Why Spouse before Children?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CHCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jeez, I am so on the other side of this! Perhaps because my children are so young…

Here is my thinking. A spouse is an adult. Sometimes children have needs that will not wait, and if my husband is selfishly thinking I am going to ignore them, or meet them less than fully, because spouse should be first, he’s got another thing coming. And same back at me… if I have to wait for him because the children have a need and he is meeting it, that is how it should be. We choose (with God’s help) to create these needy little beings and bring them into this world. Without an affirmative choice and action on our part, they would not exist. Therefore, we owe them the best we can give. They deserve us being focused on their needs. And if that means the grownups have to wait, so be it. We are grownups and know how to put our needs and desires behind those of others. Children must be taught how to do that as they grow, but while they are still children, we owe them our focus.

Yes, your spouse will be with you long after your children leave. Which means there is plenty of time for focusing on each other once children are out of the nest.

None of this is to say that our marriages should not be a priority. Mine is second only to the needs and well-being of my children. We do need to have healthy marriages in order to serve our children’s best interests. And our own… marriage is good for everyone involved in it, when it is working right.

I suppose I react so badly to this idea because it is one pushed so hard by Gary Ezzo (of Babywise notoriety) and his ilk. Those people literally justify child abuse in the name of marital unity and putting spouse before children. But even in absence of that, the order just strikes me as wrong. We choose to create children who need us… it seems to me that they must come first after we make that choice for them.

Honestly, though, in my every day life, this whole discussion makes no sense. What is good for the family as a whole is what is good for each of us individually, and for the marriage covenant. It’s all the same.
 
Dusky,

I do see where you are coming from in saying this whole conversation doesn’t make a lot of sense in practicality. My husband and I are soulmates and best friends, but God forbid we were ever in a situation where we had to choose saving our children’s lives or each other’s, believe me, we would each choose our children. You can’t really quantify love in such a way that you can say you love your spouse MORE than your children. It’s a totally different kind of love.

I do think, though, that there are a lot of couples (even Catholic ones!) in which the parents mistakenly think they need to be slaves to their children’s wants/needs and that their spouses come in at a very distant second. I think it’s in reaction to this kind of attitude that people say “spouse before children” Obviously, in the very happiest of homes, the spouses care very much about each other’s needs as well as those of their children, and indeed it is in loving their spouses that they are able to give their children the very best of environments to grow up in. That’s the ideal 🙂
 
duskyjewel, if you marry a good man, do you think that you would be putting him first by neglecting your chidren’s needs? I can’t imagine that he would be happy or fulfilled if you did that.

Honestly, I do think that by putting God first, then your spouse, you will be much more effective at actually doing what is best for your kids.

Imagine for a minute a parent who lets their kids do immoral or dangerous things because it makes them happy. They could think that they are putting their kids’ happiness first, but are they really giving their children lasting happiness?? No, of course not. I can’t tell you how many of these bend-over-backwards-for-their-kids parents I have encountered who have some of the worst kids around. The same goes for parents who will belittle their spouse and side with their kids. The kids would be so much better off if their parents were supportive of each other. There are a lot of examples that I am sure that you could think of where someone is neglecting their marriage in the name of wanting to be a good parent, but in doing that they really aren’t doing what is best for their kids.

I was married to a narcissist who was not able to see the value in sacrificing his own wants and needs for the good of our children. Of course in those situations, you can’t put the whims of the selfish parent ahead of the kids. Although…you could make the argument that if I was really looking out for what was best for my husband, and not enabling him, I could still put him first. Along those lines, I guess that was what I did. For so many years I really did try to build him up and was terribly forgiving of him, depsite the fact that he was abusive annd an alcoholic. I think I stayed with him so long to the detriment of our kids, but really I eventually realized that the kindest and most loving thing I could do for him was to no longer protect him from the consequences of his destructive behavior. That was when I finally left him. So, in wanting to do the most loving thing I could for my (ex) husband, I did end up doing the best thing for my kids.
 
**practical examples??:eek: **

very simply your kids are going to grow up and leave you

it’s highly likely that a spouse would do the same if not placed first in your life when raising those children. empty nest divorce is actually very common.

it is also highly likely that not placing a spouse first will undermine you BOTH with the children, which makes the already difficult job of parenting and instilling values in them harder than it could otherwise be

because the spouse is the one you will need to cry to when the children break your heart. And I promise if they haven’t yet - they will. it’s just part of the growing pains.

because every time you love your spouse, you are loving at least half of who each of your children are. And showing them they deserve the same kind of love from whoever they might one day marry.


