Why the Insistence on "Roman Catholic"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What you forget is that those who would refer to anyone as a “Roman Catholic” in a sneering sense also would refer to them as “Catholic” in a sneering sense…yet we all know you would not have a problem then with the term “Catholic.”

There is no consistency here, just gripes.

So basically we went from a term that is somehow unacceptable to a sense that is unacceptable.

What’s next?

Offense at a raised eyebrow?

…
I’m sure you can work out a raised eyebrow smiley, Atemi.

What we have been discussing is neither an unacceptable term nor an unacceptable sense, but simple rudeness.

The common usage of the term “Catholic” is quite well understood, and immediately conjures up images of the Pope, the Vatican, etc. That is a simple fact.

I call Baptists “Baptists” despite the fact that they are not in any way, shape, form, or twisted history the Church of John the Baptist, nor are they the only community which claims a valid baptism. I call them Baptists because a) that is what they call themselves and b) that is what others recognize them as.

(Edited)
 
I’m sure you can work out a raised eyebrow smiley, Atemi.

What we have been discussing is neither an unacceptable term nor an unacceptable sense, but simple rudeness.

The common usage of the term “Catholic” is quite well understood, and immediately conjures up images of the Pope, the Vatican, etc. That is a simple fact.

I call Baptists “Baptists” despite the fact that they are not in any way, shape, form, or twisted history the Church of John the Baptist, nor are they the only community which claims a valid baptism. I call them Baptists because a) that is what they call themselves and b) that is what others recognize them as.

(Edited)
 
Let me give another for-instance.

My wife and I had our car breakdown while at Mass. Being a Sunday, we had to wait awhile for a cab to come get us. When we did, it was a Pakistani Muslim gentleman. He tried to jumpstart our car, and when that failed, gave us a ride home.

Along the way, he asked us if we were coming from Church. We said we were. He asked what denomination. We said “Catholic”. (Perhaps surprisingly to some on this thread, he knew what we meant, and even referred to the Pope).

He then began to talk about his faith, stressing how Jesus was a great prophet and man of God.

Now, let me tell you what we did not do.

We did not say, “No, you’ve got that wrong. Jesus IS God.”

We did not say, “No, Jesus is not a Muslim prophet of any stripe.”

We did not say, “You, sir, are hellbound for being a Muslim.”

We said none of these things, because we are not rude. Nor does being a good Catholic require us to demand cab drivers renounce their faith on the spot. He was a nice man, we prayed for him, tipped him well, and that was that.

Some of you seem to think that simply using a common term, particularly to be polite, somehow tips the cosmic balance toward the Papists. It does not. Nor does it lead to the Catholics on this board waving your post as a trophy. It simply demonstrates good manners.

Now, you may say, “Catholics haven’t earned the right to be called Catholics by ME.” But then again, Baptists haven’t earned any such right of us, either. If it’s really that huge a deal to be polite when called upon rudeness, well then, my brothers and sisters, maybe you’ve got some soulsearching to do.
 
Do you have a problem when Catholics use the term “Roman Catholic”, such as in the examples I gave in my post #34?
I do not, but it is not the term per se which is objectionable, but the usage. If some of our anti-Catholic Catholics use “Roman Catholic” as shorthand for “Whore of Babylon”, as fundamentalists do, that would be quite another matter.

The only issue I might have is one of accuracy, depending on whether it is intended to be inclusive of the non-Latin Rite churches or not.

Of course, the examples aren’t entirely relevant to this discussion, as this type of usage is not employed in discussion threads.

A simple analogy:

If I use the common short term for donkey in a biological sense, it’s quite different than if I say, “So-and-so is an ______”. It is not the term which offends, but the usage.
 
What we have been discussing is neither an unacceptable term nor an unacceptable sense, but simple rudeness.
This thread is not about rudeness, but specifically about the term “Roman Catholic” being rude.

This has been shown again and again to be wrong.
It has certainly been enlightening that so many Protestants unable to maintain uniform dogma on any other issue can do so on this one only: “He who calls Catholics “Catholics” and not “Roman Catholics” is anathema.”
(Edited)

Both Catholic and Roman Catholic are acceptable and accurate terms. You must deal with it. (Edited)
 
Do you have a problem when Catholics use the term “Roman Catholic”, such as in the examples I gave in my post #34?
It is only non-Catholics that are “rude” if they use this perfectly accurate and acceptable term. Catholics are exempt.

The true nature of these complaints is coming to light as this thread develops.

…
 
Since no one seems to want to address the issue that Teflon93 raised. This thread is now closed.
MF
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top