I am learning more about the Catholic Church. And the more I learn, the more I wonder – wouldn’t we all be better off if the church just stopped teaching people about sin? (Or maybe stopped accepting new members altogether?)
Here’s my thinking:
- The only sins that can send you straight to Hell are mortal sins
- A sin can’t be classified as a mortal sin unless you do it with full knowledge that it’s sinful.
- If the church stopped teaching people what things were sins and which weren’t, then no one would have full knowledge, and no one would ever go to Hell.
Additionally, I read somewhere that non-Catholics who don’t believe Catholic doctrine can still be saved because they’re doing the best they can with what they know. But that once someone is Catholic, if they then turn their back on Catholic teaching, that they can no longer be saved because they had the truth and the rejected it. So again, wouldn’t people be a little better off just not accepting Catholicism to begin with?
Please discuss.
First of all, everyone who is saved is saved by Christ through the Catholic Church. No one is saved by Islam, Protestantism, etc. No one. The Church teaches, and has always taught that
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus, Outside the Church there is no salvation (CCC 846). However, this doesn’t mean every non-Catholic will go to Hell. The Church recognizes that those, who are invincibly ignorant of the need to be Catholic (i.e. those who are outside the Church through no fault of their own) will not necessarily be damned. However, the Church also teaches that, as the road to salvation is narrow (Lk 13:24), the best chance anyone has of entering Heaven is through the fullness of the truth and the sacramental life of the Church.
Vatican 2 says that " those also can attain salvation who through no fault of their own do not know the Gospel of Christ or His Church… but
often men, deceived by the Evil one, have become vain in their reasonings and have exchanged truth for a lie…Wherefore to promote the glory of God and procure the salvation of all these, and mindful of the Lord’s command, “preach always the Gospel to every creature, the Church fosters the missions with care and attention.” (Lumen Gentium 16)
Basically, being in the Church is the best shot you’ve got. The sinful world is a like a flood, the Church is Noah’s Ark. Maybe a few people make it through on driftwood and some in the Ark don’t make it, but the safest place is inside the Ark. And those who may make it on the driftwood do so only in the wake of the Ark.
Second, no one is ignorant of the natural law (CCC 1860). Thus, no one can claim a lack of full knowledge in regards to breaches of the moral law, such as sodomy. Other Christian groups teach that committing sodomy is not sinful unless it is rape. Someone in one of those groups might then decide to live a homosexual lifestyle and never repent. Sodomy is grave matter. No one is ignorant of the natural moral law. Said person consented to homosexual behavior. This is mortally sinful and this person would be heading to Hell.
Third, ignorance must not be the fault of the person sinning or it increases rather than decreases the severity of the sin. A person must properly form their conscience. To not do so isn’t a free pass to sin without guilt (CCC 1791) but is in itself a sin. Ignorance of the sinfulness of something comes into play only with those things we couldn’t have know. Again, the moral law is written on the hearts of all men, thus no one can claim ignorance there.