**because everytime you put your spouse first, you remind them why having kids with you is a great idea;) **

ETA: didn’t read other replies.
**obviously physical abuse is not anywhere on the scale of spousal love or parental love, thus endorsing it in either silence or compliance is not a loving act, firstly or otherwise, towards spouse, God or children.👍 **
 
No one I believe is talking about neglecting our children. Many times a child’s needs come before a husband’s. If a child needs it’s diaper changed and husband is hungry, the child needs come first. If a child is hungry or sick, and husband is asking for something, husband can wait. What is meant by spouse before children is much deeper. It’s more about valuing and honoring the marital relationship and vows as the highest priority. The marriage is the foundation of the family. A good Christian husband is going to sacrifice for his wife and family. He represents Christ in the family. According to Scripture, the wife represents the Church and is going to sacrifice for her husband and children. Husband, wife, and God is the Church in the home. If the children come first, the marriage will suffer, and eventually the children will suffer because of this. It’s more about caring about each other, loving each other, praying for each other, making sure there is some time, even a small amount, for each other.
 
One more thought I found interesting and useful:

Bishop Fulton Sheen says "Christian love, on the part of one spouse, will help redeem the other partner. " He says, “This transferability of sanctification from a good wife to a bad husband, or from a good husband to a bad wife, follows from the fact that they are two in on flesh. As skin can be grafted from the back to the face, so merit can be applied from spouse to spouse.” from the book Three To Get Married
 
I understand you ought to always love your spouse before you children, just as you love God more than your spouse, but what are some practical reasons I can give as to why. Of course your children are a result of your love for your spouse, but that doesn’t really explain why it should remain. I just need some practical explanations as to why and I can’t really think of any.
I am sorry I haven’t read all of the responses…but I don’t think that you have it exactly right. At least not to my understanding anyways. I believe it is about priority, not love. Put God first, spouse second, and children third. And it is about needs, not wants.

The reason? If we always put God above all else we will stay on the right path (or have the best odds). We need to put our spouses above our children because we have a different kind of relationship with each. Spouses are meant to be by our side forever. But with children our very purpose is to make them independent adults who can function without us. So if we put our children above our spouses then what do we have left when they grow up and move out?

Malia
 
**Practical examples?

How about the family where the kids are in umpteen afterschool activities which leaves mom too tired and worn out to spend any quality time with hubby?

The kids won’t die if they have to give something up, but the marriage very well could if things continue on that path.

Malia
**
 
The family is a symbol of the Trinity so, creating any kind of “priority” is non-sensical.

You don’t love the Father more than the Son and Holy Spirit. You also don’t also prioritize the love of your children. And the greatest way to keep a marriage strong is to love your children. This is not an either/or proposition. Love your spouse through your love for your children and love your children through the love of your spouse.
 
If my child and I were both drowning and my spouse could only save one of us, I hope she saves our child. If my wife and our child were drowning I would save our child first. It seems to me that a major purpose of marriage is the generation and upbringing of children. To put the marriage before its purpose seems to be making marriage into a god of its own.
 
But your children decide whether you end up in a nursing home or living with them.😛
:rotfl: that is brilliant :rotfl:

My husband to be originally said to me that once our children are born (god willing swiftly and safely following our marriage) nothing and nobody will ever mean more to him than them.

I admitt I selfishly felt a little upset at this, but I understood it as those children will be the most beautiful precious innocent creatures to him. He later changed his mind :rolleyes: and said he would always love me more than anyone else because I would be the woman who would give him the most precious things in his life. I have told him to just accept that both I and our children will be equally loved in his heart as I would have it no other way. 🙂
 
I understand you ought to always love your spouse before you children, just as you love God more than your spouse, but what are some practical reasons I can give as to why. Of course your children are a result of your love for your spouse, but that doesn’t really explain why it should remain. I just need some practical explanations as to why and I can’t really think of any.
Ephesians 5:21-33 comes to mind. A husband and wife are one flesh. If that union is broken, there will be no (more) children. First things first, in other words. God commands it.
 
You should love your spouse first for so many reasons. One, your children will eventually grow up and leave the nest. When that day comes you don’t want to be sitting across the breakfast table from a stranger because you haven’t made any real time for each other in the last two decades.

Two, children benefit from having parents who are in a strong, solid marriage. It is far better for children to get slightly less attention from two parents who genuinely love and care about each other than it is for them to get a lot of attention from parents who don’t have such a strong relationship.

