following example, which I believe may get to the heart of his question (I quote from Jimmy Akin):

In fact, there are names for the different types of cultures in this regard. Anthropologists classify cultures based on how much background information they expect a person to know already in order to understand and get along in society.

Those cultures that expect a person to know a lot in order to function successfully in society are called “high-context” cultures. Those that do not expect a person to know a great deal of background information to function are called “low-context” cultures.

The United States is considered to be toward the low-context end of the spectrum. In order to function well in the U.S., one needs to know a marketable job skill, the English language (usually), and certain basic laws. Detailed information about U.S. history, religion, customs, who is allied with whom, etc., is not necessary. A person needs only basic information to “get by” in the U.S.—at least compared to some cultures.

By contrast, Middle Eastern cultures tend to be high context. Not only does one need to know a trade, the language, and basic laws in order to function in Middle Eastern countries, but one also must understand how certain groups are allied and opposed to other groups. And most importantly, one needs to know how to avoid transgressing unspoken boundaries—“unwritten laws”—that could place one in danger if violated.

How high or low context a culture is has an impact on the way that culture uses language. Low-context cultures tend to be much more explicit when communicating information. They offer step-by-step instructions, and they less often assume that the reader will “fill in the blanks” based on the shared cultural context. A consequence is that low-context cultures tend to be more literal and more precise when formulating things. They also can tend to communicate more slowly.

High-context cultures do the reverse. They tend to be less explicit. They do assume the reader will “fill in the blanks.” They thus have the freedom to be less literal and precise and more expressive and artistic in their speech, since the reader can be assumed to spot non-literal and imprecise expressions. As a result, they often can communicate ideas more quickly since there is less need to cover the basics.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top