Why the bible is most assuredly not a Catholic book,

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hisalone
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Bill_Pick said:
Hisalone,In reading your post the bible verse you gave us said new covenant and my bible said new testament.
what bible are you using,you are not using the bible accoring to YOU
Click to expand...
I just saw this, I was looking up your posts to find out why you voted for Obama. I ran across this.

Say it aint so Bill :eek:

Covenant and Testament are synonymous.

Ill be praying for you Bill
 
Rlease hisalone do not start lies about me you tell by your self and after you read the post again you can tell me you are sorry
 
Hisalone said:
The bible is Gods book to mankind entrusted to the Jews and followed by men of good will worldwide despite their religious affiliation.
Catholics have tried to replace Jews as Gods chosen people—heresy.
Now they want to claim the Jewish book as their own. Pretty petty behavious in my opinion.
Click to expand...
Hisalone, This is off thread but I will tell you one time STOP TELLING LIE ABOUT ME.
 
Hisalone said:
The bible is Gods book to mankind entrusted to the Jews and followed by men of good will worldwide despite their religious affiliation.
Catholics have tried to replace Jews as Gods chosen people—heresy.
Now they want to claim the Jewish book as their own. Pretty petty behavious in my opinion.
Click to expand...
I can tell YOU what is pretty behavious in my opinion is telling telling people lies and for you its best it stops
 
Hisalone said:
Bill I use several translations none written by me.😉
Click to expand...
I know you get very confused and can not understand what you READ I,am talking you talking about me WHY ARE YOU TELLING IES ABOUT ME VOTING FOR OBMA,I NEVER SAID I VOTRES FROM HIM SO WHY YOU TELLING A LIE,I will be waiting for you to say you are sorry
 
Bill_Pick said:
Dont play with me,I am talking about the poll on Obma
Click to expand...
Go to the thread click on poll results andyou will see what member voted for what choice.
You will see:

Yes, I do, he’s done a lot in those seven days
AntiTheist, Bill Pick
 
Catholicism is a model Bible-based church, for the same reason Eastern Orthodoxy is.

Furthermore, the RCC were the ones who trained Martin Luther (even if he was a bit confused in the opinion of Catholics such as I) and the other theolgians who broke away. Except for Jean Calvin, a lawyer (not a theologian by profession).

If you want to assess the Bible-based-ness of Catholicism, just check out (the current) Catechism, full of Biblical quotations if you’re in doubt.

If you don’t agree with the Roman Catholic interpretations, that’s another deal entirely. You’re free to disagree, but it is not ethical to affirm baseless claims. I personally believe mainstream protestants are ok in general, but in their criticisms of the RCC, they sometimes exaggerate IMHO to the degree of sin (9th commandment [Calvinist numbering] or 8th commandment [Catholic and Lutheran numbering]).
 
Hisalone said:
Catholics have tried to replace Jews as Gods chosen people—heresy.
Now they want to claim the Jewish book as their own. Pretty petty behavious in my opinion.
Click to expand...
No we Catholics havent, you need to read your Bible, and the vision of Saint Peter
 
Vimy_Ridge said:
I’m sure that Jesus, who was Jewish, did not plan on starting a new religion.
Click to expand...
What a peculiar statement coming from a person who once said this:
Originally posted by Vimy: We cannot know for sure what Jesus taught
Click to expand...
It seems that people who make statements such as that still claim to “know for sure what Jesus taught”…when it affirms their own agenda. 🤷
 
Hisalone said:
No where do I say it is a simple agreement.
Why would you imply I did?
A true blood covenant is more than kinship it is as if two become one.
When I said olden days I was not specifically saying in the OT but in OT times. In Abrahams covenant we see that animals were split in two and both the Lord and Abraham passed through them. Again I am differentiating between the covenant itself and the ceremony or the ritual surrounding the covenant.

The New Covenat is one where God writes His law in our hearts by the indwelling Holy Spirit. It is through this indwelling that all will know Him. It is therefore imperative that teachers teach how one comes to know this Spirit who now is abiding in them.
Click to expand...
So, how does Scripture tell us we can determine the Spirit of error from the spirit of Truth?
CC
 
Hisalone said:
The New covenant is clearly laid out in scripture:
Click to expand...
Amen! And the CC affirms and embraces this New Covenant each and every hour of the day, 365 days of the year, at Mass.

The CC teaches that the New Covenant is the marital relationship between God and His people, in which our sublime consummation of our ONENESS with Christ is made manifest in the Eucharist.

And as far as the CC having the wrong interpretation of any particular verses you cite, that is quite a peculiar comment, coming from a Protestant who believes in individual interpretation of Scripture.

To paraphrase Catholic apologist John Martignoni: if, according to Protestant theology, we have the right to read and interpret the Bible for ourselves and the CC choses to interpret those passages as supporting the Catholic teaching on the New Covenant, how can you, Hisalone, tell us that we’re wrong in our interpretation? That’s the interpretation we get when we read Scripture (not to mention the 2000 years of constant teaching of the Church has “got our back” so to speak.) 🤷
 
Lampo said:
Whatever I chose, do you acknowledge the possibility that you could be wrong in your interpretation?
Click to expand...
Im a fallible human being. I am in good company the apostles were fallible human beings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top