Three, and I don’t want to offend anyone who has ever lost a spouse or a child, but this is my perspective. If I lost a child it would be heartbreaking, devastating, and change who I am as a person forever. But, I would have my husband to lean on and be there for me, and he would have me. If I lost him I would in many ways be alone. My child could not be there for me or support me emotionally through that. I would be alone in my grief and suddenly have a family to raise on my own.

I firmly believe that we should find someone that we love, that we have a deep friendship with, and want to be with for the rest of our lives. If we want kids, great, we have kids. But they grow up, leave, and do the same thing that we did. In the end we just have our spouse, and that’s what our kids eventually have to. And that’s kind of the cycle of things.
 
I understand you ought to always love your spouse before you children, just as you love God more than your spouse, but what are some practical reasons I can give as to why. Of course your children are a result of your love for your spouse, but that doesn’t really explain why it should remain. I just need some practical explanations as to why and I can’t really think of any.
I probably wouldn’t be able to say much regarding your actual topic but there’s one thing I definitely want to say in connection: there should never be a pre-determined pattern of who’s right by default in conflict resolution. For example, adults before children or children before adults or perhaps even a family member versus a stranger.

Also, spouses are grown adults and can be demanded more. This means they shouldn’t be competing with children. When they start to, they need a gentle reminder (female) or a solid jab in the ribs (male). Daddy wanting to go to Mac and sonny wanting to go Taco and both turning to Mum for arbitration kind of situation. Very, very adult on the part of the dad. 😛 I suppose women are more mature in this regard.
 
Also, spouses are grown adults and can be demanded more. This means they shouldn’t be competing with children. When they start to, they need a gentle reminder (female) or a solid jab in the ribs (male). .
That is totally right!
 
Wow, I didn’t know married people were supposed to put their spouses before their children. Is that in the Bible or the Catechism? If so, I missed it somehow. It’s so different from what I was always taught growing up, but now that I’m reading the arguments for and against, it makes so much sense.

I couldn’t do that. It’s yet another reason for me to be happy about not being called to marriage. 🙂
 
If a spouse consistently behaves like a jerk or is actually dangerous, then the other spouse may have to behave like the children are more important.
Remember that the reality of a valid marriage, and even more so for a sacramental marriage, is that the two become one. So the original question might be better understood as asking whether the left side of the body should put the right side of the body or children first. If all is well then both sides of the body work together to care for children. If something is wrong with one side of the body the other side must first act to manage the problem and then deal with the children.
This quote is an excellent one in my opinion. In my marriage, one side of the body is not functioning properly so my side has had to step in and deal with the children. As a result of the situation, the children are a higher order of precedence and this does make the marriage a more difficult one. Unfortunately until my other half comes back to reality, this is the way it will be. When you have to make contingency plans because one spouse is constantly threatening to leave, and the children’s well being is really in question, they have to come first.
 
I don’t see this as “before” in the sense of it being a conflict. Rather, part of caring for our children is modelling a strong marriage and giving a place of unique honor to each of their parents. Any adult ought to teach a child to give his or her parents honor before indulging his or her own naturally self-centered tendencies. Of course this starts with the child’s own parents and how they treat each other.

There is a reason built into us to honor our fathers and mothers; that is why it is in the Ten Commandments. A child benefits when they learn to honor each parent by the honor the parents show for each other. Therefore, while the children come first in terms of need because of their greater vulnerability and dependence–I don’t know of any parents who would not sacrifice their lives to save their child or who wouldn’t want their spouse to save their child first in a disaster–the spouse is otherwise put first in terms of being given a place of honor. Honor my mother, honor me, the best version of myself, because that is my will when my will is in accord with God’s. Honor me over my mother, it is more like pandering to me, to my ego self, to my inordinate desire to be the center of attention. IMHO, that habit of being inordinately at the center of attention actually feeds an insecurity that constantly needs to be petted and reassured.

If my father gives honor to my mother and my mother to my father, it also gives me security about the durability of their relationship. If they are each the most important to the other, then my family is going to stay intact and at peace. The two people running my life will be allies; I won’t be torn apart. No knowledge is more important than that to a child. Even when parents are divorced, that insistence on giving the ex a place of honor as “the mother of my child” or “the father of my child” is valued by the child. The child can then still feel that they are the product of two people who deserve honor. When your origins are prized, you are prized by association. When you have to defend your father from your mother or vice versa, it is like being asked to defend yourself from yourself. You’re torn.

IOW, I think it is the best for the child if their parents give each other that pride of place. As a child I would not have wanted it any other way, and that is one reason that our familly does the same thing. In fact, we went so far as to give our children’s grandmother who was living with us the first place in the house. Our children were charged more severely if they showed disrespect to her than if they had shown disrespect to either of us, because she was a parent of their parents. Teach your children that, model how a grandparent is to be treated, and I don’t think you’ll have to concern yourself with what will happen to you when you need care in your old age. Of course, she didn’t abuse that, and we don’t abuse our place in the house, either. She did not demand it, but she deserved it, and since it was freely given by both of us, she accepted it.

This was the Gospel read at our wedding: "They came to Capernaum and, once inside the house, he began to ask them, “What were you arguing about on the way?” But they remained silent. They had been discussing among themselves on the way who was the greatest. Then he sat down, called the Twelve, and said to them, “If anyone wishes to be first, he shall be the last of all and the servant of all.” Taking a child he placed it in their midst, and putting his arms around it he said to them, “Whoever receives one child such as this in my name, receives me; and whoever receives me, receives not me but the one who sent me.” Mark 9:33-37 I think that captures it.
 
I understand you ought to always love your spouse before you children, just as you love God more than your spouse, but what are some practical reasons I can give as to why. Of course your children are a result of your love for your spouse, but that doesn’t really explain why it should remain. I just need some practical explanations as to why and I can’t really think of any.
My husband and I actually gave the supposedly incorrect answer on the FOCUS test. I don’t remember the exact wording the test used, but it had something to do with how much you love your children and love your spouse.

I think this cry out about loving your spouse more than your children has more to do with the trend that people never get so fed up with their children that they divorce their children. Yet people do get fed up with their spouses and divorce their spouses. Children are also very demanding of time and can be very needy. It can become easy to get so bogged down with taking care of children’s needs plus the chores of the house, plus your work, that your spouse takes a backburner. However, it is not loving your children to let your spouse be on the backburner. Divorce hurts children. A relationship that is not tended hurts children. Children need a mother and father who are committed to living our their marital vows. Those vows are far more than merely not divorcing or seperating. Morever, its not just about the kids when they’re under your roof. Watching parents’ divorce and seperate once all the kids are out of the house is heartbreaking. I mean, their relationship is a model of love for you. If they fail to love each other and merely tolerate each other so that they’re not raising you alone, it sends the wrong message.

My protest with the FOCUS test was that it gave the impression that the marriage was more about the couple than the children. This seems to feed into the secular culture’s idea that marriage is about self fulfillment and the idoltry of romantic love.
 
One more thing. I’d like to address the pattern I see sometimes, in which people marry without really knowing their future spouse that much or really caring to know. This doesn’t necessarily improve years after the wedding. By contrast, children are one’s own blood and bone, the future generation. I’ve dodged becoming this necessary stage to family and children (while otherwise pretty much a foreign man) once or twice.
My protest with the FOCUS test was that it gave the impression that the marriage was more about the couple than the children. This seems to feed into the secular culture’s idea that marriage is about self fulfillment and the idoltry of romantic love.
That’s not necessarily secular. You can start from the idea that marriage is a sacrament and parent-child relationship is not, and arrive at the idea that one’s spouse comes before children in case there’s some kind of conflict of interest or affection or whatever. And that’s not actually a fundamentally wrong idea, what is really wrong is the weight-tipping, that is, making it a rule that somebody is always right or wrong (or more important or less important) by default. In reality, various needs have various levels of importance (e.g. a crying child is more important than a starved husband), some needs are selfish (i.e. it’s clearly visible the respective family member is looking out for number one or just being a nuisance), our family obligations need all to be fulfilled rather than just some of them (e.g. a husband and father can’t choose to talk only to his teenage daughter having trouble at school and then be content that one conversation is enough and he doesn’t need to listen to his wife’s problems), and finally, children are capable of being in the wrong (they may be innocent (or not) but they are still learning their morals—from their parents, a.k.a. us!) and adults (e.g. the other parent who seems to be in a conflict with one of the children) are capable of being petty or selfish and very much in the wrong. We all are. This can’t be solved by deciding in advance that either the co-parent or any child will be given priority or will be regarded as the one party being right in a dispute. And taking away from the co-parent does not give to a child, nor does taking away from a child give to the co-parent, anyway (I’m referring to the limited time and limited attention presumption, where talking to a child provides an excuse for not talking to the co-parent or another child). The family goes downhill with that kind of maths. We just can’t divide the pie, we gotta learn to make more pie. 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top